Welcome to "Don't Tell Me What I Can't Do," a new series here on PoYB. Please first read this blog post I wrote in 2009. There, I listed 22 subjects that I would NEVER write about on this website. Here in 2018, I say: don't fucking tell me what I can't do. For a total of twenty-two posts, I will be blogging about these subjects, in striking defiance of my 20-year-old naiveté.
TODAY'S "FORBIDDEN" SUBJECT: "A poem about how people in my theater group make me sick"
WHY IT WAS FORBIDDEN: It was a joke, because there really was a kid in my theater group who wrote a poem about how his fellow thespians made him sick. It was weird and funny and sad and baffling. The point was that I would never do that, which was the joke, I guess? I dunno, man.
HOW I WILL WRITE ABOUT IT: By posting the poem in question here, and reflecting upon the frenemy who wrote it.
TODAY'S "FORBIDDEN" SUBJECT: "A poem about how people in my theater group make me sick"
WHY IT WAS FORBIDDEN: It was a joke, because there really was a kid in my theater group who wrote a poem about how his fellow thespians made him sick. It was weird and funny and sad and baffling. The point was that I would never do that, which was the joke, I guess? I dunno, man.
HOW I WILL WRITE ABOUT IT: By posting the poem in question here, and reflecting upon the frenemy who wrote it.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Were that my heart was not heavy,
Were that my bile did not rise,
To look upon you.
Shame has no meaning to you,
Nor pride, nor honor, nor glory;
You rest your face calmly in the muck,
And think nothing of it.
Oh! How great You could be,
How great you were, how great you could be yet,
If not for your poison'd will,
Your will that was made weak by Yourself.
Your beginning afar,
Your end is soon,
And You shall know me no more.
Any theater group, no matter the college, is going to be a bizarre melting pot of different types of people. A desire to participate on or behind the stage is a broad enough interest that really anyone can join up and find their place. It's not like the basketball program, because, like, you have to be good at basketball to be part of that team. Any ol' fucker can join theater, especially if you're at a school like La Salle, which was small and generally untalented in any one thing. You wanna be on stage, but you don't have any acting experience? Fuck it, it's La Salle, let's do this shit.
So the point is that there's a lot of weird fucking people in theater (I'll go ahead and include myself in that), and people butt heads, and people fight, and people act like the outrageous teenagers that they are.
We had one kid that was truly an enigma to me personally. A lot of people gave him shit, myself included, because he did a lot of shitty things to people. Trite shit, but still hurtful. Like one time he, for some fucking reason, posted a long screed by the box office, all about my one friend and how she was "unqualified" for an executive board position (yes, our theater program had an "executive board"). It's one thing to have an opinion (my opinion: she was fucking great at the job), but it's another to go out of your way to say mean shit about somebody, ya know?
People are by and large not black-and-white. They are not wholly one thing or another. People have layers. People have great qualities and shitty qualities. It's all quite complicated.
Because, you see, I was lucky enough to see the good sides of this kid as well. We were part of a play in 2010, in which at least half the play, maybe more, was entirely me and him having a dialogue on stage. Rehearsals sometimes were just him and me, honing the craft. And dude, not gonna lie, we fucking pulled that shit off. It was a joint effort, and I sincerely enjoyed working with him.
But during other rehearsals with the whole cast, he would act differently. I dunno. Like there was one time when I guess a bunch of us had been drinking heavily the night before, and maybe it showed at the beginning of rehearsal. This kid, though, says some really snarky bullshit to one of my great friends who was also in the cast. It was totally uncalled for. It was a really uncomfortable day.
I guess here's where the infamous poem comes in. In the Fall of 2009, the Masque was putting on the show Guys and Dolls. Unfortunately, due to family constraints, I wasn't able to be part of the cast, but all my friends were in it, and so I partied with those motherfuckers as much as they rehearsed. The big incident, if you want to call it that, was during the "Fun Run."
A "fun run" takes place in between weekends of the actual show, just a little refresher. No one takes it seriously. The drinkers of the theater program really didn't take it seriously. A fun run in Fall 2008 ended in multiple people throwing up in the theater and a stern talking-to from the seniors; a fun run in Spring 2010 was so blackout I was almost banned from the theater program completely.
I wasn't technically on stage during the Fun Run of Autumn 2009, but I still pregamed the fuck out of it with the cast and went to the theater with them to witness the carnage from the seats. Our star of this blog post was part of the cast, and he was there too, and he was, I guess to say the least, NOT HAPPY. There was no direct confrontation that night, but the next morning, on Facebook, he posted the above poem, and it was pretty fucking clear to all involved whom he was referring to.
The record should be clear that there was no animosity in our drinking that night, nor was there ever, really, when the theater kids drank. It's not like we got drunk and then said terrible things to the kid or anyone else. We were just drunk and acting foolish. Kid stuff. DEFINITELY nothing that would warrant being called "weak" or full of "shame" or having faces "in the muck" or cause "bile to rise." It was a classic, pompous, kind of shitty behind-the-back attack that was completely unwarranted. People didn't take kindly to it.
And I wouldn't even classify the reaction to the poem as extreme or anything of that sort. No one shunned the kid, he wasn't booted out of the theater program, his ass wasn't kicked, nothing like that. The general reaction from everyone was kind of like: "Dude, what the fuck, that is so weird."
So yeah, the kid was an enigma to me. I saw the good in him, and he was clearly doing his best to show his worst to a lot of other people. Either that, or didn't have the ability to make a judgment call as to whether his actions were shitty or not. Some people just don't have a filter.
Making the whole thing even more mysterious, a few months after I graduated, I saw the musical he was in, along with all the other kids younger than me. After the show, me and Pam stuck around a bit, and he came up to me and... apologized. Said something like: "Dude, I know I was shitty to you in the past, and I'm sorry."
Which was kind of weird, because I was the least of all people he needed to apologize to. It hurt when he was shitty to my friends, and I probably cursed his name a few times behind his back because of that and because of his teetotaling. But he never really did anything to me directly that would require an apology. I almost wished he would have instead apologized to some of my other friends more deserving of an apology in the first place, but I suppose that's neither here nor there. It just added another layer to him.
I'm not sure where he is these days. Not in Philly, as far as I know. He's a smart dude, poor social skills notwithstanding, so I'm sure he moved to a different city and is getting his doctorate in something or other. I hope he is doing well. I hope he found a way to connect to people in healthier ways. I hope he hasn't written any Ye Olde-style poems talking shit on people.
I can't say I regret making a joke about the whole situation when I wrote that blog post all those years ago. Posting that poem was the wrong thing to do on his part, and I take out my discomfort in people by making jokes. And on top of that, it gave me the opportunity a decade later to reflect on that whole strange dynamic. College is a weird fucking time. Trust me, I know. I was in the theater program.



