The Basketball Diaries
1995
There was a day in 2001 when 3000 Americans died, and we cried for weeks. In 2020, we get an average of 1000+ preventable deaths per day from a deadly virus, and not too many people even blink. From this, we can come to the very unscientific and unresearched conclusion that we, as Americans, have become numb to death and violence, and grow more so every day.
I bring this up in the context of The Basketball Diaries, which celebrated its 25th anniversary this past April, as I have to imagine that its impact in 2020 is dulled at least a little bit because our sensitivity to such subject matters have become dulled as well. It's gone from "could this very extraordinary horror happen to my child?" to "could this normalize, regular horror happen to my child?" One need not look much farther than the closest underpass to find a handful of Jim Carrolls.
Here's the part where I should drop some numbers on y'all—how do heroin rates for teenagers in 2020 compare to teenagers in 1995 (when the movie was released) and to teenagers in 1965 (when Jim Carrol was sixteen years old)?—but I don't even know if that data exists. I assume no one was tracking heroin usage in teenagers in the '90s (certainly not the '60s), because maybe people assumed that there was no fucking way teenagers were using heroin. Maybe it took movies like The Basketball Diaries to convince people that this shit was happening.
Not that The Basketball Diaries gets too "after school special" on its viewers. It's a little on-the-nose, but sometimes movies like this have to be in order to get its point across. The gratuitous violence and drug use committed by teenagers is the point—this is happening, this is a problem, there are millions of teenagers like this everywhere.
If you grew up white and male, you might even reluctantly see a little bit of your own younger self in this characters. I know I did toward the beginning of the film, when the protagonists were simply cocky and brash. Now, I certainly never mugged an old lady or stuck a needle in my arm or threw anyone off a roof to their death, but those actions were presented as one step in a whole series of them, leading to a downfall, a downfall anyone could meet if they continued down that path.
Watching as a thirty-something was scary because it presented a concise and horrifying depiction of a road I didn't travel down, but totally could've if my situation was even slightly different (slightly less attentive parents, slightly more morally-compromised friends, slightly more pressure to be somebody, and so on). It's the horror at realizing a near miss. It's the waking up in the middle of the night because you dreamed you were in a car crash.
Had I watched this film as an actual teenager, though, I don't know if I would've even thought to consider it a cautionary tale. There was another similar film that came out only three months later, and one that I watched a lot closer to my teenage years than I did watching The Basketball Diaries. Yes, we are talking about Kids, the subject of a rare movie blog post during my early 20s. I haven't revisited that post in a long while (probably because I can't bear to think about The Wall's meat grinder any more than I have to). I wrote this thing at the age of 21, which probably seemed pretty far removed from sixteen at the time I wrote it, but from my current vantage point seems equally prepubescent.
And even in that post, the message was the same as it is here—"holy shit, these kids are awful... but was I awful too?" I have no way of knowing whether these movies or similar ones would've had a measurable impact on me as a sixteen-year-old. Probably not—teenagers are by and large headstrong and refuse to believe that they are vulnerable. I would've watched The Basketball Diaries and only seen the differences: "Well, at least I would never do heroin!" as opposed to "Holy shit, I hope circumstances in life never tempt me to do heroin," or "Maybe I should learn from these mistakes and never do heroin." I wouldn't see it as a cautionary tale because I would assume I don't need a goddamn cautionary tale, I'll be fine Mom, jesus christ, get off my back! That I ended up not needing it after all is only coincidental.
Anyways, I'm 31 years old, I have no plans on doing heroin, and my own kids are still a decade-plus away from their teenage years, maybe we should talk about how this functions as a film, ya know, since this column is supposed to be about movies I've never seen as opposed to a self-reflection about how shitty of a teenager I was?!
Here's my take: decent movie. I thought Leonardo DiCaprio gave a really good performance as Jim Carroll, and this is coming from someone who doesn't have many kind words to say about DiCaprio's acting skills in general. He found the right balance between someone who was shown to have a sensitive side that he poured into a marble copy notebook of poetry and someone who built a hard, heroiny exterior to deal with the pain of losing a best friend to cancer. He only overacted when the film called for overacting—mainly in the throes of addiction and withdrawal, and heartbreakingly so when he was outside his mother's door, asking for help and crying and cursing and slobbering and devolving into a puddle, less than human, the mask of good times finally removed to reveal a great rotting maw, snapping at every vein... if there's a time for overacting, its now, and DiCaprio fucking nails it.
