Showing posts with label The Albums That Matter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Albums That Matter. Show all posts

Saturday, August 16, 2025

Song of the Day: "Sandy Sheets"

A column about music, and about how the music informs our lives. Today's author is Joe. See the previous songs HERE.


"Sandy Sheets"
Dave Hause
from Blood Harmony
2021

Speaking of blog column eulogies, the regular feature that we should absolutely stick an elephant tranquilizer into the neck of is The Albums That Matter. Remember that one? The premise, at least at the beginning, was to attempt to write about every album on my iPod in alphabetical order. I have a tough time reading those blog posts. This is because they were mostly written between 2017 and 2019ish, which is beyond the limits of my "only blog posts written in the last five years are good" rule.

It's one of those important-not-good moments; The Albums That Matter is really important to me because it basically jump-started my music blogging hobby back when I really needed a dumb hobby. I was temporarily sober and so-far childless and spending a lot of nights alone on the couch (Pam was working nights) and I needed something to do. I rediscovered blogging. The Albums That Matter was there. 

It's bad writing, but that's to be expected at the beginning, right? Saying that my early blog posts are bad is like saying that a high school basketball team is bad because they only hit 40% of their free throws. It's expected! They are still learning! There might be potential in there yet! I appreciated having a place to practice the art of blogging. Again, not saying that I'm good at it now, but I've improved a little bit. You can see the improvement if you look at some of those old The Albums That Matter entries and compare them to anything I write today. You can also see improvement if you watch me type, and how easy it is now to sit down and bang out some bullshit, whereas it was so fucking strenuous to type 400 words about an album back in the day.

Because I'm a nostalgic piece of a shit, especially when it comes to blogging, I've thought about resurrecting The Albums That Matter plenty of times over the years. There has been a grand total of five entries in the column since the start of 2021, so obviously that idea never really seems to stick. The truth of the matter is that I don't really need this column anymore. There are more than enough spaces on this blog for me to write about albums, if I choose to do so. There's really no need to be tied down to the alphabetical list of albums that I already own. That's too restrictive. It's detrimental to my journey on how to be a good writer, at this point.

If I were to write the next The Albums That Matter column entry, it would have been about Blood Harmony, the 2021 album from Dave Hause, as that is next alphabetically after Blonde on Blonde (not including Blondie, which was already covered in a different blog column, and Bon Iver's Blood Bank, since TATM didn't cover EPs). I guess at some point in the past couple years, I had written down a few notes about what this particularly blog post would entail. I'm at the point where I don't really need to know what a blog post is about before I start to write it; sometimes I find my way as I'm writing through it. So without actually writing the Blood Harmony blog post, I don't actually know what it would look like.

But I was going to start with this idea that Hause is a descendant of Bruce Springsteen, that his music is rock troubadour shit, made for the working class, heartland rock on the near side of the fence to folk music. I would probably talk about how Gaslight Anthem does similar things in our near-modern times, but that Dave Hause puts a Philly spin on it. It feels more homegrown to me, because he grew up in the same home city as me. That's special.

I would of course have done the obligatory walk around the block with Hause, written about where I discovered him (at Nate's house, where Gilson played Bury Me in Philly), how that album grew exponentially for me that year, how it's still probably my favorite "Philly" album of all time (or maybe in a tie with Kids in Philly by Marah), how it soundtracked my middle child's first moments, how my middle child is thus far my most "Philly" child.

And then I would've written about Blood Harmony and how it softens some of that sound, how this is Philly on the outskirts, gentle and pastoral in some ways, which says to me a couple things, but mainly that Hause is experiencing fatherhood of his own and also is experiencing the 2020s wave of indie-country-Americana trends in real time. 

I would've probably wrapped it up by talking about how I didn't even bother with Hause's latest record, 2024's Versus, possibly because this album and 2023's Drive It like It's Stolen feel like they are rapidly moving away from the Philly-centric poignancy that Hause maybe even accidentally discovered on Bury Me in Philly, that maybe this has more to do with me living on the outskirts of the city now too, and losing touch with what made my time closer to Philly's heart so special. It could also just be that Hause is kowtowing to the middle, writing radio rock by sanding down his edges. The blog post proper would end with a mention of the fact that Hause is putting together a local music festival in Manayunk soon, or did recently, and how XPN talks about this guy all the time still, and how I'm not questioning Hause's bonafides, but instead might question my own. Like maybe I'm the problem here.

Stray observations would talk about Hause's backing band, the Mermaids, and how there is a NW Philly bar called the Mermaid, with me questioning whether there is a connection there, and me not having any answers, because the one time we tried to go to the Mermaid, it was closed, despite the hours posted on its website. I'd also point out "Gary," and maybe get PoYB Contributor Gary to listen to it and tell me what he thinks. The "song to listen to" would of course be "Sandy Sheets," which I have attached to the top of the actual blog post that you are reading right now.

Those are all the notes I had for Blood Harmony. I imagine that if I were to actually put together a The Albums That Matter post about this album, there would be a little more research. But I don't think that's necessary anymore. I'm running head-down into the future, devouring as many new (to me) albums as I can, making very little time in my life to do deep dives into random-ass albums that I already own. Maybe that's too my detriment. I don't know. On most days, I just think that writing is fun, and I don't want to do anything that doesn't seem fun. If The Albums That Matter stopped being fun, then it's probably time for me to shut it down.

R.I.P. to the O.G. PoYB blog column. I'll pour one out for you by finally deleting this Dave Hause notes from my blog notepad on my phone.

Wednesday, August 23, 2023

The Albums That Matter: Blonde on Blonde

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Blonde on Blonde
Bob Dylan
1966

There are too many gardens to tend to in the fields of Puke on Your Birthday, and occasionally, some get neglected. It's not that the soil isn't rich, it's just that I only have so much time in the day. There was time when I was writing an entry in the "The Albums That Matter" column every single day. That was years ago, in the nascent stages of PoYB 3.0. I've been sitting on this next entry for over a year. Time got away from me. But I wouldn't be explaining all this in the opening paragraph if it didn't make sense in the context of what I'm going to say about Bob Dylan's Blonde on Blonde.

I feel like it was to my benefit to wait on it. I've known Blonde on Blonde for a decade or more, but it was helpful for me to listen to it with a critical eye over the past eighteen months, maybe once a month during moments when I'm fooling myself that I'm finally going to write about it. I needed to be absolutely sure that I'm not missing anything, because here is my thesis: I'm too stupid to understand poetry.

The rub is that Blonde on Blonde is my favorite Bob Dylan album1. But that mostly has to do with the music, not the lyrics. There's some great shit on here that I'll get into in a second. First, I'll say that my relationship with Dylan has gone through a wild ride over the years. When I was young, he was a "hero." This was when I was immature enough that I could pretend that I knew what Dylan was talking about in his poetry. Later, as a young adult, I grew bitter, referring to Dylan occasionally as a "fraud." This is when I was old enough to realize that there were things that I didn't understand, but still young enough that it frustrated me, and I would thus lash out.

Now, I try to stay zen when it comes to that which I do not understand. Whenever I am bamboozled by something, I try to remember now that this is my fault, not the artist's fault. I wrote about this with Mulholland Drive, a movie that I sure as shit didn't "get" right away, and even now am not even sure if my rickety scaffolding of understanding is going to hold. But you take that as a challenge, right? It's not "it sucks because I don't get it," it's more "I don't get it but I want to get it or at least get to a place where I'm finding meaning in the not knowing."

Let's look at an example. "Visions of Johanna" is a good one for this exercise. Really great fucking song. Like many of the songs this album, it makes a serious claim for being one of Dylan's best. Here is a random snippet of the lyrics:
"The fiddler, he now steps to the road
He writes everything's been returned which was owed
On the back of the fish truck that loads
While my conscience explodes."
I can hear the music playing in my head as I read the words, the song is that vivid. I can hear Dylan's inflections and cadence as he sings the lyrics—the way the "-oad" rhymes at the end of each line are elongated, the way "conscience explodes" gets the implicit exclamation mark, almost making "explodes" an onomatopoeia. But as to what these words mean? I have no idea. Sixteen-year-old Joe would've have pretended he knew, and 25-year-old Joe would've said that they are stupid because they can't mean anything. But 34-year-old Joe knows enough about this world and about art to understand that it sometimes doesn't even matter what the words mean. What matters is that they look good, feel good, and are vivid and artful and meaningful emotionally, etc.

Like, I'm not gonna go down the fucking rabbit hole that Genius.com suggests that I do. Is "fish truck" a reference to "the vegetative death-and-rebirth mythology of the Fisher King via T.S. Eliot’s The Waste-Land"? Either it is (and Dylan is working at a level that I will never be capable of discerning) or it's not (and the so-called Dylantologists are fucking fooling themselves). I'd rather just let the absurdist imagery work as a valid piece of the music. "My conscious explodes" could mean something or it could not, but it's a fucking banger of a bridge into the chorus.

I just get uncomfortable because I'm surrounded on all sides by people who say that these lyrics are deep, man, and I'm over here just appreciating a harmonica solo. I'm not even saying the discussion about the poetry isn't valid. I like the act of trying to figure out what the fuck "Rainy Day Women #12 & 35" is about. I believe Dylan when he says it's not about drugs. I believe Dylan when he says that "getting stoned" is about hypocrisy (i.e. "he who throws the first stone..."). I also believe that it doesn't really fucking matter what the words mean, it only matters that they are strange and mysterious and that they pair really nicely with a drunk-or-high-but-definitely-woozy "Salvation Army-style" band.

There are lyrics that are seriously sticky, and have remained with me for half my life at this point. Check out this one from "Stuck Inside a Mobile with the Memphis Blues Again": "He just smoked my eyelids, and punched my cigarette." Is the switcheroo a goof, or on purpose? If the latter, then why? Can you even smoke an eyelid? Is it a metaphor? Is the cigarette punching an oblique reference to "Canto III: Vestibule of Hell" from Dante's Inferno? These are the types of questions that someone who needs explicit explanations for these words would ask. I don't necessarily need that. I am content with the lively quasi-psychedelic imagery in the phrase. I try not to see this shit as a padlock to be picked, because after a while, I'll start getting pissed that Dylan didn't have any keys.

Maybe this becomes a problem on an album that features Dylan spitting his lyrics over an acoustic guitar, since the focus there lands on those lyrics. That's obviously not a problem here. Blonde on Blonde is the third album in Dylan's so-called "rock trilogy," and the band behind him remains phenomenal. Standouts are the late Robbie Robertson on guitar (I waited so long to write this blog post that I had to add that adjective in front of his name, unfortunately), and Al Kooper on organ (he also plays the infamous organ part on "Like a Rolling Stone," which was on the second album of the trilogy, Highway 61 Revisited).

What I appreciate about Dylan's rock music in this era is that thing the band does when every verse builds up in volume and crashes into the chorus is an even bigger way than the previous chorus. It works every time. It also works because Dylan has his peculiarities when it comes to pronunciation, and even when he's repeating words in the chorus, those separate choruses have different inflections, so they all sound like different words, even when they aren't. This is what makes "Like a Rolling Stone" such a great and difficult karaoke song, because you have no know exactly how Dylan says the words, in addition to what he says. "Stuck Inside a Mobile" pulls the same trick, and I'd love to tackle this one in a public setting one day.

There are a thousand other musical moments that I love throughout this album, and I'm comfortable in saying that this is my focus when I listen to Blonde on Blonde, not the words (though, as noted, some words are so vivid that they jump out at you anyway). The give-and-take of harmonica and organ in "I Want You," how "Most Likely You Go Your Way and I'll Go Mine" again features that same rambunctious, sloppy energy found on "Rainy Day Women," the insane explosion into the final chorus and harmonica outro on "One of Us Must Know (Sooner or Later)"... talk about how much of a lyrical genius Dylan is all you want, but this is one of the best straight-up rock 'n' roll records of all time.

So I don't think what I'm saying here is that Dylan is a genius or a fraud. He is maybe both, or neither. What I'm really trying to say is that I'm comfortable now with the unknowable mystery of it all. I don't know what most of his words "mean," and I don't even know if they mean anything. What's important is that they mean something to the listener. And I'm not the type of listener who needs to understand poetry in order to understand the beauty of music. Blonde on Blonde gives me permission to be whatever kind of listener I want to be.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, then check out this song: "Pledging My Time"



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations:
  • 1...so far. I'm familiar with seventeen of Bob Dylan's 40ish studio album LPs. Mostly all from the early years in his career. I'm slowly but surely working my way through the discography, at a pace of about one per year. I know from previous experience that trying to binge on any particular artist's entire discography at the same time does not work for me, and actively turns me off of their music.
  • But yeah, Blonde on Blonde is probably #1, at least in terms of "favorite." If we're talking about "best," then other cliché answers would Highway 61 Revisited and Blood on the Tracks.
  • Couldn't fit in the quote "that wild mercurial sound" in the above short essay, but I feel like this description of Blonde on Blonde by Bob Dylan himself is almost as well known as the lyrics themselves. What can ya do, this man's words are usually taken as gospel.
  • ALBUM COVER: I love the blue steel look that Dylan gives the camera in this one. I like how photographer Jerry Schatzberg shuts down any nonsense "hidden meaning" interpretations right from the get-go: "We were just cold and the two of us were shivering."
  • ALBUM NAME: I was coming up on Dylan around the time that the new theory was making its rounds—"Blonde on Blonde is a tribute to Brecht on Brecht, a musical performance of Bertolt Brecht's songs which Dylan attended in 1963 and which had a profound effect on him." Eh. It's possible but not likely. But I don't want to come off as too cynical here. I want to leave at least some room for "secret meaning" shit. Maybe this can be one of them, as opposed to the likely scenario of Bob Dylan high on marijuana and free-associating random words.
  • I read some an argument one time that some of the songs on Side 3 are unnecessary, especially "Obviously 5 Believers." I mean, I get the argument. Maybe you could cut down a couple songs if you wanted to. But what's the purpose of saying this? Is it some superiority thing? "Oh, I know how to construct a better Blonde on Blonde then Bob Dylan himself." Part of the deal in consider albums a single piece of art is that you're stuck with all the parts and functions of that single piece of art. The "which songs would you cut" discussion that pops up around double albums is always a nonstarter for me.
  • Speaking of which—I was always just a little annoyed that my CD copy of Blonde on Blonde existed as a double album, even though, at 72 minutes, it could've fit onto a single disc. True—"Just like a Woman" has an ending that totally suggests "move to the next disc now please," but I'm sitting here right now listening to the whole thing on my iPod without having to flip anything or change anything or push any buttons, and I'm still getting something out of the experience. That whole "keep double albums on two CDs" thing was just a way to rob you of money.
  • Good thing Santa Claus bought me this album instead. I definitely remember the first time I listened to it. I was in the back of the minivan on the way to my uncle's house on Christmas Day. The three toddler cousins we saw that day are all out of high school now. Time flies, Blonde on Blonde stays the same.
  • Can't believe we haven't talked about "Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands" yet! The epic eleven-minute closer to the album, this is Bob Dylan working in peak form. It's also probably the best example on this album of the "words as emotions and not as hidden clues." Regardless, I love the mythology that Dylan builds over the course of multiple albums (like how in Desire's "Sara," he admits that he "[stayed] up for days in the Chelsea Hotel / writing 'Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands' for you").
  • "Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands" showed up as a Song Challenge selection from Sam. That was the first indication this summer that I needed to write this goddamn blog post. Then Maeve was saying that Bob Dylan was poetic, and I really needed to get on this shit. And when I sat down to write about "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down," I feel like I could've used this blog post as a good introduction... if it had been written yet.
  • Listening to "Stuck Inside a Mobile" and hearing Dylan charmingly screw up a lyric made me think that "A song in which the the artist makes a noticeable mistake" would be a good prompt. Though I guess I'm disqualifying this Dylan song from an answer to that prompt, if we indeed do Summer Song Challenge again next year.
  • It was around the time that I had my first high school girlfriend that I was getting into Dylan, and it tickled me that "Absolutely Sweet Marie" had her name right there in the title. Good song. I thought it would be funny to find out for this bullet point the answer to the question "Where are you tonight / Sweet Marie?" for this particular Marie. Her Twitter seems to indicate that she is probably getting married this weekend? I don't think she read Puke on Your Birthday (even though she is aware of its existence), but if you do: congratulations Marie!
  • CHARTS: Four songs on this album found their way onto the Billboard Hot 100, including "Rainy Day Women #12 & 35," which peaked at #2. To this day, it remains the highest Bob Dylan ever got to on that chart (not including his vocals on "We Are the World," or the cover of "Mr. Tambourine Man" by the Byrds, both of which hit #1).
  • PREVIOUSLY ON THE ALBUMS THAT MATTER: This is our second Dylan album (alphabetically). The first was Another Side of Bob Dylan. On that one, the last bullet point was "Might be months or years before we get to another Dylan album, so let's get this out of the way: The best Bob Dylan album is Blonde on Blonde." Good thing I added "years" into that guess—it's been five years and two months since I wrote that.
  • PREVIOUSLY ON THE BLOG: Tons and tons of Dylan shit scattered around the blog. Most relevant to the precedings today is probably "Visions of Johanna" showing up on this Top Five list.
  • Old Crow Medicine Show performed this entire album live for its 50th anniversary. I thought that was pretty cool. I also think it's interesting that, in an interview about it, they put such an emphasis on the fact that Blonde on Blonde was made in Nashville, and how this means this album is part of the lineage of Nashville music and musicians over the years. Most of which is country, mind you, and I wouldn't say that Blonde on Blonde is "country" in any sense, but the dudes in OCMS hearing something Nashvillian about the sound, and I trust their judgment.
  • Frank Ocean has an album called Blonde. Despite having never listened to that album, I am left wondering whether there is a mashup opportunity here, à la The Grey Album. Could we ever have Blonde on Blonde on Blonde?
  • My kids love playing the harmonica now. It's equal parts endearing and annoying. When its the latter, it sounds just like the long, shrill, static harmonica note in "Pledging My Time." I gotta imagine that Dylan was doing that on purpose, right?

NEXT TIME: There is finally a next time! I can finally take Blonde on Blonde off this fucking list on my phone! If (when) we get to the next album, it's gonna be Blood Harmony by Dave Hause.

Thursday, January 12, 2023

The Albums That Matter: Sam's Town

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order (not today though), and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Sam's Town
The Killers
2006

I told you last week about the family secret santa, and how my sister Brianna wrote an album review since it was on my wish list. What I didn't say last week is that Brianna actually wrote two reviews, one for a new album and one for a classic album. I'm presenting the latter here today as the main body of the semi-defunct blog column The Albums That Matter, since that seemed more aligned with the spirit of the review. And since this an important album for me too, I'll add my two cents down in the Stray Observations.

~~~~~~~~~~~

If we're talking musical impact, I don't think there's a better place I could start than with the band and album that first led me on the path I tread today.

I distinctly remember being in middle school, knowing that music was important but not knowing where I fit into that. Looking back at the Top 100 of those years, I definitely understand where that feeling of musical purgatory came from. From the Pussycat Dollz to Bubba Sparxxx and Justin Timberlake's solo career at its prime—safe to say that nothing was really grabbing me in any significant way. Enter Sam's Town.

Thinking back, I couldn't tell you why I picked that album to get for Christmas in 2006. I'd like to think there was some interdimensional Interstellar-type pull from the future guiding me in the right direction. Whatever it was, I'm grateful. This album fucking rules.

Let's start with some context. These guys were hot off the success of Hot Fuss, with arguably (or factually?) one of the most popular songs of all time with "Mr. Brightside." Were they going to continue down the synthy-indie rock road to stardom, or try something new with their sophomore try? The latter became the route of choice, and the right choice it was.

The "something new" came in a variety of ways and sounds. While the use of brass and strings have historically become the keys to my musical soul, perhaps even because of this album, the biggest change and win on Sam's Town has got to be the vocals of Brandon Flowers. Autotuned and produced on Hot Fuss ("I didn't even realize what was going on with these machines" said Flowers about his first try at studio recording), his range and style finally get to shine.

Highlights include the title track, which surely shocked the techno lovers looking for their next Hot Fuss fix, an overall album favorite in "For Reasons Unknown," and an all-time Killers hit, "The River Is Wild." Lowlights? It's be hard for me to even fathom it. At the time, I wasn't too fond of "My List," but with age and maturity, I've grown to like the slowest song on the tracklist, and admire their ability to write a powerful ballad that holds up after the upbeat, incredibly fun track "Bones."

Over the years, Sam's Town has been musically and discographically compared to Born to Run by Bruce Springsteen. A big sounding album about a hometown that encompasses both the good and the bad of life in America, I see it. And perhaps it's the K*** in me and our innate love of the Springsteen sound (did you know Bruce once sang a Christmas song to Dad?), but I could see this album being a favorite for all the years ahead.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, then check out this song: "Sam's Town"


~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • Alright, this is Joe again. Thanks for writing about Sam's Town, Aunt Bri Bri!
  • I love hearing about origin stories, and I'm glad we got one from Brianna here. It's cool when you can trace back your own musical interests to some germinal album, and you can point to it and say "this is where all this shit began." That tells me how important music is in general, that we all have these types of stories, because sometimes the impact is just that forceful.
  • Here's a funny postscript to that story: I remember specifically asking Brianna if I could borrow her copy of Sam's Town so that I could rip it onto the family computer and burn my own copy. So a delayed thank you for your generosity in this regard as well.
  • I wouldn't claim that this is as "important" an album to me as it was to Bri and others, but I do credit it for making me check my biases when it comes to artists and how I know them. My other sister Jenny used to watch The O.C. back in the day, and I remember hearing the Killers play a song on that show. So for a while, at the beginning there, I was pretty dismissive of the Killers, because I was dismissive of The O.C. and all that it entailed. This was long before the critical reevaluation that has since heralded Seth Cohen as one of the indie rock pop culture touchstones of the '00s. My own reevaluation started as soon as I heard "When You Were Young."
  • That's the reason we're all here, right? I always assumed that "When You Were Young" was the big one. Were it not for "Mr. Brightside," then it would be an unquestionable lock for the best Killers song ever. I think? Bri didn't mention "When You Were Young" in her review. Either I am wrong, or the song looms so large over the proceedings that it's difficult to write about.
  • Here's what I wrote when I ranked "When You Were Young" as the 26th best song of the 2000s: "'Mr. Brightside' notwithstanding, the Killers hit their peak when they ditched the new wave aesthetics and tried to be Bruce Springsteen. Brandon Flowers wore a fucking bolo tie, for Christ's sake! I remember the first time I heard this song. I remember the goddamn city block I was driving on when this song first came on the radio, that's how hard it hit me. Have I used the word 'epic' yet to describe any of these songs? No? Okay, cool, because 'When You Were Young' is the first one to truly deserve the description."
  • I'm glad that it was underlined here how important Brandon Flowers' vocals are to the Killers. That was kind of the hook last time I wrote about this band in this column, though for a much less successful album in the discography.
  • The other important part of that Battle Born write-up is Flowers' honesty and forthrightness when it comes to his own music. Battle Born is probably the Killers' worst album, and he's ready to admit to it. This means that you also have to take him seriously when he says about Sam's Town that it would be "one of the best albums in the past twenty years." The man doesn't miss.
  • Okay, maybe Top 50 for me, personally. Top 30, if I'm being dangerous.
  • Interesting bit about the "worst song" on this album, and how maybe there just isn't one. I'll cop to not liking "Read My Mind" when it was being played a lot on the radio, but maybe that was just because that meant the radio wasn't playing "When You Were Young" nearly enough. I agree with the assessment for "My List" too. It just brings down the energy a tad too much at the beginning.
  • "Bones" is the one whose stock has risen the most since I first heard it, I think. Not that I disliked it, but it wasn't till like 2010 that I was like holy SHIT this is good. Those horns! Ah! When I'm making playlists for gatherings at the house, "Bones" is usually the one that makes the cut.
  • ALBUM COVER: This is an album Nevada, so they needed the Desert bighorn sheep on there. And that's model Felice LaZae looking great in a bikini. I'm happy to report that her Instagram bio still mentions the Killers.
  • CHARTS: "When You Were Young" peaked at #14 on the Hot 100. Bri was correct in mentioning Timberlake, as unfortunately his "SexyBack" was sitting at #1 that week. "Read My Mind" also charted. It peaked at #62. That week, Akon's "Don't Matter" was at #1. Not familiar with that one, at least not enough to be able to pull it up in my brain from memory.
  • MORE CHARTS: Sam's Town debuted at #2 on the Billboard 200. I am very sorry to report that #1 that week was The Open Door by Evanescence. That sucks, but it also plays into the narrative of Sam's Town being underrated when it was first released. Time has shown that this album is better than an Evanescence album. I also find it interesting that Hot Fuss only peaked at #7 in its day. This is more evidence toward the theory that a band's most commercially successful album is usually the one after their most popular one. That Sam's Town just happens to be better than Hot Fuss is besides the point.
  • PREVIOUSLY ON PoYB: Lots more about the Killers scattered all around the blog, if you're interested in hitting that search bar at the top of your screen. But here's a couple Sam's Town-specific things. First, "Why Do I Keep Counting?" lost in the championship round of the inaugural March Madness Shuffle back in 2020 (man, we were all pretty bored during the pandemic, huh?). Second, Brianna's 2019 review for a Foals album proves her Sam's Town bona fides with a quick reference toward the bottom of the review.
  • So is Sam's Town a concept album? I think you could make that argument, even though I think the term "concept album" is overused a bit. Every album is a concept album if you squint hard enough.
  • Thanks Brianna! And one final Merry Christmas from the PoYB family!
NEXT TIME: I will cover Blonde on Blonde in this column eventually, I swear.

Monday, March 14, 2022

The Albums That Matter: Blisters in the Pit of My Heart

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Blisters in the Pit of My Heart
Martha
2016

Why this album "matters" might seem obvious, but I promise you that it isn't. So, to clarify: we did not name our second daughter after a mid-tier English indie band. I was indeed familiar with Martha (the band) when Martha (the baby) was born, but I don't even know if I made the connection until a couple days later. Rushing to the Pennsylvania Hospital in November 2019 while listening to Blisters in the Pit of My Heart probably would not have disqualified "Martha" as the name if it was a girl on her way. But I also wasn't jamming out to Martha (the band) so often that I agreed to Martha (the name) based on that. They are disconnected.

But suppose they aren't. Suppose that, by coincidence or not, Martha (the band) means a lot more to me now, since they do indeed share their name with my (current) youngest. It's not even that I'm listening to Blisters and finding weird connections between the band and the kid. No apophenia here, just a sense of relief, I think. Martha (the band) kicks ass. If they somehow become a lot more culturally prevalent than they are right now, like say they come out of nowhere with a Hot 100 topper of a song and my elderly neighbor recognizes a Martha song from hearing it in the supermarket, then I'll still sleep easy at night. They are a good band, and this is a great fucking album.

The best way to describe the sound is that this is an anarchist punk band that strives to sound as twee as possible. Imagine that early Against Me! wanted to be Belle and Sebastian. These are extremely catchy pop songs that take place with a heavy backdrop of (per the band) "queerness, veganism, straight edge, anarchy." On the best song on the album, "Curly & Raquel," the protagonist falls in love with their crush when they see them spraypaint "ACAB" on a wall. But, like, this takes place in a flashback after the music crescendos into a guitar solo. It's some really good shit!

The energy never really lags throughout this thing, which is something that I admire (and yes, maybe if the Marthas in my life do share something in common, it is their relentlessly high energy). Everything is fast and catchy and adorable and clever. It kind of reminds me of Los Campesinos!, too, and not just because of the heavy accents. There are lyrics on every song that just not me sideways with how funny they are. Take "Precarious (Supermarket Song)": "And when it came time to check out / you stood beside my til' / I said, "Retail is the pits," / and then I scanned your anxiety pills." It paints such a vivid picture, which to me just says the level of care and effort that went into this thing. These songs could've easily stood on their own with the hooks alone, but the fact that we also get to go deep and e.g. imagine that anarchist philosopher Emma Goldman opens up a detective agency, it just adds so many more layers of enjoyment.

The big takeaway for me, though, is always going to be: yikes, that was close. This could've been a shit band, and my daughter would discovery them as a teen and rue the day she was named after some terrible music. Not the case! Martha is great! Blisters in the Pit of My Heart is fucking amazing. Thank god.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, then check out this song: "Chekhov's Hangnail"


~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • Thank god, right Martha? Imagine being your older sister. Imagine sharing your name with a nepotistic fraud who is riding some bullshit emo revival nonsense by dueting with creepy old tattooed men (it's so bad I'm not even going to insert a hyperlink to any of this, by the way). There is nowhere else to turn, Willow, except maybe a Richie Cunningham movie about a dwarf?
  • Oh, yikes, it looks like the guy who produced this album is the same frontman of RC alumni Hookworms who got that band cancelled by being sexually abusive. Any update on that situation? Yup, looks like the allegations have been withdrawn. Not sure what to make of this. Occam's razor tells me that the victim of his abuse had to make a decision whether to go through the brutal process of a courtroom battle or swallow her truth and deal with it privately. It's kind of a shame that this no-win situation is the price you pay for daring to accuse a white male in this country of anything negative.
  • I guess this is only tangential to Martha, since they couldn't have been aware of any accusations while recording Blisters. And I'm looking at the credits for their 2019 follow-up, Love Keeps Kicking, and I don't see MJ's name anywhere on this. Either he didn't have anything to do with it or they are hiding his name. Again, Occam's razor tells me it's the former—no way a band as explicitly far-left as Martha are going to be out there ignoring abuse allegations.
  • Love Keeps Kicking is pretty great, by the way. It might be a slight step down from Blisters, but only because it's just "more of the same great stuff," which, ya know, could be a lot worse. "Wrestlemania VIII" is an all-time great, and was probably the second song that our Martha ever heard (since her first was decided beforehand).
  • Wikipedia lists Martha's influences as: "The Housemartins, Motown, Billy Bragg, the Thermals, Ted Leo, power pop, the Replacements, Heart, the Marked Men, Big Star, Masshysteri, and the Exploding Hearts." I can speak to the accuracy of about half of those (especially the Exploding Hearts (R.I.P.) and the Replacements (made explicit in the Replacements references in the final song, "St. Paul's (Westerberg Comprehensive)")), and this makes me want to explore the other half of this list posthaste.
  • ALBUM COVER: No credits to be found, but that's bassist/vocalist Naomi Griffin on the cover, looking sad. (Love Keeps Kicking has guitarist/vocalist Daniel Ellis on the cover, so I wonder if the other two members are gonna get their shot on subsequent releases.)
  • PREVIOUSLY ON PoYB: Blisters was at #18 on the Top 20 Albums of 2016 list, which is just shockingly low, to be honest. A reranking today would easily put it up at #5 for the year. "Precarious (Supermarket Song)" got an honorable mention for best songs, and while it's definitely one of the best songs, I would probably put "Curly & Raquel" in the Top 20 somewhere at this point. 
  • Totally forgot about this before going through the blog archives for the above bullet point: if this band didn't exist, we would've had to hang our Martha hats on the song "Martha" by the Beatles. No one has asked us whether we've named our daughter after an anarchist twee indie band, but multiple people have asked us whether we've named our daughter after the Beatles song. My response: "No, we have not named our daughter after PAUL MCCARTNEY'S DOG, how fucking insulting of you."
NEXT TIME: Blonde on Blonde by Bob Dylan

Wednesday, January 5, 2022

The Albums That Matter: Blind Melon

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Blind Melon
Blind Melon
1992

A tale as old as time: if you're coming to the album with expectations built by the big single, then you're going to be either surprised or disappointed (maybe both?). "No Rain" is one of the great pop singles of the '90s, and on Blind Melon, it sticks out like a sore thumb. I'm not saying that this is a good thing, or a bad thing, or whatever. It's just a true thing, that the album as a whole has very little to do with its crowning achievement.

If you are reading this blog post, then I might say it's reasonable to surmise you were alive when "No Rain" was big. Even if the guitar riff doesn't immediately pop into your head when you see those two words, you can click on the YouTube link and know exactly what song this is within seconds. It peaked at #20 on the Billboard Hot 100. Rock songs entering the Top 20 was not nearly as rare in the '90s as it would be today, but I'm just saying—the song was popular. You know it already.
 
I guess the point of today's short blog post—besides ostensibly making the case for Blind Melon's "importance," which has always been the true point of The Albums That Matter, and is a point so nebulous that it's no wonder I haven't written a true entry in this column in over a year—is to tell you why the other dozen, decidedly non-popular songs on Blind Melon are similarly worth your time. If they aren't like "No Rain," then what exactly are they like?

It may be reductive to describe them like this, but I'll do it anyway, since RIYL Calculus is a fun game to play—Blind Melon sounds like Pearl Jam + Lynyrd Skynyrd. The math works because all three bands have a similar sense of scope. Like Pearl Jam, Blind Melon are firmly in the early-'90s grunge/alternative rock tradition, but also that sound is filtered through southern roots (3/5ths of the band is from Mississippi, the other two from rural areas in IL and PA).

There is some fucking heft to this album. Stuck exactly in the middle of the thirteen-song set, "No Rain" practically feels like an interlude sometimes. Otherwise, it's chock full of loud guitars jamming out, many of the songs reaching near the five-minute mark. There is a lot going on. On most songs, each of the two guitarists are separated onto a different channel, so if you're listening with headphones, you have Chris Thorn on the left, and Rogers Stevens on the right. And they are both playing something different, and they are both playing loudly. They are able to efficiently create a wall of sound that really never lets up.

Not that the guitars are even the centerpiece here. Shannon Hoon is the vocalist, and I think it might even be fair to say that the man has one of the most recognizable voices in '90s rock? He's up there with Cobain and Vedder. Sort of a nasally falsetto that cuts right to the bone. The only reason we're not hearing Hoon's name mentioned among the greats of rock 'n' roll is because his life was tragically cut short in 1995. Like many rock stars, his end was sadly preventable. Like many rock stars who pass too soon, he left a legacy anyway.

Blind Melon is absolutely part of that legacy, and not just because of "No Rain." I mean, that song is probably the reason we are still talking about Blind Melon in 2022. Fair enough. I'm just saying that there's a lot more behind the curtain here. It might be technically true that Blind Melon are a "one hit wonder," but such a phrase is insulting to the solid deep cuts here that didn't have the pleasure of being ultra-popular on American radio.

I don't even know if I'd go so far as to say that there are "underrated gems" on Blind Melon. None of the twelve non-"No Rain" songs sound like "No Rain," but they all kind of sound like each other, if that makes sense. None of it stands out. I prefer to let the tough, gritty sounds wash over me, as opposed to trying to pick out favorites. It still works if you listen to Blind Melon that way.
 
