Showing posts with label Chelsea. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chelsea. Show all posts

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Never Seen It #347: To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything! Julie Newmar

Baby, you can have him. I've got 500 movies I've never seen before, alright. I've got a broken blog for every light on Broadway. And when one of them goes out, I just screw in another one, okay, hello good-bye.


To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything! Julie Newmar
1995
Beeban Kidron

Zoom: November 18, 2026, 9 PM to 10 PM

Participants: Chelsea, Joe, Jules, Sam, Sean E., Stef, Sunny

General consensus here, I think, is that it was a good movie. But it was interesting to me that how willing people (myself very much included) were in excusing some of the, err, cornier elements of this film, just due to what the overall purpose of it was. You'd be correct in saying that it was filled with a lot of tropes, that it was predictable in many ways, that it was lame in how "feel-good" it was, and so on. But you'd be wrong (so goes the consensus with our group here) if you said that these are what made To Wong Foo bad.

It was a good movie because it was an important movie, back then, in the ancient time period of the mid-'90s. It was revolutionary in some ways to have macho action stars portray women characters. Not only that, but they were portraying these characters because it was the characters' truth. It wasn't done out of trickery or deceit, it was done because that's who they were. An important distinction. And so it was important, generally, for the film to go down easy in all other aspects. Yes, it was a feel-good story about simple townsfolk whose lives are transformed by outsiders. It's crucial to note who those outsiders specifically are, and why. Just a different way of thinking about a movie, at least for us here in this movie club.

Some more thoughts that we discussed (and can further discuss in the comments, if you want!):
  • Drag queens are not the butt of the joke, which is integral to the overall feel of the movie. Other movies featuring men dressed as women might make femininity the joke, but here, femininity is heroic.
  • Was it misguided or a missed opportunity or whatever to not ever show the three main leads outside of their drag personas?
  • And how do we feel, both from a 1995 perspective and a 2026 perspective, that there was very little actual drag queen representation in this film (beyond cameos)?
  • The cop—I guess I didn't realize that the joke was that he was supposed to be a closeted gay man, but I think I was the only one who didn't get that sense. I think "spiraling because he realized he was attracted to a AMAB" is a pretty logical explanation for what's supposed to be going on here. Lots to discuss with this villain.
  • THOUGHTS ON MRS. DOUBTFIRE?!?!
  • Making this movie palatable for audiences who needed it versus making a movie like Pink Flamingos.
  • And what popular movies since 1995 have given representation to drag communities in this way?
  • Wait, was this popular? I wasn't sure if this was a "I haven't seen a lot of movies" thing, or if our film club crew was overrepresenting its popularity. Maybe I'll look it up for the comments.
  • There was a good discussion about why we as a culture have to continuously relitigate, as a society, hate and phobia. ER was apparently grappling with transphobia in an episode in the '90s. People are still grappling with it today. Why? When will we ever learn?
  • Bala Cynwyd—it's the fancy name that makes the joke work!
  • Elegant fashion in the movie
  • Stockard Channing's character was sad, well-acted, perhaps a bit cliché (DV is not actually like this), but the point got across eventually
  • The point of the male characters (the villains, anyway) was that they were supposed to be emasculated
  • Lots to think about with the scene of Chi-Chi and Bobby Ray
  • Speaking of Chi-Chi Rodriguez... the drag queen, not the random-ass golfer
  • The movie perhaps didn't do the best with the intersectionality of gender and race... but it tried a little bit!
Writing all that out (as I desperately try to stay awake, minutes after the Zoom ends), I'm finding that I still have a bunch of thoughts on this one. I love when that happens. I don't think "good movie" and "good movie for a film club" are necessarily the same thing, but they can be, and I think To Wong Foo nailed both aspects of it. A really fun comedy with heart, or at least enough of it that it easily overpowered any thoughts of this being lame or cliché. 4 pukes out of 5 from me. What say you?

NEXT TIME: We're crossing over with Record Club next week, when we watch the film The Virgin Suicides and listen to the score as performed by the French band Air. If that sounds interesting, let me know!

