I am happy to have been a part of Record Club for these past 250 weeks. I enjoy viewing the album as a piece of art, and I enjoy judging it accordingly. I will admit that there is a certain allure to viewing each individual song as its own work of art. HOWEVER: I'm not the kind of person to who is going to tear apart an album for the sake of some fucking Spotify playlist. That seems crass and artless to me. Consider the album as a whole.
Still, okay, there are definitely some songs that stand out. It's inevitable. In honor of 250 weeks, I've collected 25 of them here. I'll stop short of saying that these are the best songs that we've touched upon in RC. I will say that these are the 25 songs that occupied a large space in my brain during the weeks I was continuously listening to their respective albums. These are the songs that made me breathless, for one reason or another, explainable or not.
At first, I had them separated between "songs I discovered because of Record Club" and "songs I knew or would've known about anyway without it," but that distinction seemed pointless. The context is Record Club, and it doesn't matter from which direction it arrived there. And so here they are, in alphabetical order. Listen, remember, maybe even... let them inspire you to go back into the archives and review their albums?!?!
25 of My Favorite Songs from RC
25 of My Favorite Songs from RC
"Better" by Caracara — from Better EP, Week 48 — The first part does such a good job setting the scene that it probably doesn't even matter that I'm familiar with that scene in real life; the second part goes super turbo and hits me so hard every single fucking time. And it gives me... I don't know, hope, maybe? A deep sadness? No, hope, albeit a sad and distant hope. Something like that.
"The Boys Are Back in Town" by Thin Lizzy — from Jailbreak, Week 169 — I'm gonna get around to ranking and writing about my own personal Top 100 Songs of All Time at some point early in the new year, I promise. I have the pool ready, I just have to get to ranking them. Where will Thin Lizzy's perennial jam end up? Top ten? Top five? Number one? Anything's possible. If we were to talk about quality over quantity, though, I'd be remiss to ignore the fact that this song accidentally marks some sort of ending for me now... but I'll write about that later.
"Boys in the Better Land" by Fontaines D.C. — from Dogrel, Week 11 — The saying "You shoot for the king, you best not miss" applies here. Fontaines D.C. landed their first punch, clean knockout. They didn't miss. Can't expect them to ever repeat that. "Boys in the Better Land" makes me feel ten feet taller every time I hear it, and at this point, years later, I can almost bend over and touch Ireland across the sea.
"A Certain Romance" by Arctic Monkeys — from Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not, Week 165 — Whoops, a bit of an accidental crossover here—PoYB's The Burholme Tapes column is just about to cover this song in a couple weeks, and so I don't want to waste any of my bullets here in a throwaway blurb. You should know that it's unintentionally sad now, this song, but that's my fault, not Arctic Monkeys'.
"The Crowd" by Wells Fargo — from Watch Out!, Week 70 — Obviously, Wells Fargo didn't record this song in the 1970s thinking that it would be so relevant to some random assholes in 2020 America, and yet there we were, realizing that the thing that most easily bends time and space and music is wanton cruelty from the ruling class.
"Diamond" by Empty Country — from Empty Country, Week 73 — Pulling out the time capsule from Q2 2020 whenever I need to be reminded of the fear we all felt, and the music that helped keep us together (but just barely).
"Drunk II" by Mannequin Pussy — from Patience, Week 124 — I've avoided listening to song since [redacted], but I tried doing it today for the purposes of writing this blurb. That tightness I feel in my chest is regret, but not in the way you think. The regret stems from... I guess I'd describe it as my willingness to lie to myself? I write a lot of words on this stupid fucking blog, like maybe tens of millions at this point, and it's just shocking how much of it consists of me not willing to admit the truth to myself. The Patience review feels like that, so much so that I can't even read it right now, I'm sorry. It's like, the truth was right fucking there, and I just sitting there spinning white hot bullshit out of my ass, extending the pain and the misery, and for what? To relate to a fucking song? That ain't the way.
"Hard-Core Troubadour" by Steve Earle — from I Feel Alright, Week 237 — A "troubadour" is an old poet of love. Not to get too corny with it, but that's what we're actually doing here, right? Writing about love?
"Heritage of Arrogance" by Adeem the Artist — from White Trash Revelry, Week 227 — There is just so much in this world. So much of everything, but especially so much to feel and to know. Enough that you could write about it forever, as some of us choose to do. But the most brilliant artists are able to condense. Something that might take me two years to describe fit snugly into the true artist's four-minute pop song. I continue to be godsmacked by Adeem's ability to fit all this into "Heritage of Arrogance." It's the song that guaranteed that I will follow them anywhere, forever.
"I Feel Emotion" by Operators — from Radiant Dawn, Week 19 — It's so pithy that it almost feels glib. "Oh, you feel emotion, do you? Well bully for you." But then you listen to the song. Oh. Right. Yeah, I get it now. That kind of emotion. Not just any emotion, but the emotion. The one that makes life worth living. Yup. I feel it. I listen to Operators and I feel it for sure.
"Light On" by Maggie Rogers — from Heard It in a Past Life, Week 1 — I paid no attention during the making of this list to such arbitrary categories like "who picked the album" or "what the grade I gave the album was" or "what week we covered the album." But this one was inevitable. Pam didn't even pick the Maggie Rogers album for Week 1 because she wanted it to be, like, thematically significant or any bullshit like that. But that's how it goes. This really was the start of something. And I promise to leave the light on for you, whenever you show up.
"A Little Respect" by Erasure — from The Innocents, Week 86 — Record Club sometimes has a way of adding context to an album: "here was an album that we listened to at this particular time in our lives, and here's what it means now because of that." But Record Club also has a way of stripping context away. Erasure felt like a joke that somehow survived the 1980s. Then Record Club took over. Now "A Little Respect" is a motherfucking anthem, with no ironic quotation marks required.
"Move That Dope" by Future — from Honest, Week 213 — The part of my brain that latches onto certain songs and replays them over and over and over for weeks at a time without stopping is not connected to the part of my brain that is aware of concepts such as "racial sensitivity." But then there's this third part of my brain that can take the figurative magnetic tape and do an adequate cutting and pasting job. This is how I came to have the following phrase comfortably stuck in my head for the past eight months and change: "Y'all gotta move that dope / Y'all gotta move that dope / hey move that dope hey move that dope," repeated ad nauseam.
"Olde Tyme Mem'ry" by Mischief Brew — from Bacchanal 'n' Philadelphia, Week 191 — I'm working on having the emotional capacity to untangle the nostalgia-dipped knot that Mischief Brew presents in "Olde Tyme Mem'ry." It's both a song about sad acceptance of times long gone and a song about the perseverance that we somehow find anyway, despite our sadness. Plus now layer on top of that the unshakeable fact that the song itself is perfect, and how sad it feels to listen to it end, and then wonder why if we can hit repeat on a goddamn song, why there isn't a repeat button for anything else.
"pong loser" by Magic Toaster — from shvt vp and enjoy the weather, Week 178 — Or, ya know, sometimes a cigar is just a cigar... he could easily say in all of these blurbs, but then where's the fun in that?! "Ain't got too much time / I'm gonna waste it right." Exactly.
"Routine Pain" by Spanish Love Songs — from Brave Faces Everyone, Week 58 — The first song on what is still one of RC's best albums starts with a Frightened Rabbit reference: "On any given day, I'm a six of ten." I remember reading that Hutchison quote in the interview the first time around, and it was startling to hear it in this context, over a year after his suicide, in a song about "routine pain." I think what it's trying to say is that a certain amount of emotional pain is expected, but that we should never ever consider that normal. That it's okay to feel hurt but that it's important to acknowledge the hurt, and to work on yourself. "Am I going to be this numb forever?" It doesn't have to be that way. Feels that way some days, of course, but that's part of the pain. Have hope.
"Shameika" by Fiona Apple — from Fetch the Bolt Cutters, Week 72 — I almost wish that no enterprising journalist had gone out into the field to find the real Shameika. The song works better when you consider it a myth or a fable, one about the idea of showing kindness in what might seem to you like forgettable situations. It's a song that feels like a shipwreck but acts like a port in the storm.
"Steel Claw" by Tina Turner — from Private Dancer, Week 143 — A song that proved that surprises can come from anywhere, at least when we're talking about music. A Tina Turner might seem rote at first—like, psh, we know her hits, what else could there possibly be? Then a song like "Steel Claw" comes out of nowhere (almost literally) and bends you over backwards and makes you wish you never doubted her in the first place.
"The Stone" by Harry and the Potters — from Lumos, Week 21 — The Harry Potter album we covered early on in Record Club can these days act as a joke or as something deadly serious, depending on the context. It's a joke that a joke band can get their joke songs on any "Top Favorites" list without rendering the entire fucking thing a fucking joke. But a song like "The Stone" can turn it serious in a hurry. The "Thank you, Harry" section was already serious when we covered it in 2019, but Harry Potter's author's more recent heel turn only adds richness to this text. It's a complicated song on a pretty uncomplicated album that now rests on an incredibly complicated legacy. Sorry, sorry, I don't mean to ignore the joke for too long. Yes! Ha ha! An album about Harry Potter! Very funny!!
"stupid horse" by 100 gecs — from 1000 gecs, Week 56 — If there was one single moment when I learned to disavow preconceived notions and truly go along free-spiritedly with the ebbs and flows of Record Club, then it was 100 gecs week. I thought I would hate it, based on nothing. Like the best art, "stupid horse" rewired my brain. There's room for artificially sped-up vocals, absurd narratives about punching jockeys, sarcastic(?) ska phrases, a "Scotty Doesn't Know"-aping guitar solo, and not to mention the fact that exactly eight months after I heard "stupid horse" for the first time, we moved into a house next to a horse stable, and so every time I brush my teeth in the bathroom and look out the window at all the stupid horses, I think about this insane tune.
"Suburban Home" by Decendents — from Milo Goes to College, Week 238 — Speaking of that house: I want to be stereotyped. I want to be classified. I want a big, suburban home. I want to be masochistic, and so on and so forth.
"Three Evils (Embodied in Love and Shadow)" by Coheed and Cambria — from In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3, Week 231 — Of all the lyrics that were incessantly and irrevocably lodged into my brain in the past 250 weeks, the one that goes "Pull the trigger and the nightmare stops!" is probably the bleakest. As with all things Coheed and Cambria, we must acknowledge the likelihood that this line is meant to be literal and not figurative, i.e. that whatever space opera bullshit is going on in their never-ending discography-long narrative is the only meaning behind "trigger" and "nightmare" and all that. In other words, it's not supposed to be, like, a metaphor or anything. But I'm the listener, and you cannot tell me what to do or how to think. Who do you think you are, General Mayo Deftinwolf, primary antagonist in The Amory Wars, and the head of the United Red Army?!?!?!
"To Hell with Good Intentions" by Mclusky — from Mclusky Do Dallas, Week 198 — Aside from the absolutely killer hook, and some of the more ridiculous lyrics ("We got more songs than a song convention"????), my biggest takeaway—and maybe I'm only saying this because it fits into this blurb thematically, I guess, I don't know, you can never tell with this shit—is the head-turning outlier of a line, "my love is bigger than your love." It just seems so out of place on an album like this. Why is love so important for Mclusky to make known here? Love for whom? You tell me. If you figure it out: sing it.
"Voyager II" by Virginia Coalition — from OK to Go, Week 194 — Something about space and the great unknown tends to bring out the romantics in us humans. This off-brand Guster band is giving it their fucking all singing about a goddamn spacecraft that is still traveling to the far edges of the universe to deliver our message. "Send help soon! Voyager II!" There's something so sad and so beautiful about the sentiments. Maybe this would just be another fucking O.A.R. exercise otherwise. But as it exists now, this chorus has lived in my head, and comes to me every time I look up into the sky.
"Welcome to the Black Parade" by My Chemical Romance — from The Black Parade, Week 44 — Like "The Boys Are Back in Town" earlier in the list, this MCR track is going to find itself in rarified air once I get off my ass and put together my personal Top 100 Songs list. It's weird to think back on the journey that "Welcome to the Black Parade" has taken in my life, starting as sort of a joke and eventually breaking through and making me cry almost literally every time I hear it. I'll eventually have to try to explain myself, but I don't know if it will be possible when that time comes. I will speculate briefly here that maybe it has to do with my own life's journey, and how every day I get closer and closer to my own Black Parade. And maybe it's a little too scary to think about it directly, and so I use this timeless pop-punk-emo hit from the mid-'00s as a stand-in, to protect me from my fears.
"The Boys Are Back in Town" by Thin Lizzy — from Jailbreak, Week 169 — I'm gonna get around to ranking and writing about my own personal Top 100 Songs of All Time at some point early in the new year, I promise. I have the pool ready, I just have to get to ranking them. Where will Thin Lizzy's perennial jam end up? Top ten? Top five? Number one? Anything's possible. If we were to talk about quality over quantity, though, I'd be remiss to ignore the fact that this song accidentally marks some sort of ending for me now... but I'll write about that later.
"Boys in the Better Land" by Fontaines D.C. — from Dogrel, Week 11 — The saying "You shoot for the king, you best not miss" applies here. Fontaines D.C. landed their first punch, clean knockout. They didn't miss. Can't expect them to ever repeat that. "Boys in the Better Land" makes me feel ten feet taller every time I hear it, and at this point, years later, I can almost bend over and touch Ireland across the sea.
"A Certain Romance" by Arctic Monkeys — from Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not, Week 165 — Whoops, a bit of an accidental crossover here—PoYB's The Burholme Tapes column is just about to cover this song in a couple weeks, and so I don't want to waste any of my bullets here in a throwaway blurb. You should know that it's unintentionally sad now, this song, but that's my fault, not Arctic Monkeys'.
"The Crowd" by Wells Fargo — from Watch Out!, Week 70 — Obviously, Wells Fargo didn't record this song in the 1970s thinking that it would be so relevant to some random assholes in 2020 America, and yet there we were, realizing that the thing that most easily bends time and space and music is wanton cruelty from the ruling class.
"Diamond" by Empty Country — from Empty Country, Week 73 — Pulling out the time capsule from Q2 2020 whenever I need to be reminded of the fear we all felt, and the music that helped keep us together (but just barely).
"Drunk II" by Mannequin Pussy — from Patience, Week 124 — I've avoided listening to song since [redacted], but I tried doing it today for the purposes of writing this blurb. That tightness I feel in my chest is regret, but not in the way you think. The regret stems from... I guess I'd describe it as my willingness to lie to myself? I write a lot of words on this stupid fucking blog, like maybe tens of millions at this point, and it's just shocking how much of it consists of me not willing to admit the truth to myself. The Patience review feels like that, so much so that I can't even read it right now, I'm sorry. It's like, the truth was right fucking there, and I just sitting there spinning white hot bullshit out of my ass, extending the pain and the misery, and for what? To relate to a fucking song? That ain't the way.
"Hard-Core Troubadour" by Steve Earle — from I Feel Alright, Week 237 — A "troubadour" is an old poet of love. Not to get too corny with it, but that's what we're actually doing here, right? Writing about love?
"Heritage of Arrogance" by Adeem the Artist — from White Trash Revelry, Week 227 — There is just so much in this world. So much of everything, but especially so much to feel and to know. Enough that you could write about it forever, as some of us choose to do. But the most brilliant artists are able to condense. Something that might take me two years to describe fit snugly into the true artist's four-minute pop song. I continue to be godsmacked by Adeem's ability to fit all this into "Heritage of Arrogance." It's the song that guaranteed that I will follow them anywhere, forever.