The main thing is that you listen to something besides "No Rain." It's an amazing song, but there's plenty more to unpeel here. Blind Melon stands as one of those rare albums that features "the big hit" but is not in any way weighed down by that big hit.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, then try this song: "Paper Scratcher"


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • I went through a very short phase in college when I was using iTunes gift cards to purchase songs from the '90s that I was nostalgic for. I must've heard "No Rain" on the radio when I was home for winter break one year, because a gift card from Xmas was used to buy the song. So I never really stopped listening to this song.
  • I went a long time with that song being the only Blind Melon song on my iPod, however. It wasn't until Steven Hyden started pushing Blind Melon's second album, Soup, as some unheralded masterpiece that I finally got around to downloading a full album. And of course, enjoying Soup made me curious as to whether the debut self-titled was just as good.
  • And it almost is! If we're in the business of comparing Blind Melon's only two albums—which we might as well, since this column will almost certainly never cover Soup—then I'll give the edge to Soup, since there is no "all these songs sound kind of similar" problem or "the big hit, while amazing, is also kind of a distraction" problem. Still about as solid a two-album discography as you could ever hope to create.
  • Apparently Blind Melon was interested in replacing Shannon Hoon after his death, but eventually disbanded after a four-year search. Not surprisingly—dude seems like a tough person to replace.
  • (But then also apparently they did find a replacement, and released a new album with new lead singer Travis Warren in 2006. Blind Melon are still a part-time concern, with Chris Thorn saying as recently as 2019 that new music was on the way. Reading between the lines on Wikipedia, I'd estimate that those plans were scuttled due to COVID.)
  • ALBUM COVER: Okay, if you were alive in the '90s, you were familiar with "Bee Girl." A little girl dressed up like a bee dances around in gritty urban environs for the "No Rain" video that got heavy MTV airplay. The album cover for Blind Melon is also a Bee Girl. However, I just learned today that they are NOT THE SAME BEE GIRL. The video one is portrayed by a former child actress named Heather DeLoach. The picture on the cover is drummer Glen Graham's younger sister, taken in 1976. DeLoach was cast in the video due to her similar physical appearance to the young Georgia Graham.
  • I'm always interested in weird ass instruments that are played on albums. "Sleepyhouse" has a credit for a sārangī player! I suppose I can hear a sārangī!
  • "Sleepyhouse" is a reference to the house that the band all lived in together. Not the best song on the album, but I still love learning little trivia like this. (It's not even the first time that we encountered this type of thing in TATM—remember Bell House?)
  • CHARTS: Blind Melon peaked at #3 on 9/11/93. The #1 album that week was River of Dreams by Billy Joel, which is a damn shame. "No Rain" peaked at #20 on 10/30/93. The #1 song that week was "Dreamlover" by Mariah Carey. Remember when Carey was a powerhouse on the charts? You should, because she was just at #1 again two weeks ago. Let's try to get "No Rain" to #1 for Christmas 2022!!!!!!!!
  • PREVIOUSLY ON THE BLOG: I compared Soundgarden to Blind Melon a few months ago when we covered Superunknown. I'll stand by the comparison, though after listening to Blind Melon all day, I get the sense that Soundgarden were a little more polished, while Blind Melon was more content to jam out and get messy. Though that didn't stop the two bands from touring together in 1991. I also imagined a hypothetical scenario in which a Hansen brother replaces Shannon Hood in my Tinted Windows review. I honestly don't know if I still stand by that one.

NEXT TIME: Last time there was a "next time" I was saying in November 2020 that we'd be doing Blind Melon next, so I understand your skepticism. But if/when there is a next time, we will be covering Blisters in the Pit of My Heart by Martha.

Wednesday, April 7, 2021

The Albums That Matter: Boarding House Reach

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.
 

Boarding House Reach
Jack White
2018
 
Though Wikipedia states that Boarding House Reach received "generally favorable reviews," for some reason I remember it getting shit on at the time for being "too weird." Maybe I'm letting Pitchfork's panning have too much influence on my memory. In any case, I am here to defend Boarding House Reach from those P4K naysayers and anyone else who doesn't "get" Jack White's most recent solo album. Because that's what we're here for, right? This is an "album that matters." If I didn't find value in it, then I wouldn't be here writing about it.

To be fair, a lot of Boarding House Reach is, indeed, weird as fuck. At least in the context of Jack White's extended discography, anyway. There's always—since the dawn of the White Stripes—been talk of White being a "rock 'n' roll purist," or however you want to describe it, and yet here he is on a solo album, making computer noises, using autotune, reading spoken-word poems over gentle guitar strumming, piecing together seemingly disparate sounds into a collage. This isn't the Jack White you knew.

And that was too much for some people, and I get that. Maybe by the time you get to "Get in the Mind Shaft" and you're listening to four-plus minutes of Flaming Lips-style space synths and indecipherable robot voices, maybe your patience could wear thin. I wouldn't blame you.

I'll say this, though: Jack White, throughout all the new and wacky shit he throws at the wall on this album, never really loses the groove. These might not be the three-minute garage rock tunes he is mostly known for, but you can still, with very few exceptions, nod your head along to all of it. I don't have proof of this, but I have to imagine that White was listening to shit like the Meters while creating this album, or like any classic "funk" band like the Meters, the ones that rarely knocks your socks off, but always keeps locked into that groove.

A song like "Corporation" is, for instance, not like anything Jack White has done before. It's loose and ragged, it features a lot of nonsense yelling as if through a bullhorn, and plenty of conga, and there's not really a "melody" to speak of. But the rhythm hooks you anyway. Or, like "Respect Commander." You'd be forgiven if you felt this song bleeds together with some other songs around it, but you cannot deny that it's a steady groove that keeps you invested.

There's enough here to keep me satisfied that I'm more than willing to forgive the missteps (and there are a few). Like, give me those Icky Thump-style solos from "Connected by Love" all fucking day, and I'll suffer later in the album through less than two minutes of a stupid country western voice over performed by Jack White doing a terrible Woody Harrelson impression. White might try to do some weak tea imitation of rapping on "Ice Station Zebra," but the classic guitar ripper "Over and Over and Over" is coming up next, don't worry.

I wrote in my Help Us Stranger review in 2019 that I enjoyed the Raconteurs' newest album because it sounded like Jack White was allowing himself to be freed from his self-imposed constraints and just have fun. I think there's more meat on that bone of an idea if we apply it to Boarding House Reach. Not that this is necessarily as "fun" as a Raconteurs outing, but it's still fascinating to me, maybe more than any other White release, and that is because he is clearly fucking around and doing whatever he wants during a lot of this album's runtime.

That's really the main reason why I like Boarding House Reach. I find it pretty interesting that Jack White is ostensibly showing his true self here, and there's almost this impulse to recoil a little bit. I feel like White gets his balls busted for being too uptight and too serious sometimes, and then he goes ahead and releases some gonzo art house rock thing, and not everyone liked it, and then at a certain point it's like what the fuck do you people want?

Or you could look at it another way. You might choose to see Boarding House Reach as Jack White using "weirdness" as a shield against some other type of criticism or obstacle. E.g. maybe White was feeling pressure to release another album of certified guitar-driven classic-rock-style bangers, and he just couldn't do it, and instead of succumbing to writer's block, he instead just slapdashed a weirdo creature of an album and released it. No one can call it weird because no one can deny that that was the point.
 
I feel like I kind of do that too sometimes. If I feel like a blog post isn't really coming together like I wanted it to, I'll purposefully allow it to go completely off the rails, maybe lampshade the fact that it did, and acknowledge that this was a dumb thing that I did and that I'm going to publish it anyway—all of this is a defense mechanism against anyone pointing out that I could do better. I don't have to do better if I choose not to.
 
And so I do feel a weird affinity towards albums that I interpret as a similar defense mechanism. Not so much artists who have always been weird, but artists who have clearly turned toward the weird for this particular project. Clearly Jack White has been more successful, and much more coherent, in basically every album he's ever released, under any banner. But that's what makes Boarding House Reach special to me—not that it's better, but that it's different, in a particular way that captures my attention. Until White releases his next solo album, that's going to have to be good enough.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "Hypermisophoniac"


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • Let's see what I didn't talk about already. Oh, how about the second song, "Why Walk a Dog?" Interesting song! It's got a sort of slinky organ rhythm. It's also interesting because I can relate to the impulse to question why anyone would want a pet (he calls it "a cure for you to stop being bored," which is funny).
  • I don't really know what to make of the penultimate country duet track, "What's Done Is Done." It's a song about White feeling so bored with himself that he's gonna buy a gun and kill himself. Hopefully creating Boarding House Reach helped him find some excitement in his life.
  • That's Esther Rose on the duet, by the way. Her 2019 album You Made It This Far was quite fun, and hopefully by the time you are reading this I'll have dug into her new album How Many Times.
  • Previously on the Blog #1: A few other people reviewed the Raconteurs' album a couple years ago, so check out the Record Club archives and Ctrl+F "Help Us Stranger" or whatever. I also mentioned Jack White's solo work that I wasn't interested listening to in a proto-Record Club post in 2016.
  • Previously on the Blog #2: If there is an album covered by The Albums That Matter that we could compare Boarding House Reach's weirdness too, I'd go with ...And Star Power. Foxygen is a little weirder than Jack White in general, but they really brought the freaky-deaky to their sophomore album, and I appreciated it way more than critics did.
  • Previously on the Blog #3: If you want examples of blog posts that I "purposefully allowed to go completely off the rails," then I can think of a couple off the top of my head. There was a weird The Night That We... about a grade school romance, a Record Club review that ended with Miley Cyrus speaking to the audience directly. I dunno, there's plenty of shit like that. I'm just trying to say that I get it, Jack.
  • The drums on "Respect Commander" are pretty busy, and that got me thinking about the White Stripes. Like, this is a very un-Meg-White-ish drum beat, and I wonder if Jack White purposefully stays away from anything that might sound like Classic Meg on purpose, or what.
  • I always remember being fascinated with the Elephant liner notes and how they claimed that "no computers were used in the making of this album," or something to that effect. Jack White truly has always been a Luddite. I think there's a time and a place for it, and I'm glad that White clearly didn't worry about such restrictions while making Boarding House Reach.
  • ALBUM TITLE: I didn't know this until today, but "boarding house reach" is a real term for when you make a rude reach across a dinner table to grab something. Who knew! (And who knows why this was the phrase that was chosen to title the album!)
  • ALBUM COVER: Kinda weird futuristic picture of a female(?) with a cloud for hair. I don't get it. According to Wikipedia, there was an alternate cover for the release of the "Third Man Records Vault vinyl edition." This one is a little better, and still futuristic looking. Both fit the sound decently, in my opinion.
  • CHARTS: Wow, I didn't know this, but Boarding House Reach was #1 on the Billboard 200. Name recognition, baby! He knocked shitbag abuser and criminal and now-murdered XXXTentacion out of the top position.
  • CHARTS #2: But he didn't even sniff the Billboard Hot 100 with this album, which I guess is not surprising. What is surprising is that Jack White has only had two appearances on the Hot 100 at all, ever, in history. He peaked at #81 with Alicia Keys for a Bond theme in '08, and he peaked at #28 for that Beyoncé Lemonade feature. Kind of fucking wild that that is literally it for the guy!
  • I remember reading Steve Hyden's review of this album and appreciating the fact that he too appreciated it. I also remember one of his tweets from like eight months later that was basically like "Holy shit I cannot believe that Jack White released an album this year and that I apparently liked it." I can't find the tweet now, but it's a dumb take, and also a relatable one. Sometimes I'm high on music because I want to write about it and then six months after writing about it I can't tell you one fucking thing about it. I think it's more of an indictment of music criticism in general than of Jack White's recent music output, but what the fuck do I know?
NEXT TIME: Probably won't be a next time for a while, so who knows. Maybe I can circle back to Blind Melon?

Tuesday, December 1, 2020

5 PM — Song of the Hour: "Revive"


"Revive"
Crying
from Beyond the Fleeting Gales
2016

Let's check in with The Albums That Matter, PoYB's oldest continuous column, whose popularity seems to lie somewhere between Degrassi reviews (0 views) and Your Favorite Movie (100 views in its heyday).
  • After yesterday's b'lieve i'm goin down blog post, I have now written about 125 different albums. Most are bad, some of them are fine.
  • If I were to stop downloading any more albums and stick exclusively to writing about the albums I already own, there would only be... 1322 albums remaining.
  • Which is impossible. I know that. Especially because I'm adding three to five albums to that count every week. Even if I write two blog posts every week (which doesn't happen), I'll never catch up.
  • This isn't even considering the fact that some of those albums are downloaded after I pass their spot in the alphabetical queue. I downloaded Veruca Salt's American Thighs after I already passed all the A albums, and I have no current plans to go back and write about it.
  • There are currently 37 albums that begin with A that I didn't write about. There are already nine albums that begin with B that I didn't write about. Those numbers will rise exponentially the longer I write.
  • But more reasonably: there are 43 B albums left before we move onto C... or, more likely, take a long or even permanent break from writing this column.
To those who are still reading, thank you! More than anything, The Albums That Matter just allows me to fill space on the blog when I don't know what else to write. I know that doesn't make for the most compelling reading sometimes, but it's something to fill our dull lives at least.

Monday, November 30, 2020

The Albums That Matter: b'lieve i'm goin down

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


b'lieve i'm goin down
Kurt Vile
2015

I'll admit it—my fanaticism of Kurt Vile lives and dies on his singles. I think the man has some unimpeachable hits—like, sincere all-timers—and then a very deep catalogue of very above-average-at-best jams. Maybe I came to that conclusion with b'lieve i'm goin down, a very good album that only comes close to sniffing "great" on the broad back of "Pretty Pimpin." I definitely didn't hold this opinion with the previous two releases from Vile—Smoke Ring for My Halo, and especially not Wakin on a Pretty Daze.

But I learned with Wakin that sometimes it takes years for a Vile album to click, so maybe that's the case here. Unlikely—it's now been over five years—but possible! It's not like there aren't some really fun moments, even besides the entirety of the rock/folk/psych magnificence of "Pretty Pimpin." I like the chill keys on "Dust Bunnies" that give that song more of a back-alley-jam feel than usual. I like the hypnotic stutter-step rhythm underneath "Wheelhouse." Same for "Life like This," as well as that song's overlapping vocals. I think "Lost my Head there" has some fun lines, including "Fell on some keys, and this song walked outta me."

If you just want a laundry list of highlights, then I can provide you with one for pretty much any album of your choosing. That's not the point, though. The point is that not much of Kurt Vile's music is really going to make an impact on you, which is surprising considering the fact that his top five songs could go toe-to-toe with any artist's own top five in history. After that, however, there's a drop-off.

Maybe that's the point? Kurt Vile is clearly content to just sit back and jam with his guitar. He stands out because he doesn't try to stand out. This is a classic "cool guy paradox." Kurt Vile is impossibly cool, and he is cool because he doesn't try to be cool. The songs on b'lieve i'm goin down for the most part sound like a dude smoking weed and jamming on his guitar, and then in a smoke-filled daze hallucinates an entire band to flesh out the sound.

I'm struggling to think of an artist I like this much while not necessarily loving every single album that they put out. I mean, Kurt Vile consistently puts out the same sound over and over, and it often tends to turn into background music, and yet I'll happily listen to it any day. The more jammy aspects of his sound have their limits (he doesn't reach them here, but will on Bottle It In when we get to that next year), but even those are just average and pleasant and I really don't mind them.

This isn't a very substantive write-up, but I don't see how it could be. There's very little substance with Kurt Vile. The man exists on his own plane, where playing the same vaguely-Americana guitar ditties over and over will still earn you critical acclaim. I'm okay with that. Somehow, I agree that he deserves it.

~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, then try this song: "I'm an Outlaw"


~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • Even more baffling than Kurt Vile's ability to spin fandom out of some pretty basic stuff is his tendency to be flippant with the use of capitalization and apostrophes. I get that it's a trend to not use capital letters in an album's name, fine. But if you're gonna use an apostrophe in "i'm," then why not with the "goin"? Why does the song "Lost my Head there" not capitalize "my" and "there"? Where is the apostrophe for "Pretty Pimpin"? I could go on, but I know I'm the only person that gives a fuck about this kind of thing.
  • Here's some solid evidence that Kurt Vile's music sounds "samey"—the riff from "Kidding Around" is pretty much the same as Smoke Ring for My Halo's "Peeping Tomboy." Except maybe in a different key? I don't know anything about guitars or keys or chords or anything, but maybe a guitar player can confirm this for me.
  • ALBUM COVER: It's a picture of Kurt Vile looking impossibly cool, most likely in some abandoned lot around Philly.