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Never Seen It #344: House Party

Yeah, I did it, I watched 500 movies I've never seen before, I might cry two tears in a bucket. Fuck it. Let's take it to the blog.


House Party
1990
Reginald Hudlin

Thanks to all those who watched House Party and shared their thoughts! Check them out below, and meet us in the comments to discuss some more.

~~~~~~~~~~

Sunny

How much more can one say about a movie wherein the climactic scene has the hero freestyle rapping to avoid being anally raped in a county jail holding cell by some big big guys? Riveting, groundbreaking, and fiercely unapologetic (except about a handful of things, like drugs, alcohol, and teenage pregnancy, that it's pretty apologetic about), House Party captures a real youth moment and the greater culture surrounding it. This is a culture I have never been a part of, and I leave this tale really with as many questions as answers. That said, I also yukked it up at several scenes and gags, some of the character bits are good (Martin Lawrence is here! Tisha Campbell is here! The late great John Witherspoon is here!), and we clock in at 100 min. What a strange ride 2.5/5

~~~~~~~~~~

Sam

We've watched several African American boys coming-of-age stories in this project (Juice, Cooley High, Love & Basketball), and this is playing in the same sandbox. But the calibration on seriousness v. fun here tips way in the favor of fun and results in an iconic romp.

That's not to say that House Party fails to grapple with real problems. Race-based policing, red-lining in housing, cyclical neighborhood violence, and general economic inequality are dealt with. As are combating stereotypes—note the (cranky) but positive male Black father figures, the booksmart Christopher, and the apparent chastity and social responsibility around sex. But that's against a backdrop to jokes about bad breath, whacky haircuts, and cranky neighbors. 

The "one crazy night" set-up works well just to get everyone moving. And that's a vehicle for Kid and Play (credited as an entity!) to have a pretty OK rap battle as well as a very awesome dance battle with Tisha Campbell and A.J. Johnson. That dance scene was the highlight of the movie for me and really captures a moment in time.

It was also funny to see Martin Lawrence and Campbell in the same movie but not as a couple. We'd have to wait a few years for Bilal to find his Gina.

My critique is that the film is a little too basic—not a lot really happens. And the actual actors are way better than Kid 'n Play. But I like fun. So I'll give it 4 eraserheads out of 5.

~~~~~~~~~~

Allison

House Party is one of those films that was on Comedy Central all the time in the '90s and '00s, but I never stopped to watch it. I was expecting something in the vein of Porky's or Revenge of the Nerds—a raunchy, heavy-handed comedy aimed at boys that made me roll my eyes. Instead, House Party was surprisingly chaste for a rated-R teen (and we're using that term incredibly loosely) comedy. No nudity, no sexual hijinks, no explicit drug use, and only one person at the titular house party gets drunk. And it's a guy. And they take care of him and make sure he gets home alright. Wholesome! Another notably touching moment is Kid's exchange at the end with Play and Bilal about consent and contraception. Unexpected but oddly poignant. And incredibly timely and relevant, as the AIDS crisis disproportionately affected the black community. Message!

Other things I enjoyed:
  • The dancing! Kid 'n Play may not be exactly strong leading men, but they put on a good show.
  • Tisha Campbell. No further comment.
  • The very beefy bullies played by the hip-hop group Full Force. They swung wildly between silly hapless goons and would-be arsonists, but that was fun. You couldn't tell if they were going to give you a wedgie or full-on murder you. I loved the look of the cut-off sweatshirt.
  • The way Sydney's dad called the cops "fascists." A brief thought on the police presence in the film. They didn't wield much control in the community despite being ever-present. They were mostly a nuisance.  
What I could have done without:
  • The homophobic anti-gang-rape rap scene that I don't care to write about.
In the end, I was mostly entertained, but it wasn't really that funny, and it struggled to hold my attention. I think I needed more hijinks.

2.5 servings of Dick Gregory

~~~~~~~~~~~

Chelsea

Something to know about me: the only thing I love more than a dance-off is a rap battle. Needless to say, I was utterly charmed by this film. 

This movie is So. Much. Fun. The pace and plot are kind of loose and feel almost improvisational, and the film manages to balance about a dozen supporting characters so deftly that it has a little bit of a Diet Altman vibe. For me, it's an instant classic (if such a thing can be said about a 36-year-old movie) of the teen party genre, movies which tend to be excellent time capsules in a way few other genres are, for better and worse. (There are some R-bombs and F-slurs, but also my god, THE OUTFITS. Sharane is an icon.) There are so many absolutely bonkers quotable lines; I wrote down about twelve in the first 20 minutes before I gave up, but suffice to say from now on I will be using "Aw man, my rhymes!" any time I lose or forget something.

Robin Harris (who unforgettably played Sweet Dick Willy in Do the Right Thing the year prior) is a stone cold delight as Kid's dad. Sometimes the whole movie would kind of halt just to cut to him doing something unrelated (like fixing a fan) because everything out of his mouth was ridiculous. (Sad trivia fact: this movie came out nine days before he passed away. R.I.P. to a legend.) There are some real charismatic standouts here in Martin Lawrence, Tisha Campbell (they would later be reunited on Martin!), and Daryl "Chill" Miller (who would go on to play the English teacher in 10 Things I Hate About You, arguably a teen party classic in its own right). And George Clinton's cameo as a DJ is absolute perfection. 

All that said, it's not a perfect movie by any means. There are some pretty unusual editing choices, and Kid's performance vacillates between awkward/charming and awkward/very strange (although his rhymes are indeed excellent). And of course, there is the incredibly weird rap interlude during which Kid uses his rhymes to... distract a group of hardened criminals from gang raping him in a local jail's holding cell? Such a bizarre tonal misstep and also very very silly ("we're gonna tie your fade into a ponytail" raps one of the criminals during the number). Fortunately, the power of rap prevails and Kid escapes unharmed, leaving us all to collectively wonder what the hell we just watched. 

However, in spite of that absolutely unhinged moment, I was completely won over by the end. It has a scrappy, good-natured, freestyle energy (befitting a movie about aspiring rappers) that I found pretty irresistible. I'll say 3.5 out of 5 stars (an extra half star for dousing Reagan's portrait in Jell-O in the opening food fight scene) and leave you with one of my favorite zingers from the film: "Go home and bring me two bean pies and a pork chop sandwich, you little trout-mouthed heathen!" 

Thanks again for introducing me to this one! Such a blast!

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

I know the Linklater film isn't until next week, but I did feel that some of his best films (Dazed and Confused, Everybody Wants Some!!) shared a kinship with House Party in one specific way. Yes, the plot involved kids and parties and young love and all that stuff, but the crucial similarity I saw was the way that the stakes were purposefully lowered to create realism. In the same way that the keg at the Moontower ended simply because there was no more beer, the titular party of House Party ended because the home's upstairs toilet wasn't working anymore. A lesser movie would've allowed the bullies to burn down the house. (In fact, it can probably be seen as a meta-commentary on the "teen party" subgenre, that the other bullies didn't like the fire plan and were like "yo, that's going way too far.")

The realism worked in both directions. The drama felt very grounded and real, but the potential heartfelt moments were held at bay as well, because they similarly would've felt too exaggerated. Like, okay, I have been primed to expect, after so many other movies of this ilk, that Kid was going to get home and have a genuine heart-to-heart with his father, about growing up and responsibilities and the love they share despite their differences. Instead, his dad has a belt, and the ending credits roll as Kid gets corporally punished. That felt was more realistic! No teen is breaking that many household rules and then sneaking back home in the middle of the night to be met with a heartfelt moment. That only happens in the movies!

If we are making the argument that this was a great movie because of how real it felt, then we need to acknowledge how discomforting the racial tension and violence was throughout. I felt it particularly in two scenes. The first was when Kid and the bullies were being held by the white cops at gunpoint, and the victims of Kid's hijinks refused to press charges, because they knew exactly what that would entail for the youngsters ("they need discipline, not solitary confinement!"). The second was when those same white cops caught the bullies trying to start a fire, and... took them down to the docks to beat the shit out of them? I felt like the party guests in the aftermath of that. They need discipline, not illegal assaults by a bunch of fucking cops!

