Prompt: "A song that was mentioned in a Song Challenge write-up but never chosen as the featured song by anyone"
Selected by Zach
"Casimir Pulaski Day"
Illinois, 2005
I struggle with nostalgia. I have this preconceived notion of it that it's something bad, that it should be pushed away in favor of emotions in the here and now. It's not true. We need to live however we want to live. But, still, that guilt persists.
This is one of those rare songs that manages to straddle the line for me between nostalgic emotions and "here and now" emotions. This song has come up in my life a few times, though, and not just because it's one I tried to learn on guitar during the pandemic, when I was trying to learn how to play guitar to begin with, playing D, C, Am, G over and over.
I guess there's something about an American childhood and the Saturday night of Thanksgiving weekend. This day we're living in right now. Each day of Thanksgiving weekend is its own holiday in itself. Wednesday before Thanksgiving has its identity, as does Friday (I'm not even talking about the Black Friday bullshit), and Saturday. Saturday is special, though. It always has been.
I was riding my bike through Chicago on July 13, 2007 during my cross-country trip. We rode that day from Merrillville, Indiana, to Grayslake, Illinois, so Chicago was right in the middle. We stopped for deep-dish pizza. While I was stuffing my face, my mother called me. It was midday, so that was unusual, because we usually talked at night. I picked up.
She had called to tell me about Amy.
Amy was a girl from my high school class—smart, a great reader, a sweet person. I knew she had struggled with an eating disorder. I hadn't heard much about her in recent years. The truth was that I had never really been that close with her. But my mother was calling me to tell me that Amy had died the day earlier.
I just looked up her obituary today. She was 20. 20! An impossibly young age. I remember her as so human, and to realize at age 38 that she died so long ago hit me hard, probably even harder than it hit me on that beautiful summer day in Chicago. Her whole life ahead of her, and it never happened. It's awful, really.
We continued biking on that July day, along the lakeshore path I would learn well fifteen years later. I had started getting into Sufjan in college, who I first learned about when I went to my friend's a cappella group concert (they were called APC Rhythm), and they sang "Chicago." So "Chicago" was going through my head that day, for sure, but I also knew other songs on the album. I remember riding along and seeing a sign for a road called Casimir Pulaski Way.
But when I look at Google Maps right now, there's no record of any Casimir Pulaski Way in Chicago.
Did I make it up?
Does it even matter?
Or is all that matters that someone I knew had died, of an illness, and my brain was trying to make sense of it, and maybe was trying to grab at any relevant source material in an attempt to do so?
In 2014, we had our tenth high school reunion, and we raised money for a charity her family supported. We had our reunion at Brickside Food & Drink in Bethesda, Maryland. It was the Saturday night of Thanksgiving weekend.
How much pain am I supposed to hold for someone who I sat in English class with, in History class with, someone who I always admired for what she had to say in class? How much pain am I supposed to hold here, in a blog post read by people who never knew her, in a post that no one who knew Amy will likely ever read? Should I pivot to talking about my experiences at that 2014 reunion? How does anyone strike the right balance between life and death and life?
In the end, I'll save the stories from 2014 for another time. It's 2024 now, obviously. There's a 20-year reunion happening this weekend that I'm missing. It's not anything formal. My close friends from high school used to play football after school on Fridays, so we've continued the tradition by playing a football game on the Friday morning after Thanksgiving every year since 2004. 21 years of Friday Football—it's actually amazing we've kept it going that long. There will be a football game, where a bunch of 38-39 year old men run around a field. I am sure there will be an injury. We're all Fatter and Older now.
Then, apparently, there will be a gathering at 8 PM at Silver Branch Brewing in Silver Spring, Maryland on the day you'll be reading this. It looks like 25 people from my class have responded "Yes." I didn't even realize the Saturday night thing was happening until I picked through my email just now, and I even more didn't realize that many people would show up. Of course, there will be many spouses and children in tow. Now I feel sad. Another special Thanksgiving weekend Saturday, and I'll miss it.
And there's that nostalgia again.
Because one year ago, on the Saturday of Thanksgiving weekend 2023, the father of my high school girlfriend, who's been working for NPR for quite a while, published a very moving piece. It blew my mind, because I wasn't aware of any of the article's circumstances. His wife—my first love's mother—had dementia, and had moved into an assisted living facility in June 2023. You can read the article for yourself. He was debating whether to leave the Maryland area for a few days to visit my ex/his grandkids in Utah for a few days. It would mean he couldn't visit her, and he was concerned about the effect it would have on her. I cried reading it.
