Avatar
2009
Jeez, writing about this movie is starting to feel like all those research projects in college I kept putting off all semester until the very last moment, and then banged out something half-assed just to get it done. I've already skipped one week, even though I promised myself I wouldn't skip any weeks for the Never Seen It project. What about Avatar made me not care?
That's actually what interests me the most about Avatar—not the movie itself, but the public's reaction to it. This is a movie that's been watched in theaters more than almost any movie in history, and yet you'd be hard-pressed to find anyone who still defends it eleven years later. I would love to get some answers.
I suppose we should talk first about whether the public opinion change was warranted in this past decade, before talking about how such a thing could have happened. If you want to know whether I thought Avatar sucked, then I will not disappoint you. It kind of sucked. There are no hot takes in this blog post.
An especially cold take would be that there were numerous problems with the script. I honestly don't even care about the usual complaint—"it was too similar to other movies," because there are no original movies anymore, and I've grown numb to it—I just think it failed on a very basic level. The dialogue was so stilted, filled with every cliché in the book.
I made a note about the soldiers in the beginning as an example, when they are welcoming the new recruits. The new guys were referred to as "ladies," and then "fresh meat," and then were told they were "not in Kansas anymore." There was no sense of irony or humor or lampshading in these lines, but instead they were to be taken completely at face value. It's like a computer wrote this script using an algorithm.
Don't even get me started on the main villain, Quaritch. This dude was a one-man trope machine. He could've been a Buzz Lightyear doll, honestly, in the way he could push the red button on his chest and a scripted line would pop out. Here are some examples that I am directly quoting:
- I’ve got them by the balls with that, when it turns into a shit-fight.
- You got a little local pussy and completely forgot what team you play for.
- Shut your fucking hole!
- I’m getting all emotional. I might just give you a big wet kiss.
- It’ll be humane... more or less.
- Hey, don’t go limp on me now.
- That’s how you scatter the roaches.
- Get back here you worthless pukes!
- Let’s see what these blue bastards do when I bitch-slap their goddess.
- Nothing’s over while I’m breathing.
- We will fight terror with terror.
And it's a shame, because the third problem is that there are moments in this movie that should inspire awe in the audience, and they fall flat. To be clear, the characters express that awe, and I guess the audience is supposed to be right there with them, but I never was. The most prominent example of this was when the crew came up the floating islands. All the characters go "woah!" and have such a sense of wonder in their eyes... but I didn't feel it. The movie didn't earn it. I would not be shy about admitting when a movie gets me in this way (think Apollo 13), so I'm not bullshitting you when I say Avatar failed in this regard.
Maybe this would have been different if I saw this movie in full-blown 3D at movie theaters circa 2009. And this is a good segue into the question of how this movie could've made so much money and yet not be defended too often just a short decade later. One of the theories is that it only made a lot of money because 3D movies charge double for tickets, so Avatar was squeezing more money with less viewers. I guess that's part of it, but that doesn't explain why most of the internet seems to agree that this wasn't all that great of a movie.
My theory (which is not original, but it's just the one I'm clinging to) is that Avatar proves the powers of groupthink. In 2009, it was established in society that if you are a filmgoer, then you should probably go see the spectacle that is Avatar. By 2020, it is now established that it's lame to admit that you like Avatar. Opinions spread because you are influenced by the people around you, whether you mean to be or not.
If I had given a single fuck about "movies I need to see according to other people" in 2009, I would've been in that movie theater with everyone else, watching Sam Worthington strain to act his way through the CGI jungles. And it feels cheap to be shitting on this movie here in 2020, because everyone else seems to be doing it too. I wish I could give you a hot take, but I can't. I would love to believe that I wasn't influenced by anyone else, that I came to the conclusion of "Avatar is bad" completely on my own, but who knows.
Still, I suppose I'm glad I watched it, just to say that I am now part of the cultural phenomenon, even if I am eleven years too late. No one wants to be the guy prejudging a movie, even if you just fucking know that that judgment is ultimately going to come true.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Who's Involved
*DING DING DING* Ring the bell, we have our first major actor repeat in the Never Seen It series. Sigourney Weaver, the sci-fi badass from Alien, also plays a major role as a sci-fi badass in Avatar. She, unsurprisingly, does a good job, even through the uncanny valley of her CGI avatar. This seems like one of those castings that were meant to give the film an air of legitimacy, i.e. "You can't question Avatar's sci-fi bonafides, it features Sigourney fucking Weaver!" It didn't quite work, but I would've probably hated Avatar a lot more if Weaver wasn't there to ground everybody else's performances.
