"Jesus of Suburbia"
originally by Green Day
It started as a challenge. As a challenge to ourselves or to other rival bands, I don't remember. Maybe a little of this and a little of that.
"Rival bands?!" I can hear you exclaim. Yes. I don't want to exaggerate the "rival" aspect of it, but I can't imagine you assumed that Burholme was the only working teenage garage band in the Great Northeast Philadelphia Region. This is what you do when you're young and you have a little free time and you can play a musical instrument.
One of those bands that I played drums in predates Burholme. Telling this short anecdote threatens to rip the narrative away from the band we're focusing on here in this column, so I'm sorry. But I swear it's relevant to this song, so bear with me. The band's name was T.H.E., which was a backronym for "Three Horny Elephants." Also a misnomer, since there were four of us... and we weren't elephants, we were humans (horny for sure, though). There was actually a tongue-in-cheek and semi-fictional "oral history" written about this little side quest in my life on the blog already. If you click here, you can find it if you scroll down about 4/5ths of the way (sorry!).
"Rival bands?!" I can hear you exclaim. Yes. I don't want to exaggerate the "rival" aspect of it, but I can't imagine you assumed that Burholme was the only working teenage garage band in the Great Northeast Philadelphia Region. This is what you do when you're young and you have a little free time and you can play a musical instrument.
One of those bands that I played drums in predates Burholme. Telling this short anecdote threatens to rip the narrative away from the band we're focusing on here in this column, so I'm sorry. But I swear it's relevant to this song, so bear with me. The band's name was T.H.E., which was a backronym for "Three Horny Elephants." Also a misnomer, since there were four of us... and we weren't elephants, we were humans (horny for sure, though). There was actually a tongue-in-cheek and semi-fictional "oral history" written about this little side quest in my life on the blog already. If you click here, you can find it if you scroll down about 4/5ths of the way (sorry!).
Two things had happened in quick succession—Joe G. burned me a copy of American Idiot, and Joe G. brought his guitar over to my garage to "jam." My cousin Andrew brought his guitar too, and Matt S. was learning bass. Someone (probably me) had the awful idea of attempting to make "Jesus of Suburbia" our first song. Predictably, it did not go well. As it turns out, four rank amateurs at the beginning stages of learning their respective instruments were not able to adequately produce a veritable copy of a ten-minutes-long and five-parts-long punk-rock opus. The band stalled quickly after the attempt.
The history is not clean here. There was overlap. It wasn't like I quit T.H.E. one day and joined Burholme the next. Mike had, I assume, picked up the guitar sooner than Joe G. did, and was in my parents' garage possibly even before T.H.E. had made their go at it. I don't remember. I don't remember anything, apparently. But here's something interesting. In another Puke on Your Birthday column, I'm wiling away a few minutes a week rewriting entries from my old Xanga, and I'm currently moving through early 2005. In one recent entry, I was talking about early stabs at sobriety, and happened to mention "my band," referring to T.H.E. Here is one of the comments that was left on that post:
Now, it says "Anonymous," but I get the sense that this is Mike writing, right? He says "noone [sic] ever listens to mike," and he seems a little sarcastic when he says "your band." When Xanga.com went down, and I moved my files over to Wordpress for safekeeping, many of the comments' user tags were changed to "Anonymous" for some reason, so for all I know, this could've been listed as a comment from "Mike S." originally, if it is indeed him.
I think my point here being that there is evidence—weak evidence, sure, but it's there—that Mike had something to prove when it came to jamming in the Rockledge garage. It's not a coincidence that one of the first songs that Burholme learned was "Jesus of Suburbia." It makes sense logically, chronologically, emotionally—fuck those other guys, let's do this.
So... here it is. "Jesus of Suburbia," still one of my favorite songs of all time, presented through the lens of Burholme, a garage band in Northeast Philadelphia in the mid-'00s. There are three different videos on today's blog post featuring various performances of this song, totaling almost 30 minutes of Burholme for you.
