Showing posts with label Stephan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stephan. Show all posts

Friday, July 18, 2025

Sun Coming Down, Stephan


I want to like this album more, especially because of the comparison to Talking Heads of whom I have recently become a fan. However, unlike TH, I found very little that would make me want me to continue exploring Ought's discography or revisit Sun Coming Down. The shortlist of pros include the lead singer's unique vocals and spoken-word delivery, decent pace of the album, and the track, "Beautiful Blue Sky," which definitely deserves the high praise that it garnered. Other than that, very little else stood out to me. The band's collective sound is fine. The song lyrics, when I can understand them, are fine.  I'll file this post-punk experience away as just fine, but not quite my jam. 

3 ou(gh)t of 5 BB Skies

Friday, June 27, 2025

For Melancholy Brunettes (& sad women), Stephan


It's been a crazy busy week, so I didn't have much time to really sit with and absorb For Melancholy Brunettes (& sad women). Instead, this played in the background of the work chaos. Very little of the album grabbed my attention enough to impart a lasting impression. However, that's not to say that I think it's bad.

On the pro side, while not very powerful or long-ranged, I found Michelle Zauner's vocals to be very soothing and lullabic. The sweetness of her voice, complemented by each tracks' composition, provided a kind of lyrical lo-fi vibe that was different than the indie experience I was expecting, but welcome and very much needed in the moment.

On the con side, there were two things I did not like. First, it's kind of boring and monotonous. Most of the songs sounded and felt indistinguishable from one another. Two, though more like 1b, is Jeff Bridges. The only real deviation from the aforementioned sameness in the form of a duet pulled my attention for the wrong reasons. Though I didn't initially know it was Jeff Bridges, the male harmony out of nowhere in "Men in Bars" was very surprising, almost jarring.  He's not a terrible vocalist, but I don't think he and Michelle blended well at all. Sadly, it's the only song that managed to stick with me.

My biggest takeaway from this experience was that sometimes music might not give you want, but give what you need. I wanted a more meaningful musical experience, but I desperately needed something to help center me. Jeff Bridges aside, this album allowed me to do just that. 

2.75 out of 5 men in bars

Thursday, June 19, 2025

Never Seen It #224: Seven Samurai

But then who made them such beasts? You did! You bloggers did it! You burn their villages! Destroy their farms! Steal their food! Watch 400 movies you've never seen before! Force them to labour! Take their women! And kill them if they resist! So what should farmers do?


Seven Samurai
1954
Akira Kurosawa

Thanks for Group A for coming out to add to the discussion for this week's movie. Good news! There are seven of us this week. Hop down into the comments to discuss which of the seven contributors this week is which of the seven samurai.

~~~~~~~~~

Vinny

This one gets a 4 out of 5 from me.

It's impossible to overstate how influential this movie was on modern filmmaking and narrative storytelling, and similarly impossible to separate the movie itself from its outsized reputation. But I'll try. I gotta admit that I love Kurosawa, so I'm a little biased about this one. 

I love the way he takes time to sketch out each of the main samurai's personalities, especially 
Kikuchiyo. You start to understand the characters' motivations beyond just wanting free millet for their troubles. 

And speaking of Kikuchiyo, his death really bummed me out, and reinforced the film's final message of the victory being only the peasants'. 

The love story between the little rich boy and the peasant girl was a little forced, in my opinion. If it had been cut, the movie would've been fine. Conversely, I loved the foreshadowing of the one villager reacting so violently when someone mentions his wife, and the payoff of him seeing her again in the bandit camp. 

My favorite aspect of this movie, however, is the cinematography. Those long, lingering, and sweeping shots of the landscape and the way the camera pauses on actors' reactions is nothing short of art. 

If I had to criticize one thing, I'd take issue with the length. The movie really, really drags in the middle, and I often found myself questioning why certain dialogue and plot points were seemingly repeated. But then again, maybe that's my cellphone-addled brain demanding more dopamine from shorter and concise stories, which usually come at the expense of character building. 

If you like Westerns, as I do, you'll love this movie, which feels like a primordial form of later movies to come in the '60s, '70s and beyond.

~~~~~~~~~~~

Allison

Not exactly a hot take, but I generally have a problem with movies that are over two hours long. Maybe it's my waning attention span from my crippling phone addiction, but if you can't tell a story in 120 minutes, maybe you're not a good storyteller. The Wolf of Wall Street is 180 minutes long (groan), Oppenheimer is 181 long (grooan), "The Snyder Cut" is 242 minutes long (grooaaaan); at a certain point, it's just vanity. Pay your editors! Cut down your movies!

That said, at 207 minutes long (with an intermission; why did we ever stop doing that?), Seven Samurai did not feel excessive. I wouldn't exactly describe myself as "engrossed," but I was definitely engaged. I even managed to put my phone down and refrained from Googling a single thing during our viewing. Now, this is quite a feat, considering I could not have known less about this movie, genre, culture, or time period if I tried. Japanese cinema of the 1950s, referencing Japanese culture of the 1500s—two huge, gaping blind spots. So, it's hard for me to judge a film when I have nothing to compare it to.

It is obviously an immensely impactful film. Seven Samurai's influence is so evident that the movie feels at times clichéd. This movie invented the idea of assembling a team to kick ass; without it, movie theaters would have been wiped out in the mid-2010s. I'm interested in seeing more of Kurosawa's work, especially his other collaborations with Toshiro Mifune, who plays the unhinged and often ass-out Kikuchiyo. While I don't consume much Japanese media, I instantly recognized his exaggerated mannerisms as typical anime characteristics. I would also be interested in learning more about Bokuzen Hidari, whose portrayal of Yehei, the human grimace emoji, absolutely tickled me every time he was on screen.

I liked it, I'm glad I watched it, but I probably won't watch it again.

One unanswered question remains: what's so bad about millet?

3.5/5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Brianna

Seven Samurai: a film often regarded as one of the most influential in cinematic history, watched as (I'm sure) director Akira Kurosawa always imagined—in 45 minute intervals on my school laptop during the last week of school. 

In a way, I feel like I may have done the film a disservice by watching it in this way. The movie theater enthusiast in me can imagine how much more enthralling the tale would have been in a larger scale format. I feel certain that the b&w film and the subtitles would have kept my attention better at least. Getting through this thing was a struggle.

Not to say that I didn't enjoy it. I did! A good deal actually once everything started to come together. A mix of classic movie plot points with feudal Japan as a backdrop, there was a lot in there that I appreciated. I chalk my struggle up to my busy week rather than the movie itself.

With Shōgun's recent time in the spotlight still lingering in my brain, historical Japan specifically remained intriguing to me in many ways as I began my time with Samurai. To be honest, I was a little surprised to find that these two stories take place in roughly the same time period, but after sitting with it for a while, it does make sense. 

Shōgun is a story of the feudal lords, where wealth and status demands rigorous following of the culture norms. Respect for word and language seemed to drive almost every interaction. Seven Samurai is about those on the direct opposite of this social system, the peasant farmer. In this world, poverty and survival are at the helm and decorum is less stringent. 

And yet these world's coexist, as they do today, and often impact each other. I mean, would the farming village be in the position they were in with the roaming bandits if the shoguns were not too busy fighting each other to take care of those on their lands? The rich and powerful fight their wars and the common people struggle because of it. 

We see a lot of this struggle in the movie. Poverty at its cruelest, war at its least humane. Somehow in the midst of it, you have these Seven Samurai who are willing to fight against that. They're endearing from the start in that way. Who doesn't want to root for the hero looking out for the common folk? 

4 out of 5 Pukes!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stephan

— Swords are cool... but never bring a sword to a gunfight. I'm sure having multiple samurai die at the hands of a musket-wielding marksman is a commentary on modern technology and obsolescence of samurai culture, but I would have preferred less gunplay and more sword fighting because, frankly, swords are badass.

— Very effective cinematic techniques—Kurosawa artfully captured the chaotic nature of battle. The choreography is a bit unpolished—deliberately so, in my opinion, but it is still very thrilling and well-executed.

— Standout performance: the obvious standout here is Toshiro Mifune, who plays Kikuchiyo.  He delivers a layered and thoughtful performance. It's the best written and fully developed character in the film, and Toshiro is giving a 100% effort. He makes me genuinely interested in watching more of his films. 10/10. 

— Balance: One of Seven Samurai's strengths lies in how well it balances drama with humor. It's obviously not an overt comedy, but I like that it has small moments of humor and doesn't take itself too seriously all the time. The use of big, overexaggerated facial expressions/movements and lightly comedic situations makes the film feel less heavy. In particular, the samurai recruitment scene where Kambei has Katsushirō stand by an entryway and attempt to strike a prospective ally. This reminded me of some anime in which absolute silliness is thrown into the middle of an otherwise dark and/or serious situation.

— Lengthy runtime: no movie should exceed the three-hour mark. My wandering mind can't focus that long.

— Lackluster endings for the samurai: I don't need a ceremonious ending for all of the samurai, but not a single one gets a satisfying end. Heihachi, the first to die, is fatally shot and killed. Not only does it happen so quickly that it's unclear what has transpired, it's completely overshadowed by Rikichi's hysterics in response to his wife's death. Gorōbei is killed off-camera. And, Kyūzō and Kikuchiyo suffer the same fate as Heihachi—death by musket. The movie denies the viewer time to mourn. Even the remaining samurai get very little out of their victory. Katsushirō doesn't get the girl in the end. Shichirōji remains useless—he is truly forgettable and gave very little. And, Kambei, who should at least feel a sense of pride for fulfilling his duty to the villagers, says "the farmers won, not us." The farmer's gain greatly outweighed their sacrifice, whereas the samurai sacrificed greatly with little return and no progress in the long run. The surviving samurai return to their ronin state, directionless and masterless.  All of this is likely curated by Kurosawa to highlight the futility and cyclical nature of war, but I would have liked ONE happy end for the heroes. 

Rating: 3.8 out of 5 bowls of rice (fuck millet!)

~~~~~~~~~~~

Zach

For a movie that came out in 1954, I was surprised at how modern it felt. The way the characters talked to each other at times felt like it was straight out of the therapy playbook. I can't keep track of all the specific characters and names, but here are a few examples: 
  • Two of the samurai talking to each other. One is bottling up his feelings. The other calls him over. "Unburden yourself," he says.
  • Kikuchiyo cradling the baby in his arms. "That baby is me," he said. Such emotional depth that I wouldn't expect from the post-World War II era. Maybe Japan had a head start on that that the US didn't have because it was forced to reckon with total devastation at home after the war.
  • Katsushirō saying to Kyūzō, after he retrieves the musket, "you are a magnificent person!" Again, a deep emotional relationship.
The way the movie treated the love story between Katsushirō and Shino also felt very modern. We saw Shino being beaten by her father, and we thought it would just be a typical old-school dead in the water story, Romeo and Juliet style, where two star-crossed lovers cannot be together. But no! We have a character talk to the father. "These things happen," he essentially says. True love winning out against tradition! Color me surprised for a movie from the '50s.

If I felt like getting into historical significance, I would look at the rice vs. millet conversation, and the significance of each. I couldn't focus on every detail of this movie, though. There were just so many. I have to give the movie credit. For three and a half hours, it never felt too long to me. If anything, it ended abruptly. It still meant I couldn't focus on everything.

There were a few other elements I wanted to highlight, though. The role of laughter was interesting. The Japanese laugh is different from the American one. It's mocking, a little bit. It doesn't always mean they think it's funny. (Although the joke that Kambei made about Katsushirō now being a "real man" was a sick burn, on par with the comedy roasts you'll see on Comedy Central today.) There was also a ton of running in this movie. Why did everyone always run after each other? What's it trying to say? It definitely contributed to the sense of urgency in the movie. It also felt funny. Did they use stunt doubles in this movie? If not, that's a very demanding role for the characters. It was a well-cast movie, and everyone played their role so, so well.

Yohei might have been my favorite character. His faces were so absurd and incredible. His death could have been prevented, but he also had to die. The camera focused too much on him for anything else to happen. He was cute, sweet. I liked him. The relationship between Kikuchiyo and Yohei was a beautiful one.

"Are we all going to die tomorrow?" Shino asks. "There's no way to know. But we might!" Kikuchiyo responds. I wish I could internalize that more. Even in times when death is closer than others, I wish I could internalize that more.

GRADE: 4.5 out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Catherine

Despite my attempts at neutrality, Seven Samurai's reputation was harder to escape than a ronin's blade, so I found it difficult to get out of my head while watching. Almost every scene transition had me wondering if the film was living up to the immense title of greatest movie of all time. I know that assessment isn't helpful until AFTER you've seen the movie, if ever, but I couldn't help it. It reminded me of finally seeing the Sistine Chapel in person after years of studying photographs. Expectations through the roof, I prepared for an experience that would change me in a profound way, and somehow it didn't quite live up to that fantasy—but how could it?

Scrolling through Reddit hoping to inherit a perspective, I stumbled across this argument: 

A lot of the times people bag on the "classics" (in any media, really) I feel like this is the root of the problem. Something that has established so many genre conventions we are used to now and been borrowed from so many times by other works has a tendency to not seem remarkable at all to modern viewers.

To be clear, I'm not "bagging" on Samurai, but it is difficult to transport your 2025 self to 1956 for a whole three hours and 27 minutes (butwhoscounting). This is a film I very much appreciated and probably will never watch again which is a fact I don't want to be true. I want to be an insatiable cinephile that can hold court at a party and explain why Kurosawa was the best to ever do it. Something about telephoto lenses! Multiple cameras! Interchanging slow motion and regular speed! I want to want to watch this "masterpiece" 100 times and get something new out of every go-around, but there are only so many hours in a lifetime and I simply cannot play fast and loose with my time like that—unless it's on reruns of Frasier or Forensic Files or Gilmore Girls or scrolling through my cursed telephone for hours on end. While I struggle with my own movie-related self-image, here are some things I definitely without a doubt LIKED about this movie:
  • For an epic, the plot is refreshingly simple. Roving bandits threaten to raid a village of farmers (giving them until their next harvest, in an oddly reasonable move for career criminals), then a very specific number of samurai step in to save the day. Got it.
  • I was moved by the samurai's incredible sense of honor, laying down their lives for no reward but service to society—all while fighting with their entire butts out, Winnie the Pooh style.
  • Seven Samurai apparently directly inspired A Bug's Life, which directly inspired A Bug's Land at Disney World which indirectly inspired me to throw up as a child, a very formative experience for me. In this regard, Seven Samurai has shaped me more than any other film.
  • Nearly every frame of this movie makes for such an incredible photograph that I'd like to paper my walls with it. A world-weary samurai surrounded by a bed of daisies. A withered old man meditating in front of a water mill. Breathtaking.
As a rube, the classics can sometimes feel like homework to me, but this one is undeniably important. Above all, I'm excited to finally recognize its impact on other films that I've missed until now, which seems crucial. Like finishing your vegetables so you can scarf down your tooth-rotting Marvel cinematic desert.

Rating: 4 out of 5 hidden barrels of sake

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

I'm sure everybody's gonna talk about the length, and why wouldn't we? This was a long-ass movie. Too long. We can all agree there. Pam and I had to spend three nights watching it, and it was only three because I had Father's Day to press her to finish the second half that night, like "c'mon, it's Father's Day, you have to stay awake." (There's a good chance that this film made her quit Film Club.) We can talk about what could be cut to make this a tight 150 minutes. There's a lot! Maybe you don't need endless scenes of some dude trying to make sure his daughter stays a virgin! I get it. I get your frustration. I was right there with ya. But I think that it might be helpful to look at it from a viewpoint of: it was long, so let's talk about what was great about it, and try our hardest to justify the length, even if many of us in our heart of hearts know it's just not true.

One thing I'll mention right here at the beginning is that I like the second half a lot more than the first half, which dragged a little bit. But let's think about this. I have read that Seven Samurai basically invented the whole "let's build a team of heroes to defeat the villain" trope. It feels like such a basic and ubiquitous premise that it's kind of insane to think that it hasn't always existed. (Being told Seven Samurai invented the team-up action movie feels like being told that the dude from Yankee Doodle Dandy wrote "You're a Grand Old Flag.")

But let's take Ebert et al. at their word for this. Seven Samurai is inventing tropes, in real time. And so I think some optimism might be that the film needed just a little extra time to put the tropes into existence, since it was the first time, and they weren't tropes yet. I think I'm making sense? Maybe not. Think about how much time a dumb Marvel movie would need to explain that they were gathering superheroes to form a team to defeat the bad guy. Basically none, right? Because you know what they are doing. There's a shorthand. But not with Seven Samurai. You can't use shorthand because this sort of thing has never been done.

Because Seven Samurai did it so well and so particularly, you basically see hundreds or even thousands of action movies do the same exact thing over 70+ years. You can talk about direct references (The Magnificent Seven, a remake that somehow did not make the Film Club list, so we'll have to save it for the Expansion Pack in 2027), you can talk about major influence (George Lucas was very upfront about Seven Samurai influencing Star Wars), you can talk about oblique trope use (the aforementioned superhero movies, the mentioned-too-often Fast and Furious movies, etc.). Seven Samurai is here, blazing the path that so many others would walk. Of course that's gonna take more time. You gotta explain to the audience (through showing, through telling) what is happening here!

The pop culture relic that was on my mind as I witnessed Seven Samurai unfold was Game of Thrones. A clear influence on that TV show, mostly in the way that a battle is planned, and then enacted on the screen in grand scale. I was thinking about the battle at King's Landing, with Tyrion coming up with a plan and then the thousands of anonymous extras carrying out that plan. That felt like what I saw here, with the samurai leader Kambei stoically leading the "good guys" to victory through meticulous planning and lots of courage.

I put "good guys" in quotes, because I think Seven Samurai does a good job in giving that phrase nuance. Depending on how you view it, this might be the most important through line of the film—the line between good and evil is often blurred. The farmers initially fear the samurai because samurai have throughout history destroyed the farmers' way of life. The farmers initially hide from the bandits but then all rush out to kill one, but only once he is captured. The samurai are hired hands and have to earn their skin in the game. The farmers dismiss them once the task is complete, despite the heavy casualties. The bandits themselves are former samurai, and choose to continue to attack the village instead of retreating. The 16th-century Japanese caste system makes it difficult for all these folks to work together in the first place. It's all pretty complicated! And yet, for the most part, we get to see the joys of people from different walks of life coming together for a common, and noble, cause. It's no wonder to me that the trope of "bringing the team together" took off like it did.

There's no segue into this, I just need to write about it before I end my piece: shoutout to Kikuchiyo for being fucking hilarious. I did NOT expect to be laughing during this movie, but Toshiro Mifune is clearly an incredibly talented actor, and brought so much to this fucking role (after the credits rolled, HBO Max recommended four movies, and all four had a picture of Mifune on the cover, including Rashomon, which I didn't realize the connection until that moment). The part where he took the battle gear of the bandits and sat next to one of them to steal his gun was a hoot. The gag with him riding the horse behind a wall and then the horse emerging on the other side sans Kikuchiyo was priceless. Then, of course, his turn from comedic relief to hero was memorable (another trope created here, I'm sure). The whole thing with his love/hate relationship with Yohei and then both of them finding the best of themselves in each other's bravery... I mean, that's the shit I watch movies for.

Being a long movie, there is just so goddamn much to discuss, but let's see what everyone else thought first.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 3.9 pukes out of 5

Thanks again to all those who joined us today. If you're reading this, come down to the comments and continue the discussion!

(NEXT TIME: We hop aboard the Russian Ark for a tracking shot.)

Thursday, May 8, 2025

Never Seen It #210: Mommie Dearest

"Why can't you give me the respect that I'm entitled to? Why can't you treat me like I would be treated by any stranger on the street? One who would be watching 400 movies they've never seen before?" "Because I am NOT one of your BLOGGERS."


Mommie Dearest
1981
Frank Perry

A huge thank you to Small Group A, who bit the bullet and put together our first all-online movie discussion for Film Club. Everyone in the group who saw the movie wrote a little something about it. I've compiled them all below. Let us know what you think in the comments. I'll be down there, trying to stir some more conversation. There's a lot to talk about!

