What does a blog see? Into the head? Down into the heart? Does it see into me? Into us? Clearly or darkly? I hope it sees clearly because I can't any longer see into myself. I see only 500 movies I've never seen before. I hope for everyone's sake the bloggers do better, because if the blogger sees only darkly the way I do, then I'm cursed and cursed again.
2006
Richard Linklater
Thanks to all those who watched A Scanner Darkly and submitted some thoughts! Check 'em out below!
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Kait
I wish I watched this movie in one sitting instead of over two, because two separate viewings with a few days in between really muddied the plot for me. I also did not finish it in time to write this review. I think I have about 20 minutes left. Here are my thoughts on what I did see:
I had a hard time following what was going on. But maybe I've got it... My understanding is everyone is addicted to drugs and ratting each other out. "They" (the government / New Path?) got Keanu Reeves addicted to Substance D, big time, while doing undercover work. They used him to get to Barris and don't care about any collateral damage. Donna was in on all of it too.
Cool although somewhat predictable story of government and corporations exploiting humanity for their own whatever the fuck gains. I liked those scanner suits that hid their identities, and the animation was neat. I would love to see some behind-the-scenes acting footage, and am curious how they did the animation. Also, the acting was good. I just didn't get a chance to really connect to this film. Again, could be watching it in two sittings.
Oh! One thing that stuck with me was this weird policy of if an Officer becomes an addict but doesn't report it promptly is subject to a misdemeanor. That's some legal fine print bullshit right there.
Anyway, I'd say 2 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~
Brianna
I will admit it took me entirely too long to pinpoint the profound sense of déjà vu I had while watching
A Scanner Darkly from my couch this week. The "Is that... no, it can't be. Alex Jones?" moment should have been a dead giveaway, but yeah. It was even later that I remember the similarly animated, philosophical acid trip of Film Club's past:
Waking Life.
I didn't like that one a ton, to be honest. I remember appreciating the big swing of its animation technique, but wishing the story was something more coherent. And while "coherent" is not necessarily the first word that comes to mind when I think about A Scanner Darkly, I suppose that it could still apply under the circumstances.
In a way, the incoherent parts of Scanner actually ended up being some of my favorite bits. The scenes of Woody Harrelson and RDJ just going back and forth, for example, did absolutely nothing for plot progression, but man, I could probably watch that all day. The bicycle gear discussion and escalation to hammer fight were both excellent fun. Long-winded deep dives into metaphysics? Noticeably less.
One thing both films did have in common was a sense of purpose behind the choice to animate. In Waking Life, it felt like a way to visualize and imagine the ideas being discussed. No way I would've sat through those scenes without that, honestly. In A Scanner Darkly, it felt like an embodiment of the drug-addled world we were thrown into. I doubt any visual effect available in 2006 would have made me as uncomfortable as those animated bugs in the opening of the film did. And the scramble suits: impossible without the animation, though I probably could've done without the motion sickness I felt every time Fred had to go to the office.
Without its style, I don't think the film's story stands up on its own. The story was kinda meh, with its strengths lying in the unrelated moments in between plot points.
2.5 out of five pukes
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Catherine
I read that Richard Linklater's A Scanner Darkly is a well-made, "faithful adaptation" of the Philip K. Dick novel and I guess I'll just have to take everyone's word for it. I'm sure Philip and Richard have a good understanding of what's happening in their story, but most of it was sadly lost on my simple mind. It's been a while since I've been a real shameless hater in Film Club so I'm gonna fully dive in for my own enjoyment.
BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.
Kidding, sort of. I know lots of people love this film and I could almost see why in a few glimmering moments of clarity, but overall it just could not hold my attention. A big part of the problem was my inability to get captions working on YouTube so I spent a lot of time struggling to make out all the whisper acting in this goddamn film, which I know begs the question: did I really watch it at all? I don't know!!
There are a few things I can say definitively did not work for me. I hate the rotoscope animation overlay that is clearly supposed to invoke a trippy, hallucinatory feel but to me just really accentuated how much Woody Harrelson's character looks like Shaggy from Scooby-Doo.
I also fall into the large category of red-blooded American that adores Keanu Reeves but thinks he sucks pretty hard at acting in a way that distracts the hell out of me during a film that was already testing my patience.
On a positive note, I found Robert Downey Jr. incredibly captivating, and thought he handled his tricky dialogue well. What the fuck he was talking about or what his character's motivations were is simply beyond my comprehension, but good job, Bob.
There was a moment when I was peeking at the clock and trying to keep my mind focused for just a little longer that I'll admit I had a little breakthrough. It was during Keanu's monologue that explains the film's title:
"What does a scanner see? Into the head? Down into the heart? Does it see into me? Into us? Clearly or darkly? I hope it sees clearly because I can't any longer see into myself. I see only murk. I hope for everyone's sake the scanners do better, because if the scanner sees only darkly the way I do, then I'm cursed and cursed again."