The history is not clean here. There was overlap. It wasn't like I quit T.H.E. one day and joined Burholme the next. Mike had, I assume, picked up the guitar sooner than Joe G. did, and was in my parents' garage possibly even before T.H.E. had made their go at it. I don't remember. I don't remember anything, apparently. But here's something interesting. In another Puke on Your Birthday column, I'm wiling away a few minutes a week rewriting entries from my old Xanga, and I'm currently moving through early 2005. In one recent entry, I was talking about early stabs at sobriety, and happened to mention "my band," referring to T.H.E. Here is one of the comments that was left on that post:
Anonymous: Hahahahahahaha.... republicans have a phrase for a change of heart like this: FLIP-FLOPPER!!!!!!!!.... soo once again im ahead of the times in my philosophy cause thats what ive been sayin the WHOLE damn time.... and NOONE EVER listens to mike cause you know hes never ever right about stuff.... o well sucks for your band———–>actually dont really care about them but sucks for YOU that your band got caught
Death to the system....
Now, it says "Anonymous," but I get the sense that this is Mike writing, right? He says "noone [sic] ever listens to mike," and he seems a little sarcastic when he says "your band." When Xanga.com went down, and I moved my files over to Wordpress for safekeeping, many of the comments' user tags were changed to "Anonymous" for some reason, so for all I know, this could've been listed as a comment from "Mike S." originally, if it is indeed him.
I think my point here being that there is evidence—weak evidence, sure, but it's there—that Mike had something to prove when it came to jamming in the Rockledge garage. It's not a coincidence that one of the first songs that Burholme learned was "Jesus of Suburbia." It makes sense logically, chronologically, emotionally—fuck those other guys, let's do this.
So... here it is. "Jesus of Suburbia," still one of my favorite songs of all time, presented through the lens of Burholme, a garage band in Northeast Philadelphia in the mid-'00s. There are three different videos on today's blog post featuring various performances of this song, totaling almost 30 minutes of Burholme for you.
That we were able to play the song at all was, I think, a success. It's a difficult song. Maybe not when broken down, but when put together, all those transitions and all those variations on punk music, it can't possibly be considered "easy" for a band of our ilk to play. I'm saying that it was completely understandable that T.H.E. was unable to pull it off, and I'm saying that it is commendable that Burholme eventually could.
I was debating whether to say the following: "This is emblematic of everything that Burholme did wrong, musically." But I only think that's half-true. Sure, a ten-minute medley is gonna expose a lot of your faults. At the same time, the fact that a band is playing a fucking ten-minute rock medley is just really cool, in my opinion, and definitely papers over some of the imperfections that might come up in such a situation.
There's a lot to talk about / marvel over / complain about here, at least when we're talking about the music itself. Like: while it's kind of funny to stick a few classic Green Day songs in the middle of a (then) modern one, it only works if you can really perfect those classic songs, because everyone knows them, and I don't think we got there. The drums in the brief snippet of "Longview" make me cringe. It's not just that I wasn't playing the right beat, it's also that my tom-toms are way too hollow-sounding. Tré Cool's has a sort of thud to them, and my shitty Mapex set couldn't do it justice. Doesn't help that the songs falter energy-wise during these parts. It just seems so fucking quiet in that Church Hall during "Longview" and "When I Come Around," et al.
I was debating whether to say the following: "This is emblematic of everything that Burholme did wrong, musically." But I only think that's half-true. Sure, a ten-minute medley is gonna expose a lot of your faults. At the same time, the fact that a band is playing a fucking ten-minute rock medley is just really cool, in my opinion, and definitely papers over some of the imperfections that might come up in such a situation.
There's a lot to talk about / marvel over / complain about here, at least when we're talking about the music itself. Like: while it's kind of funny to stick a few classic Green Day songs in the middle of a (then) modern one, it only works if you can really perfect those classic songs, because everyone knows them, and I don't think we got there. The drums in the brief snippet of "Longview" make me cringe. It's not just that I wasn't playing the right beat, it's also that my tom-toms are way too hollow-sounding. Tré Cool's has a sort of thud to them, and my shitty Mapex set couldn't do it justice. Doesn't help that the songs falter energy-wise during these parts. It just seems so fucking quiet in that Church Hall during "Longview" and "When I Come Around," et al.
