Showing posts with label Pontifications. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pontifications. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 16, 2024

Pontifications: Ski and Flow

Walter shares his weekly thoughts, fears, and philosophies (or some bullshit like that).

Alison and I took a last minute split drive up to Albany/Vermont for a day of skiing yesterday. Ski conditions were not bad despite the lack of accumulation and fluctuations in temperatures throughout the season thus far... I've been having a hard time thinking of things to write about. I don't really love divulging too much of my personal life in the blog, and my absorption of certain topics have waned lately. But I realized something profound which Alison said to me that I wish to write more about...


"Skiing is the one thing, I've realized, which forces me into single-mindedness," she said (or something like that), as we entered the lodge's restaurant to grab tea and some grub before the lunch-time rush began. What a profound statement this was for me. Something I resonate with in some sense, yet also don't trust as pure single-mindedness. I agree, in the sense that Skiing takes away all the other tasks which one may be doing otherwise. You simply cannot conduct computer work while skiing, nor can you load laundry into a washing machine. So yes, skiing requires a focus that takes you completely away from your regular life.

The requirement to focus on your speed, obstacles, and direction can also pull you away from thinking about anything else! One merely can't think too hard on any subject while skiing, else they lose their balance, hit a tree, miss a turn. Awareness of these consequences leaves little else to worry about in the moment. But these are merely one dimension of the consequences of skiing versus thinking about regular life. The other dimension includes thing, such as: the beauty of the surrounding nature; the sensation of cool air flowing in and out of the nose; the feeling of perfecting a weight transfer while carving between the wells of several bumps.

Flow state. That sums up this characteristic of being completely single-minded, or in the moment. But what if an activity one loves doesn't bring them the sense of flow any longer? I responded to Alison, saying "I don't feel that way all the time. I'm often thinking of all sorts of things while I'm skiing." Like what if I forgot to hit "submit" on the parking pass. Would the resort really tow my car for not paying $15 dollars for premium parking? Or how excited I will be to marry Alison in the Rockies in a few weeks. It's as if skiing has become so second nature to me, that at times I forget that I'm doing it. 

This made me wonder why I don't feel like I'm in a flow state when Alison does. Skill level is certainly one aspect of flow state. Where the trails we were taking too easy? Am I holding myself back from honing techniques that require full attention to practice? Should I try sending myself off one of the larger ramps on the terrain park, so I that I can force my mind away from any other thoughts to focus on my center of gravity and land safely on the down ramp? Or am I simply not paying attention to some spiritual aspect of being able to ski? I've certainly been aware of myself not in a flow state in the past. In a way, a flow state is achieved when one loses sense of time and self-consciousness. But when was the last time I truly felt this?

I haven't a clue when I last felt like I was in a flow state. I'm often interrupted, and don't go back to something. I struggle to finish things; to want to achieve much. In a way, I feel very much like there isn't much to achieve. Perhaps I could consider myself in a state of flow at all times. I'm constantly just flowing with the rest of the world, and when I zoom out on my life, time seems to be passing faster and faster. So am I mapping incorrectly the concept of flow state to just individual tasks or goals? Maybe, I don't know. I feel disconnected from myself when not in a flow state.

Tuesday, January 2, 2024

Pontifications: The Pontification About Nothing

Walter shares his weekly thoughts, fears, and philosophies (or some bullshit like that).


Joe shared with me a hobbyist's AI-generated sitcom that can be watched on Twitch. I don't really have much context beyond what Joe has shared with me, but some more context may be helpful to understand better what's going on—I'm a bit lazy lately to do more research, so I'll just write with a lot of assumptions here (as any Pontification post is typically written). I previously wrote about the various stages of AI, and there is even more nuance within these stages than what I described, and maybe even more nuance than can be understood by the smartest humans on earth. Remember, humans love categorizing things, but as we get further along the AI journey, we may not be able to categorize all the things that we think AI experiences—a decent indicator we've actually reached ASI, of which I might argue we may have already reached, but have just started appropriating "it," just as we do for all things we desire, despise, or don't understand. True AI (I probably shouldn't use the term "AI," because it probably wouldn't be considered artificial at this point, would it?) will feel alien to us, unless we contain and control it, however we desire. However, why reduce AI to the same characteristics by which humans behave?

