April 12, 2005, 7:44 PM
I hate to frame it this way, but it really is true: for the very first time in my academic career at La Salle College High School, nearly two years in, I can finally say that my religion class made me think.
Well, okay... I guess it started when I read The Da Vinci Code. An okay book. Maybe a nice beach read. Probably overhyped, as far as these things go. And definitely fiction, like, I'm not here saying that the Church is full of conspiracies!! or whatever. I don't think it's real, but the very fact that it could be real is what got me thinking. What if the Church had it's own agenda, separate from the teachings of Jesus? Couldn't that be plausible?
And that line of thinking just kept extending, right through a recent discussion in my Sophomore Religion class. Dougie D. was discussing the Biblical character of Mary Magdalene. We're told that she was a prostitute, but was she? Maybe you might consider the Da Vinci Code theory that her alleged choice of career was really an anti-female campaign launched by a misogynistic Church a millennium later. I can't say what is true because I don't know. But the very idea that it could be true, and that it would be quite plausible to imagine it is, is what's got my mind humming and spinning right.
Keep going. Maybe ponder for a moment all those books that were cut out of the final version of the bible. Ponder the Gospel of Phillip, which didn't make the final version for whatever reason. I'm told that it explains how Jesus and Mary Mags were more than just friends. They liked each other, and they like-liked each other. Who made the decision to exclude this particular gospel, and why? Who says that Matthew or Luke or the others were "more inspired" than Phillip? Maybe the decision to squash Phillip was an attempt to quell any notion that Jesus laid pipe. There are a ton of gospels like this. There's a Book of Thomas, written by a dude who was actually alive when Jesus was, and had a friendship with him, and so why not take his word for it rather than John's, from a dude born 100 years after Christ was killed? Why not literally include the Gospel of Mary Magdalene, and get a first-person perspective on whether Jesus was hooking up or what?
It's just one small question, but that leads to other small questions, which lead to bigger questions, and on and on, spiraling out of control, until I'm literally questioning everything about this Church that I've considered myself a part of for my entire life. It's like, maybe the Church is losing (or already lost) their focus from where it all started: Jesus Christ. Like, would Jesus be a homophobe? Get fucking real. But the Church is, explicitly so. So where's the Christ in that?
Maybe less important but still relevant to the discussion—what the fuck is up with the Old Testament? That shit's even crazier than the New Testament and its ostracizing of certain voices and stories. Why, for instance, is God such a fucking prick? What's up with him pulling going all Ashton Kutcher and Abraham getting Punk'd about killing his own son!? What's the deal with all the contradictions? Why is God so totally accepting of violence and misogyny and murder, and then changing his mind by the time he sends his son down to earth, totally contradicting everything his father said in the previous book, with literally zero explanation for the flip-flop?
While I'm on the subject, it's kinda weird and suspiciously convenient that the Church can pretty much explain away literally anything that doesn't make sense with something like: "Even if there is no logical explanation, we just have to believe." That's not really good enough for me anymore.
I know I'm rambling. Sorry, sometimes I just get so worked up about all this and I start rambling. I guess there's a good chance that I'll go back and read what I just wrote and find that it doesn't make any sense. But I'm more attempting to explain an emotion than lay out the facts, and so here's what I feel: I am starting to question the Church's plausibility. I wouldn't go far as to say that I'm "questioning my faith," because I do truly believe that Jesus had the right idea with this whole religion that he started. He taught people to love one another, and that's really all that matters. I don't care if he was technically "God" or not. I mean... I guess that qualifies as a lack of faith. I don't know if I believe in all the hocus pocus. I do know that I believe in the goodness in humans.
Well, okay... I guess it started when I read The Da Vinci Code. An okay book. Maybe a nice beach read. Probably overhyped, as far as these things go. And definitely fiction, like, I'm not here saying that the Church is full of conspiracies!! or whatever. I don't think it's real, but the very fact that it could be real is what got me thinking. What if the Church had it's own agenda, separate from the teachings of Jesus? Couldn't that be plausible?
And that line of thinking just kept extending, right through a recent discussion in my Sophomore Religion class. Dougie D. was discussing the Biblical character of Mary Magdalene. We're told that she was a prostitute, but was she? Maybe you might consider the Da Vinci Code theory that her alleged choice of career was really an anti-female campaign launched by a misogynistic Church a millennium later. I can't say what is true because I don't know. But the very idea that it could be true, and that it would be quite plausible to imagine it is, is what's got my mind humming and spinning right.
Keep going. Maybe ponder for a moment all those books that were cut out of the final version of the bible. Ponder the Gospel of Phillip, which didn't make the final version for whatever reason. I'm told that it explains how Jesus and Mary Mags were more than just friends. They liked each other, and they like-liked each other. Who made the decision to exclude this particular gospel, and why? Who says that Matthew or Luke or the others were "more inspired" than Phillip? Maybe the decision to squash Phillip was an attempt to quell any notion that Jesus laid pipe. There are a ton of gospels like this. There's a Book of Thomas, written by a dude who was actually alive when Jesus was, and had a friendship with him, and so why not take his word for it rather than John's, from a dude born 100 years after Christ was killed? Why not literally include the Gospel of Mary Magdalene, and get a first-person perspective on whether Jesus was hooking up or what?
It's just one small question, but that leads to other small questions, which lead to bigger questions, and on and on, spiraling out of control, until I'm literally questioning everything about this Church that I've considered myself a part of for my entire life. It's like, maybe the Church is losing (or already lost) their focus from where it all started: Jesus Christ. Like, would Jesus be a homophobe? Get fucking real. But the Church is, explicitly so. So where's the Christ in that?
Maybe less important but still relevant to the discussion—what the fuck is up with the Old Testament? That shit's even crazier than the New Testament and its ostracizing of certain voices and stories. Why, for instance, is God such a fucking prick? What's up with him pulling going all Ashton Kutcher and Abraham getting Punk'd about killing his own son!? What's the deal with all the contradictions? Why is God so totally accepting of violence and misogyny and murder, and then changing his mind by the time he sends his son down to earth, totally contradicting everything his father said in the previous book, with literally zero explanation for the flip-flop?
While I'm on the subject, it's kinda weird and suspiciously convenient that the Church can pretty much explain away literally anything that doesn't make sense with something like: "Even if there is no logical explanation, we just have to believe." That's not really good enough for me anymore.
I know I'm rambling. Sorry, sometimes I just get so worked up about all this and I start rambling. I guess there's a good chance that I'll go back and read what I just wrote and find that it doesn't make any sense. But I'm more attempting to explain an emotion than lay out the facts, and so here's what I feel: I am starting to question the Church's plausibility. I wouldn't go far as to say that I'm "questioning my faith," because I do truly believe that Jesus had the right idea with this whole religion that he started. He taught people to love one another, and that's really all that matters. I don't care if he was technically "God" or not. I mean... I guess that qualifies as a lack of faith. I don't know if I believe in all the hocus pocus. I do know that I believe in the goodness in humans.
This is difficult to write about. It's tough to question something you've always believed, ya know? Plato's allegory of the cave, and all that. So that's why I seem so back-and-forth with what I'm writing today—I just haven't quite figured it out, but I want to get there, and I need to type this all out in order to do that.
Go ahead, leave a comment below, anyone, I don't care. I feel like this is one of these situations in which I require some additional input and opinions. I'm obviously not the only who thinks about this. Leave a comment. Tell me I'm stupid or ignorant or lame. That would be helpful today.
Go ahead, leave a comment below, anyone, I don't care. I feel like this is one of these situations in which I require some additional input and opinions. I'm obviously not the only who thinks about this. Leave a comment. Tell me I'm stupid or ignorant or lame. That would be helpful today.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Comments
Smiles128: i HATE the whole "we have to just beleive, even if there is no explaination" thing. interesting thoughts on the contradicting stuff
follow_the_butterflies: i think..... that i agree with ur rambling
i thought about the same kinda stuff after religion class once... it is hard trying to explain. but for me, i just keep it simple, jesus had a good message, and people should learn from it, and help others learn from it.
deep comment.
follow_the_butterflies: i think..... that i agree with ur rambling
i thought about the same kinda stuff after religion class once... it is hard trying to explain. but for me, i just keep it simple, jesus had a good message, and people should learn from it, and help others learn from it.
deep comment.
Jfingers88: Morals good, strict diktat of Church bad. P.S. Alcohol bad.
Anonymous: I forget the correct date, but a pagan writer wrote a book called "Against the Christians" which stated how the stories of Jesus were based off pagan myths. Since you're reading the Da Vinci code, I'm sure you know how the Catholic Church reacted to the book.
Now onto the gospels, a priest who had translated some of the books that weren't put into the New Testamnet, had left Christianity because the books put down ideas such as freedom and democracy. Though I’m not sure if thats true, since I know some of my fellow athiests can be a tad biased at times.
Anonymous: And another thing I don’t really like, is that the Church can cover up ANYTHING that doesn't make sense with "we have to just believe, even if there is no explanation."
Agreed. What makes those people think anybody's going to believe a word they say if they can't even explain their own religion? What a load of bollocks.
Stoner311: Organized religion is a burden on society with more self-contradictions that I can count.
Now onto the gospels, a priest who had translated some of the books that weren't put into the New Testamnet, had left Christianity because the books put down ideas such as freedom and democracy. Though I’m not sure if thats true, since I know some of my fellow athiests can be a tad biased at times.
Anonymous: And another thing I don’t really like, is that the Church can cover up ANYTHING that doesn't make sense with "we have to just believe, even if there is no explanation."
Agreed. What makes those people think anybody's going to believe a word they say if they can't even explain their own religion? What a load of bollocks.
Stoner311: Organized religion is a burden on society with more self-contradictions that I can count.
Anonymous: much sense joe.... props to u
CoCain18: What’s up with him pulling an Ashton Kutcher and punking Abraham (and about killing his own son for christ sakes!)?……….HAHA i member that part of the Bible….To tell u the truth I think that the church is starting to be a whole bunch of bullshit…all there beliefs and they tell us that the Muslim religion could possibly be a whole crack of bullshit…so y couldnt the catholic faith be the same thing all written by some crazy ass guys???…please let me no of wat u think about this….leave a message on my xanga!
tank1189: holy shit joe ive been sayin all that stuff for the longest time.... but of course mi padre being the religion teacher that he is u'd think hed be tellin me to sit down and shut up... but he really is like lettin me question some stuff, and he even agrees that some of the stuff is probably b.s. or manipulated (its gotta be the da vinci code man—its like the seed of descent)
CoCain18: What’s up with him pulling an Ashton Kutcher and punking Abraham (and about killing his own son for christ sakes!)?……….HAHA i member that part of the Bible….To tell u the truth I think that the church is starting to be a whole bunch of bullshit…all there beliefs and they tell us that the Muslim religion could possibly be a whole crack of bullshit…so y couldnt the catholic faith be the same thing all written by some crazy ass guys???…please let me no of wat u think about this….leave a message on my xanga!
tank1189: holy shit joe ive been sayin all that stuff for the longest time.... but of course mi padre being the religion teacher that he is u'd think hed be tellin me to sit down and shut up... but he really is like lettin me question some stuff, and he even agrees that some of the stuff is probably b.s. or manipulated (its gotta be the da vinci code man—its like the seed of descent)

No comments:
Post a Comment