Real life chases you. It chased me on that July day in 2007, when I didn't process that a person in my life had died at age 20. It chased me when I read that article. Was I really now at an age where the parents of my classmates were getting dementia? It all seemed so impossible. I thought I was supposed to be young forever.
A wise man once wrote the following:
"I think about this as I sit here and listen to 'Casimir Pulaski Day' and feel all the emotions that Sufjan Stevens is conveying through this song, most of which are different flavors of 'sad.'"
And:
"This is a fictional story—probably—and yet I often find myself close weeping when I listen to this story. It doesn't even have to be sadness—[it can also be] joy, confusion, anger."
I couldn't agree more with this. I've been writing this post for over an hour and playing "Casimir Pulaski Day" on repeat the whole time. I haven't gotten sick of it. This song just provides the right backdrop for all the emotions a person can feel.
There's sadness of course, over death and dementia. There's a different kind of sadness over missing out on seeing people I love because I chose to live far away. There's joy in knowing I've maintained connections with those people, that those connections are basically unbreakable at this point. There's confusion of how I'm spending my time, what I'm doing throwing a post like this into the void, if it's somehow insensitive or not expressing what I really feel. There's anger that sometimes I feel like I'm wasting my life, that I'm 38 and still haven't "figured it out," whatever that means. And then there's sadness again when I think about how the three words "Casimir Pulaski Day" fit together and how, somehow, those words are sad, even though they simply state the name of an obscure Illinois holiday. It doesn't matter if Sufjan's friend actually had bone cancer, just like it doesn't matter if Casimir Pulaski Way exists or not. What matters is that I'm listening to the song, the same way the wise man above was listening to it, and even though we live on different continents and have different lives, we can connect over a shared emotion listening to the same words, the same chords, the same everything. What a cool thing that music can do for us.
This Saturday, I'll go to synagogue, like normal. I'll probably go to a post-synagogue hangout my friend is having. Another friend told me she might host lunch; if she does, she'll invite me. I'll probably walk south, to the Chabad synagogue for the afternoon prayer. Then I'll walk back up north, back home, maybe along the beach. I bought tickets Saturday night to a Lamb of God tribute concert, because I have so much unused energy inside me and I've been wanting badly to go to something resembling a metal show. I don't think I've ever gone to a show like that.
Meanwhile, my classmates will be getting together in Silver Spring. Amy's family will be remembering her, I am sure, like they do every day. Marc Silver will visit his wife, Marsha, at the assisted living facility. My parents and my brother and his wife will probably all be together too. I'll be far from all that. My Saturday of Thanksgiving weekend won't be one of nostalgia. There's no such thing as Thanksgiving weekend here, really, aside from the attempts of the Americans to make something of the day. My day will be about my life in the here and now.
I don't always know if I'm OK with that. I want the nostalgia. I want to grab on to the past and listen to "Casimir Pulaski Day" over and over again until it grounds me to a pulp.
But then I remember that this song encompasses so much more than simple nostalgia. It tells us what we're feeling right here, right now, even if we listen to it over and over and remember my magical past, the ups and downs and the disappointments and the sadnesses.
We have to live. We have to live and do the things we're meant to do here. Yes, our time here is short. How much more so, then, do we need to let the past propel us to doing all those things? Yes, we're borne back ceaselessly into the past, but we beat on, boats against the current. Of course we do. We knew this all along.
"He took my shoulders / and He shook my face / and He takes and He takes and He takes."
Shake me up, world. Shake me up bigger than any Saturday night could ever do. Shake us all up. Let us be here. Let us eat turkey and stuffing and cry and laugh and feel it all. Let us touch the skin of a new baby and feel alive, ourselves. Please. Anything. Anything at all.
Anything at all, except feeling stuck.
1 comment:
Lots to say here even beyond the usual "this was a great post, man." Thanks for the quotes. I sometimes wonder if we're drawn to sad songs because we want to feel sadness, in some perverse way. You felt sadness at the age of 20 and that made an impact on you and informed in a small way who you are and now here you are with this post. Sufjan went through it with a pal back in the day (assuming this is autobiographical, which I do), and that made an impact on him, so much so that he wrote a song about it. I don't know, I'm thinking out loud as four women surround me pulling at my attention simultaneously.
Post a Comment