Zoe Saldana is a name that I recognize but wouldn't have been able to put a face to without the help of Wikipedia. That she is unrecognizable in her two most famous roles doesn't help much. It is because of those two roles, though, that Saldana is the second-highest grossing film actress of all time. We won't see her next week in The Avengers as Gamora, because that character doesn't show up Phase Two of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (getting way ahead of myself mentioning any of this). She is fine in this movie. I know there is a lot more work that goes into motion-capture filming then it seems in the final product, but from my ignorant perspective, this might as well be voice acting work for Saldana.
I warned you there would be no hot takes in this blog post: Sam Worthington wasn't that great. Perhaps not the cardboard cut-out that the internet makes him out to be, but he was definitely part of the problem when it came to my lack of investment in this film. There's probably a reason his filmography doesn't quite have the pedigree of his costars.
Speaking of PEDIGREE, the dude from Grandma's Boy and Dodgeball is in this too—Joel David Moore. With movies like those, he is actually the second-highest grossing film actor of all time (just kidding).
I'll be kinder to Michelle Rodriguez, no slouch in the ticket-selling department due to her roles in the Fast and Furious series. She is military in Avatar, but turns babyface halfway through with little reason given. I guess because they needed at least one military character who wasn't a violent destructive racist? Her role here does not sooth my pain at her early dismissal from Lost.
We've already mentioned Colonel Quaritch, who is a shitty character, but I can't decide if Stephen Lang should shoulder any of that blame, or if the script is the sole perpetrator here. I've literally never seen him in anything else, so I plead the fifth.
If it wasn't for Quaritch, Selfridge would've been the worst character—equally one-note, but admittedly fewer opportunities to spout cliché bullshit. Giovanni Ribisi performs the moustache-twirling as best he can, I guess. Maybe I'm giving him a pass because he a very minor role in That Thing You Do!, and I just can't fault anybody in that movie for anything ever again.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sequels
I didn't know anything about Avatar before watching this except for one fact: Avatar is infamously getting at least two long-delayed sequels, and eleven years later, they are still not released. Seriously, you guys—James Cameron has done nothing in eleven years except work on these sequels. From my perspective at least, this appears to be an insane act of hubris, especially when you consider the fact that the world does not seem as into Avatar as it was when the first movie was released. I would think either or both sequels could be a bomb, but apparently the studio execs thought that about the first movie, and look what happened there.
(There were originally four sequels definitively planned for release, but in the past few years, Cameron has admitted that there won't be an Avatar 4 or Avatar 5 if 2 or 3 don't make enough money. Reasonable take!)
It looks like everyone is set to return, even the actors and actresses whose characters died in Avatar 1 (I won't spoil it for you). Also cast are Kate Winslet, Edie Falco, and Vin fucking Diesel (so this movie is definitely going to feature a crossover with Fast and Furious 13, right?).
I cannot imagine what this is going to be about. Wikipedia says that it takes place twelve years after the original, and "an old threat comes back to finish what it started." Boy, sure sounds like James Cameron did it again with a sterling script, huh?
If I were in charge of this billion dollar franchise, here's what I would like to see happen in the sequels: a Na'vi and a human have sex; Vin Diesel drives a car really fast; Quaritch quotes Shakespeare; Joel David Moore becomes a violent Na'vi dictator; big bomb go boom; Jake paints a large poster that reads "killing our forest is bad!!" in big red font; Edie Falco has sex for sure; I dunno, they explore different parts of the floating islands I fucking guess????
(I don't know where else to put this: Avatar has no connection to the allegedly fantastic cartoon TV show, Avatar: The Last Airbender. It's something I always wondered, because I am dumb.)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
IMDB Trivia
The Avatar IMDB trivia page can be found HERE.
BEST: "James Cameron was convinced that CGI effects had progressed enough to make this film when he saw Gollum in The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002)." I like this due to the fact that me and Bob discussed that movie at length, and how much Bob hates CGI.
WORST: "Director James Cameron, known for being tough on set, allegedly kept a nail gun on set that he would use to nail cell phones that had the misfortune of ringing to a wall above the exit sign." I'm only interested in this because it makes James Cameron seem like a complete asshole. Imagine signing on to film FIVE Avatar movies with this jabroni.
