The Record Club Alumni Association meets every week to discuss the larger body of work that our RC alumni have put together, outside of the specific albums that were covered in the main section of our club. You can follow along with everything that the RCAA has covered so far HERE.
(Deeper Dive)
Rusted Root
When I Woke — RC Week 267 — 3 pukes out of 5
October 22, 1996
Oh wow, "Send Me on My Way" did a LOT of heavy lifting when it came to the lack of accusations of Rusted Root being a bro-y jam band. Without that immaculate pop song protecting it, this sounds like the obvious answer to where something like O.A.R. came from. These are the songs that make you know that the crowd in those Rusted Root audiences in the '90s were white and dreadlocked and smelled like they didn't bathe in a week. But they were well-intentioned too, just like I believe Rusted Root is well-intentioned when they dip into world music that sounds like Ali Farka Touré if he got lost in Vermont. As much as I like the Matilda song, I really appreciated the room that Rusted Root had room to breathe on Remember. There are no hits (obviously, as they are a one-hit wonder), and the songs hang around only a minute or two past their expiration, which is cool! Everyone is just happy to be here! I like how Rusted Root frontman Michael Glabicki tries to sound like Eddie Vedder on some of these songs. I like how Rusted Root isn't serious all the time, like when they are boogying down to "Virtual Reality." Finally, I like how there are very few DMB vibes this time around. They are just out here, doing their thing, way past their brief time in the spotlight. I dig it. I too haven't bathed in a week.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
(Follow-up)
BTS
BE — RC Week 103 — 2.5 pukes out of 5
March 20, 2026
I didn't know that this album was purposefully bifurcated into a hip hop side and a pop side until it was done. Listening to all the hip hop songs, I was ready to declare BTS as a pop group worth following, which, ya know, is pretty close to faint praise, but far and above anything I'd be comfortable declaring when we covered their last album, approximately one thousand years ago. The pop songs are fine, though, and exactly what I expected. I won't complain about being forced to listen to a BTS album that upended my expectations exactly half the time. It's a shame too, because the thematic hook is so much easier with the hip hop stuff (should I be putting "hip hop" in quotes? I think maybe). These jabronis took a six-year break in between albums because they had to join the military! And now here they are, rapping over stark military beats! Logistically, it makes sense! It even makes sense that they'd be aping Kendrick Lamar in the "Hooligan" video, because now they are grown up! Adults who have been hardened by the South Korean military industrial complex! But alas, all that pretty much goes away once they start doing their heartthrob act on the second half of ARIRANG. What can ya do. I'm satisfied, overall.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
Harry Styles
Fine Line — RC Week 154 — 3.5 pukes out of 5
Harry's House — RC f/u #8 — 3 pukes out of 5
March 6, 2026
I feel like we see this all the time in RCAA with pop stars—there's a difference between being different in the context of making music, and being different in the context of making pop music. Basically every song on Harry Styles' new and garishly titled album sounds like another band that I'm already familiar with, but at the same time, every song sounds nothing like anything anyone of his genre and stature within that genre is doing right now. There are songs that remind me of Radiohead, LCD Soundsystem, Discovery, Foals, tUnE-yArDs, and on and on and on. If I was writing a proper review and this was some random British indie rock band from the mid-'10s, I'd scream the word "derivative" from the highest mountaintop I could find. But this isn't some random band, this is one of the biggest pop stars of our age. The fact that this fucking guy is putting out a pop song like "Season 2 Weight Loss" is fucking fascinating. Now, I'm not saying that I like all of it, or even most of it. I don't need someone like Harry Styles occasionally making music that sounds like Everything Not Saved Will Be Lost — Part 3, but I do think it's pretty cool that we have it. It tickles me to think of all the moms who cracked this thing open expecting another "Watermelon Sugar" and instead finding a legitimate road of discovery toward Kid A and This Is Happening. The only time I get bored is when Harry Styles sounds like... Harry Styles. He is a certified pop star, after all, so this happens a disappointing number of times (e.g. "Coming Up Roses"). I'd still say that, overall, this is at least worth a sniff, especially if you're bored with the state of pop like I am, and are desperate for something that at least tries to shake it up a little bit, occasionally.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
Gorillaz
Song Machine, Season One: Strange Timez — RC Week 97 — 3.5 pukes out of 5
Cracker Island — RC f/u #15 — 2 pukes out of 5
Demon Days — RCAA #1 — 3 pukes out of 5
February 27, 2026
Damn, now this is a hook that I can get behind. I've never been a huge fanatic of Gorillaz, but I've always had a lot of respect for them, and how versatile they are. You never know what genre any particular song is gonna end up being. There are a lot of Indian Hindustani sounds on The Mountain, as a great example in the present day. ("The Manifesto" is a Spanish rapper spitting bars over an Indian beat, and yeah, it still sounds like Gorillaz.) They can do anything. With that comes the risk of any one album becoming "a great collection of varied songs." (I think the issue I ultimately had with Demon Days, when I finally listened to it a few months ago, was that there wasn't enough variation.) What Gorillaz needed for this new one was a strong hook, and they found it. This is Gorillaz's death album. Not only are many of the songs about death, reincarnation, the afterlife, that sort of thing, but also, many of Gorillaz's past collaborators are brought back into the fold... even though they themselves have passed away. At least six artists who previously featured on a Gorillaz track and have since died are featured on this album (yes, including our boy Dennis Hopper, whose inclusion in Demon Days was fascinating already). They found old recordings from sessions with these artists, and added them into The Mountain. After only a couple listens, I'm ready to declare this a late-career triumph for this band ("band"? I still don't really know), and also ready to commit to a more listens, to see how deep it goes.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
(Random RC News)
- Animal Collective is gonna play some live shows together soon, the first time in a while.
- You hear of this Stella Lefty person? She is not an RC alumna, but she has been credibly accused of ripping off at least four songs at this point, including an RC song from Noah Kahan and a non-RC song from the Chicks.
- Mackelmore is not an RC alumnus either, but he's open for RC artist Ed Sheeran on a big tour these days. Now certain groups are asking that Ed Sheeran kick Mackelmore off the tour for using the stage to offer this opinion: "To all of my Jewish brothers and sisters: Criticism of Israel, criticism of apartheid, being against genocide in no way is a criticism of you. My message is for peace. Love. For all human beings to be treated with dignity, respect, and equality. So I say free Palestine." Seems pretty reasonable to me! Not sure why people would think that's not reasonable, but ya never know!
- The electronic music artist who is depicted as a witch on the cover of Black Sabbath is revealed to be an AI freak. Yikes!



