But my point here is that it's been noted by many people who were young and Black in the late '80s and early '90s that House Party was an accurate representation of their lived experience at that time (for example, Philadelphia 76er Lebron James, who produced the 2023 remake based on how much he and his friends loved the original back in the day), and if that's true, then there are some pretty heinous societal injustices that are being noted as accurate. I don't think anyone watching the film has a responsibility to take action based on what you see here. It's not that kind of movie. The responsibility is only to acknowledge that this movie is the truth, in incredible ways and horrific ways.

Mostly incredible ways, though. As someone who used to throw house parties all the time, I saw so much of my former self in Play. House parties were not how they are portrayed in teen comedies. The house is never destroyed. You're not grappling over the fact that your mother's precious heirloom was shattered on the ground and you're gonna be "so dead" when they get home. Teens, by and large, are not assholes. They're just trying to have a nice time at a party. No one is malicious, and if they are, you just don't let them in, simple as that. Play had the trust in his friends needed to throw this house party successfully. One friend got a little too drunk, but he got home safely. Kid's dad showed up and stopped the party briefly with some quips, but then he left and the party continued. The toilet broke, and Play was upset, but let's be real, it was most likely an accident, and he's easily gonna fix that thing before his parents return.

I loved the way that the movie refused to kowtow to the hyperbole that this genre of film typically calls for. It was more relatable, and it was certainly more enjoyable. I just think it's rare when a movie upends expectations by underplaying it. By portraying the type of shit I used to see all the time back in the day, the film ends up showing the type of shit that I very rarely see accurately portrayed in movies. Even the interpersonal drama felt so fucking low-key and thus accurate. There was mild drama between Sydney and Sharane, over who was going to hook up with Kid. Sharane said that Sydney could have him if she was able to hook up with him on the walk home. When Sydney does just that, and tells Sharane, Sydney gives her this perfect look that says "you said you weren't gonna start shit, so are you gonna start shit or what?" And then Sharane sighs and admits defeat and solidifies the friendship and avoids all the maudlin eyeroll-worthy teen drama that would typically spawn from here in a much worse movie.

Two moments broke this rule of groundedness. I understand why both of them exist—because this movie is starring the '80s rap duo Kid 'n Play, of course you're gonna have them perform in the movie. Only one of the two in-movie performances was successful though. The rap and dance sequence at the party itself was joyful, and, though less believable than the rest of the occurrences at the teen house party, it still maintained the air of innocence that pervades the entire film. Just two friends having fun and goofing off! The other one was the song about prison rape. Much less enjoyable, and probably the only part of the film that has aged poorly. I'm coping by pretending that this is a fantasy sequence in the warped mind of a dumbass teenager.

Oh, and I wasn't a huge fan of the mid-credits sequence with the racist cops meeting their demise. Not that they didn't deserve it, and not that contemporaneous audiences didn't earn some payoff with that real and ugly strain of racism they had to endure from these white cops. It still felt out of place. It was very purposefully not real (the roof that is blown off the house in the opening credits is the thing that lands on them), which goes against everything that makes House Party an amazingly real film in the first place.

I'm not too concerned. I'm walking away from this movie knowing full well why it's considered a classic. I consider it a classic now too. House parties happen all the time, and it's so rare that they are shown with any sort of accuracy in a movie. House Party nailed it.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Sean G.

I watched House Party and had a LOT of fun with it. Not gonna get you a proper review, I had to leave town. But I’ll give you a score. Make it 4 pukes. I really enjoyed it. Worth linking to this Criterion write-up in the comments or along with my score.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 3.417 pukes out of 5

Grab all your DJing equipment and meet us in the comments!

(NEXT TIME: Joe and Sunny discuss Fiddler on the Roof for a very special reason.)

Thursday, October 1, 2026

Never Seen It #337: In the Heat of the Night

Now, look. I got no wife. I got no kids. Boy, I got a town that don't want me. And I got an air conditioner that I have to oil myself, and a desk with a busted leg. And on top of that, I got this, uh... blog. Now, don't you think that'd drive a man to watching 500 movies he's never seen before? I'll tell you a secret. Nobody comes here. Never.


In the Heat of the Night
1967
Norman Jewison

Thanks to all those valiant Film Club members who watched a movie and wrote about it. See our thoughts below!

~~~~~~~~~~

Catherine

I accidentally stayed up way too late watching Sidney Poitier's Oscars acceptance speeches and mini documentaries about his life and now I have to do this stream-of-consciousness/bullet style, apologies:
  • This was somehow my first Sidney Poitier film, and I can't believe it took me this long. He's such a haunting, captivating performer with seemingly little effort, and every time he was on screen, I couldn't look away.
  • (Favorite shot of dozens of unbelievable frames)
  • The film's presentation of racism is devastating in its accuracy because it denies us any real payoff for Tibbs or growth from our prejudiced characters to make the audience feel better. By the end, hearts and minds aren't really changed. Virgil Tibbs did his job in spite of every obstacle thrown his way, and we know this uphill battle will follow him for the rest of his life. And Gillespie is definitely still racist. He merely acknowledges Tibbs' humanity a bit more than he did in the beginning, and with a quiet final handshake sends him on his way.
  • It was a wild feeling realizing I've been missing a classic cinema reference in a Disney film for nearly thirty years. I'm talking, of course, about Pumba screaming, "They call me, MISTER PIG!" in The Lion King. I applaud any cultured five-year-old who understood the joke at the time.
  • On a critical note, the twist ending/whodunnit reveal didn't really pay off for me. They kinda seemed to follow flimsy Scooby-Doo rules by setting up a pretty obvious red herring (Endicott), then suddenly bringing back an unassuming character from the beginning to pin it on. Slightly disappointing.
  • Poitier/Steiger had some incredible chemistry as Tibbs and Gillespie. I really enjoyed the scene at the end where Gillespie is housing a bottle of Wild Turkey and finally asks Tibbs about himself. "You ever been married?" "Ever been close?" Close is all we'll ever get to learning about who Tibbs the homicide expert really is. And I love the mystery.
  • Finally, what happened to the family Tibbs was staying with? He meets them, they get a room ready for him, then we never see them again. Was this intentional? It's entirely possible I'm wrong and just forgetting a scene.
Fantastic film, 4/5 pukes

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Chelsea

This feels like the type of movie the Hollywood loved to crank in the '90s: a fish-out-of-water police procedural designed to soothe white guilt by assuring us that racism is over because two cops bonded over their love of... justice, I guess? Which is to say, I feel like I've seen so many lesser versions of this movie that it's easy to forget how boundary-pushing it was at the time of its release, although even then some critics called out the uneasy friendship that develops between Tibbs and Gillespie for being trite and convenient. I agree with that critique to some extent, although I will say that the performances of the two leads helped sell me on the complicated kind of respect that evolves over the course of the film. Sidney Poitier, who already had an Oscar under his belt at this point, is pulling off a tightwire act as Tibbs. It would be easy (too easy) to play this character as patient and dignified to the point of saintliness, but Poitier is able to show that Tibbs's poise masks a rage and obsessiveness that for a time derails the investigation while he tries to prove the murderer is the racist plantation owner Endicott. Though innocent of murder, watching that guy get open hand slapped by Tibbs was the highlight of my week so far. 

Rod Steiger, chewing gum with more commitment than I would have thought possible, is also doing a bit of a balancing act as Gillespie. While definitely racist as hell, he immediately clocks that Tibbs is more capable that anybody on the force, and is able to convey a vulnerability that drives his resentment. Nobody in town seems to like him or think he deserves his job, and he is constantly being upstaged at every turn by the guy he initially accused of the murder. He gets a little redemption arc, and while it's definitely a bit pandering to a liberal audience, it doesn't feel totally unearned. 

As far as how the film operates as a procedural, it certainly kept me guessing, and although the ending didn't have the sort of satisfying "I never would have guessed it was them but OF COURSE it was them" a-ha moment, it mostly worked for me as a murder mystery. The actor who played the murderer is like an unholy redneck amalgam of Anthony Perkins and Crispin Glover, so the vibe was spot on, and his rubber band flicking tick that the film opened on, and then revisited during his confession, was a nice little bookend. That said, the film does seem more interested in the thematic and socio-political elements of the story than the actual murder mystery, which almost felt like an afterthought at some points. 