~~~~~~~~~~

Vinny

Overall, I'd give this one a solid 4.5. It's an extremely uncomfortable movie to watch; you spend the entire time actively hating the main character, and rooting against her horrible actions.

I will say that I enjoyed how the film was made, particularly the cinematography. There is great foreshadowing about how tumultuous Joan Crawford's mental state is, including from the very first scene, which is essentially the morning routine from American Psycho, but for 1930s Hollywood starlets. Not to mention her overbearing OCD when it comes to cleaning her house.

Faye Dunaway is shot like a horror villain in some scenes, particularly the "no wire hangers" freakout. It's a little ham-fisted, but I think it works overall for what they're trying to convey: how aggressive, strict parents can look like monsters to little kids.

The acting is probably the weakest part of the movie. A lot of the lines are delivered like soap opera melodrama, but, again, I think it fits with the theme of mentally ill, extremely narcissistic people.

It's hard for me to too harshly judge the story since, ya know, it really happened. 

I will say that the final quarter of the movie, when Crawford seems to rekindle her relationship with her mother, only to have her steal her part on a soap opera, would've been a stroke of brilliant writing, if it wasn't something Crawford really did to her daughter.

I'll admit this movie made me pretty depressed, as someone about to have a kid. It reminds me how badly equipped some people are to be parents. 

If nothing else, I can use this as an example of what not to do.

GRADE: 2.5 out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Catherine

I made the mistake of reading Roger Ebert's Mommie Dearest review before I watched the film and quips like "painful experience" "unremittingly depressing" and "who wants to watch this?" rapidly deflated my excitement as I smeared on my clay face mask and poured a glass of wine to start this journey. Despite catching a meme or two over the years, I was somehow unaware of MD's critical reception and cult classic status. I've always assumed it was just noteworthy for being an unprecedented takedown of a Hollywood icon, nothing more. NOW I GET IT.

Sorry to speak ill of the dead, but Mr. Ebert, you're a fucking idiot. Half-joking, of course, since it's definitely bad from a filmmaking standpoint if you're into coherent plots and character development and that kind of thing, but, with the exception of The Room, I've never known a movie to miss the mark so spectacularly that it launches itself into the cultural stratosphere, nestling into our psyches forevermore—like reaching down to pick up a quarter and tripping headfirst into a gold mine (if that gold mine also tanked your career... sorry, Faye Dunaway).

Gun to my head, I could not define "camp" (and I'm not going to read that Susan Sontag essay, so don't tell me to), but I know this is peak camp. I can feel it in my bones. What a feat to crank out scene after scene after scene of unimaginable cruelty and child abuse and leave the audience absolutely tickled. Of course, if you watch the movie as the director intended—like that nerd Ebert—there's nothing funny about it and you'd have to be a monster to be amused, but I think that's what's so special about it: it awakened a fan base of like-minded weirdos, mischievous and macabre. This could be the postmodern irony talking, but rather than writing a review of how the Minecraft movie stinks, isn't it more fun to scream and whoop and throw popcorn when you hear "Chicken Jockey!" because you're aware everything is stupid and it feels powerful and freeing to laugh in the face of pandering and faux sincerity? Can we have a nice time, please? Anyway, eat shit, Roger.

GRADE: 4 out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~

Stephan

I expected Mommie Dearest to be a melodramatic and entertaining trainwreck. While very heavy on the melodrama, this movie is far from entertaining. If not for Film Club, I likely wouldn't have finished this film. Most of the performances are devoid of life. The exceptions here are Faye Dunaway and Diana Scarwid. While certainly full of life, Dunaway's wild portrayal of Joan Crawford delivers an unhinged, over-the-top performance that lacks any sort of depth or nuance. Though I know very little about the real Joan Crawford, I know there was evidence to suggest that perhaps she may have struggled with an undiagnosed personality disorder. Be it the writing or Dunaway herself, the depiction of mental illness here is not reflective of lived experiences of those with similar conditions. What could have been a very interesting and compelling film about mental health and its impact on family dynamics, the film chooses instead to depict Crawford as deranged and narcissistic in a way that lacks humanism.

Turning to Diana Scarwid's performance, I actually think that her acting was pretty solid. The main problem for me was the poor character development. Because of its vignette style, the movie never truly builds characters and relationships. It's usually just here are characters in conflict at a moment in time, now on to the next without much consideration for or reflection on what previously transpired. As it relates to Christina's relationship with Joan, the movie leaves so much to be assumed about their relationship, which, yes, is obviously complicated. But the film could have done much more to show and explore its complexities.

A couple final and random thoughts on the movie:
  • What's with the timeline of events here? In particular, early in the film, young Christopher ages five years, while Christina hasn't aged at all.
  • Speaking of Christopher, we're going to show him being strapped to bed at night with absolutely no context??
  • The scenes of child abuse without any sort of character motivation make me feel disconnected from the characters, which, in turn, elicits no emotional response. Though I am probably more desensitized by this kind of content than most, it's absolutely crazy to feel nothing when watching a mom whale on (wail on?) her child. That's an issue with the movie, not with me!
  • Diana Scarwid looks and sounds a lot like Laura Linney to me, who I love. So, score another point for Scarwid.
In conclusion, this film did not do it for me.

GRADE: 1 wire hanger out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~

Pam

I don't think I'm the only one whose frame of reference for Mommie Dearest is very narrowly based on the various references made to it on RuPaul's Drag Race. I was always aware of the "NO WIRE HANGERS" quote, but without any context. But otherwise, my knowledge of Joan Crawford was pretty slim. 

I liked Mommie Dearest. For starters, give me a taste of old Hollywood and I'm content. The costumes, the makeup, the sets, the way in which Faye Dunaway speaks when playing Joan Crawford—it's alluring. 

On the other hand, as a parent—and I knew this was going to happen—it was a bit of a tough watch at times. Not only due to the child abuse, which was pretty shocking, but also because there were moments that I understood Joan Crawford in the tiniest of ways. Have I brushed my kids' hair a little too hard because they were fighting me the whole time? Probably. Have I perhaps flipped out at Joe because the bed wasn't made perfectly? Check. (I was pregnant, I'm cutting myself some slack on that one.) 

I think Christina Crawford is smart. And the movie makers were smart. And there is no truer statement than saying that women have complicated relationships with their mothers. Christina Crawford hated her mother, but she also loved her. I think the acceptance speech she gives at the end is telling of this, and I believe this is how she wanted her mother to be portrayed. Not as a hero or a villain. 

I think this is what I like so much about Mommie Dearest. Was Joan Crawford a monster at times? For sure. With her night cream caked on her face, she literally looked like a monster during the NO WIRE HANGERS scene. But she had her shining moments as well. Did she work insanely hard to end up being fucked over by the same people (men) who referred to her as "Hollywood Royalty"? Like, yes, her reactions to that were extreme, but also... were they? I'll be honest, I was pretty happy to root for her during the "DON'T FUCK WITH ME, FELLAS" Pepsi board of directors scene. 

I think Mommie Dearest is about way more than a mother and a daughter. It almost reminds me of The Substance. Like, let's see just how much ugliness comes between women in these types of situations. I'm glad to have finally seen this movie. I feel like I'm always way off with these things, so I'm really looking forward to reading everyone else's thoughts on Mommie D!

GRADE: 5 out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Zach

I know movies don't always exist to make us feel good about ourselves. Movies that are too feel-good or too cheesy don't appeal to me. We can be excited, we can get into a good story, one that feels real. In the best of worlds, movies should tell a story that resonates.

There's nothing wrong with the movie Mommie Dearest being made. The movie couldn't be more real. It's based on a true story. But there was a point, about halfway through this movie, that I thought about turning it off. It was making me physically ill. I was trying to eat a grapefruit, but I felt incredibly sick. There was something about the scene where Joan gets mad about the wire hangers made me feel so awful that I really didn't want to continue.

And some might say that's a good thing. It's making me feel something. But I can't say I enjoyed this movie. That doesn't mean it's a bad movie. Faye Dunaway is pretty incredible as an actor. But her character doesn't have a lot of complexity in that she seems to be entirely a villain. Yes, there are scenes that I think are meant to make you feel sympathetic to the relationship between Joan and Christina. When she comes by her apartment, for instance, and gives her "support" for her budding acting career. Anything good Christina does for Joan is just to feed Joan's massive ego or anything else. 

I can't tell if Christina has any bone in her body that actually likes her mother, or if it's entirely an act when she smiles at her and acts excited when she calls. When she tells her she loves her, is there something real there? It's that lack of clarity that makes Christina a much more complex character than her mother. Her mother is simply pure evil. It's hard to think of a redeeming quality for her mother.

And that's partially what made the movie hard to watch. She's a horrible person, without much more to her. Can a movie character really be this bad?

I think if this movie sheds light on abuse—as I'm sure it did in its time, when abuse was less discussed—then it might have been worth making. But I would never watch it again. I want to run far away from it. It was disturbing and I felt awful after watching it.

I will say the last line delivered by Christina, after Christopher said their mother got the last word—"does she?"—sent chills down my spine. It's a meta moment, one that is self-referential to the film and the book on which it was based. And I am very happy Christina got her moment. Her mother's reputation is ruined, and deservedly so.

GRADE: 2 out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Allison

Everything I knew about this movie, I learned from drag queens, and I wish I had kept it that way. I was looking forward to watching Mommie Dearest until I really thought about it and remembered that the most well-known and quoted scene is a depiction of horrific child abuse. Fun! God, it's hard to enjoy things in 2025. Unsurprisingly, the movie didn't live up to my camp-classic expectations. Melodramatic interpretations of mental health and child abuse aside (not to mention my own complicated feelings about my relationship with my mother, but this isn't YSC, so let's move past it), this movie is just bad. Faye Dunaway truly thought she was going to win an Oscar for this. Barbara, please! Even if this is an accurate portrayal of Crawford (which it isn't, according to the real-life Christina Crawford), it is too over-the-top and too unhinged to be seen as anything other than a grotesque caricature. Dunaway had the look down, but I give most of the credit to the costume, hair, and makeup departments. I did love the get-ready-with-me / morning-shed-vibe opening scene. You heard it here first: TikTok beauty influencers are ripping off Joan Crawford.

Both young and old Christinas give surprisingly compelling performances despite the script actively working against them. Mara Hobel (young Christina) has a quiet and measured sass, making her a worthy opponent against Dunaway's unhinged Crawford. Old Christina, Diana Scarwid (25 at the time), is a convincing mildly rebellious teen despite her face looking the way it does. Once she's able to act her age, her performance breathes life into a weary second act as she tiptoes around her mother's accelerating insanity. However, the choice to only use two actresses paired with the loose storytelling makes it nearly impossible to understand the passing of time, when one actress plays a three-to-ten-year-old and the other plays a twelve-to-40-year-old. I know audiences watching this in the '80s couldn't actively research the accuracy of plot points, but this based-on-a-true-story biopic takes crazy liberties with the timeline. Young Christina remains frozen in time as brother Christopher goes from baby to toddler to adolescent. The movie spans nearly 40 years, but Joan barely ages, yet Renfield-esque Carol Ann has had the life force sucked out of her by the end.

Intentional segue to the true villain of the film, Carol Ann. She's not based on a real person, but rather a composite of housekeepers and assistants from Joan Crawford's life. That said, why was she portrayed as a brainwashed indentured servant? If Joan Crawford were Jim Jones, Carol Ann would be first in line for a glass of Flavor-Aid. If this was a film class, I might write about how Carol Ann represents the countless people in Crawford's life who enabled her mental illness and failed to protect her children, as well as a personification of the toxic celebrity culture of classic Hollywood. But I'd rather just ask, "Hey, what the fuck, Carol Ann?"

