Tuesday, November 21, 2023

Never Seen It: Pan's Addendum

After I posted my and Fisher's thoughts on Pan's Labyrinth last week, I received a letter and some pictures from PoYB Contributor Sunny, who had some wanderlust but nevertheless wanted to share his thoughts about the movie. Find below the letter (transcribed) plus a few pictures. Thanks Sunny! —Joe



preface: sorry for the delay, & sorry this is written—I have no computer here. Maybe use ChatJMK to transcribe & summarize this? But I saw you posted, so I figure I send -something- for this movie.

Pan's Labyrinth. I have no seen this movie since 2014, & before that 2006. It's stuck in my mind since, as sort of a "magical" thing. I rewatched it as the director intended—see attached photo.



The 2006 experience had a certain magic intrinsic to it—who is this GDT guy anyway? (I knew of Hellboy & Blade 2, but frankly hadn't watched either. It's this Spanish film garnering attention, we have to go into the city to watch at the Ritz, there's a bunch of crazy makeup & practical fx like this Pale Man skin walker guy... cool stuff. I recall leaving that theater feeling some real emotion, & this is in a time most movies still felt to me as fun/funny entertainment primarily.

It's funny what sticks in the memory after years:
  • the rabbits in the hunter's bag
  • the knife in the apron
  • the leg amputation
  • the Pale Man scene, in total
  • both the mouth-cutting & final death of the Captain ("he won't know your name")
What didn't so much register then, that does now:
  • the significance of Spanish civil war / fascistas / antifascistas
  • moviemaking cues (i.e. knife in apron, camera lingering on medicine bottle)
  • the whole father/son subplot for the Captain
  • Moanna's dad's a tailor, symbolism of her dress, dress getting ruined, being clothed in the end sequence, etc...
Which goes to show I was a pretty stupid kid.

I'm pleased to see the movie holds up, & is still greatly entertaining even on a shitty little screen. The whole conceit of a fairy tale makes sense—we're escaping into a movie, Moanna escapes into her books & world. The context sets a stark contrast between the seriousness of rebel war & one girl's challenge to thrive, when she's been abandoned by practically everyone.

GDT shows movie-making prowess by not letting the movie get (too) corny. The sound design, the set design is fantastic (the movie's lullaby sticks in my head). It's well-paced, well-acted, particularly from Moanna's performance, in a world where child actors often tank a whole project. The world building of both mid-century Spain & an imaginary underworld are believable. It's a fun and sweet movie.

Again, even knowing the ending, I feel an emotion ring through that final scene. The & now, I wonder what's "real," what's "in-her-head." But as I grow older, I find this distinction less important. Ultimately, it's real "for her," & so call it delusion, rationalization, fear, fantasy, or totally real, it is still a vehicle for a hero to discover her own courage & freedom. Not the greatest movie of all time, but magical & very fun.

Stray thoughts:
  • I love the fascists' toast to "choice" (not to make another IJ reference—[stick-figure drawing of a wheelchair assassin])
  • Why is "labyrinth del fauno" translated to "Pan's Labyrinth"? In school I joked all fauns are named Pan (Narnia, Shakespeare) but idk
  • GDT isn't my favorite director, but his unique voice is valuable & special. I'm sad the Kojima / GDT / Junji Ito game never happened.

a bit of tourism I saw today which reminded me of the movie

No comments: