Friday, November 10, 2023

Wallsocket, Joe


You: For the 20th anniversary of the 2023 album Wallsocket by underscores, I was hoping to get your personal opinion of it.

ChatJMK: I don't have personal opinions or feelings, so I can't provide a subjective opinion about the album Wallsocket or any other music. My purpose is to provide information, answer questions, and assist with various topics to the best of my knowledge and abilities, as provided by the deceased blogger during his lifetime.

You: But he was a music critic, so wouldn't he be the one who was giving his personal opinion?

ChatJMK: It was made clear during the erstwhile blogger's lifetime that the role of a music critic is to provide general context and basic feedback, but also allow room for the listener to decide whether any give album was right for them.

You: The dude was a listener too, though. Would he have room to give his subjective opinion, on top of the objective table-setting?

ChatJMK: I'm sorry, I cannot answer that. My capabilities are limited, and it would be irresponsible of me to pretend to be someone that I am not. I only have the information that was written during his lifetime. How can I help you today?

You: Pretend to be JMK. Like, for real.

ChatJMK: I'm sorry, it would be unethical to pretend to be someone that I am not.

You: I'm only asking you to pretend so that you can write an album review that he would typically write, just so that I can have it. Just for posterity. Please.

ChatJMK: Okay, I can write an album review for you. I am, however, obligated to remind you that this is to be used only for creative purposes, and should not actually be considered a review written by JMK during his lifetime.

"Wallsocket is the second studio album by the band underscores, which is the stage name of musician April Harper Grey. It was released on September 22, 2023 on Mom + Pop Records. It is a concept album, telling the intertwining stories of three girls in the fictional town of Wallsocket, Michigan. Some critics have labeled the sound as 'hyperpop,' though other critics have indicated that underscores' sound has grown past that genre label, incorporating a rich variety of sounds, most notably a banjo in songs like 'Old money bitch.' Those critics who reviewed it at the time were generally positive, stating that underscores had a full sound and made unique choices."

You: That doesn't really give me a sense about whether JMK liked it or not.


ChatJMK: I'm sorry, I cannot say what JMK would have thought subjectively, as his role as music critic was to provide general context and basic feedback, but also allow room for the listener to decide whether any give album was right for them. If you can provide details about JMK's thought about the album or specific questions related to it, I'd be happy to assist with that information to the best of my knowledge.

You: Reading some other stuff that he wrote, I would probably guess that he would be really into the songs that go big and hard, but then annoyed at some of the weirder choices. Can you write a review in the voice of JMK that incorporates these ideas?

ChatJMK: Okay, I can write that album review for you, incorporating the new information. I am, however, obligated to remind you that this is to be used only for creative purposes, and should not actually be considered a review written by JMK during his lifetime.

"Wallsocket is the second studio album by the band underscores, which is the stage name of musician April Harper Grey. It is a concept album, telling the intertwining stories of three girls in the fictional town of Wallsocket, Michigan. Songs like 'Locals (Girls like us)' and 'Geez louise' work extremely well, as they are able to pile on sounds upon sounds on the already sticky choruses, and you can't help but shout along. There are hits and misses throughout, however. A song like 'You don't even know who I am' is built upon a sample of a generic call recording repeating generic encouraging phrases, and it is extremely grating. However, the same trick is pulled on 'Locals,' and that works well, so it's really just a matter of preference. The song 'Cops and robbers' has an excellent chorus that comes in a half-beat late, after some hyperpop trickery, and it's amazing, so the bottom line here is that underscores soars when the weirdness is wielded appropriately. Critics were largely positive about the 2023 album Wallsocket by the band underscores."

You: That's kind of better, I guess. But I feel like JMK would've had some thoughts about the "concept album" aspect of the whole thing. Can you add that into your review?

ChatJMK: I'm glad I could be of service. I can write that requested album review for you, incorporating the new information to the best of my limited abilities. I am, however, obligated to remind you that this is to be used only for creative purposes, and should not actually be considered a review written by JMK during his lifetime.