Ultimately, am I glad to finally have context for the "no wire hangers" scene? Not really!

GRADE: 2 out of 5 exasperated "Jesus Christ"s while sitting on the bathroom floor covered in soap powder.

~~~~~~~~~~~

Brianna

I had never heard of Mommie Dearest when Pam first offered the movie as an option, and I wanted to go in as blind as possible. With the way trailers are anymore, it was a rare opportunity to know almost nothing about the world I was about to step into, and so I stepped in with both feet. 

And holy shit. What a world, huh?

It was jarring, at first, to be thrust into such a whirlwind. Plot points fly by at such a rapid rate. In one scene, Joan (who I had known by name but nothing of her story) is rejected by the adoption agency, and in the next, her beau has wrangled up some kind of deal and the baby is arriving. A scene or two later, baby Christina is now a walking and talking child! 

It's straightforward enough to keep up with plot-wise, but I found myself wondering who exactly Joan was in the midst of her theatrics. It could've been my lack of context on the Crawford story, but I didn't really understand her motives. I suppose that could be the point. If this movie is based on Christina's memoirs, then the big fight scene (you know, the attempted murder by strangulation no one talks about again) could be the key to this. 

"Why did you adopt me?" 

The publicity, perhaps. The desire to be truly loved, sure. Joan didn't seem to know anymore, and Christina certainly didn't. So I'm led to believe the book, and then the movie by association, is an attempt to put a name to it all. Who was this lady and why did she do these, at times, awful things? 

Where the movie went wrong for me was the lack of any real effort into this attempt. It became more of a circus than a character study. And, like, an obviously abusive circus where the animals are all sad and/or ready to snap at any moment. Some of the scenes were painful to watch, and without any real contribution to our understanding of Joan other than: she's horrible!! What's the big problem with wire coat hangers anyway?

The saving grace of horrorshow was the acting itself, honestly. I know Faye Dunaway got a lot of shit for her over-the-top performance, but if there's a reason people are still talking about this movie today, it's her. Whether or not that was really who Joan Crawford was, the woman in this film is true villainy, and it was equal parts terrifying and awe inspiring to watch.

And that poor baby Tina!!

In the bathroom scene, when she's looking around at the mess, positively reeling in trauma and emotion now that Mommie Dearest has left the room. I had to pause the movie to see what kinds of awards this child went on to receive in life. It's none, by the way. A role in Broadway's infamous one-day Moose Murders, and a 2019 spot on Blue Bloods. Maybe she was too traumatized to continue down that road? I know I'd be. 

So where does that leave it? Too heavy of a story without the character depth to make it feel worth it, and yet enough star power to make it hard to look away.

GRADE: 2.5 of 5 Pukes!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

I don't think I've ever been so shocked to learn that a movie won Worst Picture at the Razzies. It honestly makes me hate the Razzies. I liked this movie a lot! Sure, it was over-the-top at points, but I saw that more like "hyperbole" than "camp." I believed what was happening in this movie. Yes, sure, I know now that this is barely non-fiction, that the truth of what actually happened was skewed slightly in Christina Crawford's memoir, and then morphed into a whole different thing in unfaithfully adapting that memoir. I don't care about what's real and what's not. I only care that, in the moment, as I'm experiencing that movie magic, I believe. I believed Mommie Dearest.

I don't give a shit that the real Tina has claimed that she was never actually beaten with a hanger. I was fully invested in that scene. It was like a horror film in moments like that. It's insane that anyone would accuse Faye Dunaway of "overacting" in that moment. That would be like accusing the actor who plays Jason Voorhees of overacting. That's the whole fucking point! You're supposed to be horrified!

And look, I'm not going to lie, I laughed a little bit at the beginning of that scene, when Joan made it clear that she was gonna go bugshit over the idea of her young daughter using a wire hanger to hang up her expensive dress. But the laughter faded quickly. If you're still laughing at this shit, then that just means you're uncomfortable with the idea of child abuse, and the need laughter as a defense mechanism. 36 hours before watching Mommie Dearest, I had to place a kid with a family member because her mom beat her with a belt. I don't think that mom was behaving like Joan Crawford with a wire hanger. I also believe with my whole heart that it probably felt that way anyway to the kid getting beat. So it's really just a matter of perspective, and you gotta remember the POV of this film (through the eyes of Christina, basically).

On the other hand: you're playing a losing game if you look at any adult with children, an adult real or fictional or a weird Joan/Faye combo of the two, and attempt to make a judgment on their parenting. It's pretty clear that Christina Crawford was abused by her mother. Maybe not in the exact way it is portrayed in the film adaptation of her memoir, but still, this is the point of the movie, and ostensibly the memoir. The abuse. A rough childhood. No, it's not right, but it's too easy to say that Joan Crawford (as portrayed in Mommie Dearest) was a shitty parent. Often, it's more complicated than that. She probably had some mental health stuff going on. She was clearly warped by the cold hard Hollywood film system and that warped too her perception of parenthood. And most importantly, who the fuck am I to judge? In what ways am I fucking up my children right now that will look TERRIBLE when one of their memoirs gets adapted into a major motion picture in 40 years?

I will say that it's bizarre to me that my first exposure to the existence of Mommie Dearest was a RuPaul Rusical in which the queens danced around with wire hangers. I assumed at the time that "wire hanger" was a reference to abortion, which would have been dark. But I'll argue that it's almost just as dark that drag queens were having fun dancing around and singing a song inspired by child abuse. I am more forgiving of the drag queen community than most, and I think this is another obvious example of "laughter as defense mechanism." But something about the idea of Mommie Dearest being considered "camp" sits really uneasily with me. Overacted or not, Christina's cries felt too real to me, and they are going to make me recoil the next time I hear a similar crying out in my own home.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 2.875 pukes out of 5

Thanks everybody! See you in the comments!

NEXT TIME: Might get to see some patriotic tapdancing when we watch Yankee Doodle Dandy.

Thursday, May 1, 2025

Never Seen It #208: Rear Window

He killed a dog last night because the dog was scratching around in the garden. You know why? Because he had watched 400 movies he'd never seen before.


Rear Window
1954
Alfred Hitchcock

Zoom: April 29, 2025, 9:00 PM to 10:10 PM EST

Participants: Allison, Batts, Brianna, Brittany, Frank, Joe, Kait, Pam, Pat, Sam, Sean E., Sean G., Stephan, Sunny, Walter

I tried to take notes during the Zoom meeting, and was inconsistent at best (I kept getting distracted by the good conversation). But here are some points and thoughts that I wrote down.
  • This is a movie about the audience, how it makes as a part of the action, and holds us accountable.
  • There have been so many Rear Window-type movies and references that it can be hard to view the original as "fresh"
  • How did the ending play to you? Did you think he was "crazy"? Should he have been?
  • Everything was intense, including the score (diegetic music)
  • Jefferies only got horny for Lisa when she was playing into his obsession
  • Was Jefferies supposed to be an asshole?
  • He's always viewed other people's stories through the lens, that's always been his thing.
  • This whole story is about a fear of commitment.
  • It was pointed out that the least erotic part of the movie involved the most touching (the massage).
  • Some brief information on the background of Alfred Hitchcock, how some elements were autobiographical or alluded to himself, the voyeurism etc.
  • Were you angry during this film?
  • A charge against Rear Window for being sexist.
  • The monologue about the dead dog is one of the only times that we "break the meta movie," i.e. the camera leaves the apartment and does close-ups of other characters
  • "Murder porn"
  • Does Thorwald entering the apartment break a fourth wall?
  • Lighting / the use of flashbulbs during the climax
  • The use of the camera in filmmaking as what controls how we view it, creates a box that we're in
  • The Hayes Code was still in effect until 1968, but its enforcement lessened throughout the '50s.
  • Interesting how thoroughly Stella gets roped in after being dismissive at first.
  • Is this a condemnation of being invested in other people's stories?
I'd love to hear some more thoughts, whether you couldn't make the Zoom meeting and have something to say, or you were there and some new ideas have sprouted in the past 36 hours.