"I Feel Emotion" by Operators — from Radiant Dawn, Week 19 — It's so pithy that it almost feels glib. "Oh, you feel emotion, do you? Well bully for you." But then you listen to the song. Oh. Right. Yeah, I get it now. That kind of emotion. Not just any emotion, but the emotion. The one that makes life worth living. Yup. I feel it. I listen to Operators and I feel it for sure.
"Light On" by Maggie Rogers — from Heard It in a Past Life, Week 1 — I paid no attention during the making of this list to such arbitrary categories like "who picked the album" or "what the grade I gave the album was" or "what week we covered the album." But this one was inevitable. Pam didn't even pick the Maggie Rogers album for Week 1 because she wanted it to be, like, thematically significant or any bullshit like that. But that's how it goes. This really was the start of something. And I promise to leave the light on for you, whenever you show up.
"A Little Respect" by Erasure — from The Innocents, Week 86 — Record Club sometimes has a way of adding context to an album: "here was an album that we listened to at this particular time in our lives, and here's what it means now because of that." But Record Club also has a way of stripping context away. Erasure felt like a joke that somehow survived the 1980s. Then Record Club took over. Now "A Little Respect" is a motherfucking anthem, with no ironic quotation marks required.
"Move That Dope" by Future — from Honest, Week 213 — The part of my brain that latches onto certain songs and replays them over and over and over for weeks at a time without stopping is not connected to the part of my brain that is aware of concepts such as "racial sensitivity." But then there's this third part of my brain that can take the figurative magnetic tape and do an adequate cutting and pasting job. This is how I came to have the following phrase comfortably stuck in my head for the past eight months and change: "Y'all gotta move that dope / Y'all gotta move that dope / hey move that dope hey move that dope," repeated ad nauseam.
"Olde Tyme Mem'ry" by Mischief Brew — from Bacchanal 'n' Philadelphia, Week 191 — I'm working on having the emotional capacity to untangle the nostalgia-dipped knot that Mischief Brew presents in "Olde Tyme Mem'ry." It's both a song about sad acceptance of times long gone and a song about the perseverance that we somehow find anyway, despite our sadness. Plus now layer on top of that the unshakeable fact that the song itself is perfect, and how sad it feels to listen to it end, and then wonder why if we can hit repeat on a goddamn song, why there isn't a repeat button for anything else.
"pong loser" by Magic Toaster — from shvt vp and enjoy the weather, Week 178 — Or, ya know, sometimes a cigar is just a cigar... he could easily say in all of these blurbs, but then where's the fun in that?! "Ain't got too much time / I'm gonna waste it right." Exactly.
"Routine Pain" by Spanish Love Songs — from Brave Faces Everyone, Week 58 — The first song on what is still one of RC's best albums starts with a Frightened Rabbit reference: "On any given day, I'm a six of ten." I remember reading that Hutchison quote in the interview the first time around, and it was startling to hear it in this context, over a year after his suicide, in a song about "routine pain." I think what it's trying to say is that a certain amount of emotional pain is expected, but that we should never ever consider that normal. That it's okay to feel hurt but that it's important to acknowledge the hurt, and to work on yourself. "Am I going to be this numb forever?" It doesn't have to be that way. Feels that way some days, of course, but that's part of the pain. Have hope.
"Shameika" by Fiona Apple — from Fetch the Bolt Cutters, Week 72 — I almost wish that no enterprising journalist had gone out into the field to find the real Shameika. The song works better when you consider it a myth or a fable, one about the idea of showing kindness in what might seem to you like forgettable situations. It's a song that feels like a shipwreck but acts like a port in the storm.
"Steel Claw" by Tina Turner — from Private Dancer, Week 143 — A song that proved that surprises can come from anywhere, at least when we're talking about music. A Tina Turner might seem rote at first—like, psh, we know her hits, what else could there possibly be? Then a song like "Steel Claw" comes out of nowhere (almost literally) and bends you over backwards and makes you wish you never doubted her in the first place.
"The Stone" by Harry and the Potters — from Lumos, Week 21 — The Harry Potter album we covered early on in Record Club can these days act as a joke or as something deadly serious, depending on the context. It's a joke that a joke band can get their joke songs on any "Top Favorites" list without rendering the entire fucking thing a fucking joke. But a song like "The Stone" can turn it serious in a hurry. The "Thank you, Harry" section was already serious when we covered it in 2019, but Harry Potter's author's more recent heel turn only adds richness to this text. It's a complicated song on a pretty uncomplicated album that now rests on an incredibly complicated legacy. Sorry, sorry, I don't mean to ignore the joke for too long. Yes! Ha ha! An album about Harry Potter! Very funny!!
"stupid horse" by 100 gecs — from 1000 gecs, Week 56 — If there was one single moment when I learned to disavow preconceived notions and truly go along free-spiritedly with the ebbs and flows of Record Club, then it was 100 gecs week. I thought I would hate it, based on nothing. Like the best art, "stupid horse" rewired my brain. There's room for artificially sped-up vocals, absurd narratives about punching jockeys, sarcastic(?) ska phrases, a "Scotty Doesn't Know"-aping guitar solo, and not to mention the fact that exactly eight months after I heard "stupid horse" for the first time, we moved into a house next to a horse stable, and so every time I brush my teeth in the bathroom and look out the window at all the stupid horses, I think about this insane tune.
"Suburban Home" by Decendents — from Milo Goes to College, Week 238 — Speaking of that house: I want to be stereotyped. I want to be classified. I want a big, suburban home. I want to be masochistic, and so on and so forth.
"Three Evils (Embodied in Love and Shadow)" by Coheed and Cambria — from In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3, Week 231 — Of all the lyrics that were incessantly and irrevocably lodged into my brain in the past 250 weeks, the one that goes "Pull the trigger and the nightmare stops!" is probably the bleakest. As with all things Coheed and Cambria, we must acknowledge the likelihood that this line is meant to be literal and not figurative, i.e. that whatever space opera bullshit is going on in their never-ending discography-long narrative is the only meaning behind "trigger" and "nightmare" and all that. In other words, it's not supposed to be, like, a metaphor or anything. But I'm the listener, and you cannot tell me what to do or how to think. Who do you think you are, General Mayo Deftinwolf, primary antagonist in The Amory Wars, and the head of the United Red Army?!?!?!
"To Hell with Good Intentions" by Mclusky — from Mclusky Do Dallas, Week 198 — Aside from the absolutely killer hook, and some of the more ridiculous lyrics ("We got more songs than a song convention"????), my biggest takeaway—and maybe I'm only saying this because it fits into this blurb thematically, I guess, I don't know, you can never tell with this shit—is the head-turning outlier of a line, "my love is bigger than your love." It just seems so out of place on an album like this. Why is love so important for Mclusky to make known here? Love for whom? You tell me. If you figure it out: sing it.
"Voyager II" by Virginia Coalition — from OK to Go, Week 194 — Something about space and the great unknown tends to bring out the romantics in us humans. This off-brand Guster band is giving it their fucking all singing about a goddamn spacecraft that is still traveling to the far edges of the universe to deliver our message. "Send help soon! Voyager II!" There's something so sad and so beautiful about the sentiments. Maybe this would just be another fucking O.A.R. exercise otherwise. But as it exists now, this chorus has lived in my head, and comes to me every time I look up into the sky.
"Welcome to the Black Parade" by My Chemical Romance — from The Black Parade, Week 44 — Like "The Boys Are Back in Town" earlier in the list, this MCR track is going to find itself in rarified air once I get off my ass and put together my personal Top 100 Songs list. It's weird to think back on the journey that "Welcome to the Black Parade" has taken in my life, starting as sort of a joke and eventually breaking through and making me cry almost literally every time I hear it. I'll eventually have to try to explain myself, but I don't know if it will be possible when that time comes. I will speculate briefly here that maybe it has to do with my own life's journey, and how every day I get closer and closer to my own Black Parade. And maybe it's a little too scary to think about it directly, and so I use this timeless pop-punk-emo hit from the mid-'00s as a stand-in, to protect me from my fears.
Cheers to the next 250 weeks.

No comments:
Post a Comment