There's a video that occasionally makes the rounds online that never fails to piss me off whenever I see it pop up. It's a video of "Memphis, Tennessee" performed by Chuck Berry, John Lennon, and Yoko Ono, on The Mike Douglas Show in 1972. The video deviously presents the situation as such: John Lennon is performing a classic Chuck Berry song with Berry himself, one of Lennon's heroes, and during their duet, Yoko Ono "ruins" the song with her screaming, causing Chuck Berry to look "bewildered" at the screaming, and allegedly causing the sound engineer to "cut the mic." The implication is that Yoko Ono is an interloper, unwelcome among these great MEN of ROCK 'N' ROLL.
The video is bullshit, and it's easy to know that it's bullshit if you take off the fucking Beatles rose-colored glasses for a goddamn second and think about it. John Lennon and Yoko Ono were guest-hosting The Mike Douglas Show that entire week, and Chuck Berry knew this when he signed up for the musical guest gig. He would have to have been a fucking moron to not understand what type of music Yoko Ono and John Lennon were making during that time. Two of the most famous people on earth. Any still-shot of Berry looking "shocked" is just clever editing, clearly designed to paint Yoko Ono in a negative light. Fuck out of here with that "Yoko is ruining John's time with his idol" patriarchal bullshit. That's just an extension of the foul racist, sexist shit that rained upon Yoko in the aftermath of the Beatles' demise. As if John Lennon was tricked by his wife. Get fucking real.
As if Chuck Berry's "Memphis, Tennessee" was some fucking paragon of creativity, either. Maybe it was in 1959. But this video (which I won't be linking to, by the way) takes place in 1972. Only thirteen years, sure, but those thirteen years featured a seismic shift in popular music, due to... well, due to John Lennon and the other Beatles. In 1972, "Memphis" was old news, a throwback. The idea of John Lennon singing "Memphis" with Chuck Berry (nine years after the Beatles covered it for the BBC) bores the hell out of me. The idea of Yoko Ono screaming bloody murder into a microphone while John Lennon and Chuck Berry rehash some fucking old chestnut of a boilerplate rock 'n' roll tune? Honestly, that excites me.
Whether you consider it "art" or not isn't really the concern here, at least not for me on the day after Thanksgiving, here in the trenches of the incredibly artless music month known as "the Christmas season." Or maybe it is. I don't know. I do know that the definition of "art" is so subjective that it might as well not even fucking exist. If art is "the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination," then Yoko Ono/Plastic Ono Band is art—in my opinion. Whether you like it or not is a completely different story. Pam asked me the other day if I could consider something like "AOS" of "Paper Shoes" to be something I would sincerely listen to of my own free will (i.e. outside of the confines of Record Club), and I don't really know. I'm glad I'm listening to it now. I'm interested in this album and why it exists (or why not), and I think it's reasonable to say that that interest lies beyond such base questions as "do you like it?"
I read a AITA post the other day that went something like: "Am I the asshole for throwing this birthday party? I wanted to try 'molecular food pairings' and so that's what I served at my party, and then my friend accidentally texted me instead of my other friend saying 'she's so fucking weird, why would she throw that type of party' and I want to know if I'm the asshole for doing so." C'mon, girl, have some self-respect. Throw the birthday party you want—it's your birthday. And if your friends don't like who you are, then it doesn't make sense that they are your friends, ya know? Doesn't sound like what a "friend" would do.
Okay, sure, 40 minutes of Yoko Ono yelping over some badass Klaus Voormann basslines and proto-punk Ringo tom-pounding is not necessarily everyone's cup of tea. Fine. But if it isn't, and your entire takeaway is "this is WEIRD," then it's like, why the fuck are you even here? The comparison to the AITA thing isn't 1:1 because you don't owe Yoko Ono anything, but not putting knee-jerk reactions aside, and not attempting to see the why here (after the first song literally asks you to do as much), and not at least attempting to find beauty in the bizarre and the weird, but instead just dismissing it outright because of its avant-garde nature, that just seems like a fucking waste of time to me. Make the effort or don't, but there's no reason to take a half-measure and then talk shit. I don't get why that's even a thing.
If I was taking my job as listener seriously—okay, fine, I don't always do that, and I don't mean to come off as pretentious in this "album review," so pretend all the ire is self-directed so you don't get offended—then maybe I'd try to construct a narrative around some of these songs. Understand the why. "Greenfield Morning I Pushed an Empty Baby Carriage All over the City" starts with a George Harrison sitar loop (that alone adds significance to the narrative, since this means that McCartney was the only Beatle not involved in the making of this album), and evolves into a sad downer shuffle beat (heavy on the low notes, that Ringo, really well done here), with some incredibly haunting wailing from our frontwoman. Consider the title, and what that might mean. Consider the fact that Yoko Ono had a history of miscarriages. Consider the fact that Ono was an artist, and had thus had (and has) the unique ability to translate immense pain into art. Now consider why Yoko might be wailing here.
There's screaming all over the album, but it's not just screaming for screaming's sake. That would be artless. There is a purpose to the screaming. There is meaning if you are looking for it.
Not saying you have to, though. Who gives a shit. If you're just looking for catchy tunes to add to the Spotify playlist, then move along. If you're looking for something a little complex and a little obtuse and a little mysterious and a little abrasive but in a good way like pulling out a long crooked beard hair that you missed during yesterday's trim, a pain that feels good in a purposeful way, then maybe here it is. But maybe not. I think you're wrong if you can hear the alien vocal sounds of "Why Not" layered on top of a looped and rock-solid rhythm section and, like, not be stopped in your tracks and be sucked in, but it is what it is.
What I don't like is some fucking asshole Redditor sneakily editing some old video to make it look like art is artless, a sniveling fucking coward hiding behind editing software, pushing an agenda that he has no right to push. I'm not saying you have to like Yoko Ono/Plastic Ono Band. There are plenty of moments on this album when I am pretty sure that I don't even like it. But it's worth considering. That's all I'm saying. I can totally understand why you'd listen to "Touch Me" and think "WOW that is a little too much for me, I don't know if I like it." But I can never fucking understand, not in a million fucking years, why you would ever listen to a song like "Touch Me" and think such churlish, vulgar thoughts like "this is nothing like the Chuck Berry songs that I love." Of course it isn't, you jag.
It's Thanksgiving. Time to take account of all the things in your life that you're thankful for. There's a lot in my life that I appreciate and am infinitely thankful of, and I don't need to list them all here. The most important thing I'm thankful of, though, at least in this context, is the fact that there is art like Yoko Ono/Plastic Ono Band out there to make life more interesting. No breadth, no wide appeal, nothing to take home to mother, sure, sure, fine, okay, but there's infinite depth here. No limit to how deep you can go with this fucking thing. That's art, baby. Don't just move along. Stop and stare for a bit. Take it in. What does it mean? And why do you think it means that?
Why? Why not?
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
Okay, sure, 40 minutes of Yoko Ono yelping over some badass Klaus Voormann basslines and proto-punk Ringo tom-pounding is not necessarily everyone's cup of tea. Fine. But if it isn't, and your entire takeaway is "this is WEIRD," then it's like, why the fuck are you even here? The comparison to the AITA thing isn't 1:1 because you don't owe Yoko Ono anything, but not putting knee-jerk reactions aside, and not attempting to see the why here (after the first song literally asks you to do as much), and not at least attempting to find beauty in the bizarre and the weird, but instead just dismissing it outright because of its avant-garde nature, that just seems like a fucking waste of time to me. Make the effort or don't, but there's no reason to take a half-measure and then talk shit. I don't get why that's even a thing.
If I was taking my job as listener seriously—okay, fine, I don't always do that, and I don't mean to come off as pretentious in this "album review," so pretend all the ire is self-directed so you don't get offended—then maybe I'd try to construct a narrative around some of these songs. Understand the why. "Greenfield Morning I Pushed an Empty Baby Carriage All over the City" starts with a George Harrison sitar loop (that alone adds significance to the narrative, since this means that McCartney was the only Beatle not involved in the making of this album), and evolves into a sad downer shuffle beat (heavy on the low notes, that Ringo, really well done here), with some incredibly haunting wailing from our frontwoman. Consider the title, and what that might mean. Consider the fact that Yoko Ono had a history of miscarriages. Consider the fact that Ono was an artist, and had thus had (and has) the unique ability to translate immense pain into art. Now consider why Yoko might be wailing here.
There's screaming all over the album, but it's not just screaming for screaming's sake. That would be artless. There is a purpose to the screaming. There is meaning if you are looking for it.
Not saying you have to, though. Who gives a shit. If you're just looking for catchy tunes to add to the Spotify playlist, then move along. If you're looking for something a little complex and a little obtuse and a little mysterious and a little abrasive but in a good way like pulling out a long crooked beard hair that you missed during yesterday's trim, a pain that feels good in a purposeful way, then maybe here it is. But maybe not. I think you're wrong if you can hear the alien vocal sounds of "Why Not" layered on top of a looped and rock-solid rhythm section and, like, not be stopped in your tracks and be sucked in, but it is what it is.
What I don't like is some fucking asshole Redditor sneakily editing some old video to make it look like art is artless, a sniveling fucking coward hiding behind editing software, pushing an agenda that he has no right to push. I'm not saying you have to like Yoko Ono/Plastic Ono Band. There are plenty of moments on this album when I am pretty sure that I don't even like it. But it's worth considering. That's all I'm saying. I can totally understand why you'd listen to "Touch Me" and think "WOW that is a little too much for me, I don't know if I like it." But I can never fucking understand, not in a million fucking years, why you would ever listen to a song like "Touch Me" and think such churlish, vulgar thoughts like "this is nothing like the Chuck Berry songs that I love." Of course it isn't, you jag.
It's Thanksgiving. Time to take account of all the things in your life that you're thankful for. There's a lot in my life that I appreciate and am infinitely thankful of, and I don't need to list them all here. The most important thing I'm thankful of, though, at least in this context, is the fact that there is art like Yoko Ono/Plastic Ono Band out there to make life more interesting. No breadth, no wide appeal, nothing to take home to mother, sure, sure, fine, okay, but there's infinite depth here. No limit to how deep you can go with this fucking thing. That's art, baby. Don't just move along. Stop and stare for a bit. Take it in. What does it mean? And why do you think it means that?
Why? Why not?
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment