Tuesday, November 14, 2023

Top Ten Albums of 2013 (Revisited)

god fucking damn do i love google images

A common complaint regarding Record Club is that having one single week to absorb an entire album for critical analysis just simply is not enough time. One of the core principles of RC is that this fact is acknowledged and ignored as we attempt to review albums after one week anyway, but still, doesn't mean the criticism is wrong. That isn't enough time.

The same could be said about critics' Best Of lists at the end of each year, when everyone who's anyone gathers their thoughts and ranks their favorite albums of the year. Maybe a year isn't enough time either. I would say that's fair. Calendars are arbitrary markers of time, and who says that we have to say what's "best" before that arbitrary marker reaches its end?

A trend I've seen recently is that some folks are redoing their Year's Best lists ten years later. Is a decade enough time to say what the best is? I'm not sure. Maybe that's not enough time either. Maybe a lifetime isn't enough time. In any case, it's been a decade since I ranked my favorite albums from 2013, and I thought it might be fun to redo that list. I've grown to love albums that I wasn't even aware of while living in 2013, and I've discarded albums from artists that have revealed themselves to be not worthy of our adoration. Plus, my tastes have changed and evolved in ten years. I am older (definitely) and wiser (definitely not).

Top Ten Albums of 2013 (as of 2023)

HONORABLE MENTIONS: The Bones of What You Believe by Chvrches; B-Room by Dr. Dog; Cerulean Salt by Waxahatchee; Muchacho by Phosphorescent; Surfing Strange by Swearin'

10. Love Sign by Free Energy

Love Sign works as both an underlining and a doubling down of everything that went right on the self-titled debut. Big crunchy guitars, sticky hooks, and a pervasive feeling of love and brotherhood throughout—this is classic "good times" music. I appreciated it in 2013, though its #6 ranking was probably more indicative of how little music I was digesting back then rather than any sort of overrating.

I actually get the sense that I underrated it at the time. That's because we had no idea that this was to be Free Energy's final statement before disappearing into the ether. Albums like this make it seem like the artist is going to live forever. But Free Energy, like youth, has a shelf life. As the years progress as a rapidly accelerating clip, I find myself thinking back and remembering and cherishing every moment.

9. Pure Heroine by Lorde

There was no one single moment when I disavowed childish notions of "if it's popular, it must be bad." It was instead a gradual process that took over a decade to undo. Lorde's galactically popular Pure Heroine was the sort of album I would've held at some distance ten years ago. I was familiar with the hits, of course. Who wasn't? Religious nuts who don't own radios, maybe? But it took me till well after 2013 ended to admit that this was music worth pursuing.

I'm glad I finally did pursue it, though. This is pop music in its leanest and most spartan form. A programmed drum track, maybe a single warbling note, and the voice of a teenager who seems like she's way too cool for this, and she knows it. Something about it seems sincere and honest to me. The coolness isn't a marketing pitch. It's just someone who is cool. Lorde is cool. She's remained cool in the decade since, but an album like this can't be repeated. The word "pure" in the title is fitting in this way. Once megastardom touches you, you can't go back.

8. Trouble Will Find Me by the National

The most basic thing you can do when you're writing one of these blurbs for a list like this is to describe the memory you have of listening to this album for the first time, even if it's a mundane one. Here's mine: I was in a coffee shop that doesn't exist anymore at the Piazza in Northern Liberties, on a 30-minute break from my job hawking product for Zipcar at a pop-up table, stretching that break into more like 60 minutes, and that coffee shop was playing this album in full. It had just come out the day before. I remember appreciating just how much I loved the National, and loved that they were still around.

The reason you're allowed to write about such humdrum nostalgia in these blurbs is that there is a dual purpose to them. On the one hand, you are marking your own chronology. Like, okay, I was working a shit job at the time and I was finding comfort in music in a very specific way. On the other hand, you are marking the band's chronology as well. Like, okay, here was a band who was in some ways peaking in terms of commercial appeal, and here they were starting their new album with not one, but two songs with wonky time signatures. On both timelines, we can see signs of malaise, of anxieties about the future, and a certain sense of struggling to break free.

7. Run the Jewels by Run the Jewels

You can do the opposite too. You can, for a blurb, describe how there is no story, that an artist just seems to have always been. There's a function to that too; you can in that way make it seem like the artist is too big to be contained by some stupid nostalgic vision of a quiet coffee shop. Run the Jewels is bigger and better than that, by design.

It's funny. I do have an hazy and undefined memory of listening to the debut album from this legendary hip hop duo somewhere in the marshes of my brain, but I don't know where it takes place. I only know that it was early in the morning in a house that was not mine, and that I was hungover from a crazy night and that I had slept over somewhere and that I couldn't sleep and so I popped in the iPod and just lied on the mattress on the floor and listened to some bangers before everyone else woke up and the party continued. I've tried to sift through the detritus and put a memory to a location or event, but try as I might, I can't seem to do it.

It probably doesn't matter. Run the Jewels is still here, spitting hard bars and making grandiose claims about their penises. I've come around to the idea that maybe they were never better at it than they were on this first album.

6. Days Are Gone by Haim

I don't profess to know what is "popular" and what isn't. Haim feels popular, even though I don't really see evidence of that on the Billboard Hot 100. Maybe they just manage to be ubiquitous on the music blogs that I tend to follow, which, true, is limited in scope. But there were the T. Swift collabs, and the youngest Haim sister was legitimately snubbed from getting an Oscar nom last year, so it just feels like the threat of breaking out is always there, at the very least. Popularity beyond that is out of my jurisdiction.

Days Are Gone proves that the threat was there this whole time. A complete package, right out of the gate. There are other collaborators on here, of course—producer Ariel Rechtshaid's fingerprints are all over the fucking thing—but when I think about this debut album, I think about how comfortable this group of sisters were already. I don't know if they are stars, but listening to this, and they feel like stars. Not sure what the difference is.

5. Wakin on a Pretty Daze by Kurt Vile

Kurt Vile in particular makes out well under the framework of the ten-year retrospective list. Of all the artists that I currently love, Vile is the one that requires the most time to sink into. Ten years helps. I remember my boss at Zipcar being really into this one (she being very Fishtown Chic, and the exact type of person whom Vile might whisper to), and me having to say something like "I just don't know yet."

This is the second time I've mentioned Zipcar so far. This isn't really the point, but it's worth noting: Zipcar was the most recent job I've had in my lifetime where I could (and did) pick up music recommendations that have stuck with me. I was gone from that job before 2013 was over. A subsequent decade of working shit civil service jobs where co-workers listen to sports radio and watch TikTok or don't consume any art at all.

Maybe that's why Kurt Vile's opus Wakin on a Pretty Daze took longer to reveal itself to me. This is music for the languid days of your boring middle years. It's music for an escape inward. There was no need for that while we were pulling out sixers of Rolling Rock on Fridays at 4 PM and getting loaded right there in the office. No escape necessary. But as I type this now in a cubicle, drab surroundings for a drab career, I find that I need these sounds more than ever, to for a few moments collapse inward and enjoy the excitement in doing so.

4. Night Time, My Time by Sky Ferreira

I guess one of the negative things that happen when you do a list like this is, after ten years, some of your own tastes start to converge with some of the critical consensus that has accrued over that time period. Which is fine, but there's currency to be found in having "hot takes" on such a blog as this one, and when I say something like "hey, the album that everyone seems to like really is an album that I also like," then that's boring.

Yes, Night Time, My Time is just that good. I didn't know about it at the time, but ten years was plenty long to get intimate with this thing, and so here I am, a few weeks after its actual ten-year anniversary, saying that it's everything that everyone proclaims it to be. Revelatory pop music, kinda like synthpop but darker than your typical outings from the genre. Mythmaking in real time, especially because the sophomore album still hasn't dropped. An exercise in turning real pain into towering hooks. I don't know if I necessarily understand this album, or if anyone does, really, but we can all agree—good shit.

3. The Silver Gymnasium by Okkervil River

Ah, I was afraid this would happen. The Silver Gymnasium stood atop my original rankings, but I cannot in good faith return it to that position. I revisit the album every so often, and I never have any negative notes. It starts really strong with those first three unimpeachable songs ("Down Down the Deep River" has especially stood the test of time). Maybe the rest of the album occasionally dips into "filler" territory, but not often. Musically, I am hard-pressed to find anything to fault here.

The thematic hook of the album—that this is frontman Will Sheff's nostalgia album, in which he dives back into the childhood archives and tries to fit the pieces together to inform his adult existence, somehow—holds up too. But the idea of "nostalgia" is tricky. The expectation for such an album is that one man's nostalgia will subsequently work as another man's nostalgia stacked on top of it. I.e., that I'll listen to The Silver Gymnasium and remember fondly the days when it meant so much to me. And if I'm being completely honest with myself, it doesn't quite feel that way. 2013 was a middle year. I was back from the travels of post-college Vegas, and I was counting the days until I married my wife, and in the meantime, I was basically just a shitass walking to McNally's on any given Sunday night. The Silver Gymnasium brings me back there sometimes, but mostly doesn't.

And so what we're left with is simply an incredibly powerful and unjustly underrated album of music that deserves it's top-three spot here and then some, but fails to capture now what it did then, at that different time in my life. I love all my #1s in the same way that I love all my years, but the distance of one affects the perceived distance of the other. That's all. I hate that I have to say anything negative about this thing just because it committed the sin of not being my absolute favorite album of the year it came out.

2. Modern Vampires of the City by Vampire Weekend

The idea of "good songwriting" is so nebulous to me. That's a phrase that music critics throw around wantonly, and I don't know if I've ever really got it. It's like, every song has to be written, and thus every song has a songwriter, and so wouldn't a good song necessarily have good songwriting? I never said I was a music critic, by the way.

But if I were forced to try to describe what "good songwriting" looked like, I would probably point my finger toward Modern Vampires of the City. There is such a tangible leveling-up in these songs as compared to the first two, just in terms of complexity and variety and, I don't know, depth? My favorite VW album is the self-titled, and my favorite VW song is on Father of the Bride, but when I look to Modern Vampires, I see a band that figured out how to be a band first. And I can see that. I listen to this album and I can push everything in my personal life and personal opinion aside, and can appreciate the craft for what it is.

Is that good songwriting? I don't fucking know, man. Probably? Who cares? This is an unimpeachably great album and I don't give a shit how that came to be.

1. Pedestrian Verse by Frightened Rabbit

I've probably already written enough on this blog about Pedestrian Verse for you to be able to comfortably guess that this album is my favorite from the year it was released, and also one of my favorite albums of all time from any fucking year. I discovered it late, but not too late. It was there to see me through the late '10s, and it was there to comfort me when its creator took his own life. This veritable and often deeply sad chronology ties it to particulars times and places in my own story, and yet, Pedestrian Verse remains as timeless as ever, ten years later.

The music somehow is able to be depressing and uplifting at the same time. You'll hear the biggest choruses of all time on a song about feeling like you want to crawl into a hole. There's a dichotomy at work in this way. Were I to describe how that dichotomy functions, I might say that it works as a source of strength for the listener. Here is Scott Hutchison, clearly hurting, and yet, despite that, he is able to create these soaring odes to being alive. Makes you want to take a step back sometimes and appreciate how he was able to do this, and what perseverance it must have taken to feel so personally sad and to still turn around and tell someone else that it's all gonna be okay.

When I listen to the big cuts like "Backyard Skulls" or "Holy," I am happy. I am happy both despite and because all the misery that trails in the wake of this towering achievement. I am happy that I am here, alive, experiencing this album, again and again, for as long as I choose to be here.


Hey, this was fun. Let's meet up here in this same space the week before Thanksgiving next year to talk about my favorite albums from 2014.

No comments: