Joe: Okay, so.... Barbara Jean.
Sunny: Yeah.
Sunny: And she stole the show.
Joe: [
laughter] Right, yes. Okay, so this has been written about before,
I'm going to link it here. The picture was already posted four summers ago. You could pull it off. Just like you could pull off anyone looking like Errol Flynn. That gave us something to talk about within the episode. This is basically nothing. Besides the fact that, yes, she's saying that she "stole the show," which is probably a comedic misunderstanding of what "stealing the show" means.
Sunny: And what "theft" is, and what "crimes" are.
Joe: I didn't know beforehand what Tevye's role in this play was. Clearly, he is the main character.
Sunny: She also referred to it as a "play," not a musical. I find that interesting.
Joe: Oh wow. Yeah, I wonder if there is a non-musical version of this. Like a "junior" version.
Sunny: Did he say that he's a rich man?
Joe: She doesn't say what school. It could be a second grade play. And... she's not Jewish, right?
Sunny: Yeah, so "Barbara Jean Hart," I was looking at that name for a while. Hard to make a case that she's Jewish.
Joe: I mean, right outside of a Houston, Texas...
Sunny: And her maiden name is even more goy-sounding. So...
Joe: Well, this isn't a requirement for playing a character in a play.
Sunny: She's an actress! And a great actress!
Joe: I think that's maybe part of the joke, is that—
Sunny: Well, the point wasn't that she was saying she was a good actress. The point was that she was a good thief.
Joe: [laughter] Right. And, we don't know enough about Barbara Jean to know whether she is being sarcastic. Or maybe, I don't know. You've seen a couple more episodes of this television show.
Sunny: Have I? Have I? I can really only just speculate...
Joe: I appreciate you keeping up the act of speculation here. Just in case Barbara Jean reveals—
Sunny: Key information! Which she could at any time. Yeah, so, if it was a musical, I would love to see a rendition of "Rich Man." If it wasn't, if it was the flat version, I would still be curious to see how she delivered the pogrom scene.
Joe: Do we think it was an all-women version?
Sunny: Presumably! Texas? I could see it. Maybe she went to a Catholic school.
Joe: That's definitely a thing in amateur school-age theater, is that there's not enough guys, and there are too many girls involved. I can't think of a major character, of a production that I was a part of though, that was gender-switched. Some minor characters that were probably originally played by men, then played by women.
Sunny: The reverse-Shakespeare!
Joe: Right. It wasn't like in Into the Woods, the Baker was a woman. I'm trying to think... I mean, I assume that the Fiddler on the Roof that I saw in person, Tevye was a man. I don't want to lean too far into this completely throwaway joke—
Sunny: Oh, we're leaning!
Joe: Okay, so let me ask you this way. So this is specifically about characters in this episode of television. Do you care about these characters?
Sunny: Deeply.
Joe: Because I feel like that's a thing with sitcom characters over time. That you grow to love these characters. That's because you see their ups and downs. The most popular network sitcoms across history, people might start to say that the characters are "part of their family."
Sunny: Kramer!
Joe: Uh... yes. The ultimately example of this. Kramer, my father, Kramer. But yeah, I was just curious, if that's possible, just watching the same episode over and over. Because it's quite static, in that we see Barbara Jean do the same thing over and over, and yet, find a way to care about her anyway?
Sunny: I mean, I feel like I know more about these characters from the depths of those 22 minutes than I would from seasons of watching it. Like, would I really have known that Reba was trying to keep her cholesterol down? Would I really understand that Barbara Jean stole the show? Probably not. Probably not. I would've just heard the jokes and moved on. I wouldn't have appreciated the depth of the character-building.
Joe: I know this is something we talked about last year, is there a limited depth, or unlimited depth? And I felt like I was hitting a wall last year. I don't know if there's any depth to this Tevye joke. But I do think that it is an indication, the fact that we are able to talk about it, and care about it, and actually talk about Barbara Jean as if she's a real person, despite the fact that this sitcom experience has been very different than a typical situation like that. I think it gives credence to the theory that this is a good and artful and, I don't know, emotionally worthy thing to do. The watching of this episode over and over.
Sunny: Sure!
Joe: Not necessarily because of the Tevye joke, that's just one piece of it. One example of it. Like, having seen Barbara Jean on the screen for thousands of minutes at this point, it's really funny that she would don a beard in high school.