  • ALBUM NAME: There's a bonus track that would've served as the title track, had it ended up on the album proper. I don't do bonus tracks, and I am not even going to bother today—I love Kurt Vile, but a 60-minute album is enough for one day.
  • CHARTS: b'lieve i'm goin down is actually Kurt Vile's highest charting album on the Billboard 200, peaking at #40 (when Fetty Wap's self-titled was #1—remember Fetty Wap?). It also peaked at #4 on the "Billboard Tastemakers Chart," which... what the fuck is that? I've never even heard of that chart. Apparently, it's "ranked albums based on an influential panel of indie stores and small regional chains." Interesting. Don Henley was #1 on that chart that week, so I don't know if it's a chart that I would hold in high esteem, but you do you Billboard.
  • I'm surprised I made it this long without mentioning it—Kurt Vile is a Philly native. He lives in Mount Airy. I looked up his exact address one time on the city government's public website (he lives right around the corner from Hannah and Sam!), but the site has since removed the ability to search property by owner. Probably because too many people were looking up Kurt Vile's address!!
  • Completely forgot until now that Vile released a country EP this year. I'll probably make that Record Club's album of the week in a month or so.

NEXT TIME: Blind Melon by Blind Melon

Tuesday, November 24, 2020

The Albums That Matter: Blackstar

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Blackstar
David Bowie
2016

He is known as the Shadow Man. There's a reason for that. He is a man with many personas, but all of them seem impenetrable and inscrutable to me. They always have. To say I don't "get" David Bowie might be an understatement. It's frustrating as fuck because everyone else is out there having a great time with the guy, singing Portuguese covers and hanging out at art exhibits and I'm over here wondering how the fuck anyone could appreciate the wacky back half of "Heroes". 

On the morning of January 8, 2016, I listened to Blackstar on the way to work, and for the next 48 hours, it felt like I finally GOT IT. So let's talk about that feeling for a little bit, and why I felt it. 
 
I think the short answer is that David Bowie's enigmatic musical stylings blended really, really, really well with the absolutely batshit freeform jazz that takes up the bulk of Blackstar. It's a genre of music that I understand even less than I do Bowie, and yet here they were, mixed together, and it just made sense to me, even though I can't really explain why. 

You can tell I don't know anything about jazz because I used the word "freeform" above, but the more I think about it, I wouldn't consider this type of jazz freeform. It might even be the opposite—the form here is rock solid. The rhythm section—Tim Lefebvre on bass and Mark Guiliana on drums—are so busy all over these tracks, and yet are still able to hold the whole thing in place. Meanwhile, Donny McCaslin is playing sax like a fucking wild man. I have never heard or even heard of any of these guys, but they make this album what it is. 

Well, Bowie does too. I don't want to give all the credit away. There are moments when Bowie feels like he's in a completely different universe and he's bringing me along for the ride—those "Woo!"s on "'Tis a Pity She Was a Whore" are a thrill every time—which is a feeling that everyone claims they have had with Bowie but I had never experienced before. There are other moments when Bowie feels like the same old kook whom I've always known and never really understood—talking gibberish (sorry, Nadsat, ugh) on "Girl Loves Me," dropping his phone in the toilet and looking for "ass" on "Lazarus"—moments that still work, but only because they are against the backdrop of jazz so wild that I can't even remember Miles Davis' name half the time.

I talked a lot about Bowie that weekend with friends and family, because I was excited! It had felt like I was finally given the key to this vast city of knowledge that had been previous obscured from my view. The David Bowie! 68 years old and with a new album! An album that made sense to me! One that I already loved! On Saturday night, I was chilling with Dave, and we talked about it. On Sunday, I was with my in-laws, happy to discuss music from an artist they had actually heard of.

By Monday morning, David Bowie was dead.

The spectre of death already rested comfortably over Blackstar as a whole, so of course an actual death of the actual artist is going to change the narrative. It was no longer a late-career gem, but instead a straight-up swan song. The skronking of the saxophone was no longer Bowie's life force, it was now a funeral pyre. Lines like "Something happened on the day he died..." from the title track were all of a sudden seen as prophetic. I've written before about albums that take on a new meaning when their creators pass away, but this all took the idea to the extreme.

It affected my own personal relationship with the album for sure. I think it I had a gun to my head, I would choose Blackstar as my favorite Bowie album (that I'm familiar with so far), but that's a really uncomfortable opinion to have now that this is the album that Bowie released 48 hours before dying, and I don't try to spread it around too often. It would be like saying that your favorite memory of your friend was the day you saw them in a casket at their funeral. Even if it's perversely true, then that means your relationship with that person was fucked up when you were both alive, and so why are you even at the funeral at the first place?

So I try to pay my respects to one of the only versions of Bowie I know and love by listening to Blackstar every once in a while, and then shutting the fuck up about it. And I'm still out there, trying to figure out who this man was when he was still making music. What is it about the Shadow Man that draws people to him? And what am I missing?

There's still so much to examine in this discography. But I have faith that eventually, I'll find some late career deep cut that is going to resemble Blackstar in some way, and I'll be able to at least tether some appreciation to a part of Bowie's legacy that isn't so macabre.

~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, then try this song: "Sue (or in a Season of Crime)"


~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • I went back and read a few reviews of Blackstar from when it first came out, to see how weirdly they read before Bowie passed away, and holy shit, I completely forgot that this is how the Pitchfork review started: "David Bowie has died many deaths yet he is still with us." I wonder if the writer of that review ever wonders if he murdered David Bowie.
  • I linked to the Life Aquatic interview above, and I'll link to the Prestige interview as well, since I discuss a little Bowie in each. I made it clear in those interviews, and I'll underline the point here—I don't think Bowie is a bad musician. I think he's really good, and I enjoy a lot of his music. I just have an issue with the fact that the general consensus is that he is an unimpeachable genius, and from what I've heard so far, I cannot imagine how we arrived there.
  • ALBUM COVER: Jonathan Barnbrook is the artist on this one, as well as all four of Bowie's final albums. However, the art is credited to "NASA," for reasons that are both obvious and mysterious. Also, fun fact, it took me until right this second to understand that the star fragments below the big star are supposed to spell out "BOWIE."
  • ALBUM NAME: It is unknown if this is why Bowie named it this, but apparently a "black star lesion" is a term for a type of lesion related to cancer, which Bowie died of. Death is sincerely all around you when you're listening to this album.
  • Oh, also, the official title of this album is not "Blackstar," but instead a literal picture of a star, like an emoji. I don't abide by that. I am all about fidelity when it comes to tagging artist names, album names, etc., but I have my limits. 
  • CHARTS: Blackstar hit #1 on the Billboard 200 on 1/30/16. Shit, when was the last time an album in this column hit #1? Fucking ever? I know it was fueled by his death, but still. Better yet: It beat out the milquetoast snoozefest of Adele's 25. Interestingly, Bowie's greatest hits collection was #4 this week as well. I guess the rest of the American public can't agree on what constitutes a good Bowie album either.
  • PREVIOUSLY ON PoYB: I had ranked Blackstar the #5 best album of 2016, which, I dunno, seems a little high? But looking at the rest of the list, I could see it maybe dropping to #6 or #7 at worst. "'Tis a Pity She Was a Whore" was #11 on the 2016 songs list, and got an Honorable Mention in the decades countdown.
  • I've gone back and forth as to whether I should be uncomfortable with the subject matter on "'Tis a Pity," or at least the title, but I think at this point I agree with Stereogum's Tom Breihan, who describes it as "a song that doesn’t even qualify as problematic because who in the fuck even knows what it’s about."
  • Bowie indicated that Kendrick Lamar's To Pimp a Butterfly was a big inspiration for the music on Blackstar. Sure, they both feature some pretty bugged-out jazz theatrics, but the two albums feel opposite to me in ways that I might have trouble articulating. To attempt—the jazz on Blackstar is essential to its being, as they are one in the same; the jazz on TPaB exists more like a hurdle for Kendrick to clear as he achieves his goals.
  • More trivia regarding other musicians besides Bowie: I just read a couple weeks ago the Stereogum interview with Win Butler, who drops a pretty interesting Bowie/Blackstar-related anecdote. Ctrl+F that shit.
  • I keep getting stuck on the final line of the album: "I can't give everything away." What a cryptic way to end your life and your career. I could come up with at least three different interpretations as to what that could mean.
 
NEXT TIME: b'lieve i'm goin down by Kurt Vile