Joe's weekly reflections on the greatest teenage rock 'n' roll cover band to ever come out of Rockledge, PA in the mid-'00s, covered on the blog one song at a time.
"Twist and Shout"
originally covered by the Beatles
You've read the previous 27 entries in this blog column, and are currently reading the final Burholme write-up, and you've followed the story and you've read the pithy (ha) words on the legendary (ha) teenage garage rock cover band, and you might have one lingering question—why did Burholme ever break up? I am here, at the end, to answer that question.
We broke up because that's what high school bands do. Unless you're great enough and ambitious enough to make a run at music-making as a professional career—and there wasn't one single second throughout this entire fucking endeavor, not during and not after, in which any of the three of us harbored any ambitions toward doing this full-time, nor ever became deluded enough that we ever thought, not fucking once, that we were actually good at this, let alone great—then the thing to do after high school graduation is to magnanimously split up the band before you split up the friend group and head off to college and make your own world there, leaving this petty high school shit in the fucking dust.
Approximately eleven days after the final Burholme concert, the drummer took the fifteen-minute drive to La Salle University. The drumming continued through jazz and pep band, and the regular rehearsals kept the spirit alive, at least for a little bit. It wasn't as loose or free but there was merriment and drinking and friendships forged and all that good stuff that comes associated with the act of making music. That the peak of that collegiate experience vis-à-vis drumming happened two years after graduation and involved surreptitiously playing the bass drum in Kansas City and on national television (with a hat over the face so that his boss back in Philly wouldn't come to understand the true reason that he had called out of work) probably says more about the reason that he was drumming in the first place than anything else.
The bassist would give up the bass after that final show, more or less, though he would never admit it. He would lead the charge of the calls for a "Burholme reunion," but after weeks turned to months turned to years, those calls turned from serious into a well-meaning joke, the weight of adulthood pressing upon it so tightly that the joke turned into diamond. After a while, the response to the call for a Burholme reunion became "yeah, right after you get your bass out of Joe's parents' garage." For all I know, that bass could still be there.
Approximately eleven days after the final Burholme concert, the drummer took the fifteen-minute drive to La Salle University. The drumming continued through jazz and pep band, and the regular rehearsals kept the spirit alive, at least for a little bit. It wasn't as loose or free but there was merriment and drinking and friendships forged and all that good stuff that comes associated with the act of making music. That the peak of that collegiate experience vis-à-vis drumming happened two years after graduation and involved surreptitiously playing the bass drum in Kansas City and on national television (with a hat over the face so that his boss back in Philly wouldn't come to understand the true reason that he had called out of work) probably says more about the reason that he was drumming in the first place than anything else.
The bassist would give up the bass after that final show, more or less, though he would never admit it. He would lead the charge of the calls for a "Burholme reunion," but after weeks turned to months turned to years, those calls turned from serious into a well-meaning joke, the weight of adulthood pressing upon it so tightly that the joke turned into diamond. After a while, the response to the call for a Burholme reunion became "yeah, right after you get your bass out of Joe's parents' garage." For all I know, that bass could still be there.
The frontman of our little crew would go off to an ivy league school and turn into a lawyer eventually, but not before a quick sojourn in a fraternity that had a "house band." And so of course the guitarist and vocalist of Burholme would eventually turn into the guitarist and vocalist of the Sammy Band, or "the greatest post-teenage rock 'n' roll cover band to ever come out of University City in the late-'00s." The bassist and the drummer would visit that guitarist at some point, probably early sophomore year, and get drunk on Lionshead like always, and crowd the makeshift stage in that Walnut Street house, and grab the mic whenever a Burholme song came up in the queue. I don't remember what songs they were. Probably not "Another Wartime Statistic."
If I'm remembering correctly—and, as you well know by know, that's far from a guarantee—Burholme had one final rehearsal, during the summer of 2008, probably ten-ish months after that final concert. You might think that it was a bittersweet reunion, like we were picking up the pieces or trying to take back a moment we had lost or something like that, but I don't remember it that way. I remember being rusty but finding a groove. I remember having a nice afternoon. I remember beers shared afterward, and I remember light, hypothetical chitchat about whether we could keep doing this, or maybe even have another concert at the end of the summer, or some shit like that. College had changed us but not irrevocably. We could, perhaps, slip back into the personas we once knew, up on that church hall stage.
You know how it goes. Plans are made and then fall apart. Life was already too busy for a hobby like this. Too many summer work hours, too many cases of Natty Light to consume, too many other lofty plans—parties in the apartment above the butcher shop, long bus rides to temporary girlfriends in Maryland, former drummers and former bassists heading to Wildwood for a week with no place to sleep and a truck bed full of Hurricane forties. The friendships were still there, just as they are now, but as all friendships must, they evolved, and adjusted, and settled in for the long stay of adulthood ahead. No time for teenage garage rock cover bands.
You know how it goes. Plans are made and then fall apart. Life was already too busy for a hobby like this. Too many summer work hours, too many cases of Natty Light to consume, too many other lofty plans—parties in the apartment above the butcher shop, long bus rides to temporary girlfriends in Maryland, former drummers and former bassists heading to Wildwood for a week with no place to sleep and a truck bed full of Hurricane forties. The friendships were still there, just as they are now, but as all friendships must, they evolved, and adjusted, and settled in for the long stay of adulthood ahead. No time for teenage garage rock cover bands.
There was a call, once upon a time, for "one more song." And I believe that call still rings out today, both on the screen via a YouTube copy of a moldy VHS tape found in a dusty tape recorder bag in a friend's dad's basement, and in our hearts and minds. And I believe that I can hear it now, at the age of 35. Like our friendships, the call for more requires an adjustment of perspective. There is a zero-percent chance that we will ever find ourselves—me, and Mike, and Kev—up on that church hall stage, playing music for our friends, ever again, for as long as we live. But the call is there, and the question becomes how we answer the call. And I think we answer it, in the here and now, by considering it a call for adventure and discovery and curiosity and optimism, even here, even now, even as a crusty-ass adult sitting at a dumb fucking job bored out of his fucking skull. One more song. One more. Always one more.
The big joke of The Burholme Tapes is that I'm taking this—"this" meaning the existence of and documentation of and reflection on a concert that three friends stumbled through seventeen years ago—a lot more seriously than it calls for. Yes, that's the joke! I am fully aware that to take this seriously, to think seriously that we were good or had potential, to believe seriously that I could ever go back, to try seriously to make these video seem "important" in some way, would be an exercise in futility. It would be sad. I refuse to do it unironically. Ironically, though? Hell yeah. That was the whole fucking point. Ha ha ha, remember this? How silly, and so on.
But now I watch as three lads get the crowd moving through a rendition of "Twist and Shout," a party classic, hearts fully on sleeve, the whole fucking crowd singing along with their hands in the air, and now I'm thinking that maybe it's more than a joke. Maybe we can take this seriously. Not in a literal sense—"Don't look back, you can never look back"—but in a lessons-learned sort of way.
Those lessons? That music is awesome, in any form. That completing a task and having fun doing so can be fulfilling and can ripple through the ages. That sharing interests with other people is emotionally healthy. That I should shoot Mike and Kev another text even if they keep ignoring me. That I had something special back then and that I should be thankful, even in the face of a thousand other special moments that have occurred in the two decades since. That I want this feeling for my own kids.
On that last point. A couple months ago, my parents et al. were over our house for one reason or another, and somehow the subject of Burholme came up. Specifically, the fact that Burholme had practiced, loudly, in my parents' garage for those couple of years in high school, at a volume that could be heard by the entire block of houses and so especially within my own house, on the ground floor, where my parents were hanging out, listening to us practice, whether they wanted to or not. And my dad made it seem to me, here in 2024, that this had been a problem. That he was annoyed that we were there.
And he's like "you'll see, one day your own kids will do something like that, and it'll annoy you too," and I refused to agree with him. I don't agree now. I said I don't agree out loud and he took a video of me disagreeing because he's a fucking boomer who thinks he's going to be able to embarrass me one day with it, or prove me wrong. Fuck out of here with that shit. No. I am an adult and I am a parent, and I told him and I will tell you now: if any or all of my daughters start a band and practice in my basement and I can hear that shit blasting through my ears as if the amp was right next to me, I will love it and I will soak up every moment.
Because I know what it's like to be in that moment, in a basement or garage like that, playing music with your friends. I know how great that feels. And I would walk over hot coals and eat broken glass and burn Burholme woods to the fucking ground if it means my daughters get to experience that too.
Despite the impression you may have gotten from this concert footage presented on the blog over the course of six months or so, Burholme the band does not need to live on. It can be buried. There was value in the music and the experience, but there's no value in trying to keep it alive in its corporeal form. The value comes from what we got from those experiences in a past life, and how we take all that into the next life and reinvent it or at least reinvest it.
This teenage garage rock cover band doesn't mean shit, but the idea of the existence of any teenage garage rock cover band means everything. To do this, and to do it when you are young, is probably one of the most important things you could do.
Now twist a little closer, and let me know that your mine.
Thanks for taking this journey into the past with me. Now let us continue into the future. Rest in peace, Burholme.
Those lessons? That music is awesome, in any form. That completing a task and having fun doing so can be fulfilling and can ripple through the ages. That sharing interests with other people is emotionally healthy. That I should shoot Mike and Kev another text even if they keep ignoring me. That I had something special back then and that I should be thankful, even in the face of a thousand other special moments that have occurred in the two decades since. That I want this feeling for my own kids.
On that last point. A couple months ago, my parents et al. were over our house for one reason or another, and somehow the subject of Burholme came up. Specifically, the fact that Burholme had practiced, loudly, in my parents' garage for those couple of years in high school, at a volume that could be heard by the entire block of houses and so especially within my own house, on the ground floor, where my parents were hanging out, listening to us practice, whether they wanted to or not. And my dad made it seem to me, here in 2024, that this had been a problem. That he was annoyed that we were there.
And he's like "you'll see, one day your own kids will do something like that, and it'll annoy you too," and I refused to agree with him. I don't agree now. I said I don't agree out loud and he took a video of me disagreeing because he's a fucking boomer who thinks he's going to be able to embarrass me one day with it, or prove me wrong. Fuck out of here with that shit. No. I am an adult and I am a parent, and I told him and I will tell you now: if any or all of my daughters start a band and practice in my basement and I can hear that shit blasting through my ears as if the amp was right next to me, I will love it and I will soak up every moment.
Because I know what it's like to be in that moment, in a basement or garage like that, playing music with your friends. I know how great that feels. And I would walk over hot coals and eat broken glass and burn Burholme woods to the fucking ground if it means my daughters get to experience that too.
Despite the impression you may have gotten from this concert footage presented on the blog over the course of six months or so, Burholme the band does not need to live on. It can be buried. There was value in the music and the experience, but there's no value in trying to keep it alive in its corporeal form. The value comes from what we got from those experiences in a past life, and how we take all that into the next life and reinvent it or at least reinvest it.
This teenage garage rock cover band doesn't mean shit, but the idea of the existence of any teenage garage rock cover band means everything. To do this, and to do it when you are young, is probably one of the most important things you could do.
Now twist a little closer, and let me know that your mine.
Thanks for taking this journey into the past with me. Now let us continue into the future. Rest in peace, Burholme.