Ultimately, the thing that struck me the most about this movie was the feeling that it is trapped between two times. Not just thematically, although obviously the film is very directly speaking to that. I'm talking more about the visual language of the movie. There was the sense at several points that the director was experimenting visually with ideas that we would see fully fleshed out later in the American New Wave movement. The POV car shots early in the film were so effective in making the audience complicit in Officer Woods's voyeurism and gave that scene a creepy immediacy. These opening shots felt like baby steps towards the kind of visceral POV car stuff that Friedkin would do later in The French Connection. In some cases, these experiments were a little clunky, like in the fight between Tibbs and the gang in the warehouse. The director keeps cutting to a low angle shot with only Tibbs in the frame, and I'm not sure what he was trying to express exactly, but it wasn't as effective for me at conveying danger as a more conventionally shot wider frame would have been. Nonetheless, it was a moment where I felt like I was watching the language of film evolve right in front of me, and I could see the throughlines that other directors would be using with greater deftness in the '70s. That was really cool. 

Final thoughts: Quincy Jones as music supervisor? Okay!!! I am also a sucker for featuring a song in the movie that contains the title of the movie! 

Overall 3.5/5 for me!

~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

I know it's stupid, and privileged, to still be shocked by racism. Also says something about geography, I guess, since I am from the place that Virgil Tibbs is from, and would probably be shocked by the amount of racism in small-town Mississippi too if I traveled down there 60 years ago. But mostly privileged. I am a white man watching this film. A Black man watching In the Heat of the Night would probably not be as shocked to see this particular portrayal of racism, I think. This film takes place 60 years ago, which is not so long ago when you think about it. Philando Castile was shot ten years ago, in the same way that the mayor and the police chief speculated it would've gone with Virgil in the '60s South—"claiming self-defense"—and ten years ain't fucking nothing.

I liked In the Heat of the Night for a few reasons, first of which was it didn't try to portray Chief Gillespie as fully reformed, or changed in large ways, and certainly not any sort of "white savior" or whatever. He was a complicated man who maybe is just beginning the very first stages of questioning the pillars of the reality that the racist South had constructed for him. I think that it'll be easier to fall back on old ways once Virgil Tibbs leaves and makes his way back to Philly, and I think that this is truer to life, unfortunately. It's easy for us, the audience watching this movie in 2026 who are willing and able to believe that racism is a pox on society and should be eradicated, to understand the lesson here, but it's harder for the good ol' boys of the '60s South to hold onto that lesson. The complicated juxtaposition of Bill's upbringing versus the facts in front of his face is... well, it's what earned Rod Steiger the Best Actor Oscar for sure.

I guess what I'm saying is that the movie was never patronizing. It never beat you over the head with the fact that racism is bad (despite the fact that it is). It instead allowed you to take that journey with the chief, whether you needed to or not. And Sidney Poitier was perfect for the role as Detective Virgil Tibbs. He was so fucking good at acting in a way that you could tell he was angry as fuck but learned over the course of his life that he needed to hold it in. It was a righteous anger that occasionally escaped, and it made you feel for him even more that he even had to hold it in in the first place. I saw online the scene at the plantation described as "the slap that shook the world," and that was something that made me reconsider what I had just seen. Because I had trouble not viewing it through a modern lens, and missed how extraordinary that scene must have felt back when racism was more outwardly portrayed in society. From my vantage point, I'm thinking, "okay, Virgil got slapped first, it makes sense that he slapped back." And the fact that characters in the movie and I'm sure many people watching in the theaters during its initial run must have been shocked by the idea of a Black man slapping a white plantation owner... it just acts as a marker for me on how much we've changed as a society, but also how far we still have left to go.

The final thing that I loved about this film was that it was a sort of twist on a genre that everyone is already familiar with. The "who done it" murder mystery is technically how this film is designed, on the surface. But at its core, it's a sociological drama about race. There is conflict to be found in the murder plot, but the true conflict is the battle over Bill Gillespie's soul. It's the conflict between right and wrong, and the conflict that comes about when different people have different definitions of right and of wrong. And it's the conflict of the past and the present, how someone like Gillespie is forced to consider a man he views as so different than him ultimately as his equal, and, in the opposite direction, how someone like Tibbs is forced to consider a man like Gillespie, despite the hell that people like Gillespie have put him through in his life, as someone who is similar (in that they have similar desires for justice, I guess). It's not just a who-done-it, in other words. The layers are what makes it a great movie.

Just because we as a society have basically learned nothing from In the Heat of the Night doesn't make it any less important. And just because it remains important today doesn't mean it also can't be a fun and fascinating film in its own right.

GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~

GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

Call me MISTER Puke in the comments.

(NEXT TIME: Some blogging bodies are watching Bodies Bodies Bodies.)

Thursday, September 24, 2026

Never Seen It #336: Winter's Bone

You don't wanna go around Little Blogger's askin' them people about anything they ain't offered to talk about. That's a real good way to end up watchin' 500 movies you never seen before... or wishin' you was.


Winter's Bone
2010
Debra Granik

Zoom: September 22, 2026, 9 PM to 10 PM

Participants: Brianna, Chelsea, Joe, Sean E., Stef

I think the first question to ask yourself is: how accurate is this movie? That's what it all hinges on. It's a fictional movie, but if it seems real, and if it's how they're really living out there in the Ozarks in the '00s or whatever, then it's gonna be a good movie. If it's unreal, or exaggerated in any way, then it becomes a farce. It felt like we were all in agreement that it was a "real" movie. Thus, everyone enjoyed it. 

Is that how the best movies function? That they feel real, even if it's not, like, a documentary? I don't know. Something to chew on. Lots to chew on with Winter's Bone. We had a great discussion! Here's some other shit we chatted about, in case you missed it:
  • There was "zero catharsis," which set a good pace for the movie, in the opinion of most
  • The lack of music was eerie, but also made the one scene with the family jamboree pop more (that scene was described as "an Anthony Bourdain episode")
  • This was a real place that they filmed at, which made it more accurate
  • Dale Dickey, great actress
  • The is a code for men and women in this community, rules about violence
  • But don't forget that Teardrop was violent too, but within the agreed boundaries of the community... what do we think about all this?
  • What was the point of the squirrel dream? To show that Ree felt protective of the woods (and her siblings)? The chainsaw sounds foreshadowing the climactic scene with the chainsaw and hands?
  • What's up with the mom? Mental health or substance abuse? Both?
  • There is hardship here in this life, but acceptance as well, perhaps too much
  • I.e. how resilience can be a bad thing, like what happened to cause that resilience to build, and what fucked up in society to make it get that way?
  • What does it do to a community when no one trusts each other?
  • On the surface, there is good will, but a lack of true trust among family and friends here below that surface. Communities need trust to function.
  • Where is Teardrop off to? He says he's going to avenge his brother's death. What is Ree's reaction to that as it's happened?
  • "Never ask for what oughta be offered"—thoughts on this line? Does it have to do with dignity? Or a literal inability to find anyone who can help?
  • What is the banjo at the end signifying? The repeating of a cycle, or the breaking of that cycle?
  • People used to move when things are bad. But now, with thing moderately better, especially in small towns, people feel stuck. Did Ree feel stuck?
  • Why don't they sell the house? Because of that feeling of being stuck. But also, it is their one true reliable thing.
  • Good acting; good singing from that one lady
  • Is this a bleak ending? A bleak movie?
  • Probably some other stuff here, but I'm falling asleep typing it up, sorry...
After the discussion, but probably even before it too, I'm giving this film a 4 pukes out of 5. Sad and realistic and incredibly well-made, but perhaps a little too chill. Admirable to eschew catharsis for the sake of realness, but I could go for some catharsis every once in a while. Good movie overall though.

How about you? What did you think? Any cool thoughts to share? Drop 'em in the comments!

(NEXT TIME: One more round of small groups before we knock everything down and regroup—In the Heat of the Night is up next)