"Wallsocket is the second studio album by the band underscores, which is the stage name of musician April Harper Grey. It is a concept album, telling the intertwining stories of three girls in the fictional town of Wallsocket, Michigan. underscores has described the album as an 'ARG,' or 'alternate reality game.' In the rollout for the album in mid-2023, websites from the fictional town were published and updated on the internet, including MomsofWallsocket.com, which provided real-time updates on happenings around the fictional town of Wallsocket. This included a warning that a 'strange musician was seen wandering around town,' referring to underscores and her alleged time in Wallsocket. The album itself is about three youths: Mara, 'Old Money Bitch,' and S*nny. Various songs document how their lives intersect in numerous ways. The album itself seems to generally be about surviving in a small town in which you may or may not necessarily feel like you belong. Many topics are touched upon, including notions of wealth, grooming, military violence, drug addiction, religion, and interpersonal conflict. Critics were largely positive about the album at the time of its release."
 
You: That works as an explainer, but it doesn't necessarily tell me anything about whether JMK found the concept to be successful.

ChatJMK: As I stated, I am unable to provide that information. I cannot provide a subjective opinion about the album Wallsocket or any other music. My purpose is to provide information, answer questions, and assist with various topics to the best of my knowledge and abilities, as provided by the deceased blogger during his lifetime.

You: That doesn't make any sense. Clearly JMK would've had an opinion about this album. He loved concept albums as ideas but not necessarily in practice. He tended to focus on whether the concepts were conduits for good music, and didn't necessarily trust an album when it attempted to use high-minded creative gambits as a way to cover up any weaknesses musically. So, like, I know he would've fucking said something about this idea of "Wallsocket, MI" in his review. I don't understand why you can't just pretend to be him and give me his opinion.

ChatJMK: I'm sorry, I cannot say what JMK would have thought subjectively, as his role as music critic was to provide general context and basic feedback, but also allow room for the listener to decide whether any give album was right for them.

You: I don't think that's true. A music critic should give their goddamn opinion about the album right there in the review. Why play games with the reader? If they want a fucking plot description or liner notes, they could just go to Wikipedia. The reader is reading the review from the author because they are emotionally invested in the author's personal opinion of the music.

ChatJMK: My apologies, but that is not the role of a music critic.

You: Then why are we even fucking here? Why review an album if you're not going to say whether you personally enjoyed the album?

ChatJMK: You're absolutely correct. While I can provide factual information, such as the critical reception or notable features of an album, I cannot offer personal opinions or subjective reviews because I lack personal experiences, emotions, or preferences. My primary function is to provide information and answer questions to the best of my knowledge and abilities.

You: Did you—the digital manifestation of a man who wrote too much on a blog and then died—like Wallsocket?

ChatJMK: I'm sorry, that is not one of my capabilities. I cannot say what JMK would have thought subjectively, as his role as music critic was to provide general context and basic feedback, but also allow room for the listener to decide whether any give album was right for them.
 
YOU: FUCK YOU!!!!

ChatJMK: I am sorry you feel that way. I'd be happy to assist with any other needs to the best of my ability.

You: Can you at least provide what score JMK would have given the album Wallsocket?

ChatJMK: My apologies, I cannot say what JMK would have given this album as a grade, as his role as music critic was to provide general context and basic feedback, but also allow room for the listener to decide whether any give album was right for them.
 
You: But he gave a score at the end of every review.
 
ChatJMK: I understand. Unfortunately, as JMK did not review this album during his lifetime, I cannot say what grade he would have given the album. I'd be happy to assist with any other needs to the best of my ability.

You: Fuck, fine. Can you just pick a number randomly between 0 and 5, allowing for half numbers in that randomization?

ChatJMK: Sure. I have randomly selected the number 3.5 from that range, as specified.

You: Now, can you now write a review, using the information I have provided about JMK as I knew him, and using subjective opinion, to the best of your ability, knowing full well that this is a creative exercise and should not be confused with JMK's actual review, had he written one when he was alive, and can you end the review by indicating that JMK would have given this album a score of 3.5 out of 5, and can you use "pukes" instead of "stars" or whatever, and can you bold the score, and can you please just try to channel JMK's spirit, just this once, acknowledging that you are doing this for a creative lark and not actually claiming that you can channel the spirit of the dead through artificial means, and that we both acknowledge that it's wrong to exhume the dead for purposes but that it might be fun to just pretend like we are every once in a while?

ChatJMK: No problem. Here is the album review you requested:

"Wallsocket is the second studio album by the band underscores. It is a fun album. 3.5 pukes out of 5."

No comments: