Tuesday, November 17, 2026

TxIxL DxExAxTxH #31: "Everybody Digs Doug"

A review of S02E09 of the American sitcome 'Til Death.


Satan said, "Welcome to hell." He was being sincere, not sarcastic. It was an honest gesture of welcome. Satan isn't the leader of hell, he's an active participant. He feels just like you feel, similar emotions. Including grief, sorrow, regret. And always a little bit of a pang of guilt, that he has to welcome into hell the children who never were.

She, being one of them, spoke her first words: "Why am I in hell?"

And he answered, without making eye contact. "You're in hell because that's how it works. You had a soul, but that soul was in a collection of embryos. You were never full human. You never walked on earth or any other planet. You existed, briefly. And without any evidence in either direction about what kind of person you would have been, had you lived a life, they are forced to stick you here.

"It's not a punishment. Just know that. It's not. You didn't do anything wrong."

She responded: "I never lived. But I wonder. I wonder what I would have been like, if I did."

Satan looked up. This usually happened. It was the one saving grace of the process. An opportunity. He said, "I don't know what you would have been like. But why don't you tell me what you think? What would you have been like? You can guess. There are no wrong answers. It's helpful to speculate. I know from experience. Please, tell me what you would have been like."

She said:

"I think I would've have been part of a full, loving family. I know that for certain. I would've been born to a mommy and a daddy who loved me. I see them love my older brother and I can see the future now and see that they will love my little brother too, and they would've loved me. So much. Their hearts would've burst with joy when they saw me for the first time. And they would've held me in their arms and rocked me back to sleep after the ordeal of childbirth. And I would have lived. I think I would have lived a long, happy life. I would have been named Ruby. My name would have been Ruby, and my parents and brothers, they would've loved me. Ruby. And I would have grown up. I would have had everything I needed. I would have been testy sometimes, or, rather, testing, of those around me. I would have known what I had and still occasionally wanted for more, against my better judgment. I would have tested the limits of what could be provided to me. And when I reached that limit, I would have scaled back and started working for it. I would have been such a hard worker. I would have loved and been loved, and I would have let that two-directional love fuel me to staggering heights. I would be loved by many. Hated by a few, sure, but that's what life is like, so I'm told. It's complicated. But I would've been diligent and I would've won over some of my enemies too. I would have loved and I would have worked hard to be loved. I would have taken it for granted at a young age but as I grew older I would've worked so goddamn hard for that love. I would've sweated through shirts with how hard I was working. I would've loved my daddy and I would have spent each night snuggling with him as I fell asleep. I would have tested him too, oh yes. I would have wondered if there was anything I could do to get him to regret that love. I would have never found that limit in him, but, regretfully, I would have tried. And he would've been there. He would've always shown up. That's how he would have shown his love for me. And on some weeknights we would have sat down and watched the American TV sitcome 'Til Death, as a family, me and Mommy and Daddy and Tommy and I think his name will be Dylan, the whole Bines family, we would have been happy together, the five of us, watching this show, and there would have been an episode in which the great tall guy's daughter, you would have known his name if you were watching this episode, the guy, you know, the tall guy from Hoodwinked Too! Hood vs. Evil, the voice of the giant, right, and his goth daughter comes home for the weekend, or week, I would've been confused on that point but it wouldn't have mattered, I'd be watching this with my family, and seeing the tall giant guy struggle to find purpose in life without a job, and he would have leaned on his goth daughter who was home now, leaned on being her father figure in order to give his own life meaning. I would've been watching this, laughing at the secret conflict that once again arises between tall guy and his hot wife, and the semi-related foibles of character actress Kat Foster and her loathsome piefucking husband, and in the middle of laughing at this family's lighthearted japes, and the care and concern (however misguided) the giant was showing his goth daughter, my dad would've turned to me and whispered, "that's how I feel about you." He would be smiling as he said it. He would maybe have a single tear in the corner of his eye. I would've known then the scope of how truly large and overpowering his love of me, his daughter, was. I would've held that moment in my heart like a totem. I would've added it to the flame of my own love for him, and for my whole family, and all my friends, and all the humans I would have held dear. And I would have lived a long and happy life. I would've had ups and downs. The ups would've made the downs worth it, and the downs would've been survivable because of that love within me. And I would've lived a long time. I would have seen each of those four family members passing in time, my parents blessedly of old age, my older brother of brain disease but at an old age himself, my younger brother at the hands of some preventable accident that I can't quite predict right now, I would've ushered them all into the place where I am now, with love and hope for their own unknowable futures. And then I would have continued to live. And I would have been sad some days, but mostly I would have been happy. And I would have grown old, and frail. And I would have found myself on my own deathbed eventually, surrounded by all the descendants that I can now never give the chance to exist. And it would have occurred to me, in a rare moment of lucidity toward the end, what the title meant. 'Til Death. The American sitcome. I would have suddenly realized that these feelings we feel, all the myriad emotions we are lucky enough to touch while we are alive, that they stay with us until we aren't. Alive. They stay till death, in other words. And that would have brought me peace, I think, in my final moments, until I finally expired and was brought right back here."

"Full circle," said Satan.

"Full circle," said Ruby. "All paths lead back here eventually. I know that now."

"I'm glad," said Satan. "But I'm also glad you thought about what could have been. It would have been a nice life. I'm glad you shared that vision with me today."

"I would've been sad," said Ruby. "I would've been sad if I had could be alive and feel that emotion. I would have been sad because my parents will never see it. My life as it could've been. They will never know me. They will never see me born, will never see me live."

"Yes, that's true," said Satan. "But they will certain see that you are loved. That doesn't change. Not ever."

(GRADE: 5 pukes out of 5)

In My Place 320

November 16, 2026. 40.0853, -75.04756. See the updated map here. See all the blog posts here.


Signs of the old world still linger all around us. This used to be a 7-Eleven. It's not anymore. It's not anything. But you can tell it was a 7-Eleven. You can just tell. There are signs. There used to be a payphone here. It's not anymore, because payphones aren't anywhere, let alone here. But you can tell. You can tell by the sign that there was a payphone. "What's a payphone?" at least two of them asked at the same time. She responded "...nothing." She wasn't wrong. They aren't anything anymore. Payphones aren't a thing. But they used to be. Someone made an important call right here, right at this spot, many years ago. They won't anymore. Cue the song.

Monday, November 16, 2026

The PoYB Monthly Playlist: November 2026

You get a dozen songs every month, in playlist form, that act as official PoYB music recommendations, since none of the other music columns are necessarily recommending anything, just exploring. These are your recs. Fuck the algorithm.


This is probably the final Monthly Playlist. At the very least, it'll be the last one of the year (I haven't done any in December in the past, since that's more of a reflective month on all the stuff I've already listened to, and included on previous playlists basically). We'll see how I feel in 2027. I want to believe that we're gonna be playing a little faster and looser on the blog next year, so I probably won't feel like structing playlists in that mindset. But we'll see! We'll see.

November 2026



1. "The Spinning Continuous" by the Olivia Tremor Control — I guess the whole point of making these playlists was that I wouldn't let bands like Olivia Tremor Control fall in between the cracks. I'm talking about the blog in general but I'm also talking about for myself, my personal listening habits. The playlists have a way of reinforcing it. An album like The Same Place feels SO BIG during the week that it's new (or new to me), but then its importance tapers off. And I don't want that. I don't want to listen for a while and then forget about it (or forget about it the whole year and then drag it back out for the End of Year Best Of lists). One of my favorite bands from high school coming back after 27 years and after both of their frontmen died, to release one final psychedelic epic? That's some major shit. I want it on the blog. Here it is.

2. "Tongue" by Fontaines D.C. — But there are other bands and albums and songs that are sufficiently covered here and elsewhere. I reviewed the new Fontaines D.C. album already. What else is there to say? Is the purpose of this playlist just to list my favorite songs, even if I don't have anything interesting to say? Can we all just admit that there are one hundred thousand articles online elsewhere about this band and their new album, and that perhaps PoYB isn't the place to come to if that's what you're looking for?

3. "Ghost's Host" by Classic Traffic — However... I suppose there are some bands that are total niche concerns and covered in a couple places already, but who are worth noting and wouldn't be on the blog otherwise and are, frankly, impossible to google anyway. And so maybe the playlist is worth it then? Is the hilariously named Classic Traffic worth the time? I like the album. I don't know if it was anything special. But I liked it and I certainly like this song enough to include it on a playlist. I just wonder if it's worth it, the playlist.

4. "Bitches Talk Shit" by Sophia Stel — Most of the cool songs that I cover on this blog in spaces like this are songs from artists that I discovered on Stereogum. I'm just spreading the word. But if you want to know more about this singular artist, then I can direct you to my favorite music blog (second-favorite, if you're including PoYB) to read all about them. What is this? Erm, I guess electronica with a thick layer of indie folk layered on top, with an attitude problem of a true Gen Z kid? I am fascinated by it. But I wouldn't know about this music if it wasn't for the professionals.

5. "Colors" by the Tallest Man on Earth — Conversely, I've been with Tallest Man for so long that I don't remember where I first heard about him, or why. Sixteen years later, he's still out here releasing great music. And so I feel obligated to tell you about it, here on the blog. Maybe a playlist is a good way to do it. What more can I tell you about this guy? That this song is cool because it sounds like it's working in some indigenous instruments of some kind, an ocarina or some shit, I don't know, but sounds very cool to me. I guess I could come up with a whole separate blog post about it? But I think more likely would be that I listen to it and enjoy it and forget about it.

6. "FF" by Troye Sivan — And then you have songs that are already covered here on this blog and would've been without a Monthly Playlist or not. "FF" was my big find from Troye Sivan's week with Record Club. A great album, a special song. I don't need the playlist to let you know that. I already let you know in the review. But it is one of my favorite songs of the past 30-ish days though, is the thing, and so it goes on the playlist. I'm just saying that I'm getting tired of it.

7. "Field of Stars" by Greta Van Fleet — I have a friend whose mom is the president of the GVF fan club in Michigan, and when I asked my friend loudly around a campfire if she listened to the new Greta Van Fleet album yet, I could tell by the laughs I got from others that I am not the only one fully cognizant of her mother's extracurricular activities. What the partygoers didn't know, however, is that I'm part of the fan club too. Another good album from our boys! Rack 'em up!!!

8. "Gabriel" by Worldpeace DMT — Another Stereogum find, one that I absolutely would have never known about if gatekeepers online hadn't informed me of it. The most twee album I've heard in years! Some of it gives me nostalgic flashbacks to, like, Architecture in Helsinki. I don't know what people want here on this blog. Should I share it without telling you about it? Share it and repeat what others have said? Share it and graft on some unrelated blog post about it? I don't know what people want, and I don't think there's enough people that actually give a shit that such a question would even be relevant here.

9. "Mr. Train Conductor" by Jalen Ngonda — I have my own personal journey, but I could probably work that out through other columns on this blog. I could've written more about Jalen Ngonda in our Record Club Alumni Association feature. I've only grown to love this album more in the month since writing about it after listening for the first time. That story doesn't need to be spread out to a playlist. I can weave through other things. Not all would be lost, if I got rid of the playlist.

10. "On the Importance of Media Literacy Under Authoritarian Rule" by Harry and the Potters — There are some bands that I have no problem writing "too much" about, though. Harry and the Potters, man, what a band. I put Lumos on my kids' iPod, and they've wanted to listen to it each week on the way to and from dance class. They ask what the title names are when the songs come on, and this one usually puzzles them. I've been trying to explain it as simply as I can. There's an in-book explanation and an in-life explanation, right? We've been talking about what "media literacy" is, and how the maga movement does in many ways look like authoritarian rule, and what that means for the news and media. I don't know if anyone is comprehending it, but we'll get there eventually. Until then: catchy Harry Potter songs.

11. "Autosmile" by @ — Sometimes I feel like my thoughts on a particular band are useless. Here's my thought on @: because of the silly name, I now have a new artist at the bottom of my artist list on my iPod (which is in alphabetical order), displacing 50 Cent. See? Is that really worth writing about? No. But it's a good song, on a good album, by a good band, so maybe that makes it worth it? What exactly am I trying to do here? I don't know!!!

12. "i wanted to be a singer" by PISS — Finally, there are bands about whom I have a lot to discuss, but I'm holding back, for blog reasons. Namely, that the PISS album is going to be the RC Album of the Week in early December. So let's save all those intense thoughts for then. Until then, however, you get a song. Consider it a preview. It's not the best or most important song on the album, but that's on purpose. I'm holding back. More later. Always more later.

For now, that's a wrap on this playlist. Hope it was worth it for ya. Hope it was worth it for me.

In My Place 319

November 15, 2026. 40.05077, -75.01295. See the updated map here. See all the blog posts here.


Go. Go ahead. Grow up. Be a big kid. Learn how to understand what you're feeling, what it means. Navigate this cruel world. Find the joy in it. Take the good days with the bad ones. Try not to be sad that it's over, and try to be happy that it happened. Remember this, but move forward.

Go. 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Album of the Week: 2 Hype

Next week is our OFFICIAL Record Club x Film Club crossover, when we cover both The Virgin Suicides the album by Air and the movie by Sofia Coppola. This week, in anticipation, we have an UNOFFICIAL RC x FC crossover. We already watched House Party. I didn't know anything about the movie before we watched it, or else I might have said that we should cover House Party stars Kid 'n Play in Record Club sooner. You could fill vast oceans with the number of things I don't know. It took me till writing this very blog post to realize that Kid 'n Play and Kris Kross were different hip hop duos! I'm an idiot! You should know this by now.

Record Club:

WEEK 407 — November 15-21, 2026


2 Hype
by Kid 'n Play

LISTEN:
Spotify | YouTube | Bandcamp | Apple

~~~~~~~~~~

PICKED BY SUNNY

SUNNY'S PITCH: "My pitch? After the knock-down fun of House Party a few weeks ago, I figured we could spend a little more time with Eraserhead. I just had to know what put these guys on the map. (Also, Ice Cube is probably antisemitic, but has also vocally distanced himself from Ye, saying he wouldn't ever associate with someone who's so flagrantly antisemitic, all of which makes picking a record hard these days.)


~~~~~~~~~~

ALBUM DETAILS

GENRE: Pop rap, boom bap, new jack swing

RELEASED: October 26, 1988

LENGTH: 43:37

TRACKLIST:
  1. Rollin' With Kid 'n Play
  2. Brother Man Get Hip
  3. Gittin' Funky
  4. Soul Man
  5. Damn That DJ (The Wizard M.E.)
  6. Last Night
  7. 2 Hype
  8. Can You Dig That
  9. Undercover (ft. the Real Roxanne)
  10. Do the Kid 'n Play Kick Step
  11. Do This My Way
LYRICS: Genius.com

~~~~~~~~~~

ARTIST DETAILS

PUNCTUATION: The incorrect apostrophe use around the contraction of "and" has been one of my biggest pet peeves for a while now. It's not just Kid 'n Play who use it incorrectly. But there's nothing I can do about it. It's too late for them to change their name to Kid 'n' Play like it should be. I am obligated to follow their lead, regardless of whether I'm a card-carrying member of the Apostrophe Protection Society or not.

PRONOUNS: Kid prefers he/him/his, while Play prefers he/him/his

ABOUT: Kid is the stage name of Christopher Reid, and Play is the stage name of Christopher Martin. Chris 'n Chris formed Kid 'n Play in the mid-'80s, recording their first singles in 1986. They are from New York City. They mostly worked alongside DJ Wiz, a.k.a. Mark Eastmond. Along with the rapping and the acting, they have an original dance called the Kid 'n Play Kickstep. I feel like I've seen other people do that before I saw the original in House Party. They starred in six movies together, and had their own NBC Saturday morning cartoon in 1990. The duo broke up in 1995. Kid kept acting, but Play became a born-again Christian. They reunited in 2001, and have more or less been a working duo since then, but nothing too crazy. Wikipedia notes that they were at the 2021 Gathering of the Juggalos.

DISCOGRAPHY: This is the first of three studio albums. The second was 1990's Funhouse. The final album (so far!!!!) is 1991's Face the Nation.

~~~~~~~~~~

ADDITIONAL INFO

READING SOME SHIT: 2015 interview with The Boom Box

WATCHING SOME SHIT: Besides the movie? Watch them perform Live at the Apollo 1989

RECORD CLUB CONNECTIONS: It's a shame that this album isn't called II Hype.

In honor of the erroneously apostrophed artist name, here are the three other times in RC history when an N has followed an apostrophe: Bacchanal 'n' Philadelphia, K'naan, Shaquille O'Neal. A special shoutout to Mischief Brew for getting the contraction correct! Two apostrophes!

Oh, and this music is classified as new jack swing, which is a genre that we covered extensively with Bobby Brown.

MENTIONS ON THE BLOG: Besides House Party? I couldn't find anything. Searching for "kid play" turned up 1,600 results, so maybe I missed something. Oh, but wait! You should know that House Party lost the Favorite Movie award to Home Alone at the 1991 Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards. No KEGOT for Kid 'n Play just yet!!

~~~~~~~~~~

RECORD CLUB ALUMNI ASSOCIATION

This week's discography dive album: Social Studies by Brick + Mortar

This week's follow-up album: Wowed Out by Jim James and Ride Lonesome by Beck and Bass Persuaded by Miley

This week's keeping up album (probably): Future Nausea by Spanish Love Songs

Listen with us! Keep your favorite Record Club artists in the rotation!