In a way, the Twitch show, which seems to mimic a Seinfeld framework, could be considered alien to us now. To assume that this is a sitcom show like Seinfeld is just my own internal machine categorizing and labeling based on intuition and what Joe told me. So let's remove the assumption that this is a Seinfeld-like sitcom. When we do this, what is left? I see and hear a myriad of things: pixels creating scenes of various nature, but mostly of indoor places; people, with humanoid figures, but little detail to their emotions or otherwise; conversations between these humanoid figures, of which are fragmented and are of high latency—basically incomprehensible, insensible discussions. But what I describe here is mere categorizations of what I observe. Could these beings be manifested by another being, behind the scenes? Maybe a ChatGPT? Is what I see on the screen the manifestation of various given parameters to abide by? Was this AI trained on Seinfeld content? Was the goal or objective function, driving what I see, trained from millions of Seinfeld movie frames? I'll never really know unless I peel back the layers of abstraction that underpin this content. Underpinning it all are electrons, flowing through trillions of stage gates in a data center somewhere.

Another thing is for sure, I feel little connection to the characters on the screen. They are alien to me, despite looking humanoid and speaking my language. However, if I spent infinite time with these "characters," would I begin to understand them better? To empathize? The problem is that the language is too disjointed for me to want to tune in indefinitely, likely because of the latency between various ChatGPTs making requests and responses to one another. Not to mention the voiceover is hard to connect with the actual characters. The pixelated faces, along with various camera shots/angles, make associating a voice with a character nearly impossible. Even when the camera is focused on a single character I am not sure if what I hear should be mapped to that character or another off-screen character. I assume whatever GPT is generating the voice-over is disconnected from the GPT orchestrating the pixels on the screen (I later rewatched the stream, and it turns out that I process the video and audio in a way that seems more cohesive the second time around—this just validates what I said earlier about spending more time to understand something). Even when I try hard to process the connection between what I see and hear, I am continuously distracted by the random pulse-movements of the humanoid figures! I watched one character, sitting on what looked like a couch, thrust, what looks like its hips, up and down. No mind was given to what was being spoken, because I was trying to figure out if this humanoid figure was intentionally thrusting itself back and forth or if there was some polygonal graphical collision bug occurring. As if this low resolution scene was actually a stimulus overload for me! What a paradoxical mind-fuck, much like these Pontification posts can be.

And so this experience with this Twitch channel has reminded me of something consequential. Generalized knowledge is really hard to describe, comprehend, and teach others without infinite time and resources to digest all the signals and noise coming at oneself. So, it's safe to nod our heads and call this "impressive," despite awareness of the noise and low resolution. I'll reiterate that I re-watched this stream, and found some of the content to actually be more coherent and funny. That is, it made me laugh, maybe because of the absurdity of it all.

Tuesday, December 19, 2023

Pontifications: The Gift That Keeps On Giving

Walter shares his weekly thoughts, fears, and philosophies (or some bullshit like that).


All of this consumption of AI concepts and tooling, lately, is not inspiring anything productive in my life. I use it at work to script little transformations in order to validate data coming from external parties meets the requirements—what requirements?—for our internal Analytics team. Data pipelines should have been built already to do this for me; however, everyone is swamped at work between the myriad of requests, not only for clients, but also the administrative end-of-year bullshit that doesn't have a clear meaning to me yet.

A three-sixty (360) review process was just rolled out at work and I am not a fan of it. It's not that I cannot be a fan of it, it just takes more time than is given to complete it, and with little to no thought on how best to complete it, and no clear understanding of the reward is for completing it. Maybe provide the training 30 days before the roll-out, and give fifteen days to select folks for the 360 review; another fifteen for the review process itself. Instead, leadership has stuffed it all into three weeks, among regular work and holiday partying. No one wants to give reviews while they're partying on-site for the week. Taking time to reflect on co-worker's achievements is drowned out just by having to hang out with them in real time. And what's the point of these week-long Summit-parties? I basically just used the whole week to be constantly distracted from the work that I now have to catch up on just before the holiday break; time I'd like to spend with friends and family. So much for getting a holiday break—instead, leadership foisted upon me their insecurity of the company not feeling connected enough, and more anxiety about having to support new revenue targets for next year that appear to be 2x the multiple of the previous year.

