See the rest of the exit surveys HERE.
It never matters who's not at a party. The only thing that matters is who's there. You appreciate the folks who showed up, and you forget about the people who didn't. I've always believe that to be true, from back when I actually went to real-life parties without children, up until today in "parties" such as Record Club. Yes, of course it would've been cool to get everybody in on the fun, but in this very specific context, anyone who didn't write a Ms. Robinson review doesn't matter. What matters is the six people who showed up for the party. We had fun.
There's another theory about parties—sorry, Martha's birthday party was last night (I'm typing this before it, you're reading it after), and so I have parties on the brain and am going to keep extending the metaphor—that a certain percentage of people need to be personally asked to attend if you want any chance of them RSVPing. That's just a fact of life. Some people just don't respond to email blasts or group invites or general mass-disseminated bullshit. You might be tempted to think "Well if they really cared, then they'd read the invitation regardless," and maybe on some level that's true. But you can't take it personally. There is so much technological bullshit hitting your typical American person every second of every day, and you can't really blame some people for not being able to sift through it all to get to the good stuff. There are some party planners who look on the guest list at all the people who didn't respond and say fuck it, if they don't want to respond then they obviously don't want to come. I try not to be like that, mostly. I saw there were people who didn't respond to Martha's birthday party invitation, and I reached out to those people individually to see if they were coming or not.
The same applies to Record Club, just on a more lopsided scale. I send the emails out every week, and after 250 weeks, I get the sense that the emails do very little to persuade the vast majority of people who receive them to pursue new music or, god forbid, write about it. Sometimes that is frustrating to me—sorry about the Wednesday email this week—and it's frustrating on two levels. One, because no one likes to feel like they are in a dream and they are screaming and no one can hear them scream. Two, because I know on some fundamental level that the blog is like the silliest fucking thing to get frustrated about, and it's embarrassing to spend this much time for something so stupid that a fraction of a percentage of the people I know and love even give a fuck about.
This week in particular was probably just bad timing for a "fundraising" week of Record Club, since I just did not have the emotional bandwidth to do the necessary individual reaching out to people on a personal level that the majority of RC member obviously require, a level of personal outreach that made something like the McGruff week such a success. I just couldn't fucking do it, and I'll tell you why. I had the stupid idea that I should start to try to find a space on the blog for friends who don't normally write for Record Club, and so I've been working through individually texting and emailing people about that other thing, either writing one's own column about whatever or participating in the Yearlong Song Challenge or whatever the fuck. But: extremely low response rate. Depressingly high number of people who just don't respond at all. Look, I'll say it as many times as I need to—I get how stupid and unnecessary all of this is, and on a human level I don't blame people at all for ignoring the fucking goon who is pestering them about writing words on a blogspot account in 2024 for reasons that even he can't really even explain. I'm not here in this Exit Survey making a case that I'm right and everyone else is wrong. I'm just explaining why I didn't have the stamina to then, after all that, again text everyone and grovel and beg that they write a review for a fucking hip hop math album. Couldn't do it. Emails would have to suffice, and they did the job that they usually do.
But see, now typing all of this, I see that I'm going against the original party theory, and that I'm focusing too much on the people who didn't show up, which is doing a huge disservice to the people who did show up. Gary and Melissa and Pat and Nate and Sunny showed up. They always show up. They are good people like that. Yes, blogging is stupid, and pointless, and meaningless, but maybe it means something to me, and the fact that others take time out of their own busy schedules to participate means the fucking world to me. Thanks, friends.
[UPDATE: Sara sent a late review in, and so I'm tacking this on at the last second. We got a review from Sara, and we got the inside info about Ms. Robinson's tutoring app that is still functional in 2023 (see link in the comments of the album's write-up). Thanks pal!]
2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?
Oh, definitely samey. I mean, there was a similar thread of "what the fuck even is this" weaving through each well-written review, so that's one. Two was that everyone besides Melissa's philistine students understood that, despite the baffling fact of the album's very existence, Hip Hop Tables actually succeeded in completing the implied job that it set out to do (rap). The question of whether it succeeded in completing the explicitly named job that it set out to do (teach math) remains to be seen. My five-year-old is currently learning addition and subtraction, and I can personally attest that she did not give a fuck about the references to OutKast, Montell Jordan, the East Side Boyz, or Terrell fucking Owens.
3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?
As usual, I will use this space to go through each review and briefly give one example of how it made me view the album in a different light. Gary's: that there might be a hidden third objective of Ms. Robison's Hip Hop Tables—to get you PUMPED UP and EXCITED (for a football game; for whatever). A.S.S./Melissa's: that maybe one of the unintended consequences of the shift from music ownership to streaming music becoming the norm (a shift that was only just starting to accelerate around the time Hip Hop Tables came out in 2007) is that kids just really don't give a shit about music enough to appreciate the craft, and their brains are so thoroughly rotted out by Spotify's throwaway culture that one of the only responses they can think of is "Does she make money off of this?" Pat's: that Ms. Robinson, whether she knows it or not, is part of a lineage of teaching in entertainment and art, and that this is true and valuable even if the art that she actually made might not be. Nate's: that, okay, someone who has listened to more hip hop in their life than the other five reviewers combined is able to confirm for everyone else that this is a "pretty good rap album," which is good to know. Sunny's: that maybe the question we should have been asking re: whether this is a good way to teach kids math is whether this is an outdated way to teach kids math.
4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?
Tricky question, because it's my general belief that any writing at any quantity is worth it. Can't really ask people to write more than they already did (unless we're talking about all the people who wrote zero words, in which case, yes, write more please).
Maybe it would've been interesting to hear from someone who was very bad at math growing up? Someone who maybe needs help with their times tables currently? There's a chance that the intelligent young men and women who wrote a review this week (or even the Advanced AP Honors Plus students in the A.S.S. class) were not the intended audience of an album designed to help with practicing the multiplication tables.
5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?
Fuck it: success. Any week there is more than one review is considered a success. We had six reviews, and that's $60 to kids in Philadelphia. [UPDATE: Sara sent in a late review, but it was submitted after I made the donation. I owe the next charity $10 in Sara's name.]
I don't ever want to go into a week expecting an uptick in album reviews ever again. Appropriate expectations will help facilitate a soothing and more enjoyable experience overall. There was a time when I was legitimately worried that I was going to be the only reviewer that week. Here at the end of 2023, we're still averaging over seven reviews per week for the year. Things are good.
7. What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?
There's literally nothing more I can do.


No comments:
Post a Comment