Showing posts with label Your Favorite Movie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Your Favorite Movie. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 25, 2022

Your Favorite Movie: A Conclusion, and a Look Forward


In my Research class this past semester, we learned a little bit about "qualitative research," and how sitting down with a person or a group of people and just asking them about their experience is indeed a legitimate form of research. Less structured, sure, and maybe not as useful in the grand scheme of things, but legitimate and important research nonetheless. Of course, every time we talked about qualitative research, I couldn't stop reflecting on my time as a qualitative researcher of films and friends.

What was the Your Favorite Movie project, if not research? I gathered specific participants, and used their words and their experiences to help answer a question. This is research, in its loosest, clumsiest, and often drunkest, form.

But that beggars the retrospective question: what exactly was the "question" I was trying to answer throughout Your Favorite Movie? When I started the project, I thought that the question was: "Why is one's favorite movie their favorite movie?" In other words, what makes a film worthy of "favorite" status? The only problem is, after 36 interviews, I feel like that question was first answered, and then ultimately came to be more of an albatross than the thing that kept the project afloat.

What I mean is that I realized way too late in the game that "favorite movie" should have been a red herring the whole time. The real question that a more competent and in-tune interview would've attempted to answer during these interviews was "What makes you the way you are?" The real magic, when it was occasionally and accidentally happened upon during any given interview, occurred when we were witness to a part of the interviewee's true self. When we glimpsed the inner truth, some part of that person when they use film discussions to let their guard down, that's where this blog project really worked.

The fact that it didn't always work that way (and see yesterday's archived interview for a great example of when it doesn't work) was due to my own shortcomings, my own inability to see the true purpose of this project before it was too late. What I should have done was to use the "favorite movie" conceit as an excuse to talk about the person, and too often I would use the person as an excuse to talk about their favorite movie. And that isn't as fun or exciting or worthy of the research time given to it.

If I could start it over, I would, now knowing what could have been achieved with the right question in mind. And, like I said, it's not like we didn't accidentally get there sometimes anyway. But this could have been better. I could've been better.

Could I start this over? It's tempting to think about it, during these first quiet weeks of a summer that stretches out before me. What if I asked people about a different art form? Your Favorite Album?

Two thoughts about this hypothetical. The first is logistics. The bulk of my movie interviews were done in a household with one child who slept soundly at the same time every night. Now, with two kids here and who knows how many more in the future and extremely tenuous sleep schedules, the timing seems closer to impossible than possible. Plus, factor in the move to the Great Northeast in the interim, and the shrinking likelihood that people are going to want to make the trek a further 25 minutes in this direction for a fucking blog project, and man, things aren't looking good, are they? And then you have to consider the fact that transcribing takes so much time. Time that I definitely had when I was in the office five days a week, taking calls that only sporadically rang on my desktop phone. Time that I definitely don't have now, removed from the office three of those days, with homework squeezed into what used to be downtime. I dunno.

Logistics aside, though, I really do think that the Your Favorite Album idea (perhaps with a more creative name this time) would be worthy of pursuit, if not now, then eventually. It would work well for a few reasons. One, my understanding of and appreciation for music is more advanced than for movies (if I thought originally that YFM would help me in this regard, I was mistaken), so I'd feel more comfortable in the interview role. Two, there would theoretically be less hard facts and data to discuss, since the average album is like half the length, at least, as your average film. That would translate to less sprawling interviews. This would also mean that there would be more room to talk about the person in the context of the album, and not the other way around.

In that regard, we should probably change the question that I'd be presenting to interviewees to begin with, right? "What is your favorite album and why?" would just lead us down the same dark paths again. How about: "What is the album that means the most to you, and why?" Now there's a question that puts the focus on the person. That's what we want here. That's where the magic is. (Plus: changing the question to maybe "What is an album that means a lot to you?" might mean we could do multiple interviews in a way that asking the finite question of "all-time favorite" impeded.)

So it is here that we pause. Our deep dive in the human psyche via film is concluded, and we will start up again in a different arena, at a different time, with a more clearly stated purpose.

Until then, I want to thank every who participated in the interviews for everything they contributed to the project, despite my shortcomings in the process. Looking back, I really do feel like I know more about my friends than I did prior to asking them about their favorite movie of all time. This was all about you, even if I didn't realize it until it was too late. So a very delayed thank you to you all.

And where does that leave you, humble blog reader? Well, two options for you. The first is that you can start your own blog series. Buy a decent, reasonably priced voice recorder, and get out there and start talking to people. You know you have a place available to you for dropping transcripts, right here on Puke on Your Birthday.

The second option? I guess you can tell me what the album that means the most to you is. Maybe we can get this thing started before 2023. Probably not, but the more rumblings I feel, the likelier I am to motivate myself to do it.

Tuesday, May 24, 2022

From the Vault: The Lost Titanic Interview, for Your Favorite Movie


Welcome back for what has to be the final time to Your Favorite Movie, in which we ask the question—you guessed it!—what is your favorite movie, and why?

Today, we travel back to September 20, 2019, when the interviewee was my own mother. We gathered in a shore house during the first night of Irish Weekend, around the table with some pizza and beer and family and friends, and discussed what Mom said was her favorite movie of all time—Titanic.

The movie needs no introduction (and not just because there was already a published YFM interview for this movie). It's one of the most popular movies of our lifetime, and if you were born before like 1992, then you are already familiar with its existence.

Perhaps the context of the interview needs some explaining, though. After all, it's been over two and a half years since the interview took place (like, a sixteen-month-old Willow is in this, and she just turned four a couple weeks ago in our present-day timeline). It's been a while. Why wasn't this interview published at the time?

To be frank, probably because it sucked. It was the wrong place to conduct the interview (loud music, at the beginning of a weekend, too many people involved, everyone distracted with priorities elsewhere, a crying baby). I probably didn't do a good job articulating what exactly I was trying to achieve with this interview. Maybe I didn't even have a firm grasp myself at that point as to what I was trying to achieve, I dunno. Due to all this, it was a very surface-level and scattered interview, with a lot of silence, and a lot of one-word answers.

But I also didn't like the idea of a recording just sitting in the vaults, so here you go. You can finally read the lost Titanic interview, at last dredged up from the bottom of the ocean. Let's get it out there for posterity, and then let's come back tomorrow to officially wrap up this whole movie interview project. See you then.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe: I want us to start in 1997. Paint us a picture of what it was like then, that the country fell in love with a boat movie. How did that happen?

Mom: 1997. Let's see. I'm guessing... I mean, I think it was just a good love story.

Joe: It had nothing to do with the time it was released?

Mom: No. It was a love story. A bunch of girls went—[to Dad] you didn't go with me, right?

Dad: We had tried to go to see it several times, and it never worked out.

Joe: I guess me and Jenny went with you guys at one point.

Mom: To see Titanic?

Joe: And I don't know... I mean, the day we went to see it, it was like the sixth or seventh week that it was out.

Mom: But yeah, it didn't have anything to do with the time it came out.

Dad: It was just a blockbuster movie.

Joe: But you personally... those six weeks leading up to when you finally saw the movie for the first time... what made you want to see it so bad? What were you told? Do you remember?

Mom: I don't really remember.

Joe: Like, you talked to friends and family, and—

Dad: People said it stayed with them for days. I remember Uncle Hoof saying, "You gotta see it!" That it was a timeless classic, breaking all attendance records. Commercials on TV.

Mom: The music too!

Sarah: And Leonardo DiCaprio too! As a young teenager, I had a huge crush on him.

Pam: I feel like he was also... that wasn't his first movie, right?

Joe: I think Gilbert Grape was his first movie.

Pam: Yeah, but he wasn't "big" in that. Did this put him on the scene? [Editor: I'm not a Leo expert by any means, but at least two movies discussed on this blog since this interview have tracked his rising stardom—The Basketball Diaries, and Sean's Romeo + Juliet interview.]

Mom: And I remember Aunt Maggie and everyone in the family talking about it because of all the stuff about Ireland. The Irish coming over. Grandmom's family supposedly made the linens for the Titanic? [Editor's note: the names of ships also use italics, so you're going to have to use context clues to figure out if the transcript is referring to the ship itself or the movie. Like, in this case, I'm 99% certain that distant family in Ireland made linen for the ship, not the movie set. Right?]

Joe: Was that something Grandmom used to say?

Mom: Mhmm. Grandmom, her cousin sent over linens from Ireland to her. Oh, is the pizza here?

Joe: [audible sigh] Pause.

[pizza break, kind of, plus lots of live music heard in the background]

Mom: I forgot that you guys saw it in theaters.

Joe: I could've sworn we saw it with you.

Mom: We only saw it the once. Then we bought the... DVDs.

Joe: No, the double VHS tapes, right?

Mom: I guess.

Joe: I don't remember where the cut-off was, like when in the movie you had to switch it over. Does anyone remember?

Pam: It stopped right after they hit the iceberg, I think. They were on the deck. Because the climax of the first act is them hooking up. And after they hook up, they come out of the carriage thing, and they hear, or feel, the ship shake.

Joe: Aren't they on the deck when it hits?

Pam: Maybe they had just come out when it hits.

Mom: Yeah. I haven't seen it in years.

Joe: It was good! I was surprised how affecting it was, even 20 years later.

Pam: I don't know if I'm proud to admit this or not, but it was a craze. It was in theaters when I was in seventh grade, and I went to see it three times.

Jenn: What movie was that?

Everyone: Titanic!

Pam: That was the most I'd ever seen any movie in theaters.

Dad: Pizza is here.

Pam: Are we actually pausing the tape?

Joe: I don't know... I also forgot to get everyone's permission to tape...

Mom: You didn't have to.

Willow: [sneezes]

Pam: God bless you.

Dad: [at least three minutes of fake sneezing for Willow's benefit]

[actual break to get pizza]

Mom: Okay, so we established that it didn't have to do with the year it came out.

Joe: But do you think that Titanic would be as successful as it was then if it was released today?

Mom: I think so.

Joe: Because it's a timeless love story.

Mom: Right.

Joe: Okay. It's actually interesting—this is probably the only time I'll talk to someone whose favorite movie is one that I saw for the first time with them.

Mom: Ah, that's cool.

Joe: I remember a lot of my friends being very excited about Kate Winslet's topless scene.

Dad: Oooh, yeah. Uh huh.

Mom: Joe, you're on tape.

Dad: Oh yeah... [laughter]

Joe: And how you guys made me cover my eyes in the theaters.

Mom: Did we really?

Joe: I peeked. How old was I?

Mom: '97?

Joe: Nine years old.

Dad: We took you to see Titanic?! At nine?

Joe: Yeah! Did you peek, Jenn?

Jenn: ...No. [laughter]

Dad: Wasn't it rated R?

Pam: It was PG-13.

Joe: Was it PG-13?

Pam: It wasn't R. I went to see it!

Chris: I don't have to be in this.

Joe: Sure you do. What are your thoughts about Titanic, Chris?

Chris: [no answer]

Joe: Who do you think the villain is of this story?

Pam: Oh, Billy Zane. And his henchmen. Also, just, ya know... the class system?

Mom: Okay.

Joe: I was kind of thinking that Rose's mother was the villain.

Pam: They're all together.

Willow: Mama! Mama!

Joe: The mama. Yup. You're right. I agree. Because the mother kind of forced this life upon Rose, right? So the sort of "breaking free" of her hold was—

Pam: Weren't they broke, though?

Mom: That's right.

Joe: Then think about that. Is that right? You want your daughter to be unhappy just so you can get some more money? He was a jerk, that was established, and yet she was still going to force that marriage upon Rose.

Mom: And that was... yeah, that was the whole moral. Like we were saying early, you can have all the money, but then... yeah.

Pam: And in the end, the epilogue I guess, when they're talking about Cal, he says that he killed himself anyway. [Elderly Rose impression] "I heard that he put a pistol in his mouth."

Mom: He lost all his money.

Joe: So that wouldn't have been a happy ending, had she stayed. She at least would've gone broke. Her and the mom would've gone broke too, right?

Pam: Eventually, yeah.

Joe: Or... is Jack the villain?

[silence, assuming eye rolls are happening]

Pam: Jack the villain?!

Dad: He's the hero!

Joe: [laughter] Think about it from Cal's perspective! "Some riff raff is gonna make my wife cheat on me!"

Pam: They're not married!

Joe: "—is gonna make my fiancĂ©e cheat on me!"

Pam: But Cal also slapped her too!

Joe: Okay, fine, Jack would not have done that.

Pam: No!

Joe: Do you think it would've worked out for Rose and Jack, if Jack lived?

Mom: I think it would have. Absolutely.

Sarah: If only she would've made a little room on that door. She had to move over just a little bit!

Bob: She says "I'll never let go" and then she immediately lets go.

Chris: I don't understand it either.

Joe: Has anyone seen the MythBusters episode where they proved that they both could've been on that door?

Mom: Yes.

Sarah: I don't even need MythBusters to tell me that.

Joe: I don't know though. Jack seems very impulsive! I don't know if it would have worked out long-term for them.

Pam: Can I go back to the door thing?

Joe: Sure.

Pam: I feel like that's something you would do. I'd be like, "C'mon, just get on the door," and you'd be like "No! No! You go ahead." [laughter] "I'm fine! I'm fine!" And we'd fight about it!

Joe: With my dying breath? We'd fight to the literal dying breath?

Pam: You would freeze to death!

Dad: Most men would do that!

Pam: He'd be like, "No, I'm fine, I'm fine."

Joe: I mean, she let him chill in the water, so... it's kinda on her too. I dunno, though. Rose, 80 years later, has such a romantic... Jack is the romantic ideal, even when she is a senior citizen. Would that have been ruined, had she seen more than three days worth of Jack. Like, I'm thinking about the ending to The Graduate, when Dustin Hoffman and Katharine Ross are on the back of the bus, they make their grand escape, and then they have this look on their faces like, "Oh man, what's next? Did we do the right thing?"

Mom: Right, right.

Joe: Would that have happened to Jack and Rose?

Pam: That's why the ending was so good!

Mom: Because—yeah. Ya know. Maybe the excitement of the boat, once they got off.

Chris: Maybe she would've gotten tired of him. Because if she was with Jack, would she have had all the adventures that she had otherwise?

Mom: Exactly. Exactly.

Joe: Yeah, I don't know. This is all hypotheticals. Do you think Leo was a good actor in this?

Mom: He was okay.

Chris: He's become a good actor.

Pam: He's come a long way.

Mom: This was the early part.

Dad: I can't imagine anyone else doing that part!

Joe: I guess not.

Chris: Her too. She's really good in this.

Mom: Yeah.

Joe: So Kate Winslet was nominated for Best Actress, but Leo DiCaprio was not nominated for Best Actor.

Mom: I forgot he was snubbed at the awards.

Chris: Probably because he came from television. He used to be on TV!

Joe: What was he on? Facts of Life?

Chris: Facts of Life was George Clooney [Editor's note: he did indeed guest star in seventeen of the 201 episodes of Facts of Life]. He was on the one with Michael J. Fox.

Mom: Oh.

Dad: Family Matters.

Mom: No, that was Urkel. What was that show?

Chris: I forget.

Joe: It wasn't Facts of Life? Alex P. Keaton?

Mom: Family Ties! [Editor's note: Chris is right that Family Ties is the show with Michael J. Fox, but wrong in that Leonardo DiCaprio was ever in it. She's probably referring to Growing Pains, which featured Leo in Season 7 as a recurring character, a homeless kid that the family takes in. I know nothing about any of this, clearly.]

Joe: Okay. I guess his acting took me out of Titanic a little bit. I'm not saying he's a bad actor. I'm not saying he deserved an Oscar either. A lot of his line readings are like, [bad Leo impression] "C'mon Rose! You gotta breathe, Rose!"

Pam: That's what his lines were!

Joe: Psh. He was just readin' the script.

Pam: Well, even if he didn't deserve the Oscar here, his career was just starting.

Chris: He was really good in The Aviator.

Joe: Maybe I saw that too young, but I thought that was a dumb movie. He's just pissing in jars.

Chris: He actually did that, Howard Hughes. I looked it up.

Joe: I'm sure Leonardo DiCaprio did the method acting for that. He peed in jars for a year. He might've!

Pam: What was his method acting preparations for Wolf of Wall Street?

Joe: I guess we'll talk about that tomorrow.

Pam: [laughter] No we won't. 

Sarah: He did text me today about it! [Editor's note: Yes, this interview took place the night before the Ant S. Wolf of Wall Street interview. We're joking here that Ant, who has a history of not showing up when he says he's going to show up, was probably not going to show up to the interview. You, being a huge fan of Your Favorite Movie, already know that he shows up.]

Joe: Leo didn't win an Oscar for Wolf of Wall Street either.

Chris: The Revenant is a really good movie.

Mom: Okay, what else you got?

Joe: Kate was nominated for Best Actress. But Helen Hunt won for As Good as It Gets. Okay, so this was actually the first time that two different actresses were nominated for an Oscar for playing the same character. The old lady was nominated for Best Supporting Actress, for playing Rose.

Pam: Didn't you say that—

Mom: She won, didn't she?

Joe: No, Kim Basinger won for L.A. Confidential. What were you saying, Pam?

Pam: What about The Godfather? Wasn't DeNiro nominated for playing Corleone? Same character!

Joe: Right, right. This was the only time two actors were nominated in the same year for playing the same character.

Pam: Oh, gotchya.

Mom: What about... I have a question. What about how she kept the necklace all those years. And she never gave it to her grandniece... was it her grandniece?

Pam: I think it was her granddaughter.

Mom: She could've been... that was the whole idea, they were looking for the necklace, and she had it the whole time. [Editor's note: Willow screaming in the foreground, tough to hear at this point.]

Pam: That could've been her... I mean, if she was with Jack, she would've had the money still!

Joe: So ditching the necklace meant letting Jack go.

Mom: She was letting him go, finally.

Joe: Finally accepting the fact that Jack was the villain of this story?!

Mom: No.

Dad: Didn't Cal claim the insurance money for that necklace? So, if she had turned it in, or whatever, she would've been charged with a crime.

Chris: And then he would've been able to find Rose too. That's why.

Pam: That's right.

Joe: I never thought about it that way.

Pam: I think they said it in the current day story. "This was claimed by that person," ya know, they went through it, and she was like, "I know of the necklace."

Mom: And she had it the whole time.

Joe: She was a little reckless, though. To dump a fifty-million-dollar artifact into the ocean.

Dad: But she accidentally dropped it. She just went, "oops."

[laughter]

Joe: It did seem like that, didn't it?

Mom: No, I think that it was her letting it go. Letting everything out.

Chris: Do you think the old lady died at the end?

Mom: I think so.

Pam: That whole movie was such a craze, that it was in that Britney Spears song! "I got you this necklace," and she's like, "I thought the old lady dropped it in the ocean at the end!" and he's like, "Well, baby, I went down and got it." That's who much it was in pop culture.

Joe: It had a pretty big song attached to it, right?

Pam: Oh my god. Yeah.


Mom: CĂ©line Dion became famous from that. Didn't she?

Joe: She was famous before that, wasn't she? [Editor's note: Yeah, pretty much. I know less about CĂ©line than I do Leo, but I do know that "My Heart Will Go On" was her third Billboard #1 hit, so yes, she was famous before this, but I wouldn't know how to compare them.]

Mom: But that really...

Pam: She was untouchable.

Dad: Now it's tough to get tickets in Vegas.

Joe: Is she still in Vegas?

Chris: She looks like a walking skeleton. She really does! Really thin.

Joe: Wasn't there just a headline yesterday, something like "Celine Dion Begs Drake Not to Get a Face Tattoo"?

Chris: Who did what? 

Joe: I guess Drake gets tattoos of famous people on his body. Celine Dion said "please don't do one of me."

Bob: Who?

Joe: Drake.

Bob: Oh.

Pam: Is Drake Canadian?

Joe: Yeah!

Pam: Because she's French Canadian.

Joe: Is she?

Mom: Oh yeah, that's right.

Chris: Her husband discovered her when she was fourteen or fifteen.

Joe: What do you mean?

Pam: He was her agent or whatever.

Chris: He got her teeth fixed.

Joe: And they go married?

Pam: When she turned eighteen. [Editor's note: 24 years old, actually. And thankfully.]

Dad: He was older. [Editor's note: his name was RenĂ© AngĂ©lil, and he was 26 years older, to be specific.]

Chris: Way older.

Pam: He's dead now. [Editor's note: Died in 2016.]

Joe: Does... does her heart still go on for him...? [no laughter]

Pam: I mean, I think she was pretty devastated when he died.

Mom: One of my favorite scenes was when they went downstairs to the lower decks, to the poor Irish people.

Pam: When they're dancing.

Mom: And they all thought she was going to be snobbish. And she did the whisky shots, and... I love that. Stood on her toes.

Joe: I guess we can relate more to those scenes. To the people having fun. I guess on Irish Weekend...

Chris: Those stuffy people, the rich people...

Joe: We would've had to break down the gates though. Those scenes, they kind of affected me.

Chris: It really happened!

Mom: And when you think about it, with the mom reading the stories... that could be you reading Willow her stories, because you know this is it, just to keep her mind off it...

Joe: Every scene with like a two-year-old was like... it hits me in the gut now. Because of this crying little sneak!

Chris: [Editor's note: literally cannot hear what she is saying here because of Willow screaming.]

Pam: Oh yeah.

Mom: Are you done, Willow?

Pam: I hope so!

Chris: Have you ever heard of the Wideners? Or Lynnewood Hall?

Joe: No.

Chris: It's right around you guys. That was Widener, the one who died on the Titanic. He had built that hall. It's up for sixteen million dollars now.

Mom: Where is that?

Chris: It's near the Cheltenham post office.

Joe: I did see that everything about this movie was real. Except for Jack and Rose.

Chris: You should see inside of that building.

Mom: Musicians playing till the ship goes does.

Chris: Beautiful marble.

Joe: I remember seeing a promotional movie or something, whatever, from 1997, and they showed a picture that they had recovered from the ship, a drawing, of a kid playing with a top. Then they showed the part in the movie where the kid was playing with the top, it was pretty cool.

Mom: And the picture of us, we haven't talked about that.

Joe: That's right! I have had many people ask me about that, referencing the Titanic movie.

Chris: Which one?

Joe: In the living room in Rockledge. From a cruise ship, near the cruise ship's main steps. [laughter]

Mom: Is that what it was supposed to look like when they took the picture?

Joe: Maybe! We all survived, so that's good. [Editor's note: I can't find a copy of the photo that is still, to this day, hanging above my parents' mantlepiece. Probably for the best. Kinda talked about it HERE though, if you wanna read more about the cruise.]

[Editor's note: three minutes of everyone being distracted by Willow.]

Dad: Don't put any of that in.

Mom: He is going to include you talking about your favorite part.

Dad: What?

Mom: Kate Winslet topless! [laughter]

Joe: Is that still your favorite part of the movie? It's my favorite part of the movie.

Pam: What is your favorite part, though?

Dad: I mean, it's gotta be when they are at the front of the ship going "I'm on top of the world!" right?

Joe: It's actually...

Dad: "I'm on top of the world!"

Joe: Nevermind.

Chris: How about the chef when he's drunk?

Joe: Oh, when the ship's going down?

Chris: Yeah.

Dad: That's pretty cool though, to see the ship going down.

Sarah: The worst part is the old couple in bed together.

Joe: True, that was sad.

Willow: [crying]

Joe: This is the last interview we ever do with Willow present. [Editor's note: I think that's actually true. I believe Martha might've been present for a couple, but was very young and sleeping. The only other one that features Willow is the Your Favorite Movie interview that doesn't count.]

Pam: This is the first interview with Willow!

Joe: And the last, for sure.

Dad: Who wants pizza?

Mom: Bob, did you eat your five slices?

Joe: What would be a good sequel to Titanic?

Mom: A good sequel? I don't think there can be.

Joe: There was! Titanic II!

Pam: What?

Joe: Yeah! It was a Syfy channel original. They built a ship for the 100th anniversary of the H.M.S. Titanic, and it was also unsinkable.

Mom: And it sunk?

Joe: Yeah. A hurricane hit it or something. It was a story about climate change.

Chris: Didn't they just build a ship that is bigger than Titanic?

Joe: It's my understanding that most cruise ships today are bigger than Titanic.

Chris: The United States is big, right? The one on Columbus Boulevard?

Joe: I have no idea. [Editor's note: I still don't, because I don't feel like doing research on ships along the Delaware River. This article mentions a U.S.S. United States, but I don't know if that's still there. This is a very boring subject to me, I'm sorry.]

Chris: You can tour it.

Dad: I thought it was gutted.

Chris: True, it's empty. It's a shame, they... it should go out for scrap.

Mom: [talking on the phone, trying to give my sister Brianna directions to the house]

Chris: I had a lot of books about the Titanic.

Joe: Yeah? You were into it?

Chris: When we went to Vegas, we went to see the display they had. What's the one with the triangle? The hotel with the triangle?

Joe: Oh, the pyramid one. The Luxor?

Chris: It was cool because they had a piece of the ship there.

Joe: Yeah?

Chris: It was as big as this table.

Mom: This is the first time Brianna has ever gotten here before dark.

Willow: [gibberish]

Mom: What do you want? All done your food?

Chris: Mommy wants you to sit there till she's back from the bathroom.

Mom: Is she done food?

Joe: We usually give her a little bit more.

Mom: Aunt Bri Bri is here! She has to stay in this high chair?

[silence]

Joe: Alright... I think...

[turns recorder off]

Tuesday, April 6, 2021

Your Favorite Movie: Almost Famous, with Mandy B.


Welcome back, for possibly the last time (but I feel like I say that every time), to Your Favorite Movie, a semi-regular feature on Puke on Your Birthday in which we turn the proverbial (and literal) microphone to a friend and ask: Yo, what's your favorite movie of all time?

No stranger to silly blog exploits, Mandy B** finally sits down and talks about her own favorite movie. I've known Mandy for a lifetime, and we've certainly had our ups and downs, so I appreciate the fact that we are currently on an up, and were able to have such a good time chilling on her roof deck, drinking beers, and talking shop. Her favorite movie is Almost Famous, a movie about a moppy-headed goofball attempting to get a good interview, which ends up being fitting in more ways than one.

I'll note here that I enjoy Mandy's friendship, and know her pretty well at this point, enough to acknowledge that Mandy can be somewhat of a guarded person sometimes. In that vein, I appreciate that she was so open in this interview, and I hope that by publishing it, I am doing her justice. I also acknowledge that maybe I am not doing her justice, and I say that based on her somewhat uncomfortable reaction to the publishing of this interview's prequel, all the way back in October.

When she finally got around to reading that first blog post, I was asked to trim it down and take out some of what she perceived as sensitive material. I did it without question. But you can also understand that, after that, I was pretty unmotivated to get around to transcribing the main movie interview. It took till this week—a week that I have committed to writing a new entry for every regular feature PoYB has ever started, under any circumstance—to finally get around to it. Even then, it is somewhat truncated; I had to get home, and cut the interview short, and we planned on doing a Part II at some point, but just never got around to it. I'm putting up Part I anyway. I'm hoping this is all okay with everyone involved.

Alright, that's it. Strap in, get drunk, and enjoy reading endless opinions about music, including an absolutely bonkers tangent about the Baha Men.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Mandy: I appreciate you.

Joe: Likewise! I wouldn't be here if I didn't appreciate you.

Mandy: I know I don't have to defend that.

Joe: What's taking you out of your comfort zone? What we're about to talk about, or what we talked about before?

Mandy: I just don't let many people into my world. It's by choice. So me utilizing my amenities, and all of this shit... it's meaningful to me. I don't do it for everyone.

Joe: Well I appreciate it then. I appreciate you being comfortable around me.

Mandy: Let's do this.

Joe: Yeah, I can't think of a segue into Almost Famous from that. You're cool with me recording this? I should've asked.

Mandy: Yes. Also, it is so nice out. For real.

Joe: Feels good in the shade. I personally am really excited to talk to you about this movie in particular, just because of the music aspect of it. I know you were part of the Prestige conversation, and you had expressed the question: Why didn't I give a shit about the music in The Prestige? I really didn't, and I still don't, but at the time I thought: I'm definitely going to give a shit about the music when Mandy picks her favorite movie and we talk about it. And this is a really easy movie to talk about the music. Obviously we're going to talk about the music a lot. Because our relationship is built... not solely upon, but a large chunk of it is built upon sharing opinions about music. I feel like that's a big part of the movie as well, with the characters connecting and sharing their opinions about music in general, and how important it is. Not saying that's what the movie is about...

Mandy: But it kind of is.

Joe: What would you say the movie is about? If you had to give a general one-paragraph statement. What is Almost Famous about? If someone asked you. If S*** S***** asked you.

Mandy: It's about a common person who loves music so much that he feels compelled to let it consume him, and to write about it. Over all the other things that are happening in your life, being able to chunk out a piece of time for music, and in this case, let it be your life. William, in the movie, gives up his graduation, compromises his relationships with his family—which were already splintered—to follow his passion.

Joe: He does it for the music, is what you're saying.

Mandy: Yeah. I mean, he eventually ends up falling in love, but at the end of the day, he really just wants his interview. That's the overarching theme.

Joe: And what's the question he asks? "Why do you like music?" basically.

Mandy: "Do you have to be sad to write a sad song? Do you have to be happy to write a happy song?"

Joe: Do you feel like you have to be sad to listen to a sad song?

Mandy: No, but I do think that sad songs, in their own way, are gluttonous. When I'm sad, I listen to things that make me sadder and sadder. One example I can think of is when I reread my journals from when I was eleven, twelve, thirteen. Those preteen, horrible years, when your hormones are racing through your brain but you don't understand that.

Joe: Sure, sure.

Mandy: I wrote this entry about Dashboard Confessional. It was about listening to their first album—The Places You Have Come to Fear the Most [Editor's note: Technically their second album, but it was a whole complicated label-fuckery thing—Stereogum did a good job last year breaking down what happened]. I remember, I was laying on my bed, listening to it over and over—on a cassette, which is still kind of weird—

Joe: Isn't their big song about listening to a sad song?

Mandy: Um...

Joe: It's like, [attempts to sing] "The saddest songs, the saddest words" and so on? Right? Something like that?

Mandy: [sings] "As for now I'm going to sing, the saddest songs." Yes. It is an album about being sad and making music about being sad. I go back to the word "gluttonous"—it fed into what I was already feeling. I think that, as I matured and listened to music, it wasn't that same need. When you're younger, it's almost like fast food. It's there, it's what you need. But as you mature, if you care about music or invest any time in it—which I feel like I do—

Joe: For sure, and not everyone does.

Mandy: Honestly, music is... if you're ever wondering "what Mandy is thinking about," it's music.

Joe: You're casting yourself as the William character.

Mandy: I am. But it's also like Russell is on the roof, and he's about to jump into the pool, and he's like: "I dig music... I'm on drugs!" And then: "Russell, I think we should rethink your last words!"

Joe: Which is a great bit! But is also definitely something that we should unpack at some point, that scene. There's a lot to unpack. But I'm glad we got off on the foot that I wanted us to get off on, just talking about music in general. I feel like... you can't deny that music is very integral to an appreciation for Almost Famous.

Mandy: Yeah, definitely.

Joe: Actually, I should ask. Can someone who doesn't like classic rock, or any of the music that is played in this movie, could they like Almost Famous?

Mandy: I think so. I think it's the classic underdog story, to an extent. You have William, who, in the beginning of the movie, finds out that he is actually two years younger than he thought. His whole life has been controlled by his mom. It's such a huge move for him to break away from his familial connection, which is something he saw his sister do—who is the person who gave him music—but still try to stay in tune with his mom. He's not saying "I don't love you or respect what you've done," he's saying, "I need to do my own thing." That thing, which is him following a band and writing about it, seems so extreme to his particular world.

Joe: You're saying that people who watch this but who don't necessarily appreciate the Who's Tommy could nevertheless apply their own life's situation to it?

Mandy: Totally.

Joe: Like if someone grew up, I dunno, on a dairy farm, but they really wanted to be a... fruit farmer? They could watch Almost Famous and say, "This is how I'm going to rebel against my parents"?

Mandy: Yeah, but maybe not even "rebel." Just, like, follow your passions, whatever they may be, and still be able to synthesize your life's relationships and your foundational morals, but still go after what you truly feel passionate about. If you really wanna grow raspberries, then go for it. Also, I will have a raspberry seltzer while you're at it. [laughter]

Joe: Spoken as a true dairy farmer.

Mandy: I'm actually kind of dairy-sensitive. I drink almond milk. Fuck oat milk. Actually, can we make that an extreme quote, "Fuck oat milk"?

Joe: I'll put it in bold lettering.

Mandy: It's just not good.

Joe: No, I think you are speaking to the true meaning of this movie, and we have another hour to stutter-step into it. I feel like we should keep talking about music specifically, before we start talking about how this all could apply to the general idea of... I dunno, dealing with your parents and that kind of stuff. I dunno, I think it's important to talk about the music that's featured in the film, and this might serve as a way to shoo away the readers who don't give a shit about this.

Mandy: Because they don't give a shit about what my favorite musical moment in Almost Famous is?

Joe: Right. If a reader doesn't want to read this because we're going to discussing Bob Dylan's Blonde on Blonde because it was on camera for 0.2 seconds, like, I want the reader to see this in minute five as opposed to in minute 45.

Mandy: Word.

Joe: So let's talk about some musical shit in this film. Oh, and I should clarify that we're not going to talk about Stillwater until after all this. Because Stillwater is a fictional band, based on a bunch of bullshit.

Mandy: Interestingly enough, it was completely crafted by Cameron Crowe and his then-wife, who is one of the Wilson sisters.

Joe: Nancy.

Mandy: Yup.

Joe: Married from '86 to '10.

Mandy: They just holed up in a hotel or a cottage or something and wrote, essentially, the entire Stillwater catalogue.

Joe: Which is like five songs.

Mandy: [sings] "Fever dog!"

Joe: You know what, fuck it, let's talk about Stillwater first.
 
Mandy: Okay. You're the interviewer, you're in charge.
 
Joe: There's a difference between what you as the audience of Almost Famous thinks about Stillwater and what you as the prospective 1973 audience member at a Stillwater concert would think of Stillwater. What do you, Mandy B**, think about Stillwater's music?
 
Mandy: Um... I like it. I would go see their concert, for sure. I really like the moment in the movie when William first gets into interacting with the band, and it's just because he's knowledgeable about the music they're making. He's a fan. There's a danger to that. I love Russell. I feel like he's my favorite Stillwater member—I think that's what we're supposed to feel. I think that he has a deeper knowledge of guitar than everyone else. Jason Lee is completely ego-driven.
 
Joe: I can think of at least three things I want to talk about from the past ten seconds, but let's focus on the music itself.
 
Mandy: Okay. It's good.

Joe: Their big song is "Fever Dog."

Mandy: Yeah.

Joe: It's not that good! If you say this is a mediocre song, I'm not going to question your fanboy-ism of Almost Famous or something.

Mandy: I'll say this. First of all, I don't have fanboy-ism about anything. Secondly—

Joe: Well it's your favorite movie of all time!

Mandy: There were other movies, but this is what I've chosen. I dunno. "Fever Dog" is that song you would put on a playlist, trying to represent a band for their totality. Ya know? It's their big hit, but it's still rock 'n' roll.

Joe: Is that because Stillwater is an amalgam of a bunch of bands he followed when he was young?

Mandy: For sure. It's semi-auto-memoir-ish... is that a word?

Joe: It's supposed to be the middle ground between Led Zeppelin and the Allman Brothers, basically.

Mandy: Which, by the way, I don't really get down with the Allman Brothers that much. It's a little too jammy for me.

Joe: That's fair. 

Mandy: I had this moment when I was at McGillin's in like 2014. I was with a bunch of people who were putting shit on the jukebox. The bartender then put on a stretch of Allman Brothers—which are like twenty-minutes songs—I was just like... I hated everything about this.

Joe: Like, the live version of whatever?

Mandy: Yes, all of that.

Joe: "Whipping Pole" or something? No, "Whipping Post"?

Mandy: Yeah. I mean, I guess when you actually make me think about it... Stillwater wasn't the greatest band in the entire world. They're a little jammy. Too jammy for me.

Joe: Fair. I mean a lot of fictional people like them a lot! But that doesn't mean that the real people watching Almost Famous have to like them, in order to appreciate the movie.

Mandy: And I do like that, in the movie, they are constantly referencing actual bands, that were actually making great music at that time. Like Cream. Who does Lester Bangs talk about? The Doors.

Joe: The Doors versus Guess Who.

Mandy: "Give me the Guess Who!"

Joe: That's definitely my intention, to talk about all the real bands, after we talk about Stillwater.

Mandy: Cool.

Joe: Sorry. I hate the beginning of interviews, because I want to talk about so much.

Mandy: That sounds normal.

Joe: Okay, Stillwater. Yes, they reference a lot of other bands. I guess other bands that influenced Nancy Wilson to write these songs about.

Mandy: She also, herself, when you think about where she came from—that's rock 'n' roll royalty. So I think there is a level of elitism about the entire movie. If you think about what Rolling Stone was at that time—which it's not anymore—as a publication, people cared about it a lot. So it's like, whatever band people told you what was the next big band, was the next big band. So Stillwater was that band, at that time.

Joe: So I guess my question would be, is Stillwater supposed to be legitimately popular, in this movie? In the world of this movie?

Mandy: I think it's probably as popular as any band that I think is popular, which is a different set of glasses than other people.

Joe: I mean, on the one hand, they were going to be on the cover of Rolling Stone magazine.

Mandy: They were! But think about who else has been on the cover of Rolling Stone magazine. Especially recently.

Joe: But not in 1973.

Mandy: But Rolling Stone is a monthly publication. There are twelve months in a year. Are there twelve hugely popular bands? Probably not! I don't know. At the end of the day, the important thing is that William was a true fan of this band.

Joe: And Lester Bangs was not.

Mandy: He wasn't!

Joe: He described them as the type of band that was trying to be like every band who was already on their deathbed. Right? All the hard rock... ya know, he was talking about Guess Who, other hard rock bands...

Mandy: Something that equates to this conversation is that—oh god, this is going to get off course—one of my friends, recently—not even my "friend," this musician that I know—named Pat Finnerty—hashtag Pat Finnerty—had this campaign to get Dave Grohl to FaceTime with him.

Joe: During COVID?

Mandy: Yeah, and if you haven't followed this, please do, because it'll bring you so much joy. And Pat is the guy who runs Live Band Karaoke at Fergie's. It's kind of an incredible thing to see. Any song you want, that band can just do it. Performing with a band, if you're not someone who already performs with bands, like if you aren't a musician, that's like a crazy feat. But anyway, he had this campaign to get Dave Grohl to FaceTime with him. And it happened! And he has this amazing conversation with Dave Grohl about rock 'n' roll, and about COVID... I wish I remember where I was going with this point...

Joe: Maybe... meeting your idols is something to be weary of, maybe? Was there any downside to meeting Dave Grohl via Zoom?

Mandy: No. I mean... okay, I actually know where I was going with this. So I had a conversation with my boss at ***** ** about it, about this guy talking with Dave Grohl. When I watched the conversation, I cried—not that that's weird, because I cry all the time—but... [laughter] I was like "I love Dave Grohl!"—

Joe: And this dude was prepared to interview Dave Grohl?

Mandy: Yes. Dude, I strongly encourage you, of all people, to watch it. But anyway, my boss was like, "I don't really like the Foo Fighters, or that kind of popular rock and roll," is how he described it. "It's kind of like sugar," like what I was saying earlier about fast food. Fast Food Rock. And maybe in the movie, if you took the fandom out of it, maybe Stillwater isn't that great of a band? But if you are a fan, if it moves you to that extent, then why does it even matter? And also, I think anyone who is still trying to be a champion of rock 'n' roll, trying to keep it alive, is important. I think that rock 'n' roll is going away. Lester Bangs talked about that, in his 1970s brain. And it's still happening! So has it always been happening? Is it just a bunch of fucking nerds who are always talking about "the death of rock 'n' roll"?

Joe: Right! He calls it "the death rattle," and this is 1973! Fifty years ago!

Mandy: Dude, you're in the prime. So maybe Stillwater falls into that vein? But it doesn't actually matter. I don't think it really matters if they're good or not.

Joe: Doesn't matter to who?

Mandy: The viewer?

Joe: The viewer of Almost Famous.

Mandy: Yeah.

Joe: That's fair. And I don't... I like Almost Famous. I don't give a shit about how "good" Stillwater is or not. I don't think that's the point. I don't think the movie is trying to say they are the best band ever.

Mandy: I don't think they are either. I also think the movie is trying to say that everyone is a human being. Even the players in the band. They're dealing with their own shit. They're dealing with the fact that they are in complication relationships, competing egos among band members. Nothing, at the end of the day, is really about how good the music is.

Joe: It's not important to the people watching Almost Famous.

Mandy: I don't think so.

Joe: I gotchya. Pam brought this up when we were watching it the other night. How rare is it—wait, let me back up. The movie makes the case that Russell is "The Guy" from Stillwater. Nobody's questioning that—though Jason Lee takes offense to it. But no one is questioning that Russell is The Guy. That doesn't really come across—to me, anyway—why Russell is The Guy in this band. That might not even be my question. My question is, has that ever happened in history? Can you think of a band that everyone in the audience is like "That guitarist who doesn't sing, he's the one who's going to make it, and this Jason Lee-type frontman character, he's just a schmo"?

Mandy: Maybe not to that extent. But when I watch the movie, I often equate Russell to, like, George Harrison.

Joe: Okay.

Mandy: Traditionally, the quiet Beatle. But if you look at what he actually contributed to their entire catalogue, and what he did as a solo artist... everyone is like, "Yeah, Lennon and McCartney, they're the songsters!" But to me, the musician who always stuck out was George. I think there is an element to that with Stillwater and Russell. The difference between someone who is playing music because it's really all they know how to do, and it's all they love, versus someone who has an ego built into it, or showmanship. Ya know? So that might be the case with Russell. That might be the thing that stuck out to William and Russell.

Joe: Maybe? I guess I kind of felt the opposite. So you're saying that Russell would be in the position where everybody was saying like—hold up, what the fuck is Jason Lee's character's name? I'm tired of calling him "Jason Lee."

Mandy: Let's just keep calling him "Jason Lee."

Joe: Okay.

Mandy: I feel like he is Jason Lee, in the movie.

Joe: Earl, let's call him Earl.

Mandy: No! He's Jason Lee.

Joe: If it was a Beatles-type situation, then everyone in the audience would be assuming that Jason Lee is the heart and soul of this band, but then later on, after Stillwater, you realize that Russell is The Guy. Which is not the case in Almost Famous!

Mandy: I don't necessarily think that the fans in Almost Famous think that Russell was The Guy.

Joe: But the movie makes it clear that Russell is The Guy.

Mandy: Yeah, the people who know. People who get it. William. Penny. 

Joe: So you're saying that there was a prostitute hanging out backstage at the Beatles concerts saying "George Harrison is the man."

Mandy: ...Probably! But also she's not a prostitute. She's not getting paid.

Joe: Okay. Let's talk about Penny Lane. And then we will definitely transition over to talking about music as it exists in the real world! Because I really want to talk to you about that. How do you feel about how the character of Penny Lane holds up?

Mandy: As I've rewatched it... it makes me sadder and sadder, because her aura, everything she's portraying—her confidence, her idea that we're gonna reform groupies, all this stuff—is really important.

Joe: It's good-intentioned.

Mandy: And, at the end of the day, she's just a sad girl. She's a sad girl who fell in love with music, who found so much solace in it, but always wanted to get away. Almost knowing that the place she was in wasn't her full potential, and wanting to literally go to Morocco, which she says over and over. And, in my most recent rewatch of the movie, something I always discount—both she and William are children! They're not adults. So it's like, children who want to be adults, putting themselves in an adult world, there is underlying sadness in there.

Joe: Sure.

Mandy: And the most striking musical moment of the entire movie—which is a movie about music—is when she takes the quaaludes, and "Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters" is on. That's always the musical moment I take from the film.
 


Joe: This is the moment that William realizes that he is in love with Penny Lane.

Mandy: I think he always knew he did. But he's in the hotel room, and ends up kisses her—boldly going where many men have gone before.

Joe: Kissing a half-catatonic woman?

Mandy: As they are pumping her stomach.

Joe: Yes!

Mandy: When you take all the fanciness and pageantry and movie-ness of that moment, it's actually really sad. You have to wonder what lead this girl—because she's a girl, she says she's seventeen or sixteen—to be around these grown men who don't respect her, and end up selling her for a fucking case of beer? So in terms of it "holding up," I think it does. I think that's a huge reality of women who involve themselves in a band's life, or become "band-aids" or "groupies" or whatever. But there's a lot of sadness! I think there's a lot of sadness throughout this entire movie.

Joe: Do you feel like—sticking with the Penny Lane aspect of it—obviously, by the end of the movie, she realizes that she was being used. But I thought it was interesting that for most of the movie, she made a point of saying that she felt "empowered" by the position that she was in.

Mandy: She "revolutionized being a groupie." Her words.

Joe: Was she still the victim of predatory behavior by musical artists?

Mandy: Absolutely. Of course she was. That's not a novel idea or situation in what was happening in those times.

Joe: And it's still happening today!

Mandy: It does. It happens in all different ways.
 
Joe: Even in music specifically.
 
Mandy: Something that has been tough for me is, for example, the lead singer of Brand New. He was clearly using his influence to have these young—and by "young," I mean teenager women—do what he wanted.
 
Joe: I'll definitely put an editor's note here linking to Brand New and those stories. [Editor's note: You can start here I guess, but yeah, don't listen to Brand New.] But I guess I want to pivot real quick, only because I want to get all this in before I have to fucking get out of here...
 
Mandy: What time do you have to get out of here?

Joe: Like four at the latest. What time is it now? Three o'clock? Okay. What... so in that vein, is it irony that fucking Mark Kozelek is the fucking bassist? Are you familiar with him as a musical artist?

Mandy: Not really. I tried to do some research prior to this, because I knew you were going to ask me about this, but I didn't get that detail.

Joe: [laughter] You knew I was going to ask about Mark Kozelek?

Mandy: Yes, I knew it was going to go down this road.

Joe: So, he has dozens and dozens of albums. His most critically acclaimed albums are under the name Sun Kil Moon.

Mandy: Oh yeah, I actually saw him one time.

Joe: Did you really? What year?

Mandy: Damn... 2016? '17?

Joe: I only ask because I was curious if it was during the time period when he was constantly talking on stage about how much he hated the War on Drugs.

Mandy: Yeah, it was at XPN Fest, and he was a fucking piece of shit. Wait, he is the bassist in this?

Joe: Yes, he plays the bassist in Stillwater. He was the one who wakes up from a stupor on the tour bus because a high school girls track team is running past!

Mandy: And Penny does her whole thing.

Joe: Sure, Penny and Billy pull focus from the fact that fucking Mark Kozelek, a known real-life sexual abuser, is the character who does this. [Editor's note: After I transcribed this interview, an additional seven women spoke out about sexual abuse at the hands of Kozelek.]

Mandy: I dunno, I feel like people's flaws are never really that deeply under the surface. So it's like, there is—to answer your question—irony in that. It's like if you listen to early Louis C.K. comedy routines—

Joe: Does he talk about jerking off on people?!

Mandy: Yeah! Damn... maybe it's too much... but he talks about seeing his daughter's vagina. Like, "Oh, that's a vagina." Like, how is this a thing? And then you think about what he's really done. I don't think the director or producers of Almost Famous had any inclination that—
 
Joe: Well, it's Cameron Crowe's script. Did he direct this? He wrote it.

Mandy: Yes, he directed it.

Joe: And it was the year 2000.

Mandy: His only Academy Award. For scriptwriting. Which is a whole different topic.

Joe: What, Cameron Crowe, or scriptwriting?

Mandy: Scriptwriting. I mean, my favorite category of the Oscars is Best Original Screenplay.

Joe: Okay, you clearly have something to say about this. Go for it.

Mandy: I don't know if I have much to say about it. I just think it's the most prestigious award. You are the person who made this idea. 

Joe: Original Screenplay.

Mandy: Adapted Screenplay is kind of impressive too, especially when you look at what works have been adapted. But, like, to have a completely original idea, and to write it, and to make it a real moving picture, I think is very impressive.

Joe: But you're saying the most impressive.

Mandy: Yeah.

Joe: More so than Best Movie?

Mandy: Yeah.

Joe: Okay.

Mandy: Because Best Movie puts a lot of other variables into it. But if you are the person who crafted an original idea, and made it a script—and I think scriptwriting itself is very impressive. As a writer I'm sure you understand. I love that about this movie.

Joe: That it's about a writer?

Mandy: It's about a writer, and it's about a writer who memorialized his work, but also made it entertaining enough for us to like. Not everything that happens in the movie was true in his life. But he was able to encapsulate his experiences enough to...

Joe: Win an Oscar for it?

Mandy: Yeah. And it was the only award that it won, so when you think about that... I mean, Kate Hudson was nominated as well.

Joe: Alright, yeah, we can talk about the Oscars. You're right—Kate Hudson, and also Frances McDormand were both nominated.