Here is the full quote from the dog lady after the dog's death. This felt like the most poignant moment in the movie for me:

"Which one of you did it? Which one of you killed my dog? You don't know the meaning of the word 'neighbor.' Neighbors like each other, speak to each other, care if anybody lives or dies.

But none of you do! You don't talk, you don't help, you, you don't... even see. But I couldn't imagine any of you being so low that you'd kill a little helpless, friendly dog! The only thing in this whole neighborhood or liked anybody!

Did you kill him because he liked you? Just because he liked you?"

What grade would you give this? If that's the kind of thing you do. It is for me, so I'll give it a 4.5 pukes out of 5. I don't think that grade changes after talking about the movie, but it's a pretty strong 4.5. The ending just gives me pause—not that it's weak, per se, but more so that it confirms a pessimistic view of humanity that I've not fully bought into.

ANYWAYS, let's hear what you think.

Saturday, November 23, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 163: Joe

Prompt: "A song that reminds you of your favorite recipe"

Selected by Joe


"Cacao and Cocaine"
SOFIA ISELLA
I Can Be Your Mother EP, 2024

I can imagine that it takes great patience to be a baker. I mean, I've seen Great British Baking Show. I see what those hot British women and mopey crooked-toothed old British men are up to; they probably edit a whole lot, like I'm just imagining there is a lot of intricate details and a lot of waiting around and planning for the next steps and whatnot, which doesn't make for great TV.

I'm not a baker myself. I've baked, but I'm not a baker, if that makes sense. I don't take initiative with ingredients, I'm not creative in the kitchen, I just don't have the patience for it, maybe. I remember early on in my and Pam's relationship, I made an effort to make peanut butter rice krispie brownies, some recipe taken from the internet, like I was trying to show off for the in-laws or whatever. You know how that goes, during new love. I think they turned out okay? But I was just following a recipe. I didn't know what I was doing beyond that.

Which is totally fine—I mean, the aunts liked the brownies, so it really doesn't matter how the brownies got there or why, especially as this was years before I had to worry about peanut allergies in this family—but I am under the impression that to become a baker, either by trade or by hobby, there needs to be more than that. You need to be able to start understanding the why of the recipe. How it works. How chemicals and heat interact. Which requires patience, which I don't have.

Damn, though, I think it's such a worthy art. Baking a cake is akin to performing a song. You could just follow the directions, and things will most likely turn out fine. But those with the gift are able to perform their art with knowledge and finesse. The difference, I guess, is in the audience. I'd argue that it takes a lot of practice to be able to tell which is a good song and which is a bad song; there's some instinct involved, but it takes a lot of patience from the audience too to learn what they like and what they don't, and why. But with food, it's a little different. I can love a slice of cake just as much as a food critic. All I have to do is take a bite! I don't need to know why. I don't need to practice. I just fucking eat the cake and I enjoy the fucking cake. So what I'm saying is that it's much easier for the recipient of that art—the baked goods—to appreciate the art. And thus, we appreciate the baker.

I wonder how many people are reading these thoughts about good baking and thinking about our pal Stephan, who is a very good baker. (I would assume at least his wife is, as she's already written about this.) I know this because I have been the uninformed-but-appreciative audience for his art on multiple occasions. When you're at a friends gathering or book club or that kinda thing, you know to reach for the baked goods in the tupperware container with the blue lid. Stephan drunkenly told me one time that baking food for the people he cares about is his love language. I think about that a lot.

It's such a simple and effective way to give and receive love. That simple act of passing a homebaked good to a friend. "I did this for you." This thing that required patience, and skill, and care, and let's be honest here money, but also this deep desire to just create a simple happiness in this very effective way, it's all there in the cookie or brownie or tart. Maybe the most effective aspect to it is that the act of passing the baked good from baker to consumer is only a small peek into the window of the process as a whole. There's a bit of mystery there for the person eating it—"this is great, and so I wonder about how much time and care went into this thing?" Maybe more like: wonder, awe. You know it took a lot but you don't get to see, because the act of baking itself is private.

That is a type of privacy that I sometimes wonder about, but only because I myself seem to lack the need for it. I could maybe spend an hour in the kitchen if I needed to, but the privacy wouldn't be calming for me. I'd need loud music, I'd need an instructional video, I'd need my partner here to answer any dumb questions I have. And then, let's be real, if it went really well or even really poorly, that experience would most likely be turned into a blog post in one way or another. Because that's how I'm calmed—by stripping away the privacy, by exposing myself to the wider world, by saying "this is my true self" and shoving it in people's faces. I can imagine the audience for that is much less receptive than it would be for a tupperware full of immaculately baked goods.

I don't get it, but I understand it. Because I've probably asked Stephan a few times over the years whether he ever wanted to write a baking column or something along those lines for PoYB, and the answer has always been that he wasn't interested. Which makes sense, because the man has found the thing that gives him that sense of purpose that we're all out here craving. He feels more whole because he gets to spend that time in the kitchen, turning ingredients into food into art into love. To then write about it would probably be watering down the experience. 

Stephan picked the song that is featured above, since it's his birthday tomorrow, and this prompt was written with him in mind, because—like Nate, Pat, Bob, Maeve, and Sam—he completed the Summer Song Challenge last year, and I tried to make prompts that would honor the Song Challengers of yesteryear in some way.

I was not expecting "Cacao and Cocaine" to sound like this. I don't know if I like it. Kinda like Lana Del Rey mixed with Wet Leg? It occurs to me that I have no idea what kind of music Stephan listens to. I mean, I do, in a sense. He's written for Record Club before in very forthright ways. He completed the Summer Song Challenge in 2023, which means he chose 99 songs. But take a look at those songs. They are all over the board. Five consecutive days went: Talking Heads, Tennis, Pink Floyd, the Notorious B.I.G., Black Pumas. I did not get the sense that he was just randomly choosing songs he only kind of knew. These were songs that meant something to him... but we just weren't privy to the process. You see where I'm going with this.

"Privacy" is the wrong word, because I also believe that Stephan would tell you about his passions if you asked him. I guess what I'm saying is that there is value in finding happiness in yourself and in the things you do for yourself and, occasionally, for others. And I think that there's value too in not having to explain why it makes you happy, or how. It just does. There are simple pleasures in life, and we need to acknowledge them, and cultivate them, and keep them safe. Baking, or eating baked goods, either way.

Here's my way: I'm going to give you the peanut butter rice krispie brownies recipe that I somehow found in an archived documents folder on an external hard drive. I will not make them for you, though. My love language is blogging, not baking.

"Better-Than-Crack Brownies"
  • 1 batch brownies (boxed mix or oooey gooey brownies)
  • 1/2 cup salted peanuts (if don’t have salted, add sea salt)
  • 1 cup chopped Reese’s peanut butter cups
  • 1 1/2 cup milk chocolate chips
  • 1 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1/2 tablespoon butter
  • 1 1/2 cups Rice Krispies cereal
Directions
  1. Mix brownies according to directions, and bake for 20-25 minutes in a 9x13 baking dish. Remove and top with peanuts and peanut butter cups, and bake for 4-6 minutes more.
  2. While they are finishing baking, melt chocolate chips, peanut butter and butter. Stir in cereal. Remove brownies from oven and evenly pour chocolate mixture over top.
  3. Refrigerate for 2 hours before serving.

Friday, November 1, 2024

The Order of Nature, Sunny


Transcription of a conversation on the walk to Fadó Irish Pub.

JOE: How many times did you listen to the album?

SUNNY: I think my first time was yesterday, around noon-ish. Probably listened to it four times. Yeah, four or five. Listened to it the last time early this morning, and then I listened to a track or two before you got here. So not, like, a deep week of listening. Maybe a lot of these thoughts are gonna be fresh and fit, but, it is what it is.

JOE: I think there's an art to knowing what you think of an album after one listening. And I think that is built over time. And I also think that 250 weeks of writing album reviews in a row, I think you're there. So, I think we can trust these thoughts.

SUNNY: Perhaps. We can let it rip. Well, I'll say, my first blush impression—there was a bit of... disappointment is when expectation meets reality, and they mismatch, right? This album was billed as classical—

BEN: Hey guys!

JOE: Headed to the bar?

BEN: I'll walk with you. Just strolling around.

SUNNY: Killing time? We're on Locust, right?

JOE: Yes. Please excuse us. Interviewing Sunny about something, I'm sorry.

BEN: No, you're fine.

JOE: Just on the walk there.

SUNNY: And, ya know, when I hear "classical," I'm thinking Bach, I'm thinking Mozart, ya know, the big boys. Beethoven. Ironically, last week, a friend took me to the orchestra here in Philly. Which was great! They did this whole Vivaldi thing, they even added some new stuff. My point is... why is this classical? This came out in 2019. Is it "classical" just because there's an orchestra? There's that Simpsons episode where Cypress Hill comes out with an orchestra, is that classical music too? So, I mean, that maybe put me on the defensive a little bit. I also don't... Jim [James], I'm not as familiar with his work as I think a lot of the blog readers and writers are. Your sister being one. I think Gilson. Probably yourself. And even Pam's "Why She Chose It," which was like "Oh yeah, it's the guy—"

PASSERBY: [giving both middle fingers as he passes] Fuck Kamala Harris, and anyone who votes for her!

JOE: Aw, sorry man, I'm sorry you feel that way about me!

SUNNY: So, I mean, that's a great segue way, right? This thing comes out in 2019. It's got two elements I see. One of "classical," air quotes, combining with nature, spring, Vivaldi, that kind of thing. And also this whole pain/compassion thing. This was put out in the four years between trump being elected and COVID starting. A fun time for ideas. I think both of those are in there. My point of this whole build-up is, after the second or third listen, I think I softened to it. I kind of got what he was doing. And I started to enjoy it a lot more. The... oh, look at these boys.

DRANDERS: What's shakin'?

JOE: What up?

STEPHAN: Hey.

JOE: We'll be right there.

SUNNY: Just a little chat. Some quick drugs! The opening is a little slow. I think it's my second-favorite "Walking in the Snow" song that we reviewed for Record Club.

JOE: Run the Jewels, right?

SUNNY: Yeah.

JOE: Pure classical music right there.

SUNNY: See, yeah, that's classical. Ironically, both are going with the idea of pain, compassion, the human condition, versus nature, which is interesting. But then once it gets to the second track, "Here in Spirit," it gets a little catchier, and little more fun. It goes through some moods. I think "Human Touch" is a bit overwrought, "In Demand" is a bit catchy. Where I really start to like it is the track before... yeah, "Back to the End of the World," I think things start to pick up a little bit more, it's a little bit more fun. Which leads to the "Who Am I?" track, which has a Leonard Bernstein credit on it, which I thought was interesting.

JOE: Ah, yeah?

SUNNY: That's the one track that feels orchestral more than anything. Even such, he comes in and starts doing his whole singing thing. But it has that sort of "big feel." And then it ends with an audience clapping. Which I didn't even realize up until that point that this is a live album being recorded, ya know? So that seemed like an inflection point for the album, which brought me into it. I also don't know anything about Leonard Bernstein, other than that Bradley Cooper movie.

JOE: I have to assume that all the words about "Was I a rooster? Was I a wren?" all that shit, that seems like Bernstein. I didn't know about the Bernstein credit until right now. But that was the one point on the album where I was like, "okay, that's kind of corny."

SUNNY: And then he goes into songs that kinda play on that same theme. Reincarnation, life, cycles, love, hate, whatever. But it's more catchiness. I think "Over and Over" is a very fun song. "Set It to Song" is maybe a bit cheesy again. You can say in the review that I did that thing where I took the flat of my hand and seesawed it back and forth [Editor's note: he did not seesaw his hand back and forth]. But then it ends with "Same Old Lie," which I think is a really good six-minute song, it's a big song, it encapsulates all the themes. It's both catchy and sonically enjoyable. That's the one I listened to a couple more times. 

JOE: Nice.

SUNNY: After listening to it all, I'd say that 80% of the tracks are very good, a couple of them are skippable. Generally a strong 4/5 album for someone who doesn't really know My Morning Jacket's body of work. Or Leonard Bernstein's. But I would not call this "classical music." It's just good indie rock, with spiritual elements, backed by an orchestra.

JOE: Does it make you want to listen to more My Morning Jacket, or no?

SUNNY: It's made me interested in the work.

JOE: I feel like people who are into My Morning Jacket are really fucking into it.

SUNNY: Exactly. That's the sense I get.

JOE: To their detriment, probably!

SUNNY: It's one of those cults-of-personality-style bands, and from what I hear, this is a guy who has a wide range of styles and productions and output, which I think makes it even more of that, if you're into the artist.

JOE: It smells like piss real bad right here.

SUNNY: Real bad.

JOE: Alright. Any more thoughts?

SUNNY: No.

JOE: Feels like a good transcription instead of summarizing. You okay with that?

SUNNY: Yeah, that works.

Friday, October 11, 2024

Transatlanticism, Stephan


It's a safe bet that Transatlanticism is my wife's favorite album. While I cannot say the same for myself after more than a decade and a half of casually digesting this record, I have a new appreciation for Transatlanticism. More importantly, I (think) have a better understanding of why Allison holds this album in such high regard. So, this will serve as both an album review and an analysis of why she considers this album her GOAT. This should be easy after ~17 years of companionship, right?!...

Starting with companionship, this album is the journey of romantic love and navigating the complex emotional space between two lovers separated by an unspecified physical distance. "The New Year" kicks off the album with initial feelings of underwhelming and anxiety that the new year isn't quite the new beginning one was expecting, until suddenly someone comes along to give a renewed sense of optimism, albeit a bit cautious, for brighter and better relationships. Vocally, it is one of Ben Gibbard's more average performances. Generally, I find his vocal range average, but his voice is unique, and shines in songs with above-average production/arrangement or well-crafted, poetic lyricism, which "New Year" lacks a bit. That said, this opening does a solid job of laying the foundation for things ahead. Even with a few shortcomings, it's easy to understand the appeal here: safe and simple, yet thematically impactful listen, which I find true of most Transatlanticism.

The album then moves into "Lightness" and "Title and Registration." Here, we get into the quirky lyricism and lullaby-esque sound that I feel is a staple of Death Cab for Cutie. There is both sweetness and sadness in Ben Gibbard's voice that accentuates and echoes themes of underwhelming expectations and uncertainty of new relationships that are foreshadowed in the album's opener. The instrumentation remains simple but effective, allowing the lyrics to resonate. 

"Expo '86" and "The Sound of Settling" slightly pick up the tempo. Thematically, the former focuses on the feeling of being stuck in an endless cycle of relationships lacking in meaning and love, with the latter focusing on doubt and fear of missed opportunity after attempting to settle down and maintain relational stability. "Tiny Vessels" confirms that settling for an emotionally vacant relationship was a mistake. Except for a few deeply felt lyrics (a younger version of me would be in his feels listening to the lyric, "I am waiting for something to go wrong. I am waiting for familiar resolve" in "Expo '86"), none of the aforementioned songs stand out enough to be considered essential listens on their own. Still, they do work well collectively to drive the album's narrative forward.  

We reach the album's peak, "Transatlanticism." There is much to unpack here, but I'll keep it brief. The lyrics are well-crafted and artful. The song is long, clocking in at just under eight minutes. It's metaphor-heavy, but never overbearing. Typically, I'm not fond of songs of this nature, yet I cannot deny its beauty. The phrase "I need you so much closer" comprises the entire middle third of this song. Here, the instrumentation again remains simple and steady, which allows this statement to reverberate. Gibbard expertly captures the experience of distance in a relationship, whether physical, emotional, metaphorical, or literal, and makes it feel deeply relatable despite my relationships differing from the singer's. This song marks the tonal shift of the album and steers us toward the end.

The remaining four tracks all feature characteristics allowing them to stand out individually in ways the first six songs could not. The instrumentation becomes more varied and collaborative. In "Passenger Seat," we get a sweet and soothing piano performance unlike any other song on the album. "Death of an Interior Decorator" and "They Looked like Giants” lean more into the drums and bass, and are the biggest showcase of the band as a unit. "Lack of Color" delivers beautiful harmonies and acoustic guitar. This shift from an individualistic effort to a more collaborative one parallels the album's narrative. If the first section is about isolation, loneliness, and distance, this second half is about closeness and togetherness.