I was suddenly intrigued. I was moved. It felt relatable somehow. At the very least it made me want to give the book a shot. Maybe then I'll finally get what's going on (probably not, but a girl can dream).
Sorry to be a downer. 1/5 Tablets of Substance D
~~~~~~~~~~
Joe
File this one under "need to see again," a folder that grows unwieldy in its girth over the years. That's just how it's gonna be when you're devoting a majority portion of your life to watching films you've never seen before—all the interesting ones you've seen before get pushed to the side to make room. That's unfair to movies like A Scanner Darkly, movies that demand an initial watch to figure out what in the fuck is even happening, and then a second watch to thoroughly soak in the themes. So it goes.
Let's make a rule, though: it's okay to be confused while watching a movie, but only if at least one of the characters in the movie is just as confused as you are. Whether it's by design or just something you can use as an excuse, it's doesn't really matter—I was in Bob's/Fred's headspace throughout the length of the film, in that I was barely holding onto reality. That feels like a simple and effective way to get you to understand a character's motivation, make you feel what they are feeling. Even when that feeling is utter confusion.
I'm inclined to think that withstanding temptation to exposition is almost always a good thing. It might have benefited the audience for someone to turn to the camera and explain what the hell the deal with the drug D even is, but that also would've felt unearned, too easy. The tension between audience and filmmaker that happens when key information is held back and then deployed at just the right time, that's the thing that makes a movie like this work. I'm just saying that some of us are too stupid (me) to get it the first time around.
So while I'm out here figuring out what the fuck any of this even is, there's all kinds of interesting stuff happening in the next layer down, philosophical stuff that ultimately stands as the reason that Philip K. Dick is an important author (and, not incidentally, why Richard Linklater is an important filmmaker). I was confused but managed to get someone of a grip on, for example, the scene in which Bob/Fred reveals that he (might have) had a family in a previous life, a life he hated, a family he resented. That whole thing made it clear—regardless about any opaque plot points surrounding it—that this addiction—whatever it actually is, however it compares to or differs from addition as we know it here in the real world—is a reaction to some deep-seeded desire to escape.
And how that impulse should not be punished! That's I think what the deal is with the words presented at the end of the movie. I'm told these were the real words that concluded Dick's novel, how Dick lost friends to substance abuse and that his novel was a tribute to those friends, "who were punished entirely too much for what they did." I think the point (and I felt it, as you might have, for personal reasons above all else) was that the actions of the characters in this film, the D addicts, their actions are supposed to be sympathetic. It's a choice to take a drug but often times it's not really a choice to keep taking that drug, and the lack of choice should be the source of sympathy (or empathy, depending on your position in life).
That conclusion comes from thinking about the film in the week after watching it. I would imagine that I'd be able to pull more if I watched it again, knowing the layered motivations of each character (with the Scramble Suits adding that crucial extra layer). It would also probably give me more time to appreciate scenes such as a bike gear scene. I don't doubt that this is a scene pulled from the novel, but shit, man, if ever there was a movie scene that was pure fucking Richard Linklater. I can easily picture a similar conversation occurring between Slater and Pickford, or between Jesse and Céline. Amusing on the surface, these ideas often go way deeper into the film's heart than it seems at first. For example, there was an edge of danger in the bike gear scene. Why? Just because they were on hard drugs instead of just pot or beer? Or was it trying to say something else?
There was a lot I couldn't figure out, which is okay. That's especially true because the temptation is to say "it's even more relevant now!" That's true and it's also a cliché when it comes to science fiction. The good sci-fi feels predictive because it's actually timeless, meaning that it's hitting ideas that were important then and remain important now. I'll resist the temptation to say that A Scanner Darkly is even more applicable to our Flock-filled and AI-addled and cop-corrupt nation, because you know that already.
But I will say that I appreciated the presence of the noxious, despicable Alex Jones as the minor character who voices these concerns out loud before being thrown into the back of a van. This piece of shit has to peddle gas station boner pills now just to pay his legal bills, but let's acknowledge that there was something about his conspiratorial ramblings at the turn of the 21st century that touched fellow Austinite Richard Linklater in some small way. Not that he was right, not that he was a good or kind person, but more that it made sense, then as it does now, to feel the impulse to question the truth. We're told that Flock cameras will keep us safe. We're told that it's okay for cops to wear masks if we're not doing anything illegal anyway. We're told that a glass of wine at the end of the day is going to make us feel better. You should probably feel compelled to question what you're told, at least some of the time.
Lots of confusion to get there though. Which is my fault, and I guess Film Club's structure's fault too. No worries. A Scanner Darkly is sound enough that I'm confident it's a great movie, even if I'd need a rewatch to confirm.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~
GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 2.25 pukes out of 5
You are being surveilled in the comments. Submit or face consequences.
(NEXT TIME: We're having a Zoom this Wednesday, 11/18 at 9 PM, for To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything! Julie Newmar)