Mandy: I love Frances.

Joe: They both give really good performances. I don't... I mean, obviously they are really good actresses, but—

Mandy: I think Frances stands apart.

Joe: Yeah? From Kate Hudson?

Mandy: Absolutely.

Joe: I don't know if I agree with that.

Mandy: Really? It's a lot easier to be Penny Lane than to be William's mom.

Joe: Fair, but I also think that Penny Lane is also the role that could more easily slip into parody, and Kate Hudson doesn't let that happen. And Frances McDormand kind of does! A little bit. During the whole "rock stars have kidnapped my son!" thing. I know that's more of a script thing than an actress thing, but...

Mandy: I love her phone calls in the film.

Joe: For sure. They're both great.

Mandy: "Tell him I know what's going on!"

Joe: They're both worthy of nominations. Do you feel like either should have won over Marcia Gay Harden in Pollock? I'm obviously reading from my notes here.

Mandy: I really enjoyed that film also.

Joe: Did you really?

Mandy: Yeah. That's what's his fucking name...

Joe: Ed Harris.

Mandy: I love Ed Harris. I think he's a national treasure.

Joe: But if we're talking about Best Supporting Actress—

Mandy: Who else was up that year?

Joe: I don't know the other two.

Mandy: I guess you didn't do that much research then. [Editor's note: Okay, fine, it was Judi Dench in Chocolat and Julie Walters in Billy Elliot.]

Joe: I'm only writing what's relevant! I don't think it was anyone from Gladiator, a former Your Favorite Movie interview.

Mandy: I love that movie.

Joe: Did it lose...? Okay, it beat Gladiator in Best Screenplay.

Mandy: That makes sense though. If you look at two scripts as they are, if you were handed two scripts, and one was Almost Famous and one was Gladiator, obviously there's... and that kind of goes back to my original point. Gladiator was the Best Movie not just because of the script, but because of everything that went into it. Although... I love Joaquin Phoenix so much. Favorite actor.

Joe: I guess that would be a question: Should Billy Cruddup have been nominated for Best Supporting Actor?

Mandy: I don't think so. I don't think any of the men in this movie did the job that the women did at all.

Joe: No? I would put him in the same circle as Frances McDormand and Kate Hudson.

Mandy: I mean, he... again, we're talking about the "quiet Beatle" way about him. What else has he been in?

Joe: Well, he just won an Emmy for fucking... The Morning Show or whatever. With the other jabronis. Steve Carell.

Mandy: Reese Witherspoon?

Joe: And Jennifer Anniston.

Mandy: Okay. I think I started watching that? I don't know. I don't like watching TV shows.

Joe: Well we're talking about movies right now!

Mandy: Ask me another question about the movie.

Joe: Should it have lost Film Editing to Traffic?

Mandy: Um... yeah, sure. [laughter] Traffic was a greatly edited film.

Joe: Never saw Traffic. I'm sure it's on my list. Okay, here's a more important thing: Should it have been nominated for a Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Award?

Mandy: ...Yeah.

Joe: Right? You wanna know the nominees for the 2001 Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards?

Mandy: Yes.

Joe: And you tell me which of these movies are better than Almost Famous. [laughter]

Mandy: Okay. I probably know all of them.

Joe: Um... Dr. Seuss's The Grinch Stole Christmas.

Mandy: With Jim Carrey?

Joe: Yes.

Mandy: Quality film. Not better than Almost Famous. But—

Joe: Big Momma's House?

Mandy: Also quality film, but not—

Joe: Charlie's Angels?

Mandy: [mumbling] Oh god. Definitely hard no there.

Joe: The Nutty Professor 2: The Klumps?!

Mandy: Was this really 20 years ago? Are you kidding me? I mean, more power to that franchise. It's hilarious it made so much money, but... definitely not better than Almost Famous.

Joe: Do you feel like Stillwater should have been nominated for Best Band at the Kids' Choice Awards?

Mandy: Who was nominated?

Joe: Blink-182.

Mandy: Alright, they obviously won, right?

Joe: Yes.

Mandy: They did?!

Joe: Yes. Against Creed, Dixie Chicks—sorry, they are now known as the Chicks—and the Red Hot Chili Peppers.

Mandy: Blink-182 is definitely the winner over Stillwater and all those other bands.

Joe: I agree. Do you feel like "Fever Dog" should have won Best Song? [laughter]

Mandy: What else was nominated? [laughter]

Joe: I'm just lobbing softballs here. Okay, so I'll name the three losers first, and then I'll name the winner, and then we'll name the winner. Okay. "Oops!... I Did It Again" by Britney Spears.

Mandy: Quality song.

Joe: "Bye Bye Bye" by *NSYNC.

Mandy: Also an amazing song.

Joe: "Bounce with Me" by the artist formerly known as Lil' Bow Wow.

Mandy: [laughter] I don't even remember that song. I'm trying to.

Joe: And the winner—the immortal "Who Let the Dogs Out." Baha Men. You know what, it's really interesting that "Who Let the Dogs Out" beat "Fever Dog."

Mandy: Do you... You don't even know the story I have to this song.

Joe: "Who Let the Dogs Out"?

Mandy: Yeah.

Joe: ...Can you relate it to "Fever Dog" in some way?

Mandy: I don't know. Maybe.

Joe: Go for it.

Mandy: I... I don't know, maybe we have to take this out.

Joe: I won't take this out. Unless you're requesting me to take it out?

Mandy: I might. I'm going to say it, and then I'll tell you.

Joe: Okay. But let's not waste our time if you're going to tell me to take it out. Let's keep it in. We're keeping it in, c'mon. What, did you have sex with a Baha Man?

Mandy: I wish, but no. I actually don't wish. But no, okay. So I'm telling this story in a way that is meant to be very respectful.

Joe: Okay.

Mandy: Fuck. When I worked at [redacted]—obviously I was working the [redacted] unit... dude, this story out loud doesn't sound great. I also think it's a good story to tell, because I think that there's nuance. But, I was working in the [redacted] unit. My colleagues were trying homicide cases, and I was alongside them. And when someone would get a guilty first-degree murder verdict—which was a necessary and justifiable thing that happens, based on law, and the flawed law of life imprisonment—if you secure a first-degree murder conviction, when they come back to the office, we would play "Who Let the Dogs Out." And not even... it was so not even about the individuals who were in question. It was just kind of a thing that we did. And looking back on it, I don't feel great about it. But it was something that we did.

Joe: The dogs being the criminals?

Mandy: Well, obviously not, because the people we were convicting were not getting out of jail.

Joe: Right, sorry. I'm a little drunk, and I'm trying to follow.

Mandy: If someone got a first-degree conviction, we would play that song sometimes. No, every time. We played that song. And it was just a team-building thing. I don't think anyone was even thinking about the meaning behind the thing.

Joe: Because of the purpose of your department was to convict? And they were not being convicted?

Mandy: The purpose of our department was to convict people of murder. And if someone was successful and got a first-degree murder conviction, we would play "Who Let the Dogs Out."

Joe: Wait, sorry, this is why I'm asking additional questions. If you are getting the conviction that you want, why are the dogs being "let out"?

Mandy: That's what I'm saying. I personally wasn't calling anyone a dog. There wasn't really that meaning behind it. It just became ritualistic.

Joe: "Who Let the Dogs Out" was a celebratory song.

Mandy: Yeah.

Joe: Not noting the irony that...

Mandy: Not that personally, I was. I don't know. When I look back on it.

Joe: Well, okay. Even if you ignore the obvious—

Mandy: The obvious issues with what's going on?

Joe: No, the—

Mandy: The racism?

Joe: Okay, let's put aside for one second the obvious racist dogwhistle of people who are not you and are not me who would call black people "dogs"... they are letting people out in the song, but you're celebrating locking someone in.

Mandy: I don't think that anyone... no, I know that no one was celebrating that anyone's life was going to be spent behind bars for the rest of their life. What you're celebrating is... justice being served. Because I personally think that Pennsylvania state law, that mandates that if you are convicted of first-degree murder, you have an immediate life sentence—that's in the policy of the law—is wrong. And my literal first day ever at the [redacted] office, when I was being trained, that, okay, "You have to explain to this victim's family that if the person who killed their loved one is convicted of first-degree murder, they will get life in prison." No matter what. It doesn't matter what the circumstances were. If, by the letter of the law, you committed an act that was first-degree murder, you will now go to prison for the rest of your life. I was like, wait what? What do you mean? It doesn't make sense. It's not black-and-white like that. That's the law.

Joe: But I'm not questioning the law. I'm questioning the connection between the law—i.e. the fact that people are going to prison for their rest of their lives—and a song that is talking about beings that are getting "out."

Mandy: I don't know. And I can't even believe I'm saying this on record, but it was something that always felt weird in my head. Not even weird, it felt like "we're playing with irony"—

Joe: But I don't even see the irony in it.

Mandy: Why not?

Joe: Are you saying that people in the [redacted] office played it because they considered people "dogs"? And they wanted them "in"? And they were playing a song about them getting "out"? I'm saying I don't see the connection at all.

Mandy: I honestly, if I looked at the root of how it happened, I couldn't tell you. I was there. I don't know. It was one of those moral ambiguities that I've struggled with since leaving. But it was always more like... I don't know. 

Joe: Well, look, if the [redacted] office considered—

Mandy: No one did though.

Joe: Hold on! If the [redacted] office considered getting a first-degree murder charge a victory—

Mandy: It was, though, Joe. It is. It is. It is. It is. That's literally what the goal was.

Joe: No, I get it! I'm saying if that was the goal—and I'm realizing now that I'm definitely not taking this conversation as seriously as you are, currently—I'm saying that if the goal was to get somebody locked up—and there are very many violent criminals who deserved to be locked up for life—and if the [redacted] office did that, then great. Thumbs up. But I'm saying that if, in the situation where that happens justifiably, then how does the song "Who Let the Dogs Out" connect to that feeling?

Mandy: Maybe it doesn't. Maybe it's just a non-sequitur. Maybe it was just the best fucking song and won the fucking Nickelodeon fucking song of the year?!

Joe: [laughter] This all definitely feels like a non-sequitur.

Mandy: It was.

Joe: And I'm sorry. We shouldn't have taken it down this road, because I am so confused. So confused about all this. And I feel like I'm definitely going to cut it out of the Almost Famous interview...?

Mandy: You can if you want. It's just something maybe I—

Joe: Yeah, no no. And I apologize if I'm not taking this as seriously as I should. I just don't understand what you're trying to say with all this.

Mandy: I mean, you don't have to take it seriously because you weren't there.

Joe: I mean, we're talking about... [sigh, then laughter] We're talking about the Baha Men!

Mandy: The fucking Baha Men! And I happen to have a very strong connection to their song!

Joe: Oh my goodness.

Mandy: Do you know who you're talking to?

Joe: Ah, jesus.

Mandy: Do you want me to go deep on some other songs? Because I'll do that too.

Joe: No! I'll talk to you more about the Baha Men after the recording is over. But let's use this as an opportunity to segue into talking about actual, real music. Actually talk about it without talking about... the [redacted] office.

Mandy: It's fine, it's fine. It's kind of a little bit more at the forefront right now.

Joe: I understand, due to the circumstances... I mean, are you able to tie this into Almost Famous?

Mandy: Always. I just feel like... nevermind. Go ahead.

Joe: Is it fucked up if I transition into lighter subjects?

Mandy: It's fine. It's not that deep.

Joe: Let's talk about real music. Let's talk about the music that William discovers in the movie. And let's talk about how that compares to your opinion of that music in this movie.

Mandy: Okay.

Joe: Do you feel like if you burned a candle and listened to Tommy, you'd see your entire life?

Mandy: [laughter] Um... not personally.

Joe: Have you ever tried?

Mandy: [sigh] I've listened to the album. I've never lit a candle for it... okay, maybe I have. But not for that purpose. Tommy isn't my favorite. I think that I have a little bit of a handicap when it relates to classic rock.

Joe: That's important to know, if we're talking about this type of music, because there is a lot of classic rock talked about in this movie. So should we go through the nine albums that Zooey Deschanel gave William, and you can tell me which albums—
 
Mandy: Rank them?
 
Joe: You can rank them if you know all nine. Or you can tell me which albums you like, which albums you don't like, whatever.
 
Mandy: Go for it.
 
Joe: Bob Dylan's Blonde on Blonde, Jimi Hendrix's Axis: Bold Is Love, the Rolling Stones' live album Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out—

Mandy: I love that album.

Joe: Yeah? Am I going to have to attach the Puke on Your Birthday tag "Charlie Watts Sucks Ass" to this blog post?

Mandy: Probably.

Joe: Because he sucks ass.

Mandy: I also don't really like Bob Dylan that much.
 
Joe: I'd be happy to talk about Blonde on Blonde before we finish the rest of this list.
 
Mandy: Go ahead.
 
Joe: Pet Sounds.
 
Mandy: Love Pet Sounds. Huge album in my life.
 
Joe: Joni Mitchell's Blue.
 
Mandy: Love Blue. Hashtag [???].
 
Joe: Sweet Baby James. Led Zeppelin II. Wheel of Fire. Talk about anything you wanna talk about on that list. You were about to say something about Blonde on Blonde. Go for it.
 
Mandy: I mean, I don't have a lot of opinions about Blonde on Blonde. I have always found Dylan to be way too pretentious for me to relate to.

Joe: That's fair.

Mandy: And I'm someone who loves the War on Drugs, loves Bruce Springsteen unabashedly.

Joe: I guess Bruce would be getting some... Bruce was inspired at one point by Bob Dylan. The War on Drugs were certainly inspired by Bruce Springsteen. So you talk about the lineage of Bob Dylan—

Mandy: Yeah. I saw Bob Dylan perform one time.

Joe: Where at?

Mandy: It was in Brooklyn somewhere. I couldn't even tell you.

Joe: Me and Drew P***** saw him in Reading, PA. '07 maybe?

Mandy: Where was I... what's the place that has the [Editor's note: I have no idea what Mandy says here, and I can't even guess because I don't know Brooklyn]. Whatever. I just... He played with his back to the audience. The whole time!

Joe: No doubt. He's a shitty performer!

Mandy: I was like, "I came to Brooklyn to see Bob Dylan and you're playing with your back to me?"

Joe: To be fair, Billy doesn't really... he doesn't mention by Bob Dylan, there are no indications that he is influence or affected by Blonde on Blonde at all. We can probably push that to the side. Out of those nine, what do you think Billy is most influenced by? Out of those albums.

Mandy: Damn. Probably Led Zeppelin?

Joe: For sure. If he's that big of a fan of Stillwater as they exist in 1973, apparently—they are Led Zeppelin II incarnate. For sure.

Mandy: One thing I do appreciate about Led Zeppelin, even though I'm not a mega-fan by any stretch—I think you are, right?

Joe: I'm not like fucking Jay Baruchel in the film. "Oh, here's the dildo that John Bonham jerked off on!" No, I'm not a superfan like that.

Mandy: I just think they did contribute a bridge in music—


Mandy: —between traditional rock 'n' roll, like the literal "one-two step" of rock 'n' roll, there was a bridge from that to punk, which is, in my opinion, the most important thing that happened to rock 'n' roll. Because you had actual people making songs that were about issues, versus creating a cookie-cutter one-two step.

Joe: You're saying that Led Zeppelin did the cookie-cutter stuff?

Mandy: I think that they were the bridge between the cookie-cutter and the punk. Because it got so hard, guitars were ugly and dirty at times, and that set the stage for rock to be ugly and dirty. And I don't even like them that much. But I see that. There are other bands I think that did that.

Joe: Like the first band you hear in the movie.

Mandy: Yeah.

Joe: Alvin and the Chipmunks.

Mandy: Yeah... wait, no! No no no no no. But I do love that that song is in there.
 


Joe: Where do Alvin and the Chipmunks stand in the hard rock canon?

Mandy: I don't know, but I think that that song is iconic, and I listen to it once a year at Christmastime, and I'm always really happy about it, and then I never want to hear it again.
 
Joe: You listen to it because of Almost Famous?
 
Mandy: No, I listened to it before. My dad, who is the person who taught me to love rock 'n' roll, because he loved it so much. He didn't really even tell me he loved it, but it was played so frequently. And also, different types of rock, in the '80s and '90s, feminine-based, even the Wilson sisters' projects. My parents quietly taught me to love music. My dad, in his elder years, has learned to play the keyboards, which is a beautiful thing to see.
 
Joe: That's pretty cool.
 
Mandy: But, that's where I heard Alvin and the Chipmunks once a year.
 
Joe: That's the first song your dad learned on the piano. 

Mandy: No. He learned "Chopsticks," probably.

Joe: Do you agree with Lester Bangs when he said "Jim Morrison was a drunk posing as a poet"?

Mandy: Um... I like the Doors, but they kind of fall in that category of "fast food rock," ya know? They weren't saying a lot, and I think they were using the scene just to be gluttonous. Can you name a single Doors song that changed your life, or was meaningful?

Joe: No, but that's unfair, because for 99.9% of rock bands, I can't name a song that has "changed my life." I mean, "Light My Fire," it didn't change my life, but I could talk about it. I could talk about how the radio edit cut out a really important guitar solo, right?

Mandy: Or the fact that the radio edit was a really popular commercial, right? [singing] "Stronger than dirt!" Right? There was a radio edit because it was used as a commercial for some type of cleaner.

Joe: Recently?

Mandy: No, 20 years ago. [Editor's note: No idea what Mandy is talking about here. Apparently there was a Buick commercial that used a Doors song. I can't find any other commercials. Let me get back to this at some point.]

Joe: Okay, but not... when Lester Bangs called him a drunken buffoon.

Mandy: I don't know. I think Jim Morrison will always live in infamy because he died young. He's in the 27 Club. Artists who die young are only ever judged by the very slim body of work that they put out in their 27 years, including Jimi Hendrix—an artist that you named on that list—which I feel like, out of every album you named, I would love to see Jimi Hendrix perform that album.
 
Joe: Axis: Bold as Love.

Mandy: I feel like if I was in that era of rock 'n' roll, that would be incredible. But like anything else—he had 27 years. We're both 32, basically. We're five years older than him. It's such a short lifespan. Amy Winehouse. It's like... I dunno. I like the Doors, but I don't think that they're the best that was.

Joe: That's fair. How about, do you think Lou Reed shouldn't try to be like Bowie, he should try to be like himself? I'm quoting William here.

Mandy: Honestly, I never really got that much into Lou Reed—

Joe: How about we say William's full of shit!

Mandy: —But I do love the Velvet Underground. I don't know. I think that Bowie is in a fucking league of his own.

Joe: So if someone is being accused of "trying to be like Bowie"...

Mandy: Everyone was trying to be like Bowie at that time.

Joe: Alright, so William's full of shit then!

Mandy: Of course he was! He's just a starry-eyed sixteen-year-old.

Joe: He was just sucking up to Lester Bangs!

Mandy: Or he was a starry-eyed sixteen-year-old who didn't fucking know anything.

Joe: He had to know something.

Mandy: He recognized that Lou Reed was doing something different than he was doing previously, and that goes to show you that he had a keener understanding of how music works than someone else.

Joe: ...It seems like he was just trying to suck up to Lester Bangs to me.

Mandy: Maybe! Also, I feel like we would be negligent to not mention Phillip Seymour Hoffman.

Joe: Who was very good in this role. Are you familiar with Lester Bangs the person? Okay, wait, sorry, I don't mean to blow off Phillip Seymour Hoffman. I don't have much to say besides jerking off about how good of an actor he is.

Mandy: What's this about jerking off?

Joe: Figuratively.

Mandy: He's an incredibly actor.

Joe: Definitely. But can we add anything to this besides "He is good"?

Mandy: No. I don't know much about Lester Bangs the person.

Joe: I didn't either. I didn't even know if he was alive or dead or what. I looked it up this morning.

Mandy: He's dead, right?

Joe: He died in the '80s. He died when he was 33.

Mandy: He died young.

Joe: He died pretty for the same reasons that Phillip Seymour Hoffman died—overdosing.

Mandy: He says in the movie—one of my favorite quotes in the entire movie—he's talking about drinking cough syrup and staying up all night: "I'll write just to fucking write."

Joe: So the writing was on the wall, basically.

Mandy: Yeah, but it's maybe that's something we should've talked more about—the movie is about writing. It's about writing about music. It's about people who dedicate their entire lives to writing. Obviously, that's something that both you and I—

Joe: You are speaking to someone who is known to write about music.

Mandy: I've never written about music, just kidding.

Joe: I mean, I'll link to one two three articles that Mandy wrote on Puke on Your Birthday about music.

Mandy: I am an award-winning music journalist! [laughter]

Joe: I know you chuckled, but talk about that.

Mandy: When I was in college, I won a Pennsylvania Newspaper Association Award for writing about Jenny Lewis, and spent a large part of my life thinking and wanting to be a music journalist.

Joe: What do you think the difference between what you have done in your life, and what Billy does in the movie? Is there a difference? Or do you feel like there is a direct comparison?

Mandy: Do you mean "William"?

Joe: Yes.

Mandy: No, I think there is definitely a direct comparison. I have had experiences in my life when I was interviewing bands. Artists that I respected. Or, not even interviewing them, but spending time with them, trying to understand how they created their art. If anything, this movie pushed me toward that. It came out in 2000. I remember when it was a huge Oscar movie. My dad loved it, and he made me watch it. I didn't see it in theaters, but I saw it quickly thereafter. When I was in my late-teens and early-20s, I wanted to be a music journalist. I think the movie made me think that was attainable. I also watched a lot of Cameron Crowe movies after that, which includes terrible movies such as Elizabethtown. It seemed like an attainable thing! That was something about the spirit of the movie, that it charged people.

Joe: Do you, in 2020, think that writing about music is an attainable career?

Mandy: Definitely. I think that if I woke up tomorrow, and said that I would be a music journalist, then I would probably be one. And be very successful. That's just my mindset about all the things I do. I dunno. I also just think that I'm very good at writing, but music journalism, and journalism as an art, isn't what it was. Even in the vein of this movie.

Joe: Why?

Mandy: If you look at major news sources, if you look at any journalism in the mainstream sense, the integrity of the craft is gone. There is less of a pull towards factual reporting, versus skewing. That's on both sides of the political spectrum—which isn't what we're talking about, but it is important to note, because music journalism isn't news. It's review. But the field of journalism is dead. People don't want to read anything that's beyond 100 words, something that's quick and easy.

Joe: You're talking about people in general. Because I want to read things that are over 100 words.

Mandy: You do because you're special. You do that because you're smart. The people in this movie are smart, and special. Most people don't! Most people don't have that... I don't even know.

Joe: I don't even know if you could say most people. But maybe. Over 50%.

Mandy: Do you think if you polled 50 people and were like "Hey, here's a news blip, I'm gonna send you a headline," that they would read the whole thing? Every single word?

Joe: Probably not.

Mandy: You're right.

Joe: But was that the case... okay, so now you're starting to sound like fucking William's mom. In that—

Mandy: Is this your segue to talking about his mom?

Joe: Not necessarily. Like, okay, so she's saying that her daughter likes fucking Simon & Garfunkel, likes the song "America," and she's immediately blowing it off because she doesn't understand it, she doesn't know it, she doesn't give a fuck. And you're saying that most people in America, right now, feel that same way about music, music that me and you might care about.

Mandy: Yeah, I do think that.

Joe: But what percentage of people would you consider significant for people who give a shit about the same music as me and you? 5%? 1%? 0.1%? If 0.1% of America gives a shit that, like, Julien Baker is coming out with an album in February—

Mandy: Is that true?

Joe: Yes. Shouldn't that matter to us? We can definitely compare it, how it is now to how it was in the '70s. Where the Cameron Crowe stand-in was given a thousand dollars, in 1973 money, to hang out with a band and write about them, like, good for him. I know that it's not like that now. But the fact that the Cameron Crowe stand-in appreciated these bands to the extent that he did—enough to write a movie about it, obviously—versus how much we give a shit about bands, and would like write about it and care about it that much... I dunno.

Mandy: Like anything else, I think that it's an insular world.

Joe: Rock music?

Mandy: Yeah. I don't think that's ever changed.

Joe: You're the Lester Bangs saying "We're the losers! Staying home listening to shit!"

Mandy: Totally.

Joe: Absolutely.

Mandy: But I'm cool with it. I wouldn't have it any other way.

Joe: Do you feel like you personally relate more to Penny Lane or Lester Bangs?

Mandy: I was anticipating you asking me this—

Joe: That question specifically?

Mandy: I thought that William will be involved too, but—

Joe: Nah, too easy.

Mandy: Lester or Penny? Definitely Penny.

Joe: Yeah?

Mandy: Yeah. I mean, I have, from my experiences, lived a life where... oh god, how do things ever just stay shallow? But I see how men treat women. I've been treated by men like that.

Joe: In situations like hers?

Mandy: Men in music, you mean?

Joe: Low- to mid-tier rock bands?

Mandy: I have met some pretty famous musicians, and have hung out with them—

Joe: But no, that's you speaking as a William. I'm asking you as a Penny. Have you been in a Penny-type situation?

Mandy: I think I've been in a Penny situation emotionally, many times. But, I don't think it directly relates to music. I think maybe all women, at times, are a Penny. You can be so deeply in love with someone, and so dedicated to them, and as a man, they are never going to mirror that back to you. They are incapable.

Joe: You're talking about romance in general.

Mandy: Yeah, I am.

Joe: But I don't think Penny Lane thought about it that way.

Mandy: She didn't. She was in love with Russell. I think the bigger takeaway, if I'm relating myself to Penny, versus Lester... I dunno, that idea that you are using music as a way to comfort yourself. She says, "If you get lonely, you go to the record store, and you listen to your friends." That, to me, is why I would always relate to Penny. The music, the people who are making the music, have always been... it's always been about how it's making me feel, and thinking that those people, or that music, as an actual part of my life, versus these people who are disconnected from me. Even—to bring it home—Bob Mould, who I started listening to in quarantine. He was a person who comforted me. On paper, this gay white dude is not representative of who I am, but he made me feel things that I hadn't felt in a long time. In Almost Famous, Penny is going after Stillwater because, even if Russell isn't the greatest musician of all time, and Jason Lee isn't the best frontman, that's something that made her feel something. That's something that made William feel something. And that's why I can relate mostly with her. I feel a deeper emotional connection than someone like Lester, who's like, "I'm gonna comment on this from a cut-and-paste..." I dunno.

Joe: I feel like saying that about Penny Lane is discounting the fact that she is also both sexually attracted to these men that we are talking about, and also considered a sexual object by these men. There's a difference between Penny Lane being intimately wrapped up in Stillwater's story, and someone like me or you who can say "this is a good band, this is a bad band." We can know their story or not know their story, but we're not part of their story.

Mandy: I think that if you look at any successful anything that's built by men—a band or a business or anything else—there are women who are in love with the men who are in charge, probably having sex with them, and it's probably keeping those men going, and does contribute to what's happening, because we're all utilizing each other in the way humans utilize each other. And so, as a woman, I will always relate to Penny, because I am also a woman. There's... there's just that.

Joe: Have you ever felt like Penny Lane in that specific way that we're talking about?

Mandy: With a band? No. Definitely not with a band. In businesses? Definitely. It's kind of my m.o.

Joe: Feel free to say if you want to cut this, but what about Jukebox the Ghost?

Mandy: ... [laughter] Oh my god. You don't have to cut this—

Joe: Thank you.

Mandy: —but I feel like, in that scenario, it was way more just being attracted to someone because they are famous. You know what I mean?

Joe: But how do you feel the Jukebox the Ghost person felt about you, who was the fan?

Mandy: He literally... I think he genuinely appreciated that I was a fan of his music, and that I spent my time going to see his band perform. I think there's an appreciation. I don't think it goes beyond that. Even at the time, I didn't think that. Maybe that's a difference between me and Penny, who was like "This is real." That's a huge theme of the movie—differentiating between the "real world" and the "fake world."

Joe: She does say, a bunch of times, "It's all happening." Is that what she meant by that? That she's acknowledging what the "real world" is?

Mandy: No, I think "it's all happening" is... I, at times, say "it's all happening" in my actual life. I think that she's talking about "following the signs." We can get really deep into this, but she just followed what made the most sense. She wanted so badly to be a part of this band. She manifested herself into that circle. She was—for the whole movie—trying to manifest herself to Morocco. She saw something and she just said it enough that it actually happened. In the movie, again, she's a fucking sixteen- or seventeen-year-old. But in terms of myself personally, that is how I've lived my entire life. I just said something enough that it actually happened. Sometimes it doesn't, but a lot of the time it does. So it's really just being able to call something as it is, say it out loud, and let things happen. Ya know? And for her, I mean, she ended up getting her heart completely broken—justifiably. And so, from that perspective, I've definitely been there. I know exactly what it is like to invest all of your love into something, everything, and for it to be not corresponded back. Ya know? And that's why I go back to what I said earlier, about that scene with "Mona Lisas and Mad Hatter," and how important that particular song is to the movie. Because it's like, you have this girl who gave literally everything, and was discarded. That song—not written by Elton John—

Joe: Bernie Taupin?

Mandy: Maybe.

Joe: The guy that wrote all his songs?

Mandy: But that's what this song is about.

Joe: Okay, so I definitely have to leave in 20 minutes, tops. So let's make a decision. Should we talk more about this at a later date, or do a lightning round of all the subjects we haven't talked about yet?

Mandy: I'm up for either.

Joe: You're working tomorrow?

Mandy: Yes. I have Wednesdays off. If you wanted to try to do this again on a Wednesday, that's fine.