This experience of Transatlanticism was far and away my most thoughtful and intentional. Going into this album with a critical eye allowed me to connect more deeply than any of my previous passive experiences. Overall, this may be the quintessential Death Cab for Cutie album. Ben Gibbard's somewhat annoying vocals work well throughout and never deter or distract me from enjoying this album. It is not a musical masterpiece, but undoubtedly artful and poetic and deserves a listen. Much here speaks to both the younger and present-day versions of me. I wasn't expecting a meditation experience, yet I did much introspection during and after, which I value.  I can even see myself giving this another listen when I need a good cathartic release.  I can't call this album my favorite, but it's not hard to understand why it is for some. The lasting appeal of the album lies in its ability to connect deeply. Transatlanticism sits with you, waits for you, and allows you to return and feel all over again. It provides a safe space to reflect and emote.


A note on "Passenger Seat":

Shortly after Allison and I started dating, I downloaded a bunch of music from her computer onto mine. While this was mainly to broaden my horizons, I also wanted to get a better feel for the music she listened to. I'll keep my opinions of her music to myself; "Passenger Seat" holds a special place in my heart. When I first heard this song, it was during a random shuffle of her music. The lyrics immediately drew me:

"Then, looking upwards, I strain my eyes
To tell the difference between shooting stars and satellites
From the passenger seat as you are driving me home.
Do they collide? I ask, and you smile."

If I hadn't known this song was written several years earlier, I would have sworn it was written for me in the present. I never learned to drive, so all of my experiences in the car are from the passenger seat. This song felt explicitly about me and Allison. The contentment and safety I would feel next to her in the car—the idea of being her guide when direction is needed.

"With my feet on the dash, the world doesn't matter."

Wednesday, August 21, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 121: Allison

Prompt: "A song that would soundtrack a montage sequence of kids in the 1950s having some innocent fun in some cheap shitty Netflix movie with terrible cinematography"

Selected by Allison


"Sunshine, Lollipops and Rainbows"
Lesley Gore
Lesley Gore Sings of Mixed-Up Hearts, 1963

The lucky ones on this blog know my husband is a fantastic baker. He's modest, but he's very talented. It's a wonderful life. I adore being the baker's wife. There's always bread in the freezer, cake in the fridge, or cookies hanging out on the counter. It does come with a price, though. And I'm not just talking about the shelf storage I lose to endless containers of flours, sugars, and specialty ingredients. Every new bake is a test of my self-control. A test I regularly fail. It's worth it every time, though.

I have made
a plum
icebox cake
for dessert

I know you
are on a diet
and should not
eat sweets

Forgive me
it is delicious but
you don't have
to eat it

Friday, August 16, 2024

RC@5: Fyah by Theon Cross

Record Club covered this album exactly five years ago. I gave it another listen this week. Here are some thoughts.


Fyah
Theon Cross
Week 28: August 11-17, 2019

Well, it wasn't for lack of trying.

I am so glad that we covered Fyah in Record Club early on. It was a nice entry into jazz music. Not that it was a "good beginner's jazz album" or any other similar descriptor, but its tuba-forwardness really provided a nice ready-made hook for all those beginner music critics on Week 28. It didn't stop people (myself included) from ruminating on What Jazz Music Is, but it softened the landing, I think.

Still, though, five years later and a few more listens under my belt, and I still can't get over the fact that the tuba sounds absolutely ridiculous in the lead position. Maybe I've been unconsciously conditioned throughout my lifetime to think that the tuba is a silly instrument. If it's my fault, then fine, I'll take the heat. But because of my flaws of opinion, I struggle to listen to Fyah and not scoff a little at how much cooler it might have sounded if the bass took over for the tuba. On the other hand, we wouldn't be talking about this fucker if it was a bass-forward album. So there's the trade-off.

It's probably cheap to talk about "jazz" in a jazz album review, but it's a tough genre to crack, and I have patience for our former selves as we worked through it. I will say that this was probably one of my earlier moments of self-reflection within a Record Club review about Record Club reviews, in that I was self-aware that this review was following a pattern that indicative of "learning how to write" and couldn't last forever. I am still not so sure about jazz, but I'm a lot farther along in the process.

I love reading old reviews from RC writers, regulars and irregulars alike. Just as I was honing the craft, so too were they in their own individual ways. You had Nate sharpening the snark and wit, and introducing a then-unnamed uncle who would eventually turn into a Record Club alumnus and contributor. You had Sam widening his scope and managing to meld together a discussion about sitcom television with one about the energy of jazz, which manages to not be as far a reach in Sam's hands as the idea seems in mine now. You had Sean, turning something simple into something complexly philosophical (e.g. "who am I if I like jazz?"), which I appreciate immensely. And you had Stephan, who does the work in sounding professional, and whose personality is just beginning to shine through the cracks of that professionalism (and would truly come to fruition a few summers later during SSC, I'd argue). 

On a different note (contextual, not metatextual), it's pretty interesting to think about Theon Cross's place in the jazz world. When we were reviewing Fyah, I was not familiar with his other work. I didn't know he was in Sons of Kemet. I have at least heard of those guys, the jazz group being at the very least popular enough that they crossed over to the indie rock blogs and got enough coverage on there that I'd recognize the name. The drummer of that band is Tom Skinner, who you'll recognize from the Smile, a band otherwise comprised of members of Radiohead, who would become RC alumni 244 weeks after Theon. It's all connected, baby, and sometimes it takes five years to appreciate all the connections.

I reached out to the Record Club captain who chose Fyah originally, Stephan, and asked him if he was still bopping along to Fyah on a typical day. He indicated that, after a brief spell of the songs popping up in the Spotify algorithm, he basically never listens to it anymore. Which is understandable. I can't say I have either. I think that's okay. I don't think all of these albums are meant to be infinitely repeatable. I think some exist to be there at one specific point in the journey, and eventually fade. I was really glad to hear Fyah. I don't think it's essential, and I don't think it's worthy of too much praise, but I do think that it was important for us as a club to touch on these sounds, briefly, before we attempted some stronger and/or stranger jazz.

Theon is out there sharing his love of tuba with the world. I won't follow him down his own path, but I will happily wish him well.

Monday, June 3, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 69: Allison

Prompt: "A song involving a lemon"

Selected by Allison


"Lemon Boy"
The Orion Experience
Cosmicovers, 2023

A list of things to do while your husband is away for the weekend:
  1. Take your bestie out bar-hopping for her first Mom's Night Out.
  2. Let the dog sleep in bed with you. Both nights.
  3. Pick one super-specific chore that you've been putting off for way too long. Choose "clean the refrigerator." Put it off until Sunday.
  4. Finally start Hacks since Stephan had no interest in watching it because "women aren't funny."
  5. Brainstorm other libelous things to write about your husband on your friend's blog.
  6. See what Doctor Who's been up to. It's fine, but I didn't need Neil Patrick Harris to make an appearance.
  7. Lose half a day to TikTok and a mistimed edible.
  8. Order too much Chinese food.
  9. Get a tummy ache.
  10. Miss him.

Thursday, May 23, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 63: Allison

Prompt: "A song that's like 'boom, clap, boom boom clap'"

Selected by Allison


"Grindin'"
Clipse
Lord Willin', 2002

This one goes out to my husband (yes, most of these have, but this one specifically). When I read the prompt out loud, he said, "Oh, like 'Grindin'' by Clipse?" to which I replied, "I have no idea what that is." Then he made me play it on YouTube while he banged rhythmically on our dining room table. At one point, he did the Harlem Shake. It was surreal. Our current music tastes intersect at several points, but we have very different memories of 2002. Perhaps if Iron & Wine had covered "Grindin'," I would have joined in. 

For the record, this was the original song I was going to use.