~~~~~~~~~~

COUNTDOWN:
69 Weeks Until Week 420

ralph 'n malph starring in House Party 6

We are tracking and counting down every week from here on out till Record Club Week 420. We started this countdown 69 weeks out. During Record Club Week 420, we will be covering Donny Most by the esteemed Happy Days virgin Donny Most. The goal for Week 420 of Record Club is that it will feature 69 reviews from 69 different people. 

THIS WEEK: We are 13 weeks away from Week 420.

~~~~~~~~~~

Happy listening, RC family!
Have a great week!

In My Place 318

November 14, 2026. 39.97968, -75.11613. See the updated map here. See all the blog posts here.


You remember the punk rock pizza parties? We'd come in on Monday nights and they'd have the conveyor-belt pizza maker behind the bar, dollar a slice, and cheap beers, and punk rock music playing all night? We had some good nights in Port Richmond.

I'm still managing to have some good nights in Port Richmond, to be honest. I don't know how, but it's happening, here in 2026.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Record Club Alumni Association — Minutes from Meeting #23: Vulfpeck, Shania Twain, Cheekface, Sam Smith

The Record Club Alumni Association meets every week to discuss the larger body of work that our RC alumni have put together, outside of the specific albums that were covered in the main section of our club. You can follow along with everything that the RCAA has covered so far HERE.


(Deeper Dive)

Vulfpeck

Hill Climber — RC Week 49 — 4 pukes out of 5
Schvitz — RC f/u #14 — 3 pukes out of 5

The Beautiful Game
October 17, 2016

I'm still pretty enamored with the joke, okay? That this is the fake German equivalent of the Wrecking Crew, backing up a host of vocalists on a variety of different types of songs. The joke works because it adds a layer of defense against any accusation one might make that Vulfpeck's music mostly sounds like corny-ass TV sitcom theme songs. The reaction to some of these songs MUST be "...are they being serious?" Then they answer the question with an unequivocal "no," and that's what makes it work! The joke will sour over time, of course. Within each album, Vulfpeck mixes it up just enough; here, they effortless move from the bright disco-pop of "Conscious Club" to the family-friendly, skit-heavy banger of "1 for 1, DiMaggio" to the deep-bass funk of "Cory Wong." A whole album of just one of those sounds would be too much. A whole discography of albums like this album would also be too much, and I think that's what you're seeing happen to Vulfpeck in the 2020s. Listening to The Beautiful Game, though, is a nice little reset for me. These dudes are fucking ridiculous, and ridiculously fun, when they balance the joke just right.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5


(Follow-up)

Shania Twain

Come On Over — RC Week 107 — 3.5 pukes out of 5
Queen of Me — RC f/u #14 — 2.5 pukes out of 5

Little Miss Twain
July 24, 2026

"Hot old rich lady music" might be the best description of this music, but that would seem too dismissive. I didn't mind this one. It has traditionally helped, and still does here, that Twain is approaching her craft from a pop perspective instead of a country perspective. There are half-hearted attempts at country sounds ("get me a GODDAMN banjo overlayed on 'Right Time' right goddamn NOW!!!" I can hear an executive in a boardroom somewhere yelling), and the requisite country themes throughout. Pretty interesting to hear what Shania Twain decides to make upbeat and downbeat here, e.g. "Faded Blue Jeans" calls for an up-tempo country rocker, but instead we get something that is rather serious. Too many ballads on the album, but I guess I shouldn't be surprised. She's a senior citizen at this point. I guess when I see the YouTube visualizer and see her looking like a 40-year-old with short shorts, my mind gets confused. It would be sad to hear her try to compete with [insert 20-something female country star here, I don't know any by name]. She doesn't try to do that. She's singing the ballads like the talented women her age. She's also looking back, which is something you're supposed to do as an artist at this age too. I really appreciate that the title track, which is about how Shania Twain's mom thought she was going to be the next Tanya Tucker, actually features Tanya Tucker on the track. Stuff like that, you can only pull off when you're a hot rich old lady. She's out there doing it! Good for her!

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5


Cheekface

Emphatically No. — RC Week 104 — 3 pukes out of 5
Too Much to Ask — RC f/u #12 — 2 pukes out of 5
It's Sorted — RC f/u #27 — 1 puke out of 5
Middle Spoon — RC f/u #42 — 1 puke out of 5

Podium
July 28, 2026

As you can see above, my opinion of this band started iffy, and has slowly trended downward. There's still more room to fall, however, and Cheekface managed to find it with this release. The music used to be its saving grace, but in "trying some new stuff," they lose the only excuse they had. And the lyricism remains so embarrassing that I want to wear a paper bag over my head just for listening. "There Is a God" is the worst song I've ever heard in my life, and that was only the second song on the album. There's a song that mentions a cuck chair that makes me want to die. I am going to the Cheekface frontman's house and making him sit in the cuck chair while I am unplug his wifi and make him go outside and get some fresh air and get him away from the internet for a while. This band's collective brain is rotted, and I know it's not contagious, but I'm still treating this shit like radioactivity. Keep me away. I'm begging Cheekface to stop releasing so many albums, I can't take it anymore. Please. Please. Please!

GRADE: 0.5 pukes out of 5


Sam Smith

Gloria — RC Week 209 — 2 pukes out of 5

Hazel Eyes
August 21, 2026

Oh yikes! I don't know if I liked this. Let me think about it... okay, I've thought about it. I actually do think that the added gravitas of this album, compared to the pop-inflected stuff that Sam Smith was doing on Gloria, serves them well. Better than it did on that other album, anyway. I remember having an issue with them looking like an old person next to the teenagers in that club scene in the one music video, right? None of that nonsense here. Smith is spending the entirety of Hazel Eyes sitting on the edge of a hotel bed, crying into the left-behind garments of a long lost loved one. That's why the initial reaction of "yikes"—the issue that I pointed out last time was addressed, and it resulted in a worse album. More artful, yeah, but definitely in a monkey's-paw sort of way. Okay, but, this is all such an unfair way to frame all this, isn't it? Wasn't the dancehall stuff a departure for Sam Smith to begin with? Wasn't one of their first hit singles "Stay with Me," the dirgiest of dirges? And so what, we're talking shit now that they reverted back to that? How is that good music criticism? And how can you talk shit on Hazel Eyes when a song like "Sugar Rush" exists? I don't know if it's a good song, but it finds something really fascinating to do within the framework of "Sam Smith music." It's like, Hozier meets the Chordettes meets, uhhhhhhh, Algiers brand gospel music.....? This one into "Oh Mother" bumps this whole enterprise up at least a full puke. More of this, please. Less of the other dreck. (Be careful what you wish for, Joey!!!!)

GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5


(Random RCAA News)
  • RC alumnus Bob Dylan met [future RC alumnus] Pope Leo.
  • Olivia Rodrigo has a new Christmas song out. I haven't listened to it yet, because it's not even Thanksgiving yet.
  • Katy Perry performed a private show for a tech company in Thailand. Hmmm.........
  • Pitchfork released a Best Indie Rock Albums All Time list, and the highest-ranking RC album was Geese's Getting Killed (#32). The Stone Roses was on there at #49, Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not at #63, Transatlanticism at #67, Crazy Rhythms at #77, and a ton of other RC alumni with non-RC albums all over this fucking thing.
  • Noah Kahan is a big Knicks fan. Way more than New Brunswick hardcore band Taylor Swift, anyway.

Let us know if you'd like to join RCAA and write about any of these albums! There's a lot to discover!

In My Place 317

November 13, 2026. 40.07299, -75.06948. See the updated map here. See all the blog posts here.


There was a story about a man who was naked when he answered the door, and the person who had knocked was offended enough to sue, but the judge ruled in favor of the naked man, because he was in his own home, and could not be the offender if someone else was looking in, into the home of the naked man. Looking in is a choice. The story gives me comfort in situations like this, when perhaps it might seem strange to someone to turn into a back alley and find a tall hairy man holding a camera and taking a picture just as your car passes his view. I'm not in the wrong, because if you see me holding a camera, that means you're looking into my home.

also I was naked—

Friday, November 13, 2026

Discussion — Week 406: II by the Presidents of the United States of America


Will this be the last album called II that RC ever covers? Probably not. We did two of them this year, but there's still a whole list of possibilities. And since RC will always exist in some form or another, there's no reason why we can't get through the whole list before we die or the earth burns into ashes or both.

What did you think of this II? Any of the reviews change your mind? Where would the Presidents of the United States of America fall on a ranking of all the Presidents of the United States of America? Somewhere between Taft and Carter? And hey, whatchya got going on this weekend? Let's discuss it all, down here in the comments. TGIF, y'all.

II, Sunny


I've been listening to these nerds for twenty-plus years, but really, I've just been listening to the hits "Lump" and "Peaches" for twenty-plus years millions of peaches times, plus whatever loose tracks find their way into random friends' playlists and loose mixes at parties. Something about their sound, while not unique in a way I can describe, is easily identifiable. That's what you want from an American president, I guess.

I'm happy to say this album rocks. None of my mega hits on here, but who cares? It's the PUSA sound through and through. "Mach 5" and "Volcano" are obvious singles that do right. Some tracks are so far inside baseball I don't get it, like "L.I.P." But and also I have fondness for "Lunatic" (with that random rap verse), "Froggie," "Part II" with their goofiness. These are the only presidents I'll vote for.

II, Nate


The veins in my hands are more pronounced now. For a time there was no joke more complete, more obliterating in its mirth-generating properties, than whatever was coming out of the mouth of Billy Madison. For three decades now those of a specific disposition have been Tired of Sex, have been Falling for You, have been feeling an even-further-back desire to shake booty and make sweet love all the night. Cloud Nothings has a metal album coming out in a couple of weeks, I've heard the tracks and I have the release, vestigial promo phantom limb that I am. Respect to that band now and forever for knowing what it is and for recognizing the existence of neither future nor past. Crime novels always end the same.

II, Dranders


Apparently II by the Presidents of the United States of America was released the night of the 1996 presidential election (exactly 30 years ago!). But don't expect any Ross Perot commentary, because the lyrics don't touch politics at all (aside from briefly mentioning a distaste for skinheads in "Puffy Little Shoes"). Before 9/11, it was possible to simply ignore politics altogether if you wanted. That said, the album is extremely '90s, both in its definitively Seattle vibes and its deliberate aimlessness. There's wackiness to their sound, but talk about energetic! The pace was wild and never let up. "Tiki God" was by far my favorite because it's about the legendary three-part episode of The Brady Bunch where the Bradys go on vacation to Hawaii and fall victim to a cursed Tiki idol. I was thrilled to get the reference. I also found "Froggie" to be refreshingly funky, and "Bug City" was a few degrees more epic musically than other tracks. But it is an undoubtedly goofy experience, at times to a fault.

I wasn't surprised to find out the album got mixed reviews upon release, with writers criticizing the silliness and how it lacks anything to say. But wasn't that what the '90s was all about? Times were so peaceful that people just had to make up shit to talk about, in the same way Hollywood embraced Seinfeld, or Clerks, or American Beauty, which were really about how nothing of importance was happening at that time in American history. Thus, PotUSA had the privilege to write lyrics like "happy campers that poop in their pampers" in "Volcano."

Is it a dumb album? Somewhat. But is it justified in being dumb? ...Also somewhat.

II, Joe


I long for a connection. I need to know that this matters. The way I can prove that it matters is through connection. Connection to what has come before. Connection, and recognition. I reach back through the present and into the past. It's the only way. Otherwise, we're just left with a silly little geek rock album comprised of a whole lotta nothin' and stupid fucking jokes.

The connection is to the video for "Lump," which I watched a fair amount in my youth. Specifically in the late '90s, I wanna say, or early aughts. This was on our new Dell computer, with a Windows 95 operating system, which came with a demo CD-ROM, which included this music video among its grand total of two music videos ("Buddy Holly" was the other one, and vastly preferred, but this isn't a Weezer review). There was something exciting about being able to watch a music video on a computer, and that excitement bled over to my feelings about the music itself. So I've always liked that song, but let's be clear about it: this is purely a nostalgic exercise, enjoying "Lump." And, like all nostalgia formed in one's youth, when you follow up on it searching for more, you realize that your younger self was a stupid dumb immature idiot.

Have you heard "Peaches"? Of course you have. It's probably more popular than "Lump." Imagine my horror when I realize, many years later, that this stupid fucking "Peaches" song that I hate so much is by the same fucking jabronis who made that awesome song "Lump." How many lessons will I need to learn before the message is made clear? That nostalgia is so often misguided? That kids are fucking morons and they are influenced by the thinnest measures? I do still think "Lump" is a great song, but I acknowledge fully that this must only be because of when I first experienced it. There's no other reason.

You can listen to the self-titled debut album, as I have, if you want know what I'm talking about. But for today, we're listening to the sophomore album, called II. It's just a reiteration that the band I liked a lot for one song is actually just a jokey rock outfit operating in a genre that I've traditionally despised, and that the whole "Lump" thing was total coincidence, a totally fucking arbitrary decision by some unnamed Windows 95 engineer, random happenstance that landed on my lap and briefly bamboozled me into thinking that this was music worth following up on. It is not. I don't like it.

The genre tag of "geek rock" does a lot of the heavy lifting for me when it comes to explaining why I don't like this music. Because that way I can connect it to something like They Might Be Giants, arguably PotUSA's closest peers. It's not comedy rock, but comedy-adjacent. "Comedy," like with quotes around it, since comedy is subjective and I don't find it very funny a lot of the time, especially in music. "Humorous subject matter with an intellectual bent" is how RYM explains the genre—fucking kill me. Is this what we're calling something like "Bug City"? A song that is neither humorous nor intelligent but clearly striving to be both? Or am I simply missing the joke?

If there's a joke, then I'm still not laughing. Oh god, do I really have to relitigate the whole "what's cool, am I cool" hand-wringing exercise? Didn't I do that recently? Yes, I did. tl;dr: I'm a perennial fucking loser who was unfortunately had installed within me the unshakeable desire to feel "cool," and have an internal psychotic reaction to anything that the body perceives as "uncool," to the detriment of basically anything else attached to it. If you give me a rock song instrumental with a good crunchy guitar riff, then I'll say that I like it a lot. Include lyrics on that song about a sitcom character finding a tiki idol and the mayhem it causes, and these little alarm bells start going off in my head that force me to back away as quickly as possible.

Maybe it's, like, the lack of sincerity that makes it not work for me? We've been over this too. The PoYB bible explains it just fine, thank you (I'm talking about Infinite Jest), how our generation grew up constantly surrounded by irony and that way of life became the norm and there are consequences to that. A song like "Froggie" is "supposed" to be funny because it has a single layer of irony: it's "about" a froggy jumping around on stage, but it's actually about drugs. Lame as FUCK. This is just a pushback on my part against simple irony, which I'm tired of, having been raised in its muck and stink. I think it would work better in either direction on the irony scale. Make it sincere, like make it about the horrors of getting sucked into a life of drugs because of success in rock 'n' roll. Or go past the irony, and make something post-ironic, i.e. that you're joking about not joking, e.g. "Frog on the Floor," one of the greatest songs of the 21st century, and a funny song because the joke is how sincere it is (maybe even funnier that it's 100 gecs doing the post-irony sincerity).

Instead, you have the caveman reaction of "ha ha isn't this HILARIOUS, it's actually a song about drugs!" Don't piss on my head and call it rain. Don't give me some entry-level humor and call it funny. If you wanna be funny just make a fucking comedy rock album and be done with it. Don't think that one level of irony is what makes you "smart." It's basic-ass shit. At least someone like Weird Al lets you know where he stands before making his comedy. There were exactly two good songs on that Weird Al album we covered, and I think they prove my point here. The first was "Now That's What I Call Polka!", which was post-ironic in the way that it jokes about playing pop songs as polka music, but then makes the true joke how sincere the polka music is. The other is "Foil," which is meta-post-irony, in that it's (1) a joke because it's a parody of "Royal" by Lorde, then (2) sincere in the way it's actually a credible version of "Royal" but about tin foil and how it wraps up food, and then (3) a joke again in that it suddenly switches to a song about conspiracy theories, and presented in a sincere way so that you can't tell where the joke begins or ends.

Am I being clear? No? Well, that's okay. I never make much sense when I get angry about music. I just huff and puff and write a couple thousand words about nothing and then that's it, I never really have to think about it again. But you have to see, right? Why I wouldn't like this? Have you heard "Puffy Little Shoes"? They are trying to be funny by writing a song about nothing. The joke is that all these things don't matter and all he cares about are shoes. Isn't that FUNNY?! It's just too smirky for me. Wipe the goddamn smirk off your face. Half-hearted stabs at humor will not be tolerated here. Stop thinking you're clever. FUCK.

But you can see why I need to cling to something like "Lump" at least, right? That's the bottom line here. Because without "Lump," I'm losing my sanity. At least I can use "Lump" as a life raft to keep afloat out here on the rocky seas of music criticism, where I find myself for some reason attempting to explain post-irony, for no important reason. I cling to "Lump," and the simple, feel-good memory of watching these goofy young men dance around in a swamp and sing a catchy song.

What's that you say? "Lump" is another attempt at lame humor? With Chris Ballew attempting to evoke images of an "overweight middle-aged woman in a house coat with curlers in her hair and a cigarette"? No, don't tell me. I don't want to know any of that. I recognize the music on this album as of a similar quality to those pixelated men from my Windows 95 computer. Catchy, and THAT'S IT. That's all I need. I have that connection. That's fine. Let me tune out. I don't want to know what it's about. I don't want to see your rictus grin. Just let me listen to "L.I.P." and not care, not care about what it's about, no, just listen to the music, it's nice, it's catchy, that's it.

(Wait that acronym stands for WHAT?! I can't do it. Sorry!!!!!!!)

GRADE: II pukes out of V

II, Dranders


Boyz II Men's third album (mysteriously titled II) confirms why it's nearly impossible not to like Boyz II Men. Even if you're not into '90s R&B, these guys are just so smooth, and their vocal chops are undeniable. I mean, those harmonies are cleannnnn. You do NOT hear a cappella like this is mainstream music very often. I can only assume II spawned generations of Ivy League a cappella groups with rich, nerdy white boys in blazers and khaki pants attempting to croon like black guys from Philly.

Obviously, the standout track was "I'll Make Love to You," one of the most epic hits in all of R&B. It's sexy, it's pure, it's gargantuan in scale. "Water Runs Dry" refreshingly went heavier on acoustic guitar and percussion, a nice contrast. "Khalil (Interlude)" was dope because it finally explains the name of their group: "To ease the pain of changing from Boyz [to] Men." Pretty much every song aims to be romantic, but the vibes are always mature and well-intentioned, like they actually cherish women and aren't just trying to get laid.

Although I'll admit, they frequently have Michael, the bass singer, insert spoken word segments into like half the songs, and it gets cliché after a while. Like by the time we get to "Bended Knee" (which is nonetheless a jam), and I hear a bass voice start talking rather than singing, I"m like OK WE GET IT.

Nonetheless, this album transports you to the mid-'90s in the best way. You can see how much Boyz II Men influenced *NSYNC and Backstreet Boys (the emergence of those groups apparently killed Boyz II Men's popularity, and possibly R&B as a whole). The genre may have dwindled from public consciousness, but II will always be there to make you feel like you're making sweet, sweet love in the back of a '94 Ford Taurus.

In My Place 316

November 12, 2026. 40.09202, -75.13626. See the updated map here. See all the blog posts here.


Waiting. All about waiting. Waiting in traffic. Waiting for dance class to start. Waiting for class to end. Waiting in traffic. Waiting for a work call. Waiting for them to fall asleep. Waiting for me to fall asleep.

I take it back. It's all about finding the joy in the waiting.

I wrote this blog post while waiting. 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Never Seen It #346: A Scanner Darkly

What does a blog see? Into the head? Down into the heart? Does it see into me? Into us? Clearly or darkly? I hope it sees clearly because I can't any longer see into myself. I see only 500 movies I've never seen before. I hope for everyone's sake the bloggers do better, because if the blogger sees only darkly the way I do, then I'm cursed and cursed again.


A Scanner Darkly
2006
Richard Linklater

Thanks to all those who watched A Scanner Darkly and submitted some thoughts! Check 'em out below!

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Kait

I wish I watched this movie in one sitting instead of over two, because two separate viewings with a few days in between really muddied the plot for me. I also did not finish it in time to write this review. I think I have about 20 minutes left. Here are my thoughts on what I did see: 

I had a hard time following what was going on. But maybe I've got it... My understanding is everyone is addicted to drugs and ratting each other out. "They" (the government / New Path?) got Keanu Reeves addicted to Substance D, big time, while doing undercover work. They used him to get to Barris and don't care about any collateral damage. Donna was in on all of it too. 

Cool although somewhat predictable story of government and corporations exploiting humanity for their own whatever the fuck gains. I liked those scanner suits that hid their identities, and the animation was neat. I would love to see some behind-the-scenes acting footage, and am curious how they did the animation. Also, the acting was good. I just didn't get a chance to really connect to this film. Again, could be watching it in two sittings. 

Oh! One thing that stuck with me was this weird policy of if an Officer becomes an addict but doesn't report it promptly is subject to a misdemeanor. That's some legal fine print bullshit right there. 

Anyway, I'd say 2 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~

Brianna

I will admit it took me entirely too long to pinpoint the profound sense of déjà vu I had while watching A Scanner Darkly from my couch this week. The "Is that... no, it can't be. Alex Jones?" moment should have been a dead giveaway, but yeah. It was even later that I remember the similarly animated, philosophical acid trip of Film Club's past: Waking Life.

I didn't like that one a ton, to be honest. I remember appreciating the big swing of its animation technique, but wishing the story was something more coherent. And while "coherent" is not necessarily the first word that comes to mind when I think about A Scanner Darkly, I suppose that it could still apply under the circumstances. 

In a way, the incoherent parts of Scanner actually ended up being some of my favorite bits. The scenes of Woody Harrelson and RDJ just going back and forth, for example, did absolutely nothing for plot progression, but man, I could probably watch that all day. The bicycle gear discussion and escalation to hammer fight were both excellent fun. Long-winded deep dives into metaphysics? Noticeably less.

One thing both films did have in common was a sense of purpose behind the choice to animate. In Waking Life, it felt like a way to visualize and imagine the ideas being discussed. No way I would've sat through those scenes without that, honestly. In A Scanner Darkly, it felt like an embodiment of the drug-addled world we were thrown into. I doubt any visual effect available in 2006 would have made me as uncomfortable as those animated bugs in the opening of the film did. And the scramble suits: impossible without the animation, though I probably could've done without the motion sickness I felt every time Fred had to go to the office. 

Without its style, I don't think the film's story stands up on its own. The story was kinda meh, with its strengths lying in the unrelated moments in between plot points.

2.5 out of five pukes

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Catherine

I read that Richard Linklater's A Scanner Darkly is a well-made, "faithful adaptation" of the Philip K. Dick novel and I guess I'll just have to take everyone's word for it. I'm sure Philip and Richard have a good understanding of what's happening in their story, but most of it was sadly lost on my simple mind. It's been a while since I've been a real shameless hater in Film Club so I'm gonna fully dive in for my own enjoyment. 

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

Kidding, sort of. I know lots of people love this film and I could almost see why in a few glimmering moments of clarity, but overall it just could not hold my attention. A big part of the problem was my inability to get captions working on YouTube so I spent a lot of time struggling to make out all the whisper acting in this goddamn film, which I know begs the question: did I really watch it at all? I don't know!!

There are a few things I can say definitively did not work for me. I hate the rotoscope animation overlay that is clearly supposed to invoke a trippy, hallucinatory feel but to me just really accentuated how much Woody Harrelson's character looks like Shaggy from Scooby-Doo.

I also fall into the large category of red-blooded American that adores Keanu Reeves but thinks he sucks pretty hard at acting in a way that distracts the hell out of me during a film that was already testing my patience.

On a positive note, I found Robert Downey Jr. incredibly captivating, and thought he handled his tricky dialogue well. What the fuck he was talking about or what his character's motivations were is simply beyond my comprehension, but good job, Bob.

There was a moment when I was peeking at the clock and trying to keep my mind focused for just a little longer that I'll admit I had a little breakthrough. It was during Keanu's monologue that explains the film's title:

"What does a scanner see? Into the head? Down into the heart? Does it see into me? Into us? Clearly or darkly? I hope it sees clearly because I can't any longer see into myself. I see only murk. I hope for everyone's sake the scanners do better, because if the scanner sees only darkly the way I do, then I'm cursed and cursed again."

I was suddenly intrigued. I was moved. It felt relatable somehow. At the very least it made me want to give the book a shot. Maybe then I'll finally get what's going on (probably not, but a girl can dream).

Sorry to be a downer. 1/5 Tablets of Substance D 

~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

File this one under "need to see again," a folder that grows unwieldy in its girth over the years. That's just how it's gonna be when you're devoting a majority portion of your life to watching films you've never seen before—all the interesting ones you've seen before get pushed to the side to make room. That's unfair to movies like A Scanner Darkly, movies that demand an initial watch to figure out what in the fuck is even happening, and then a second watch to thoroughly soak in the themes. So it goes.

Let's make a rule, though: it's okay to be confused while watching a movie, but only if at least one of the characters in the movie is just as confused as you are. Whether it's by design or just something you can use as an excuse, it's doesn't really matter—I was in Bob's/Fred's headspace throughout the length of the film, in that I was barely holding onto reality. That feels like a simple and effective way to get you to understand a character's motivation, make you feel what they are feeling. Even when that feeling is utter confusion.

I'm inclined to think that withstanding temptation to exposition is almost always a good thing. It might have benefited the audience for someone to turn to the camera and explain what the hell the deal with the drug D even is, but that also would've felt unearned, too easy. The tension between audience and filmmaker that happens when key information is held back and then deployed at just the right time, that's the thing that makes a movie like this work. I'm just saying that some of us are too stupid (me) to get it the first time around.

So while I'm out here figuring out what the fuck any of this even is, there's all kinds of interesting stuff happening in the next layer down, philosophical stuff that ultimately stands as the reason that Philip K. Dick is an important author (and, not incidentally, why Richard Linklater is an important filmmaker). I was confused but managed to get someone of a grip on, for example, the scene in which Bob/Fred reveals that he (might have) had a family in a previous life, a life he hated, a family he resented. That whole thing made it clear—regardless about any opaque plot points surrounding it—that this addiction—whatever it actually is, however it compares to or differs from addition as we know it here in the real world—is a reaction to some deep-seeded desire to escape.

And how that impulse should not be punished! That's I think what the deal is with the words presented at the end of the movie. I'm told these were the real words that concluded Dick's novel, how Dick lost friends to substance abuse and that his novel was a tribute to those friends, "who were punished entirely too much for what they did." I think the point (and I felt it, as you might have, for personal reasons above all else) was that the actions of the characters in this film, the D addicts, their actions are supposed to be sympathetic. It's a choice to take a drug but often times it's not really a choice to keep taking that drug, and the lack of choice should be the source of sympathy (or empathy, depending on your position in life). 

That conclusion comes from thinking about the film in the week after watching it. I would imagine that I'd be able to pull more if I watched it again, knowing the layered motivations of each character (with the Scramble Suits adding that crucial extra layer). It would also probably give me more time to appreciate scenes such as a bike gear scene. I don't doubt that this is a scene pulled from the novel, but shit, man, if ever there was a movie scene that was pure fucking Richard Linklater. I can easily picture a similar conversation occurring between Slater and Pickford, or between Jesse and Céline. Amusing on the surface, these ideas often go way deeper into the film's heart than it seems at first. For example, there was an edge of danger in the bike gear scene. Why? Just because they were on hard drugs instead of just pot or beer? Or was it trying to say something else?

There was a lot I couldn't figure out, which is okay. That's especially true because the temptation is to say "it's even more relevant now!" That's true and it's also a cliché when it comes to science fiction. The good sci-fi feels predictive because it's actually timeless, meaning that it's hitting ideas that were important then and remain important now. I'll resist the temptation to say that A Scanner Darkly is even more applicable to our Flock-filled and AI-addled and cop-corrupt nation, because you know that already.

But I will say that I appreciated the presence of the noxious, despicable Alex Jones as the minor character who voices these concerns out loud before being thrown into the back of a van. This piece of shit has to peddle gas station boner pills now just to pay his legal bills, but let's acknowledge that there was something about his conspiratorial ramblings at the turn of the 21st century that touched fellow Austinite Richard Linklater in some small way. Not that he was right, not that he was a good or kind person, but more that it made sense, then as it does now, to feel the impulse to question the truth. We're told that Flock cameras will keep us safe. We're told that it's okay for cops to wear masks if we're not doing anything illegal anyway. We're told that a glass of wine at the end of the day is going to make us feel better. You should probably feel compelled to question what you're told, at least some of the time.

Lots of confusion to get there though. Which is my fault, and I guess Film Club's structure's fault too. No worries. A Scanner Darkly is sound enough that I'm confident it's a great movie, even if I'd need a rewatch to confirm.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~

GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 2.25 pukes out of 5

You are being surveilled in the comments. Submit or face consequences.

(NEXT TIME: We're having a Zoom this Wednesday, 11/18 at 9 PM, for To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything! Julie Newmar)

In My Place 315

November 11, 2026. 40.07314, -75.06954. See the updated map here. See all the blog posts here.


It's smart business, not to nickel and dime people, especially not in the neighborhood, especially for people who feel, occasionally, that they don't belong in the neighborhood. Smart business to dispel that sense of being othered for that person, by just being kind and fixing the little thing that needed fixing, vinyl cornering on a roof or whatever, just send a couple dudes up there on tall ladders with hammers, for free, pro bono. Smart business, because when that roof collapses down the line, and the big money is up for grabs, then guess who the first roofers they're gonna call is. Because you helped, that one time. Smart business.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Grannies Gone Wild #128

Joe has watched "Grannies Gone Wild" 111 times so far in his lifetime. Sunny has watched "Grannies Gone Wild" 45 times so far in his lifetime. Watch the episode HERE. You can also read every single Grannies Gone Wild entry HERE.


Part II

Sunny and I got together a few weeks ago to discuss an episode of television and the lives that have been shaped around it. Today is the 21st anniversary of "Grannies Gone Wild" airing for the first time on The WB.

The following is a transcript of our conversation. You can check out Part I HERE. Today's focus is on the Barbara Jean of it all.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe: Okay, so.... Barbara Jean.

Sunny: Yeah.

Joe: Let's tap in. This is even more of a stretch than last year's interview.

Sunny: And she stole the show.

Joe: [laughter] Right, yes. Okay, so this has been written about before, I'm going to link it here. The picture was already posted four summers ago. You could pull it off. Just like you could pull off anyone looking like Errol Flynn. That gave us something to talk about within the episode. This is basically nothing. Besides the fact that, yes, she's saying that she "stole the show," which is probably a comedic misunderstanding of what "stealing the show" means.

Sunny: And what "theft" is, and what "crimes" are. 

Joe: I didn't know beforehand what Tevye's role in this play was. Clearly, he is the main character.

Sunny: She also referred to it as a "play," not a musical. I find that interesting.

Joe: Oh wow. Yeah, I wonder if there is a non-musical version of this. Like a "junior" version.

Sunny: Did he say that he's a rich man?

Joe: She doesn't say what school. It could be a second grade play. And... she's not Jewish, right?

Sunny: Yeah, so "Barbara Jean Hart," I was looking at that name for a while. Hard to make a case that she's Jewish.

Joe: I mean, right outside of a Houston, Texas...

Sunny: And her maiden name is even more goy-sounding. So...

Joe: Well, this isn't a requirement for playing a character in a play.

Sunny: She's an actress! And a great actress!

Joe: I think that's maybe part of the joke, is that—

Sunny: Well, the point wasn't that she was saying she was a good actress. The point was that she was a good thief.

Joe: [laughter] Right. And, we don't know enough about Barbara Jean to know whether she is being sarcastic. Or maybe, I don't know. You've seen a couple more episodes of this television show.

Sunny: Have I? Have I? I can really only just speculate...

Joe: I appreciate you keeping up the act of speculation here. Just in case Barbara Jean reveals—

Sunny: Key information! Which she could at any time. Yeah, so, if it was a musical, I would love to see a rendition of "Rich Man." If it wasn't, if it was the flat version, I would still be curious to see how she delivered the pogrom scene.

Joe: Do we think it was an all-women version?

Sunny: Presumably! Texas? I could see it. Maybe she went to a Catholic school.

Joe: That's definitely a thing in amateur school-age theater, is that there's not enough guys, and there are too many girls involved. I can't think of a major character, of a production that I was a part of though, that was gender-switched. Some minor characters that were probably originally played by men, then played by women.

Sunny: The reverse-Shakespeare!

Joe: Right. It wasn't like in Into the Woods, the Baker was a woman. I'm trying to think... I mean, I assume that the Fiddler on the Roof that I saw in person, Tevye was a man. I don't want to lean too far into this completely throwaway joke—

Sunny: Oh, we're leaning!

Joe: Okay, so let me ask you this way. So this is specifically about characters in this episode of television. Do you care about these characters?

Sunny: Deeply.

Joe: Because I feel like that's a thing with sitcom characters over time. That you grow to love these characters. That's because you see their ups and downs. The most popular network sitcoms across history, people might start to say that the characters are "part of their family."

Sunny: Kramer!

Joe: Uh... yes. The ultimately example of this. Kramer, my father, Kramer. But yeah, I was just curious, if that's possible, just watching the same episode over and over. Because it's quite static, in that we see Barbara Jean do the same thing over and over, and yet, find a way to care about her anyway?

Sunny: I mean, I feel like I know more about these characters from the depths of those 22 minutes than I would from seasons of watching it. Like, would I really have known that Reba was trying to keep her cholesterol down? Would I really understand that Barbara Jean stole the show? Probably not. Probably not. I would've just heard the jokes and moved on. I wouldn't have appreciated the depth of the character-building.

Joe: I know this is something we talked about last year, is there a limited depth, or unlimited depth? And I felt like I was hitting a wall last year. I don't know if there's any depth to this Tevye joke. But I do think that it is an indication, the fact that we are able to talk about it, and care about it, and actually talk about Barbara Jean as if she's a real person, despite the fact that this sitcom experience has been very different than a typical situation like that. I think it gives credence to the theory that this is a good and artful and, I don't know, emotionally worthy thing to do. The watching of this episode over and over.

Sunny: Sure!

Joe: Not necessarily because of the Tevye joke, that's just one piece of it. One example of it. Like, having seen Barbara Jean on the screen for thousands of minutes at this point, it's really funny that she would don a beard in high school.

Sunny: And be Tevye, yeah. 

Joe: And be this character. Do you think... this is another general sitcom thing that I was thinking about, and also an emotional thing that I've been thinking about recently, for whatever reason. Do you ever get the sense that most of the conflicts in sitcoms like this are due to the fact that characters refuse to think that they themselves are wrong, about anything? Like in order to have a functioning society, when there's conflict, a lot of the time there's someone who's right and someone who's wrong. And the conflict... for example, the conflict between Van and Cheyenne. That becomes a conflict because Van can't see that he is wrong. They obviously had some type of plan in their life, the ten-year plan, and Cheyenne is going against what they planned. True! But, to jump immediately to "I am right and you are wrong," which is what he does, is what causes the conflict. Because if he had said, "okay, that's not what we planned, but let's talk about it, maybe the ten-year plan that we came up with is wrong, and maybe you're right for following your instincts." It just seems that nobody, in this episode particularly, is willing to admit this, that they could be wrong. Brock ends the episode dying rather than being wrong.

Sunny: Right. Jake is never wrong.

Joe: He gets the revenge! And I was thinking... well, one, other sitcoms, that this is how the plot is driven, how there's a misunderstanding, and no one wants to admit that they're wrong. No one can be humble enough to admit that they're wrong. And I also kept thinking about whether this is indicative of society at large, that many of our conflicts are due to the fact that people can't admit that they're wrong. Do you think that's true? What are your thoughts on this?

Sunny: Yeah, I think a sitcom needs an easy-to-solve, 22-minute conflict, and one person not having a lot of humility. It's there, it's available. It's hard to imagine an enjoyable show if there wasn't a stubborn character, like Van. Or Urkel! Urkel never admits he's wrong! He just says "Did I do that?"

Joe: [laughter]

Sunny: That's the whole show!

Joe: I don't know enough to speak to that.

Sunny: So does that expand to the wider society? Of course. If for no other reason that we were, in our generation, raised on these sitcoms. But there's plenty of people who do not want to admit they're wrong, even if they know they're wrong. There are plenty of people who don't know they're wrong even if they are. And there are probably some people where it is complicated. But I think that's the smaller percentage of the cases, where both sides are wrong.

Joe: Something that I've tried to work on—and maybe it's more talking the talk than walking the walk, and you can tell me which—I feel like it's important to work on being wrong. And maybe this is the alcoholic in me speaking, but it felt easier, and it felt to be more in touch with my humanity, if there was a conflict because of my drinking or whatever, and I woke up the next morning like "oh shit, I fucked up." Right? And to apologize for that solved a lot of conflict in my life. And I still feel that way. Within the past year I received an email from a mutual friend saying "you were wrong to do this," and I basically said to her, okay, I sent her an email apologizing. "I was wrong." I was open about the fact that this was something that I do, that I practice, and I don't know if that made it better or worse. But it's something that's important to me. To know how to be wrong. And to know how to admit being wrong. It feels like a missing piece in our culture right now. And maybe that is why it's so uncomfortable when I know I'm right, because there's no way to do that.

Sunny: Hmmm.

Joe: I do think that's why I liked Fiddler on the Roof so much. It's that Tevye was a good wrong character. That he was willing to see the other side of things.

Sunny: Willing to grow from it, yeah.

Joe: Not all the time.

Sunny: Not all the time, but sometimes.

Joe: He didn't get there with the third daughter. With the first two, he was caught off-guard, had a bad reaction, had a conversation with god about it, reconsidered, and basically admitted that he was wrong, ya know?

Sunny: I think, to your point, that is the right way to approach being wrong about something. It seems like a live wire for a lot of folks.

Joe: Do we think Barbara Jean, being the sitcom character that she is... how often is she wrong?

Sunny: Well, let's keep in mind, how excited was she to be on jury duty? She wanted to adjudicate on if someone was right or wrong in a court of law. So clearly it matters a lot to her.

Joe: Yeah! And that she was so set on being on that jury, and the judge was misinterpreting her actions, and she got so upset that she couldn't make the judge see what she was trying to do, she was so upset because she felt that someone else was wrong, and she was right. And then ended up get thrown out of court for it! So, I don't know if there's an actual way to tie all that to the Tevye joke... [laughter] But it's definitely something I was thinking about due to the nature of this project, after the 111th time I've seen this episode. I guess I was just wondering if any of that has ever crossed your mind.

Sunny: Did you see Tevye in her actions there, yeah. Getting kicked out of the courtroom.

Joe: Do you agree with the theory of acting that donning the costume of somebody else brings out a truth from within yourself?

Sunny: ...

Joe: Chew on that for a second. Have you ever been presented with this theory?

Sunny: I have not been presented with this theory. But...

Joe: I think Wallace Shawn had a good essay on it. I forget why he wrote it.

Sunny: I do love Wallace Shawn! Um, I see it. I mean, what does the actor do at the end of the day? Match their person with the persona of the character on the script, the character in the costume. Yeah. I think that's right. Why was Barbara Jean Tevye? Why was she the lead of this play? When it was gender-bending, she's not Jewish, she must have insisted on it. Why is she insisting to be in the jury case? I think all of these come together. In the same way that Tevye was insisting on certain ways of being. And while Tevye was able to bend, ultimately, and find some kind of compromise, Barbara Jean was kicked out of the courtroom, and was not able to find a way.

Joe: I don't know... okay. So thinking about Barbara Jean as Tevye, as an actor, okay? As an actor, not just Tevye, as I assume this was not her only role. And also using my own experience as an actor, I think being able to use some part of yourself to be somebody else is a skill that not everyone has. Wallace Shawn obviously has this. He is able to be that plastic dinosaur.

Sunny: And he sells it!

Joe: He sells it. I certainly did not have that skill. I forget what the context of that essay way, maybe it was something to do with the conversation of method acting. Was it something to do with that Succession dude? Remember that?

Sunny: Jeremy Strong? Yeah.

Joe: Where he was method acting and kinda being a dick about it? [Editor's note: if you clicked the link, you would see that Shawn is actually linking acting-as-empathy to socialism, which is way better.] I mean, I've always been of the opinion that method acting is the wrong way to look at acting. You shouldn't bend your will to the character that you're playing, you should bend the will of the character you're playing to who you are, as a person. I guess I just saw a disconnect between, okay, Barbara Jean is playing this character, in this play, who is not like her, the person we see in these 22 minutes, because she's not willing to consider any other points of view, just like any other sitcom character—

Sunny: I can't imagine Barbara Jean is into the method style.

Joe: [laughter] Probably not! No. I mean, I guess she must have brought something of herself, because that's just who she is. Barbara Jean seems like the type of person who can't help but be who she is.

Sunny: That's right.

Joe: To... to no one's detriment...

Sunny: It's authentic.

Joe: It's authentic, yeah... I'm obviously just thinking out loud here, so I apologize to you for this.

Sunny: No, please, keep it rolling.

Joe: But the authentic piece is also what I think I had a problem with, when we're speaking about society having the issue of not being wrong. That our president's initial "attractive" quality, quote-unquote, to half of the American populace, was that he was "authentic." Right? That might not necessarily be true. But it was interesting that it was framed as "oh, he's a dick, he's saying terrible things, and that makes him authentic." And I guess we don't have to go into the Nebraska thing, because I was thinking about authenticity there too. It all comes together!

Sunny: Sure!

Joe: I don't know. I don't know if I've thought about it enough, that aspect of it, with Barbara Jean, with acting, with Tevye, with society at large. I think there's something there.

Sunny: Again, with these 22 minutes, I can't imagine Barbara Jean trying to inhabit a character. Rather, I see character bending to Barbara Jean's will and needs. So that is a certain authenticity, to the ego as opposed to the character, whoever that may be. And you're right, I think people see someone who's a dick as authentic because, well, why would he be lying if he's going to be an asshole? I understand that some people lie to gladhand me, but it turns out that some people will just lie and be assholes.

Joe: What do you think... okay, so over the course of one hundred-plus episodes of a TV series, clearly there must have been a moment when Barbara Jean was at the losing end of a conflict. One that we'll never see. What does that look like, do you think? She's not that, here, in this episode.

Sunny: She declares "injustice" at the end, ironically.

Joe: Alright, so she... I don't know, was she a bad stepmom to Jake? She's overzealous when she's Jake's homeroom mom? And Jake's being bullied, that's why he doesn't want to go to school? And she comes to the terms with the fact that she was wrong?

Sunny: It's hard to imagine.

Joe: And yet, it doesn't make me less sympathetic toward Barbara Jean, because of having seen her so much.

Sunny: In this specific context, yeah.

Joe: She's never mean about it. She's... the over-aggressiveness is a joke.

Sunny: You appreciate when someone has something they want, they're going for it, doing it in relatively good spirit.

Joe: When she yells into the kitchen "justice waits for no one!", she says it in an aggressive way, but everyone smirks and rolls their eyes. No one thinks she's actually being a dick in that situation.

Sunny: It's understood that it's Barbara Jean's personality, which is charming.

Joe: Do you think that there's a way to talk about Van in this context? One, what does it look like for him to be humbled? And two, is there a way to hypothetically consider, that we, in this conversation about Van, over the course of four years, have been wrong, and that he is actually the sympathetic character?

Sunny: You can always see anyone as sympathetic if you really want to. I think he's humbled in this episode. He's been humbled, and his negative attitude shows what happens when he's put into that position. He's unable to deal with feeling slighted or feeling wrong in a personal situation. Can I imagine him having a better reaction? If I think about the Van at the start of the episode, and he was genuinely trying to help his mother-in-law with her cholesterol, maybe there is a sympathetic person in there. Maybe there's a live wire in his relationship with Cheyenne that makes it tough for him. That would be maybe the most sympathy that I could give, that perhaps that there's history and drama in that relationship that makes it tough.

Joe: Marrying young, I assume.

Sunny: Teenage pregnancy, presumably.

Joe: Having to give up his football career.

Sunny: His illustrious football career, presumably.

Joe: You know what my new theory is? It has to be right... I promise that this did not come from... I still have never seen another episode of Reba, okay? I don't know if you know the answer to this, but please don't tell me. I saw a commercial in which Reba was acting, for a realtor. Realtor dot com or something. She's a realtor. Right? And Van works for her. That's why they're hanging out!

Sunny: It makes sense. I could see that. He's got realtor energy.

Joe: The fucking sweater vest! That's a realtor outfit. And he's sucking up to his boss. By cooking her breakfast.

Sunny: And doing a bad job of it. Like most realtors, he's judgmental and incompetent. But decently paid.

Joe: [laughter] Does this lend itself to any additional sympathy? If that's true. Let's say that it's true, from here on out. We're seeing it now. This is their job, this is why they're able to go to the fucking old persons' center during the day. The fact that he, Van, works for his mother-in-law, and the fact that his wife is going to be working for his father-in-law, her father. And this is clearly what they talked about in their ten-year plan. Like, listen, there are these overbearing presences in our lives, but we're gonna lean on them for support. And that is how we're going to get out of this financial hole we find ourselves in as young parents. I could see, hypothetically, how he might be... not justified in his anger, but I could see where the anger is coming from. In that case.

Sunny: I can see how he's living this sort of Alexander Payne, Wes Anderson quarter-life crisis. He feels trapped, enmeshed, and perhaps his last life raft of Cheyenne is drifting, and so he's lashing out in his own way. He's even taking it out on old ladies, who are just trying to look nice. [laughter]

Joe: And also, I must have talked about this at some point, but how cruel it seems that she walks in from this conflict at the old persons' home, she walks in and he's drinking a beer, right in her face. That's gotta be on purpose. That's gotta be... if she's doing the twelve steps for... whatever, I assume it's for drinking and not for, like, heroin. Right? But that's an assumption, maybe she's doing coke. Still, whatever substance abuse she was going through... it seems malicious. It seems intentional. And that's less sympathy. But, I don't know. I guess I'm trying to be a Tevye type, in this one conversation about Van. Am I seeing this wrong? Am I seeing this wrong because I'm boxed in by the one-episode-over-and-over thing, just in the same way that Tevye is boxed in by his religion? He doesn't know any better.

Sunny: I think in a way, we are completely boxed in. And so everything else is speculation. But we can also hope that Van, being boxed in with what's going on with him, could expand his horizons, and see that there's...

Joe: You're asking for Van to be wrong.

Sunny: I think he's stuck in a Tevye situation, in that the situation with his daughters growing and changing is like Cheyenne growing and changing. And he needs to grow and change with it, just like Reba suggests. But, I think you're right, in that we can stand, maybe not in full empathy, but some sympathy for Van, because he's in a tough spot. And I can imagine a lot things have not gone his way. If we take half a step back from having seen this episode so many times, it is ridiculous, right? She's leaving her dental school to dress up old ladies at the old persons' home. That is sort of ridiculous. And it's played on a sitcom for laughs.

Joe: And it's stretched for 20 minutes, whereas in real life it could have been a conversation at the beginning, but I see your point.

Sunny: So I could see Van losing it. It doesn't excuse his behavior, but like you said, I could see where it's coming from.

Joe: Must we consider Van to be a survivor?

Sunny: [laughter] I believe a key theme is that they're all survivors. Barbara Jean surviving getting ejected from court, held in contempt. Brock surviving losing an unpaid intern. We must all survive.

Joe: And yet... sorry. Two of the characters do not survive the episode!

Sunny: Ironically.

Joe: We must consider this canon, because it's in the episode. I mean, is every... we talk about sitcom conflicts being about people not admitting that they're wrong. Could we also view it as every conflict being just a constant fight for survival? Constantly fighting against death? And that Van and Brock, by lacking humility, are forced to face their demise?

Sunny: Their hell.

Joe: The Puke on Your Birthday spin-off series of this, 'Til Death, is exploring this theme in more depth. That all of these conflicts that arise in these sitcoms are just these two people who are just trying to stay alive. And I think we can look at Fiddler like that too. Tevye is a married dad who works too hard, who loves his kids and never stops. I think that's a very optimistic way to view entertainment, that all heroic characters are brave enough to fight against the dying of the light.

Sunny: Yeah, that is the core propulsion. It keeps the plot going.

Joe: And... man, I don't remember in our official canon if Barbara Jean is alive currently. I think Reba died, right?

Sunny: Reba died, and that's why there can no longer be survivors.

Joe: [laughter] That's right. Ah man, I don't know if I have anything else to say about that. But if Barbara Jean is still alive, does she think about Tevye like we think about Tevye? Does she find more value in her experience as Tevye as years the go on?

Sunny: Does she consider her time as Tevye as more or less seminal than her time in the jury room?

Joe: Or on the [volleyball] court. I mean, I guess our lives in the present moment are a culmination of everything that came before it. Everything informs. So this will be the final question. Is there anything, anything in this episode, that you could possibly say, even remotely, in which Barbara Jean, in her actions and her life in this moment, is informed by her past experience as Tevye?

Sunny: I think it would be difficult not to see a clear thread of justice in Barbara Jean's life. And justice in Tevye's life. And the drive toward justice. With an eagerness, frankly, like Tevye, that other people around her can't understand. Others feel that it's a bit much. And I think Tevye, for some people, was a little much.

Joe: Did Barbara Jean care about justice in this specific court hearing that she was going hear?

Sunny: I cannot read it any other way than, straightforwardly, she cared. If this whole thing was a ruse, like a next-level ruse to get out of jury duty, then she's fooled us all that we have not figured out for five years. And probably never will figure out. So I must read it as straight. That this was an important day for her, getting on this jury, serving justice for this particular case, because she knew what it was, Brock informed her, and that did not stymy her whatsoever. 

Joe: And I hate to bring this part up... what has been established in the canon... that this was a capitol punishment trial, for stealing a garden gnome, that Barbara Jean actually committed the crime to begin with, and that it was all a sham in the first place, it was an FBI sting operation against Pat Bullard? The writer who was framed. We don't need to relitigate all this. But pushing all that aside. I would like to think that justice is a core human value. Despite the fact that we might get wrapped up in extraneous things, like living under an oppressive government and wanting to be a part of that government, or a general inability to say you are wrong about something that affects large-scale justice issues, but I think that at our core, we lean toward the light of justice. That that feels right within us, and injustice feels wrong, and that Barbara Jean felt that in the same way that Tevye felt that. That's how she was able to inform her acting in this hypothetical play.

Sunny: That's right.

Joe: Now if we can scrape together however much she's charging on Cameo these days, we can ask her about this.

Sunny: Whatever it is, it's worth it.

Joe: I think I'm going to wait until they start filming Haul Out the Holly 3, starring Melissa Peterman and Stephen Tobolowsky. When that happens, I'm going to ask her, so they can chat about it.

Sunny: I hope she brings Tevye into that role too.

~~~~~~~~

Thanks to Sunny for chatting! Thanks to everyone reading this too. And thanks to "Grannies Gone Wild" for existing, and for making 11/11 such a special day each year.