See the rest of the exit surveys HERE.
Quantity check: if we're comparing to all Thanksgiving weeks past, then we tied last year's high-water mark of five reviews. 2021: four; 2020: two; 2019: four. This week's expectations were like the complete fucking opposite of last week's. Five reviews is more than I think your typical blogger might expect during a week featuring a major holiday. Four people managed to write a review in the shortened week; Sunny pulled a classic Friday early AM hours review out of his hat, even after a large Thanksgiving meal.
Quality check: no need for one. If you're writing for fun, you're doing more than 99.9% of your American peers are doing. I appreciate the writing. I think the people who write on this blog do an amazing job every time they sit in front of the keyboard. Good work, friends.
2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?
Same. There was a tolerance for this music, and a willingness to meet the artist on their own terms instead of imposing your own modern-day musical expectations on a 1970s avant-garde expression of weirdness. Opinions varied, but only starting from that bedrock of understanding. Nate always does a good job of holding something at a remove and appreciating its value from that vantage point ("it's unlistenable...yet" is a good way to find the distance needed). Walter always does a good job of picking out one detail to focus on, and use that as a way to open the third eye (orgasmic indeed). Sunny always wields the question "Why?" like a blade, and doesn't even need the artist to ask the question for him first. And Gary, not gonna lie, I was expecting Gary to go hard on this, but I laughed a lot at the circumstances of his week (not a mean-spirited laughter though, I promise—painful backs are a bitch). It fit so well under the circumstances! Light psychedelics for the hip Beatles-adjacent crowd!
3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?
Nah, not really. I was more appreciative of the very specific ways that everyone reached pretty much the same conclusion. Not every week of Record Club is going to offer a plethora of opinions. Sometimes an album like this comes along and it ends up that one unifying response is absolutely warranted. But that doesn't make it a boring experience. The beauty is in the margins. I always say that a good blog post features three sections: 1) do you like this, 2) why do you like this, 3) what does liking this say about you. If everyone likes (or dislikes) a thing, then that doesn't ruin the experience, because #3 makes every response unique regardless.
4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?
Kinda shocked that there weren't more words spilled about the Beatles in the reviews. Maybe it had something to do with the AotW write-up purposefully not mentioning them, but I'd like to have more faith in the PoYB community than that. I think that it was instead the fact that our writers are well-informed and reasonable and intelligent and knew that Yoko Ono/Plastic Ono Band had very little to do with the Beatles as an institution. Don't let my hollering against the strawman in my review fool you—I knew that the RC writers are not the type of people who are going to be participating in such moronic bullshittery as "hur dur Yoko broke up the Beatles."
5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?
It was fine. Who cares? It's the week of Thanksgiving. The best album pick of all time is gonna be met with five reviews this week. I am sincerely glad that I understand Yoko Ono a little bit better now.
6. Any other takeaways from the reviews? Or from this experience in general?
I sincerely hate the fact that there are no spaces around the forward slash in the album's title. I usually forgo the spaces only if the slash is separating two interchangeable words, as opposed to phrases. But I also respect the artist's choices, typically, so if Yoko Ono wants to screw up punctuation, that's her prerogative. I'll abide by it.
7. What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?
One of my ideas for the new year is to turn the Sunday Record Club email into a Puke on Your Birthday email. That way I can just include all the other crap that we have going on around here (especially with all the new weekly columns coming up). Still in the planning stages.

No comments:
Post a Comment