Sunny: And be Tevye, yeah.
Joe: And be this character. Do you think... this is another general sitcom thing that I was thinking about, and also an emotional thing that I've been thinking about recently, for whatever reason. Do you ever get the sense that most of the conflicts in sitcoms like this are due to the fact that characters refuse to think that they themselves are wrong, about anything? Like in order to have a functioning society, when there's conflict, a lot of the time there's someone who's right and someone who's wrong. And the conflict... for example, the conflict between Van and Cheyenne. That becomes a conflict because Van can't see that he is wrong. They obviously had some type of plan in their life, the ten-year plan, and Cheyenne is going against what they planned. True! But, to jump immediately to "I am right and you are wrong," which is what he does, is what causes the conflict. Because if he had said, "okay, that's not what we planned, but let's talk about it, maybe the ten-year plan that we came up with is wrong, and maybe you're right for following your instincts." It just seems that nobody, in this episode particularly, is willing to admit this, that they could be wrong. Brock ends the episode dying rather than being wrong.
Sunny: Right. Jake is never wrong.
Joe: He gets the revenge! And I was thinking... well, one, other sitcoms, that this is how the plot is driven, how there's a misunderstanding, and no one wants to admit that they're wrong. No one can be humble enough to admit that they're wrong. And I also kept thinking about whether this is indicative of society at large, that many of our conflicts are due to the fact that people can't admit that they're wrong. Do you think that's true? What are your thoughts on this?
Sunny: Yeah, I think a sitcom needs an easy-to-solve, 22-minute conflict, and one person not having a lot of humility. It's there, it's available. It's hard to imagine an enjoyable show if there wasn't a stubborn character, like Van. Or Urkel! Urkel never admits he's wrong! He just says "Did I do that?"
Joe: [laughter]
Sunny: That's the whole show!
Joe: I don't know enough to speak to that.
Sunny: So does that expand to the wider society? Of course. If for no other reason that we were, in our generation, raised on these sitcoms. But there's plenty of people who do not want to admit they're wrong, even if they know they're wrong. There are plenty of people who don't know they're wrong even if they are. And there are probably some people where it is complicated. But I think that's the smaller percentage of the cases, where both sides are wrong.
Joe: Something that I've tried to work on—and maybe it's more talking the talk than walking the walk, and you can tell me which—I feel like it's important to work on being wrong. And maybe this is the alcoholic in me speaking, but it felt easier, and it felt to be more in touch with my humanity, if there was a conflict because of my drinking or whatever, and I woke up the next morning like "oh shit, I fucked up." Right? And to apologize for that solved a lot of conflict in my life. And I still feel that way. Within the past year I received an email from a mutual friend saying "you were wrong to do this," and I basically said to her, okay, I sent her an email apologizing. "I was wrong." I was open about the fact that this was something that I do, that I practice, and I don't know if that made it better or worse. But it's something that's important to me. To know how to be wrong. And to know how to admit being wrong. It feels like a missing piece in our culture right now. And maybe that is why it's so uncomfortable when I know I'm righ
t, because there's no way to do that.
Sunny: Hmmm.
Joe: I do think that's why I liked Fiddler on the Roof so much. It's that Tevye was a good wrong character. That he was willing to see the other side of things.
Sunny: Willing to grow from it, yeah.
Joe: Not all the time.
Sunny: Not all the time, but sometimes.
Joe: He didn't get there with the third daughter. With the first two, he was caught off-guard, had a bad reaction, had a conversation with god about it, reconsidered, and basically admitted that he was wrong, ya know?
Sunny: I think, to your point, that is the right way to approach being wrong about something. It seems like a live wire for a lot of folks.
Joe: Do we think Barbara Jean, being the sitcom character that she is... how often is she wrong?
Sunny: Well, let's keep in mind, how excited was she to be on jury duty? She wanted to adjudicate on if someone was right or wrong in a court of law. So clearly it matters a lot to her.
Joe: Yeah! And that she was so set on being on that jury, and the judge was misinterpreting her actions, and she got so upset that she couldn't make the judge see what she was trying to do, she was so upset because she felt that someone else was wrong, and she was right. And then ended up get thrown out of court for it! So, I don't know if there's an actual way to tie all that to the Tevye joke... [laughter] But it's definitely something I was thinking about due to the nature of this project, after the 111th time I've seen this episode. I guess I was just wondering if any of that has ever crossed your mind.
Sunny: Did you see Tevye in her actions there, yeah. Getting kicked out of the courtroom.
Joe: Do you agree with the theory of acting that donning the costume of somebody else brings out a truth from within yourself?
Sunny: ...
Joe: Chew on that for a second. Have you ever been presented with this theory?
Sunny: I have not been presented with this theory. But...
Sunny: I do love Wallace Shawn! Um, I see it. I mean, what does the actor do at the end of the day? Match their person with the persona of the character on the script, the character in the costume. Yeah. I think that's right. Why was Barbara Jean Tevye? Why was she the lead of this play? When it was gender-bending, she's not Jewish, she must have insisted on it. Why is she insisting to be in the jury case? I think all of these come together. In the same way that Tevye was insisting on certain ways of being. And while Tevye was able to bend, ultimately, and find some kind of compromise, Barbara Jean was kicked out of the courtroom, and was not able to find a way.
Joe: I don't know... okay. So thinking about Barbara Jean as Tevye, as an actor, okay? As an actor, not just Tevye, as I assume this was not her only role. And also using my own experience as an actor, I think being able to use some part of yourself to be somebody else is a skill that not everyone has. Wallace Shawn obviously has this. He is able to be that plastic dinosaur.
Sunny: And he sells it!
Joe: He sells it. I certainly did not have that skill. I forget what the context of that essay way, maybe it was something to do with the conversation of method acting. Was it something to do with that Succession dude? Remember that?
Sunny: Jeremy Strong? Yeah.
Joe: Where he was method acting and kinda being a dick about it? [
Editor's note: if you clicked the link, you would see that Shawn is actually linking acting-as-empathy to socialism, which is way better.] I mean, I've
always been of the opinion that method acting is the wrong way to look at acting. You shouldn't bend your will to the character that you're playing, you should bend the will of the character you're playing to who
you are, as a person. I guess I just saw a disconnect between, okay, Barbara Jean is playing this character, in this play, who is
not like her, the person we see in these 22 minutes, because she's not willing to consider any other points of view, just like any other sitcom character—
Sunny: I can't imagine Barbara Jean is into the method style.
Joe: [laughter] Probably not! No. I mean, I guess she must have brought something of herself, because that's just who she is. Barbara Jean seems like the type of person who can't help but be who she is.
Sunny: That's right.
Joe: To... to no one's detriment...
Sunny: It's authentic.
Joe: It's authentic, yeah... I'm obviously just thinking out loud here, so I apologize to you for this.
Sunny: No, please, keep it rolling.
Joe: But the authentic piece is also what I think I had a problem with, when we're speaking about society having the issue of not being wrong. That our president's initial "attractive" quality, quote-unquote, to half of the American populace, was that he was "authentic." Right? That might not necessarily be true. But it was interesting that it was framed as "oh, he's a dick, he's saying terrible things, and
that makes him authentic." And I guess we don't have to go into
the Nebraska thing, because I was thinking about authenticity there too. It all comes together!
Sunny: Sure!
Joe: I don't know. I don't know if I've thought about it enough, that aspect of it, with Barbara Jean, with acting, with Tevye, with society at large. I think there's something there.
Sunny: Again, with these 22 minutes, I can't imagine Barbara Jean trying to inhabit a character. Rather, I see character bending to Barbara Jean's will and needs. So that is a certain authenticity, to the ego as opposed to the character, whoever that may be. And you're right, I think people see someone who's a dick as authentic because, well, why would he be lying if he's going to be an asshole? I understand that some people lie to gladhand me, but it turns out that some people will just lie and be assholes.
Joe: What do you think... okay, so over the course of one hundred-plus episodes of a TV series, clearly there must have been a moment when Barbara Jean was at the losing end of a conflict. One that we'll never see. What does that look like, do you think? She's not that, here, in this episode.
Sunny: She declares "injustice" at the end, ironically.
Joe: Alright, so she... I don't know, was she a bad stepmom to Jake? She's overzealous when she's Jake's homeroom mom? And Jake's being
bullied, that's why he doesn't want to go to school? And she comes to the terms with the fact that she was wrong?
Sunny: It's hard to imagine.
Joe: And yet, it doesn't make me less sympathetic toward Barbara Jean, because of having seen her so much.
Sunny: In this specific context, yeah.
Joe: She's never mean about it. She's... the over-aggressiveness is a joke.
Sunny: You appreciate when someone has something they want, they're going for it, doing it in relatively good spirit.
Joe: When she yells into the kitchen "justice waits for no one!", she says it in an aggressive way, but everyone smirks and rolls their eyes. No one thinks she's actually being a dick in that situation.
Sunny: It's understood that it's Barbara Jean's personality, which is charming.
Joe: Do you think that there's a way to talk about Van in this context? One, what does it look like for him to be humbled? And two, is there a way to hypothetically consider, that we, in this conversation about Van, over the course of four years, have been wrong, and that he is actually the sympathetic character?
Sunny: You can always see anyone as sympathetic if you really want to. I think he's humbled in this episode. He's been humbled, and his negative attitude shows what happens when he's put into that position. He's unable to deal with feeling slighted or feeling wrong in a personal situation. Can I imagine him having a better reaction? If I think about the Van at the start of the episode, and he was genuinely trying to help his mother-in-law with her cholesterol, maybe there is a sympathetic person in there. Maybe there's a live wire in his relationship with Cheyenne that makes it tough for him. That would be maybe the most sympathy that I could give, that perhaps that there's history and drama in that relationship that makes it tough.
Joe: Marrying young, I assume.
Sunny: Teenage pregnancy, presumably.
Joe: Having to give up his football career.
Sunny: His illustrious football career, presumably.
Joe: You know what my new theory is? It has to be right... I promise that this did not come from... I still have never seen another episode of Reba, okay? I don't know if you know the answer to this, but please don't tell me. I saw a commercial in which Reba was acting, for a realtor. Realtor dot com or something. She's a realtor. Right? And Van works for her. That's why they're hanging out!
Sunny: It makes sense. I could see that. He's got realtor energy.
Joe: The fucking sweater vest! That's a realtor outfit. And he's sucking up to his boss. By cooking her breakfast.
Sunny: And doing a bad job of it. Like most realtors, he's judgmental and incompetent. But decently paid.
Joe: [laughter] Does this lend itself to any additional sympathy? If that's true. Let's say that it's true, from here on out. We're seeing it now. This is their job, this is why they're able to go to the fucking old persons' center during the day. The fact that he, Van, works for his mother-in-law, and the fact that his wife is going to be working for his father-in-law, her father. And this is clearly what they talked about in their ten-year plan. Like, listen, there are these overbearing presences in our lives, but we're gonna lean on them for support. And that is how we're going to get out of this financial hole we find ourselves in as young parents. I could see, hypothetically, how he might be... not justified in his anger, but I could see where the anger is coming from. In that case.
Sunny: I can see how he's living this sort of Alexander Payne, Wes Anderson quarter-life crisis. He feels trapped, enmeshed, and perhaps his last life raft of Cheyenne is drifting, and so he's lashing out in his own way. He's even taking it out on old ladies, who are just trying to look nice. [laughter]
Joe: And also, I must have talked about this at some point, but how cruel it seems that she walks in from this conflict at the old persons' home, she walks in and he's drinking a beer, right in her face. That's gotta be on purpose. That's gotta be... if she's doing the twelve steps for... whatever, I assume it's for drinking and not for, like, heroin. Right? But that's an assumption, maybe she's doing coke. Still, whatever substance abuse she was going through... it seems malicious. It seems intentional. And that's less sympathy. But, I don't know. I guess I'm trying to be a Tevye type, in this one conversation about Van. Am I seeing this wrong? Am I seeing this wrong because I'm boxed in by the one-episode-over-and-over thing, just in the same way that Tevye is boxed in by his religion? He doesn't know any better.
Sunny: I think in a way, we are completely boxed in. And so everything else is speculation. But we can also hope that Van, being boxed in with what's going on with him, could expand his horizons, and see that there's...
Joe: You're asking for Van to be wrong.
Sunny: I think he's stuck in a Tevye situation, in that the situation with his daughters growing and changing is like Cheyenne growing and changing. And he needs to grow and change with it, just like Reba suggests. But, I think you're right, in that we can stand, maybe not in full empathy, but some sympathy for Van, because he's in a tough spot. And I can imagine a lot things have not gone his way. If we take half a step back from having seen this episode so many times, it is ridiculous, right? She's leaving her dental school to dress up old ladies at the old persons' home. That is sort of ridiculous. And it's played on a sitcom for laughs.
Joe: And it's stretched for 20 minutes, whereas in real life it could have been a conversation at the beginning, but I see your point.
Sunny: So I could see Van losing it. It doesn't excuse his behavior, but like you said, I could see where it's coming from.
Joe: Must we consider Van to be a survivor?
Sunny: [laughter] I believe a key theme is that they're all survivors. Barbara Jean surviving getting ejected from court, held in contempt. Brock surviving losing an unpaid intern. We must all survive.
Joe: And yet... sorry. Two of the characters do not survive the episode!
Sunny: Ironically.
Joe: We must consider this canon, because it's in the episode. I mean, is every... we talk about sitcom conflicts being about people not admitting that they're wrong. Could we also view it as every conflict being just a constant fight for survival? Constantly fighting against death? And that Van and Brock, by lacking humility, are forced to face their demise?
Sunny: Their hell.
Joe: The Puke on Your Birthday spin-off series of this,
'Til Death, is exploring this theme in more depth. That all of these conflicts that arise in these sitcoms are just these two people who are just trying to stay alive. And I think we can look at
Fiddler like that too. Tevye is a married dad who works too hard, who loves his kids and never stops. I think that's a very optimistic way to view entertainment, that all heroic characters are brave enough to fight against the dying of the light.
Sunny: Yeah, that is the core propulsion. It keeps the plot going.
Joe: And... man, I don't remember in our official canon if Barbara Jean is alive currently. I think Reba died, right?
Sunny: Reba died, and that's why there can no longer be survivors.
Joe: [laughter] That's right. Ah man, I don't know if I have anything else to say about that. But if Barbara Jean is still alive, does she think about Tevye like we think about Tevye? Does she find more value in her experience as Tevye as years the go on?
Sunny: Does she consider her time as Tevye as more or less seminal than her time in the jury room?
Joe: Or on the [volleyball] court. I mean, I guess our lives in the present moment are a culmination of everything that came before it. Everything informs. So this will be the final question. Is there anything, anything in this episode, that you could possibly say, even remotely, in which Barbara Jean, in her actions and her life in this moment, is informed by her past experience as Tevye?
Sunny: I think it would be difficult not to see a clear thread of justice in Barbara Jean's life. And justice in Tevye's life. And the drive toward justice. With an eagerness, frankly, like Tevye, that other people around her can't understand. Others feel that it's a bit much. And I think Tevye, for some people, was a little much.
Joe: Did Barbara Jean care about justice in this specific court hearing that she was going hear?
Sunny: I cannot read it any other way than, straightforwardly, she cared. If this whole thing was a ruse, like a next-level ruse to get out of jury duty, then she's fooled us all that we have not figured out for five years. And probably never will figure out. So I must read it as straight. That this was an important day for her, getting on this jury, serving justice for this particular case, because she knew what it was, Brock informed her, and that did not stymy her whatsoever.
Joe: And I hate to bring this part up...
what has been established in the canon... that this was a capitol punishment trial, for stealing a garden gnome, that Barbara Jean actually committed the crime to begin with, and that it was all a sham in the first place, it was an FBI sting operation against Pat Bullard? The writer who was framed. We don't need to relitigate all this. But pushing all that aside. I would like to think that justice is a core human value. Despite the fact that we might get wrapped up in extraneous things, like living under an oppressive government and wanting to be a part of that government, or a general inability to say you are wrong about something that affects large-scale justice issues, but I think that at our core, we lean toward the light of justice. That that feels right within us, and injustice feels wrong, and that Barbara Jean felt that in the same way that Tevye felt that. That's how she was able to inform her acting in this hypothetical play.
Sunny: That's right.
Joe: Now if we can scrape together however much she's charging on
Cameo these days, we can ask her about this.
Sunny: Whatever it is, it's worth it.
Joe: I think I'm going to wait until they start filming
Haul Out the Holly 3, starring Melissa Peterman and Stephen Tobolowsky. When that happens, I'm going to ask her, so they can chat about it.
Sunny: I hope she brings Tevye into that role too.
Thanks to Sunny for chatting! Thanks to everyone reading this too. And thanks to "Grannies Gone Wild" for existing, and for making 11/11 such a special day each year.