I've been jaded by work lately. And I'm not alone. I speak with friends who describe similarly, and who also describe friends-of-friends with the same concerns. Am I just in a bubble of cynics? I don't think so. A lot of boondoggling has been going on the last fourteen years, with "easy money," and it appears to be bubbling to the surface now with interest rates now making it harder to borrow and build some fantasy start-up empire. And now the techies who are burnt out from the easy money are competing with the safer jobs, where I've probably been sitting my whole career. At least, this is the fear I have—that all the folks who abandoned SF are now moving to NYC, pushing up the rent and overselling themselves on the jobs that I typically would apply my old school corporate experience to. I'll tell you, I feel the squeeze in my rent, and at work. And as a result, the holiday season suffers as well.

Or does it? I hear that consumer spending is doing okay at a national level. Why is this important anymore? It's such a fucking stupid measure for health! But I'm no longer in the consumer crowd the way that I was brought up in my parent's household. In fact, I've been pushing back on the November-December consumer spend since before I had more financial freedom than I do now. But I can't seem to truly shake the spend. The more I make, the more I spend. And when I try to spend less, inflation creeps into my life on things like rent. I'd often ask myself as a child, after my mom would allude to how poor the family is (surprise, we're not as bad off as I was lead to believe), "well then why are we spending so much on toys and gadgets, effectively giving our money away to whoever? Why don't we just exchange money with our family?" Then, thoughts of exchanging money back and forth between family lead to a sense of pointlessness in giving at all!

The giving of anything tied to money has always sparked cognitive dissonance for me. This is not a novel revelation, so why is awareness of human's cognitive dissonance with materialism seemingly impossible to solve? Why is the act of "giving" so difficult to separate from monetary systems? Material gifts were always just distractions to make me feel better for some time. I'm not sure I ever felt a sense of "gift" from the items I received. I don't know what receiving a gift should feel like other than this latent frustration I'm describing; nor do I know how to give a gift to someone, especially my family, in a way that doesn't invoke this latent frustration! My partner is great at giving gifts; typically a well thought out card with a candle, or some other consumable item that she knows the receiver will use. She seems to enjoy this... But how are you to know if a gift is well-received? Why not give the gift of silence? Or leaving someone alone for once?

Suffice to say, I'd like the same at work. I'd like to not have to give performance feedback to coworkers. Isn't that the job of leadership? Aren't they supposed to be plugged into the work that their underlings are doing? Shouldn't that work have been done by leadership, so they know whether expectations are being met or exceeded? I'd rather enjoy the company of the humans I work with without the context of work. However, I just do not enjoy their company because of the intersection of the work that is unclear, insurmountable, and feels like a boondoggle. And it's because of the squeeze I feel in this economy that the work feels so unclear to me. I don't care if we're not in a recession—something about the state of work makes the economy feel recessed for me regardless of what Paul Krugman or any textbook economist would tell me. Our debt-to-GDP ratio is 120%! Higher than ever before, and I don't get a strong sense that America has the potential to create the momentum to become the exporter things again. And even if we were, what gift would America be giving to the rest of the world? More bombs? What gift would we want to give to ourselves? More cornmeal? I'd like affordable housing, I know that. I'd like to know that society is not crumbling, or that our ecosystem will not be decimated to a point where it cannot support my future offspring.

Tuesday, December 12, 2023

Pontifications: The Giving Tree

Walter shares his weekly thoughts, fears, and philosophies (or some bullshit like that).


I just got back from a long run with a good colleague of mine; we work at the same company and he's a German data scientist. Why his nationality matters, I'm not sure, but his general knowledge about the world is underpinned by his education of breaking down systems, measuring something about each component within the system, and then stringing those measurements together—using various algorithms—to provide some insight into the performance of that system. If he says this is what he doesn't do, then he's wrong or I'm just not doing justice in my description of his work. We share a lot of what we're thinking about, or working on. More so, he's able to focus more on specific working-ons; whereas, I'm constantly thinking—pontificating, right? I enjoy learning about what he's working on due to my appreciation of operations research and systems engineering; however, my education on the subject is undergraduate and not applied, and I feel I'm missing something fundamental to want to do this work myself...

Anyway, a couple of weeks ago, when I had just started listening to an aforementioned book The Coming Wave* [of AI, essentially], I recall discussing with this Data Scientist the idea of using plant or other regenerative tissues (proteins, I think) as media to replace the latest GPU/TPU chipset architectures that allow us to process large amounts of data to create the AI systems we have today. The current silicon chips are built using laser lithography now, and we're able to get down to some 25nm in size of the transistor in order to, generally, maintain a Moore's Law rate of "double the transistors in a circuit every two years."

Supposedly. According to a new book I'm listening to, Human Compatible by Stuart Russell, Moore's Law is expected to reach some limitation in 2025 with the current technology.  As transistors approach the size of just a few atoms, issues like quantum tunneling and heat dissipation become significant challenges. Once we reach atom-size transistors, we will need to unlock more capacity using 3D stacking of the current silicon-based architecture, and improving the heat dissipation issue using material science. This all leads the ultimate unlocker of of Moore's Law in the 21st(?) century—qubits.

The definition of a qubit sounds like some black fucking magic, where instead of having a bit state limitation of just two states (0 or 1), we will have access to double the amount of bits currently, exponentially increasing the density of compute/storage at the atomic level. The biggest limitations here appear to be concepts of interference, similar to (and including) what the human race has had to deal with regarding electro-magnetic interference (EMI). What are some of these interferences?

Thermal noise, electromagnetic fields, or even collisions with air molecules all lead to a problem of "decoherence," when the qubit essentially loses its quantum ability to provide those additional states. Other noise factors reduce the reliability of the computational gates to get into various states, which increases the potential for computational error. Just the act of trying to measure a qubit could, supposedly, change the state of the qubit. In a way, this doesn't seem so foreign to me. In my engineering capstone project, way back in the day, I used a cadmium cell to measure light interference to detect an object passing between the cell and ambient light. When I was being graded on this, the performance of the system degraded due to the ambient light! The sensor I used to measure the object needed to be re-calibrated if I moved the apparatus to a different room. I also assume, but never really cared to test it out, that a fully dark room would render the cadmium cell—by which I was measuring an electrical signal based on how much light was hitting it—completely useless in this application.

So, with all that said, I've wondered why we cannot leverage trees as a computing medium for some of the same, or similar, promises that quantum computer espousers say they'll get with reliable creation and measurement of qubits. Trees are extremely regenerative, so could they build the quantum computers for us, while drawing down carbon and effectively not require all the energy that is currently needed to keep data centers running? Though trees likely have some environmental interference which may negatively impact human's computational exploitation of them. Trees have molecular structures that seem to be stacked (I think?), allowing for more capacity for compute/storage. But are we able to measure the signals in the barks of trees? What manufacturing is needed to build these measurement tools? Does the make-up of the air cause defects in the bark's atomic layers? Would the electromagnetic interference of the earth and sun interfere with our ability to measure the states of the bits in the atomic levels of the tree bark? What if a fungus attacks the tree? Would we have enough redundancy to keep our modern compute/storage reliable for the public and corporate consumers to apply their capital to?

What I've described in the last paragraph is likely not at all not a practical realization of what is to come in regards to the future of technology. At least not until humanity reaches a precipice of exponential self-destruction. The thing is, what I describe is already happening, we just don't pay any attention to it in the grand scale of capitalism, and prefer to engineer our own simulation of what nature already does.

These thoughts continued to race through my brain, as Matthias and I rode the subway back from our run to our neighborhood, standing next to a man who is on his way to hussle-off his massive bags of collected NYC recycled cans.


*I realized I typo'd the title of the book last week by forgetting "Coming" in the title. Oops.

Tuesday, December 5, 2023

Pontifications: How AI Can

Walter shares his weekly thoughts, fears, and philosophies (or some bullshit like that).


This past weekend, some friends came into town for the normal debauchery (dinner, drinks, basketball/football games at the bar, more drinks because another friend joined at 10 PM). It was great to catch up, but I still struggle with the feeling that my life is comprised of two separate programs—one of complete sobriety, and the other not (but with personal boundaries). I'm generally okay with being bucked off my sober-horse, because I'd vacillate the other way and start to ask "what is all this programming serving me anyway"—two-sides-of-the-same-coin sort of rationalization of my happiness. By throwing myself off the normal program (let's reduce the definition of "program" down to the establishment in self-discipline of any sort of action that I've decided is worthy of my time and attention), I am able to hone my reflection sensors on the signals that start to creep into my psyche, in order to determine if I need to set even stricter boundaries in one direction or another.

Sometimes I like the challenge of these symptoms continuing, so that I may better define what the proper response should be in this feedback loop of: 1) do this and you'll be happier, 2) doing this thing makes me feel happier, 3) oh no, I'm going to do this other thing that I am feeling ashamed about doing too much of, but I still like the people who I do it with because I can feel some happiness with them, 4) oh, that was a lot of doing that thing, maybe I went too far and shouldn't be happy anymore, 5) wow, actually doing that thing made me realize that I can be happy on either side of this sine wave of emotions and that they're actually both emotions of happiness, just expressed in opposite directions.

Speaking of waves, I recently listened to the book The Wave by Mustafa Suleyman, a co-founder of Deep Mind and Inflection AI. This book was recommended to me by Spotify, and is super meta to feedback loops I often concoct in my mind and with others—Spotify is sort of an institution of knowledge and entertainment, bringing creators and consumers together. This content was just deep enough to unlock some new fear factors where the AI revolution is happening before our senses. It increased the broadness of impact that AI will have on my life and others around me. I've read other books on the more technical ways in which AI will cause knowledge work to be augmented or replaced in jobs (like project management), but this one jolted me into the future where I started to really imagine complete paradigm shifts. Some of these shifts already feel like they're being nudged along. But how can I trust what I cannot see? So here's a few links to make to help inform what we're up against:
  • The Odin — this site (i.e., a market place) for bio-genetic engineering equipment appears to have a comprehensive set of equipment and starter DIY kits to do CRISPR at home! Okay, maybe not useful without a true understanding of the steps involved to do this, but the fact that you can browse for various tools to apply to CRISPR projects is, of itself, incredible. This is like the Newegg of bioengineering. Further diving into ODIN reveals a contract service, and a glimpse into their ethos: The Open Discovery Institute (ODIN): "Our biohacker lab offers top quality. R&D without breaking the bank. A fully equipped biolab complemented by knowledgeable experts empowers us to undertake experiments other contract labs wont. We're open to any project and budget. You wont find a team that matches our proficiency and pricing anywhere else."
    • In The Wave, Suleyman warns that biohacker garages combined with genetic AI tools could allow accidental creations of deadly viruses and bacteria. I'm not sure if websites like these are regulated, or what types of bacteria may be morphed from these kits, but the potential is there. Just the access to the equipment at a lower price point is revealing to all sorts of possibilities.
  • Humane's AI pin — this product (releasing early 2024) may become what the iPhone became to Blackberry. The display is a little cheesy, so ignore that for now. Instead, focus on the idea that we could move towards a world where we don't need screens, and devices like these become our personal assistant. The AI chips are built into this, and use ambient computing—something that I've heard one ex-googler say is going to be a new concept of integrating IoT and all the apps we interact with. AI will abstract the daily technology gadgets we have into a higher level of command and control.
    • I can see this being a huge positive in our world... just watch a demo for some of the use cases.
    • But does this drain our capacity to think for ourselves? Is it a band-aid result of a system where we're over-capacity and are trying to fix it with more technology? Or is this simply increasing our capacity, using tools already at our disposal, but more efficiently?
    • Maybe Humane's AI pin can help plan more meaningful and sober trips with my friends in real time. Or maybe it can help me enforce and audit the boundaries I'd like to put on my life with others.
I'm not saying I will be using either of these products in the future, but it's super interesting to see the patterns of technology repeat itself in the early stages, like how AOL opened Pandora's box of the internet to me. Maybe, in my lifetime, I'll start to notice more and more patterns like this, and will give me new excitement for change. Whether that excitement is positive or negative doesn't really matter, because I'm convinced I won't have any choice in using these tools if they're deemed extremely helpful by the rest of the population—just the way the modern smartphone has become ubiquitous in only a decade and half.

I'm curious what other ambient computing applications are being built... and I wonder when biological gene editing will intersect with AI-enabled ambient computing... Will this be the indicator that we're in the AGI/ACI phase of the AI [r]evolution?

Can I leverage plant genetics to develop an extremely hardened tree bark that mimics the structure of nano-scale logic gates to be used as transistors that form a GPU for processing compute at super low energy/emission levels? Imagine if our global data centers were just forests of genetically modified trees!

Tuesday, November 28, 2023

Pontifications: nWo

Walter shares his weekly thoughts, fears, and philosophies (or some bullshit like that).

You know what the New World Order is going to be? Fucking AI. Before, it was just Machine Learning algorithms forecasting that you're running out of toilet paper—want to buy more? "No," Sam replied, "I bought a bunch of toilet paper behind your back because I'm afraid of a nuclear holocaust that the news has been forecasting would drive ad sales. Some humans will survive, and they're going to need toilet paper!"

Now we're in the phase of Generative AI, where all the machine learning algorithms seem combined into an abstract service layer, distilling any prompt into a forecasted answer. "Write a python script that translates a given CSV file into an XML format based on the following specifications."

Sam Altman, Illya, and "the Boys"—because the female board members of OpenAI actually seemed to be ousted after all the drama—are working to figure out how to get us into the Artificial Generative Intelligence period, where the machines are just as smart as us Humans are in logic and reasoning.

Artificial Super intelligence (ASI) is next, and will come when it comes. With that, a New World Order. My mind hasn't been able to fully distill what this will look like, but I imagine an inundation of propaganda from various class levels, based on one's geographic area. Doesn't that seem similar to our current state? What those class levels will look like may be completely different from what we see today—is this what Ann Leckie's Ancillary Justice novel is alluding to?

What that New World Order will look like doesn't really matter, because I'm still addicting myself to the generative AI offering of today. My addiction became apparent when last week's OpenAI drama coincided with some ChatGPT technical disruptions; throttling; and a temporary suspension of new user sign-ups for version 4. During this time, I realized how many hours I have been spending on generating all sorts of GPT content: for work, fun, personal debates and conversations (some with myself). Like the AOL chat rooms and Google searches before, generative AI has reinvigorated my mind to seek out my current curiosities. Any disruptions of this addiction to consume the AI tokens make me feel and wonder a few things:
  • I feel like my capacity to learn to code is impossible without AI; at the same time, I am apparently not interested enough to want to learn to code by reading books, because I'm using AI to find the solutions for me. I just want to leverage code to create scripts to do things I don't want to do, or to discover information more quickly from data that I wouldn't have analyzed because I can't efficiently (or proficiently) design and implement a script. I want to use AI to exploit something, but what that something is seems to constantly change.
  • I wonder if I will become dependent on AI like I've become dependent on search engines to find answers. Or on books and other knowledge tools of the past to satiate whatever is curious. Isn't it all the same?
  • Without AI, internet, books, or people, what would exploring curiosity look like? I'm addicted to knowing, aren't I?
With all that said, how would one even define the phases or stages of AI and the current period by which it is defined? If I'm already leveraging the current phase of AI, and feel handicapped when it's suddenly not available, can't the AI already be considered somewhat Super Intelligent due to my dependence on it? Or am I limiting myself to the whims of technology? I come full circle, without any real coherence, to the position that AI will be the New World Order. Technology rules me.

I think I need to cry because that's something AI cannot currently do, so it cannot be considered ASI. Until Altman unlocks that capability, I am my own New World Order.

Tuesday, November 21, 2023

Pontifications: Introductory Thoughts

Walter shares his weekly thoughts, fears, and philosophies (or some bullshit like that).


Lately, I've struggled with reconciling between my younger naive inner child—with him, all of the potential propaganda and prejudices that he's been conditioned to—and my older, 35-year-old self who is seeing current global crises unfold with a more critical lens.

Am I experiencing the same privilege that my analog would have experienced during WWI, WWII, Vietnam, and/or the Cold War? Are we experiencing multitudes of the previous era conflicts all in a span of five-to-ten years?
  • Is there a new world order coming as a result of these crises? It surely won't be the global south winning, right?
  • What does winning even look like with a climate crisis looming? And who would I even want to win?
  • Why do we freak out about our economic system, when human history has proven prosperity over and over again?
  • Why are there so many wellness studies coming out saying that everything I eat is addictive and will kill me?
Whatever the answers to those previous questions are, the ultimate one is: Would my analog persona have known the same information in any other period marked by rising tensions (political and economic), outright war, etc...? Or do I just have access to so much information now that my lizard brain is going nuts?

Adam Tooze has been on my radar for some time, and he does a pretty good job of posing these questions and basically saying (but not quoted) no one knows WTF is going on... but so many people seem to be feeling something is different this time... Whatever this time even means. Even the bankers are just pontificating, and many are supposedly admitting this in a way that Adam Tooze senses nervousness and lack of control they felt they had before.

So here is to my first submission of Pontifications: the discovery of the polycrisis and all the fear mongering that comes with it!