I get the joke. Here's a long and complicated song, let's make it even longer and more complicated. Remember, this was a flex over previous NEasty teen rock band lineups. We felt, either consciously or subconsciously, that this needed to be BIG. That's why you have the classic songs. That's why "St. Jimmy" and "Wake Me Up When September Ends" are tacked on to the end. That's why you have... a fucking harmonica? No one was fooled: I don't know how to play the harmonica, I was just fucking around up there. It wasn't that I was trying to impress with a secondary instrument. It was more that we was trying to impress with a "everything and the kitchen sink" credo. Results may vary.
Can we just briefly talk about how bad the drumming is? I know I'm already being selfish with the spotlight in today's narrative, but it's just really so bad. I hate it. The aforementioned tom-toms are an issue in all three iterations. Also an issue is the fourth section of the punk-rock suite, titled "IV. Dearly Beloved" (now that I'm thinking about it, I guess we usually skipped "III. I Don't Care"? I had forgotten about that). I don't understand why I felt the need to double the beat... I also don't understand why we needed to label such a beat as "polka." I'm sure it was funny at the time, but it just sounds fucking bad now. I'm sorry.
And then there's the drum solos. The thing about "Jesus of Suburbia" is that it has a drummer spotlight baked right into the first section. The end of Part 1 has some really tight fills, and if you watch the version from the final show, I think they go about as well as you could imagine. But in both of the other versions—the Roman Battle of the Bands, and another Church Hall show circa 2006—the middle section devolves into some really pointless and aimless soloing. The mallets even make an appearance at one point! Jesus fucking christ of suburbia. So bad.
It's not all bad. Here's the good part that I noticed, the specific aspect to this song that I really love (beyond the general appreciation for playing a good song good enough). This only happens in the final, and by far tightest, version of the song. During "II. City of the Damned," after Mike sings the title of the section in the first line of its chorus, Kev and I yell "HEY!!!" as loud as we can. This wasn't a flourish; it's accurate, per the official studio version on the Green Day album. But it also sounds triumphant. Something about a good "Hey!" really gets my rocks off. This was a good one.
Can we just briefly talk about how bad the drumming is? I know I'm already being selfish with the spotlight in today's narrative, but it's just really so bad. I hate it. The aforementioned tom-toms are an issue in all three iterations. Also an issue is the fourth section of the punk-rock suite, titled "IV. Dearly Beloved" (now that I'm thinking about it, I guess we usually skipped "III. I Don't Care"? I had forgotten about that). I don't understand why I felt the need to double the beat... I also don't understand why we needed to label such a beat as "polka." I'm sure it was funny at the time, but it just sounds fucking bad now. I'm sorry.
And then there's the drum solos. The thing about "Jesus of Suburbia" is that it has a drummer spotlight baked right into the first section. The end of Part 1 has some really tight fills, and if you watch the version from the final show, I think they go about as well as you could imagine. But in both of the other versions—the Roman Battle of the Bands, and another Church Hall show circa 2006—the middle section devolves into some really pointless and aimless soloing. The mallets even make an appearance at one point! Jesus fucking christ of suburbia. So bad.
It's not all bad. Here's the good part that I noticed, the specific aspect to this song that I really love (beyond the general appreciation for playing a good song good enough). This only happens in the final, and by far tightest, version of the song. During "II. City of the Damned," after Mike sings the title of the section in the first line of its chorus, Kev and I yell "HEY!!!" as loud as we can. This wasn't a flourish; it's accurate, per the official studio version on the Green Day album. But it also sounds triumphant. Something about a good "Hey!" really gets my rocks off. This was a good one.
No comments:
Post a Comment