1940
George Cukor
As we saw last time, when the word "Philadelphia" is in the title of the movie, that might be a hint that it's gonna hit a little close to home. The Philadelphia Story, though more related to a Philadelphia that I'm only nominally familiar with (Main Line high society, technically not even Philadelphia), actually ends up closer to my heart for a coincidental reason. Or maybe it's not coincidental; maybe this is the reason The Philadelphia Story ended up on this list in the first place. In any case, it was tough to concentrate on the task at hand, for a reason I'll reveal in a moment.
First—hey, great movie here. I'm definitely at the point where I can mostly trust an "old" movie to be worthy of my time if it's lasted this long and made its way across this many decades to reach me. I'm not watching any shitty 83-year-old movies; all those were forgotten before I was born. There's star power here that keeps the memory alive. This is the fourth movie I've seen with Jimmy Stewart, and that's about two more than I needed to know that this dude is one of the best actors of all time. Katharine Hepburn proved why she holds the record for most acting Oscars won by any one person. I knew Cary Grant's name but didn't know what he looked like, and The Philadelphia Story proves I won't forget him any time soon.
While it was fun watching some of the best that ever was snipe and crack wit across a two-hour comedy, I couldn't help but be distracted. You see, La Salle University performed the stage version of The Philadelphia Story the semester before I arrived on campus, and joining the Masque that fall, I heard a lot about the last play that these jabronis did. I've never seen their version, and I don't plan on seeing it, but I know every person who acted in it, and I was giggling the whole time I was watching the 1940 film version, imagining my friends as these characters on the stage. My original plan was to look up the cast list after the movie was over, but I couldn't wait. It probably would've been better if I had waited, because now the story here—my Philadelphia Story story, as presented by PoYB—necessarily becomes something totally different. It becomes how art and life intersect, and inform each other in weird ways.
The Spring 2007 cast is a great mix of graduating classes—some people whom I had one year with in '07-'08, when they were seniors, and some people who were freshman while in Philadelphia Story and thus were stuck with me for three years. There were two seniors whose collegiate years never intersected with mine—one writes for PoYB regularly, and one I can see on the Megan's Law website whenever I want. A few regular blog writers on the cast, and another few who have their old blogs on the blogroll still. Some I talk to every week it seems like, some I haven't seen in years. I probably won't drop any names in this blog post, even though many of you know the people I'm writing about anyway. It lends an air of mystique to the affair.
As soon as the credits rolled, I text my pal who played Hepburn's part, Tracy Lord. I hit her with a bad joke: "Marry / Fuck / Kill: [friend who played George Kittredge], [friend who played C.K. Dexter Haven], [friend who played Macaulay "Mike" Connor]." The joke is double-sided, since 1) I'm referencing a play that she acted in in 2007 in a text sent randomly to her on a Saturday afternoon in 2023 and expecting that she's going to get the reference without being told, and 2) she literally ended up marrying the guy who played Mike Connor, which means that she was legally obligated by Improv 101 law to not choose him for the "Marry" in the MFK equation.
This also means that my two friends who ended up getting married had a stage kiss, lending credence to my ancient theory that "a stage kiss means something." Per my friend, the director claimed that their kiss was "not believable." Prior to having seen The Philadelphia Story, I would have taken the director's claim as dramatic irony—an allegedly non-believable kiss is literally impossible to disbelieve now that they have kissed on the altar to become husband and wife. After having seen The Philadelphia Story, I view it a different way—that the director was a fucking moron, since it doesn't seem like the kiss between Tracy Lord and Mike Connor was supposed to be believable, since they were both extremely drunk and making a huge mistake, and so shouldn't Celeste Walker (okay, I have to say at least one name here) have encouraged the stage kiss to look "non-believable," since that was truer to character? Doesn't this just mean my friends are good actors? And then does this also mean that the friend whom I often get lunch with in the city can do a serviceable Jimmy Stewart impression that he's never deigned to show me?
But see, this is what I'm talking about regarding the intersection of art and life. Where do we draw the line between acting as a way of channeling truth and acting as a way of becoming someone new? My friend who played Dinah Lord, the little sister and shit-stirrer of the Lord clan, was probably perfect in her role. I laugh when I think about it because she is short and must have definitely embodied an eleven-year-old character, but also because my friend is not by any means a shit-stirrer, and so it must have been funny to see her act like one. Same thing with my old pal who played Uncle Willie. The man was the true archetype of the Lasallian Gentlemen in real life, and I have no doubt that he was a delight as a creepy old man who pinched women's butts (especially since he was acting next to, I'll mention again, a dude who literally ended up on Megan's Law—talk about dramatic irony). Not to mention my friend who played Tracy was a real-life rival to my friend who played Liz Imbrie, and how the characters are more or less rivals in the story as well, and how I wasn't aware of this real-life story until I entered school in media res a year later, and how I'm now sitting here wondering whether that rivalry existed in the spring of 2007, or if it sprung from this play, or if it predates it, and if the rivalry informed the performances, or if it's fucked up that I'm even writing about this obliquely on the blog. I don't know.
I'm thinking too about how The Philadelphia Story (1940) came to be—Katharine Hepburn being gifted the film rights to the play adaptation by Howard Hughes, and Hepburn using it as a sort of "comeback" after a few flops, and shoring up those prospects by enlisting the other A-listers (Grant and Stewart), and the three of them using their talents and chemistry to create what is generally considered one of the funniest movies of all time. You think about The Philadelphia Story, and you think about the people who made it. Screenwriter Donald Ogden Stewart, when he won his Oscar for adapting the play into this script, infamously proclaimed in his speech, "I have no one to thank but myself!" It's only a notable speech because of how untrue it is.
And it makes me think about La Salle's Philadelphia Story, and how it is only remembered now by people like me because of the people who made it. As far as I'm aware, there was no one involved in that play that was saying such bullshit like "I have no one to thank but myself." Reading through the "Meet the Cast" blurbs in the program (which exists online, but you'll have to find it yourself), I'm struck by how loving and thankful each cast member's words are. More dramatic irony abound, too. My pal who played a couple of characters who might not have even survived into the film adaptation (named Elsie and May in the play) thanks her future husband and says to him that she's "smiling," around six months before they officially started dating (and a decade or so before they both started writing for Puke on Your Birthday). My pal who plays Tracy's mother thanks a girl named Pam for being a "true friend," a friendship that would last until (and beyond) the night that she (and Tracy) introduced me to Pam, four years before I married that Pam. All the cast thank yous ring so sincere to me, and really give me a sense that this was a tight-knit cast, as the best plays inevitably end up being.
That love and grace ripples over to the film adaptation that I just watched. You get a sense of joy when you watch movies like this. That joy and satisfaction that you're feeling is the outcome of a group of people committing to a labor of love. The witticisms and the charm and the goofiness on the screen makes me smile, but the real happiness is knowing what it took to bring it to my eyes in the first place. This is the real way that art imitates life and life imitates art—there's so much joy in what goes on here, and I want to be here for it for as long as I can.
I'm thinking too about how The Philadelphia Story (1940) came to be—Katharine Hepburn being gifted the film rights to the play adaptation by Howard Hughes, and Hepburn using it as a sort of "comeback" after a few flops, and shoring up those prospects by enlisting the other A-listers (Grant and Stewart), and the three of them using their talents and chemistry to create what is generally considered one of the funniest movies of all time. You think about The Philadelphia Story, and you think about the people who made it. Screenwriter Donald Ogden Stewart, when he won his Oscar for adapting the play into this script, infamously proclaimed in his speech, "I have no one to thank but myself!" It's only a notable speech because of how untrue it is.
And it makes me think about La Salle's Philadelphia Story, and how it is only remembered now by people like me because of the people who made it. As far as I'm aware, there was no one involved in that play that was saying such bullshit like "I have no one to thank but myself." Reading through the "Meet the Cast" blurbs in the program (which exists online, but you'll have to find it yourself), I'm struck by how loving and thankful each cast member's words are. More dramatic irony abound, too. My pal who played a couple of characters who might not have even survived into the film adaptation (named Elsie and May in the play) thanks her future husband and says to him that she's "smiling," around six months before they officially started dating (and a decade or so before they both started writing for Puke on Your Birthday). My pal who plays Tracy's mother thanks a girl named Pam for being a "true friend," a friendship that would last until (and beyond) the night that she (and Tracy) introduced me to Pam, four years before I married that Pam. All the cast thank yous ring so sincere to me, and really give me a sense that this was a tight-knit cast, as the best plays inevitably end up being.
That love and grace ripples over to the film adaptation that I just watched. You get a sense of joy when you watch movies like this. That joy and satisfaction that you're feeling is the outcome of a group of people committing to a labor of love. The witticisms and the charm and the goofiness on the screen makes me smile, but the real happiness is knowing what it took to bring it to my eyes in the first place. This is the real way that art imitates life and life imitates art—there's so much joy in what goes on here, and I want to be here for it for as long as I can.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: We're watching The Pink Panther, which I can promise you La Salle University's The Masque did not perform at any point, as far as I'm aware.

No comments:
Post a Comment