ALMOST CASTED (WHO THE FUCK CARES): "Matt Damon and Jake Gyllenhaal were the studio's first choices to play Jake Sully, but James Cameron decided to cast the less-known Sam Worthington in the lead role." Who the fuck cares?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Awards
Avatar was nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars, which is always the most interesting thing to think about in this section every week. An academy of film experts decided that this was one of the best films of the year, and I love asking about why that is. What was it about this film that made them consider it one of the best of 2009? I've just written 1000 words about why I didn't like it, and clearly the important people disagreed. I am tempted to chalk it up to that groupthink again—2.79 billion dollars-worth of people can't be wrong!—but maybe I'll just never understand the Academy.
Here's what I am starting to understand, though: movies like this are always going to do well in categories like Art Direction, Cinematography, and Special Effects, because those categories are consolation prizes. There, I said it. It would look bad for the Academy for the then-highest grossing film of all time to walk away empty handed, so here, here's some technical awards for your trouble.
Also, it lost Best Picture to The Hurt Locker, which I've never seen, and which I thought was on my list, but apparently it's not. I must've taken it off when I was trying to make an even 200. Avatar and Up are the only movies out of the ten nominated, actually, so maybe I am not in the best position to say whether Avatar deserved the nomination.
I thought it would be interesting to see if the acting was nominated anywhere in the world, and there are actually a few! Sam Worthington actually won at the Saturn Awards that year! I know the Saturn Awards are sci-fi-specific, but still, Saturn Awards!! What are you doing?!
Can't leave this section without mentioning my all-time favorite award ceremonies—MTV Movie Awards, and the Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards. (Fuck the Oscars!!!!!!!) Some notable losses: Zoe and Sam lost MTV's BEST KISS to the fucking Twilight vampires; Stephen Lang was for some reason nominated for Best Villain, but thankfully lost to Tom Felton (Malfoy in Half Blood Prince, which, having never seen the movie, I will say that HBP is where Malfoy is most integral to the plot... oh god, I have to physically restrain myself from typing more about that); Nickelodeon awarded CUTEST COUPLE to, again, the Twilight vampires (at least non-adults are consistent with what they like); Miley Cyrus edged out Zoe Saldana for Best Actress, probably because Cyrus had to play two roles, whereas Saldana just voiced a blue giant.
Joel David Moore got slimed (the slime was blue).
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Unique Perspectives
In which we briefly discuss the movie with a friend. This time, Drew A*******, he of the There Will Be Blood fame, was asked to help out.
Joe: I asked you to speak to me about Avatar because I know you to be a movie guy, and what interests me the most is how the critical opinion of Avatar has shifted so violently in the past decade, at least from where I'm standing. What's your take on that? I guess I should ask first, though—do you like Avatar?
Drew: It's okay. I think it's criminally overrated though, or at least it was when it was first released. People were going back to see it four, five, six times. "Avatar Depression" was a real thing—people were so depressed that they can't actually have an Avatar and wake up in a new body on Pandora that they legit though about killing themselves... ANYWAY, the film has a lot going for it, but it never blew me away.
Joe: Wait... let's talk about this Avatar Depression thing. I hadn't heard of that, but you're right. I'm reading something on CNN about it from 2010... this is so fucking sad, man. I mean that sincerely—I can't imagine my life being that empty that I need to fill it with dreams of living in fucking Avatar. Could we lump Avatar in with things like heroin, i.e. an escape? Are there any other movies that have had a similar effect in society that you can think of?
Drew: Yeah man it's wild. I've never heard of another film having that kind of effect on people. Maybe music could do that, but a fucking movie? Like, it's just an action movie! I think perhaps the PLOT affected people in that deep way, since the protagonist is a paraplegic and gets a new body and a new life through his avatar. For him, it's not just about being able to breath in the atmosphere. EVERYTHING about his situation changes for the better when he goes into this new body. So maybe you're right, it's that whole idea of an "escape" from your situation. People saw the movie and longed for that opportunity, but then eventually realized that it's fiction, and got seriously depressed. I could be wrong but I think that's a reason people paid to see it so many times
Joe: My main question about Avatar was how it earned so much money when I'm so hard pressed to find many kind words on the internet about it in 2020. I love your theory, because that means that there ARE fans out there, but even the fans were CLINICALLY DEPRESSED after watching Avatar. Definitely one of those movies that is more interesting to think about culturally then it is to think about the actual movie itself.
Drew: Dude that's another great point. People in 2020 generally look back on it unfavorably, or don't even remember it at all. I can't believe a movie that successful did not have any longevity in popular culture. I think there's actually an Avatar theme park in Universal Studios or something [Editor's note: Disney World's Animal Kingdom]. But who the hell wants to go to that? I think perhaps the effect of this film wears off when you watch it at home. This movie was designed to be this HUGE, immersive experience. 3D, IMAX, groundbreaking CGI, all these flying sequences. It was fun in theaters. But last fall, I was in a hotel in San Francisco and Avatar was on TV, so I watched it. MAN was it unimpressive. The plot is so basic and the visuals (which were once touted as revolutionary) simply did not hold up. Like, it was kind of distracting watching these obviously fake blue cartoons.
Joe: As someone who couldn't give a shit about how "impressive" CGI bullshit is, even I noticed how out-of-date the visuals were. And this was a movie that James Cameron waited a decade to start making because he didn't think technology was good enough. Did he STILL jump the gun maybe?
I did want to get your thoughts on the plot, because you had mentioned a couple things when I first texted you about this, but first I want to drop this new theory that I literally just thought of now as I was typing:
You know how Avatar is really on-the-nose about the villains' racism (calling the Na'vi "blue monkeys" etc.)? What if I theorized that as America becomes more overtly racist itself, so too does Avatar's popularity go down, since Avatar is more likely to hold a mirror to white supremacists face and say "Oh god, look, you are Quaritch, that ain't good"?
...You can say this is a bad theory.
Drew: Firstly: I think he did jump the gun a little with the visuals. He actually seems to run into this a lot, where his ambition is beyond what is actually possible. If you've ever seen the original Terminator, the visual effects are pretty bad. The movie is overall great, but it has a lot of '80s stop-motion, and even the practical effects look fake. His vision just couldn't be achieved---UNTIL Terminator 2 came out seven years later. The world now had CGI, and he used it in all the right places. That said, I'm interested to see how much better the visuals look in the FOUR sequels he's currently making.
Secondly, it's a decent theory that the liberal themes of this franchise could backfire in the trump era. The film makes it very clear that "environmentalism = good" and "racism = bad." I can't envision James Cameron changing his mind and sympathizing with the evil corporate warlords in the next films. So we'll see!
To that point, my biggest problem with this movie is how basic the story is. It's almost patronizing—any five-year-old can fully understand this film after one viewing. That whole idea of infiltrating a native population as means to "gain their trust" and exploit them, just to eventually sympathize with them and ultimately join them and turn on your own kind has been done TO DEATH. Fern Gully, Pocahontas (i.e. KIDS movies), and even to a lesser extent Dances with Wolves, Last of the Mohicans, The Last Samurai. The list goes on. James Cameron obviously thinks the audience is too stupid for anything more complex.
Joe: I don't think I necessarily have an issue with taking ideas from other movies to use in your own. There are a finite number of ideas in the world. I do take issue when you take the ideas and make them worse. I was going to ask about Fern Gully and Pocahontas specifically, not only because you mentioned them in your text last week, but because I've never seen either one, so I can't say for sure. Are they similar only in that idea you talk about of exploiter-turned-sympathizer? Or are there other ways they are similar to Avatar? And are those movies BETTER than Avatar, in your opinion?
Drew: I mean, they are similar mainly in the exploiter-turned-sympathizer sense, but it not just a minor theme. It’s the core of the movie. Fern Gully and Pocahontas are both pretty mediocre to be honest, but their storylines worked better because they were appropriate for kids. Kids don’t know right from wrong, and they haven’t been exposed to many examples of how to overcome that. Avatar seems to make those same assumptions about an adult audience, and it comes off as either patronizing or, at the very least, predictable. We know exactly where this story is going and that it will be a happy ending. No need to think too hard, here! Titanic was the same way. ("Same way" in that it has a plot a child could follow. Not in that it was about the passengers eventually sympathizing with the iceberg.)
Joe: Oh man, you're dragging Titanic into this?! I don't want to talk too much about it, because I do plan on interviewing Big Bren about this movie, but I don't agree with this comparison at all. With Avatar, you knew where it was going because it was a shitty predictable movie. With Titanic, that you knew where it was going was the point. It was historical record, and it provided an interesting backdrop for a classic love story. BUT not trying to get into that. I agree with you about Avatar. But you never chose—GUN TO YOUR HEAD, FERN GULLY OR AVATAR?
Drew: Gun to my head, Avatar is better than Fern Gully, but NOT because of the script. Avatar was, in a lot of ways, an impressive movie. It's well-made for the time it came out, even if it hasn't aged well. It won an Oscars for cinematography and production design in addition to visual effects, all well-deserved for that year. The score was great too. It was NOT, however, nominated for its screenplay, because the script is terrible. James Cameron is a great director but a bad writer.
And not to drag Titanic back into it, but I should clarify as I did a bad job of explaining my point. You described Titanic as a “classic love story,” WHICH IS EXACTLY THE PROBLEM. It’s the same way Avatar is a “classic adventure story”. I respect Titanic a lot for the incredible ship-sinking sequence, but the middle act of Jack and Rose getting to know each other is insufferable. That whole “I’m a rich girl engaged to a rich man who I hate, then I meet a poor boy who I can’t possibly be with because he’s poor, but we’ll fall in love anyway” like are you kidding me?!! It's so cliché! That’s all I’ll say. Good direction, bad writing.
Joe: Disagree with Titanic, I'll have to take your word for Fern Gully, and I only have one more question. How do you imagine the sequels performing? I already wrote a little bit about them, how there are at least two coming out, and then two more if those don't bomb. But they will probably bomb, right? (He says, knowing that everyone predicted the first one to bomb too?)
Drew: Did everyone predict the first one would bomb? I recall the movie sort of came out of nowhere, but James Cameron’s previous film (Titanic) was the highest-grossing film of all time. So even if no one expected much from Avatar, did people really think it would, like, tank? Those IMAX 3D ticket prices also virtually double the potential box office gross.
Anyway, I think Avatar 2 will be a success, but 3, 4, and 5 are not guaranteed. 90% of sequels make more money than the original, even if it’s a worse movie. The first installment in a franchise is a crapshoot—people don’t know if it will be good. If the first one IS good, then people have a couple years to get around to seeing it. So by the time the sequel comes out, EVERYONE lines up to see it in theaters, as opposed to seeing is sporadically at home over a few years. There are always exceptions (Basic Instinct 2 saw an average of fourteen people per theater opening weekend) but I think since the Avatar sequels have been in the works so SO LONG that the curiosity factor will be enough to see Avatar 2. If it sucks, I think the rest of the installments could be in jeopardy. But hey, Spider-Man 3 was TRASH and it was the highest grossing film of 2007. And those Hobbit movies were poorly reviewed, but they already shot three movies back-to-back so they released them anyway and made decent money because of the 3D prices, which Avatar 2 will definitely have. Soooo final verdict: Avatar 2 will make money even if it’s bad, but the rest may not be so lucky.
Joe: You heard it here, folks. Avatar 2 is besting Avengers: Endgame at the box office. Can't wait to see if you're right. We only have to wait until... December 2021?!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Final Word
There's a great joy in writing about movies that I discovered to be wonderful, and there's a sadistic pleasure in panning those movies that I find to be fucking awful, but when a movie like Avatar comes around, I struggle. I thought it was bad enough to be disliked outright, but at the same time, this is a very popular movie, one that ostensibly has many fans. That divided opinion makes me wonder if I'm in the wrong, or if I missed something. Either I missed the boat with Avatar, or I lack within myself a very basic openness to simple movie magic. Regardless, I will state right now that out of the seven movies I've watched for this project so far, this has been the worst.
GRADE: 1.5 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NEXT TIME: Speaking of epic blockbuster, we attempt to watch The Avengers (without having watched any of the five movies leading up to its creation).

3 comments:
The groupthink thing is interesting and telling point. An old roommate once told me "No one would be caught dead with Creed's Human Clay in their house, but that album went 11x Platinum." There's something in folks that give them the ability to do the same thing en masse without much behind it, whether that's seeing a thing or hating the people who saw that thing 10 years later.
But where do you see the line between 'groupthink' and 'culture'?
I've thought a lot about this question the past few days, and here is the answer: The internet.
Joe I previously mentioned this via text, but for the massive readership at home: Avatar 2 will be distinct because it has a shitload of child characters in it, presumably to help sell toys. I would not be shocked if it even had a PG rating.
Also, I had never heard that James Cameron would nail cell phones to the wall on set. Though as someone who has worked on movie sets, I can tell you if your phone rings in the middle of filming a shot, you might as well change careers because everyone from the director down to the fucking extras will yell at you until you cry.
...anyway, great read, as always.
Post a Comment