Otherwise, I thought that The Basketball Diaries felt a little cartoony at times. Maybe the filmmakers were trying to replicate what it feels like to devolve into a heroin junkie, but to me it just came off as '90s-style corniness, with the fishbowl lenses and the Dutch angles and the overwrought narration (I get that the narration was literally from the autobiography the film was based on, but still). I'm not saying that I disliked The Basketball Diaries because it was hokey, but it definitely didn't hook me as much as a better-made film in the same vein could have.
But maybe that's bullshit. Again, maybe it's just that the subject matter isn't necessarily fresh or original to me. I have dealt with teenagers who couldn't get out of bed because they were too high, while their parents looked on, horrified that outside help was finally needed. There are kids dipping out on SEPTA every day. At this point and time, The Basketball Diaries have been drained of any shock value that it so clearly aspires to present. Or, maybe, like many Americans, I'm just numb to it all.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Who's Involved
I wonder if it was detrimental for me to know Lorraine Bracco first as a mild-mannered therapist in The Sopranos, because every time she pops up as a high-strung New Yawker, it's jarring for me. But that's not a knock against her work, as she was pretty great in this somewhat underutilized role. (Thought she was good in Goodfellas too, for what it's worth.) It doesn't look like we'll see her again in this column, so I guess I'll have to wait until Pam and I watch The Sopranos for the FOURTH time to marvel at her skills as an actress.
Usually, for non-A-list actors and actresses, we have to look 'em up on IMDB to answer the question "Where is that guy from?" In a rare occurrence, we did not have to do that for James Madio, whom Pam recognized immediately from Hook. He, like the other kids in this movie, did a really good job portraying terrible teenagers.
Yes, even Marky Mark did a good job, but that was only because Mark Wahlberg actually was a terrible teenager, and a violent teenager, and a hugely racist teenager. As a fifteen-year-old, Wahlberg threw rocks at black teenagers while yelling the N word. As a seventeen-year-old, Wahlberg assaulted two Vietnamese men in two separate incidents on the same day, yelling racial slurs, and assaulting the one man so badly that he went blind. From a purely cinematic perspective, it's interesting that Wahlberg was approaching the film's lessons from the opposite direction I was—he didn't have to be worried about turning into such a person, because he had already been that type of person. And possibly still was! It took him until 2016(!) to apologize to the dude he blinded, and that was only because he was trying to obtain a pardon for his crimes so he could become an LAPD officer(!!). The pardon was declined, as Wahlberg has "never acknowledged the racial nature of his crimes." I know it's not fair to paint the world as this cut-and-dry, but Mark Wahlberg seems like a piece of shit, or at the very least was absolutely an unrepentant piece of shit during the filming of this movie. (Also, can we acknowledge how differently the whole LAPD aspect of this story reads today? Oh, it's cool that you beat someone blind, Mark, just say sorry to a judge, and then you can perform racially-motivated assaults LEGALLY!! Defund the police, please?!?)
Jesus, now I'm blind. With rage. Where were we? The actors. Yeah. Patrick McGaw rounds out the group of four teen boys in the movie, and he is definitely the actor with the shortest filmography. He hasn't been in anything since a 2008 CSI guest appearance, and before that it was 2000's adaptation of Chicken Soup for the Soul (apparently there was a 2000 adaptation of Chicken Soup for the Soul). Whatever McGaw is doing right now, I hope that he is happy, and that I can rest easy knowing that he is probably not out there beating minorities until they go blind.
Oh hey, we recognized Bruno Kirby from When Harry Met Sally. This was a very different role for him than the quirky best friend. I was impressed that Kirby was able to give the role of pedophile a little bit of nuance here. The big scene where he sexually accosts a very high Jim Carroll in the showers could've been played poorly without the right touch (lord forgive me for using that word, I mean ACTING touch), but Kirby plays it with just the right timidity that curdles to anger, it makes the whole thing so creepy and so real. And the first sign of pedophilia—when he asks Jim to accompany him for pizza and deep talks about college—was played so deftly that I thought there was a chance that the coach was being sincere, and that the film was setting it up so that Jim would falsely accuse one of his role models as being a creep, or that maybe it existed simply to show that Jim was not very trusting of his authority figures. Not so, unfortunately for our protagonist—his trust of authority ended up being warranted, when his adult basketball coach tried to sexually assault him. But my main point is that Kirby did a good job with acting a delicate part.
Hey, we also recognize Michael Imperioli. He was Dwight's karate sensei in The Office. (Jokes aside, there was one other Sopranos actor in The Basketball Diaries—Big Pussy, a.k.a. Vincent Pastore. Here's a coincidence: these were also the same three Sopranos actors who were in Goodfellas.)
Pam to the rescue again with Juliette Lewis, who I just fucking knew I recognized from somewhere. Except, for Lewis, Pam tried pulling the bullshit line of "Oh, she's in a lot of stuff," as if that line could ever apply to someone who has watched as few movies as I have. But I definitely recognized her from Christmas Vacation, as a similarly snotty but way less heroin-stuffed teenager. We watch that movie every year. Still... I could've sworn I've seen her in something as an adult. Going through her filmography with a fine-tooth comb gives me nothing that jumps out. Maybe I'm getting her confused with Rachel Griffiths. Anyways, she was pretty decent in The Basketball Diaries. She gets to lay the protagonist real low after he gave her so much shit during her own rock bottom, which must've felt unsatisfying on a personal level, but from an audience's perspective, it felt totally justified.
(This is Never Seen It episode #10 and I still can't decide whether I want the "Who's Involved" section to be about the actors/actresses themselves or about the motivations of the characters they portray, so sometimes the two just kinda blend into each other.)
Ernie Hudson plays the only male adult figure in Jim's life who doesn't try to rape him. His character, Reggie, could possibly be seen as a "magical negro," though maybe not, since race didn't seem to come into the equation throughout this movie. In any case, he was pretty good here, getting to play compassion, as opposed to the other role I know him for (Oz's hardass warden).
There's probably a better time to talk about Leonardo DiCaprio. I dunno. I just don't feel like it today.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Jim Carroll / Music
I don't listen to soundtracks too often, but I do love soundtracks from '90s movies. They all sound the same, with the alternative '90s punk goofiness. This is fucking great. There's a song from Flea! PJ Harvey! The Posies! Soundgarden! And most interestingly, a bunch of songs from the dude who wrote the source material!
Jim Carroll was a Basketball Diaries triple threat. He wrote the book. He acted a cameo part as a drug abuser spouting bullshit (it is apparently required that if the person whose the movie is based on is still alive, they make a cameo, and this movie is no different). And his band did a bunch of songs on the soundtrack. I guess the most well-known song is "People Who Died," which would be incredibly on-the-nose if it wasn't a good fucking song (I think it plays over the scene when the guys skip school and cause some childish mayhem).
The first video that pops up on YouTube when you search "Jim Carroll" is a live version of "People Who Died" featuring Lou Reed. It appears that they were at least acquaintances, if not friends, since Jim Carroll is also on the Velvet Underground live album Live at Max's Kansas City. I've never heard it, but according to Wikipedia, he's the MC at the show, and can be heard inquiring about drugs in between songs.
This got me thinking about the timeline here. Carroll lived The Basketball Diaries in the '60s, but the book didn't come out until 1978. So Carroll was known as a beat poet before this novel came out, which is not what I would've thought. I assumed that The Basketball Diaries made him famous (book or movie, either one), but he was already well known (and dating Patti Smith!) long before that. Okay, fair enough. He apparently got sober in the '70s, for what it's worth, though I don't know if that's before or after the book. Maybe around the same time.
In any case, wondering about all this led me to a pretty good New York Times article published after he died in 2009. This article also quotes an unknown party in describing Carroll's debut album, Catholic Boy, as "the last great punk album," so I guess I'm gonna have to check that one out.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
IMDB Trivia
The best and worst of The Basketball Diaries' trivia.
BEST: "Stephen Lang was offered the role of Jim's basketball coach Swifty. Lang declined, citing the misrepresentation of the book in the script. The part was subsequently toned down as a result." I'm including this "trivia" in this section instead of the "Almost Casted" section below because I find it interesting, and did not respond "who the fuck cares?" Mainly because Stephen Lang apparently had standards at one point, and then years later ended up choosing to play the most hackneyed, clichéd movie villain in cinema history.
WORST: "Mark Wahlberg was widely felt to look too old to play a teenager." YEAH NO SHIT. But also, every movie and TV show (besides Degrassi) does this.
ALMOST CASTED (WHO THE FUCK CARES): "A popular misconception holds that River Phoenix was set to play the lead before tragically dying on the Los Angeles sidewalk. This is not entirely accurate. Phoenix was a big fan of the book, and as the film version entered various stages of readiness, he was always the front runner. However, prior to his death, he had declined the role, due to a combination of feeling he was too old to play a fifteen-year-old, and trying to broaden his range with more adult roles." WHO THE FUCK CARES?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Lawsuits, etc.
There's a brief interlude in the middle of the movie where the character Jim has a dream that he is in a black trench coat and has a huge shotgun and is blasting away classmates as they stare on in horror. It's not much of a scene (apparently it wasn't even in the source material), but apparently it was enough that the media started connecting the movie with the rash of school shootings in the late '90s.
We touched on this in our Oldboy discussion—just because a deranged criminal claims that his crime was motivated by a movie, doesn't mean that we should connect those same dots, and I'm not sure there's much more I have to say on the subject. If The Basketball Diaries motivated someone to commit murder, then the fault does not lie with The Basketball Diaries. The movie wasn't advocating for someone to do in real life what the fictionalized version of Jim Carroll did in a further fictionalized dream sequence. The movie was instead presenting a very damaged individual and the sick ways he coped with his issues.
Carroll defended his position similarly when news stations started to reach out to him in 1999 regarding these allegations. Here's an old blog post news story about it. Carroll stated that "artists have nothing to do with the deranged, vaguely connected actions of a few celebrated nut cases," citing Mark David Chapman's copy of Catcher in the Rye as another example.
He concluded: "The ridiculous thing is that, in fact, books like mine and others have made a lot of kids feel less isolated, less alone, relieved to know that someone else out there understood how they feel." Which got me on a whole different thought process, about how—and this is getting off topic / back to an old topic, but I'm rolling with it—how maybe this movie would've been a lot different for me had I been an ex-(or current-)heroin addict, if I could actually relate to this movie instead of just being thankful that I couldn't.
I'm all for pop culture making someone feel empathetic. Like, if there is a 16-year-old drug addict watching this movie, and they feel a kinship with the Jim Carroll character, then that's great. The Basketball Diaries is able to take the lessons that Carroll learned, and underline them with bold black ink, so if you're watching this movie and you have the same issues, then yeah, hopefully it'll make you feel like you're less alone, like there's hope to be found somewhere.
To claim instead that the movie might inspire someone to kill their classmates is an affront to anyone who is able to watch a movie and comprehend what the movie is trying to say. The Basketball Diaries isn't trying to say that. C'mon. Intent matters here.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Final Words
I guess it's kind of interesting that the crux of my argument above is "we are numb to this," when a more general argument I usually make is "good art makes you feel something," and yet I would not call this "bad art" by any means. I guess when I say "numb," I am speaking specifically about content—drug use, violence—and not about style or character. DiCaprio's performance in the climactic outside-the-apartment-door scene hit me hard for reasons that had little to do with heroin's pervasiveness in our culture. I can fault the movie for other hokey bullshit, but I find it hard to fault over the fact that I couldn't relate to the characters in the final 3/4ths of the runtime. There are kids who can relate to it, so at the end of the day, we must consider it important.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NEXT TIME: We check out A Beautiful Mind featuring Russell Crowe, whose Oscar-winning performance is literally the only thing I know about A Beautiful Mind, so I cannot even slyly allude to any preconceived notions in this section like I usually do.

No comments:
Post a Comment