Going through a list of 200 marmalades I've never tasted before.
Paddington 2
2017
Paul King
Frank's been working overtime on the movie blog recently. I really appreciate the time and efforts. Here's another discussion, this time about Paddington 2. Naturally, it is the longest and most in-depth convo we've had in a while.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Joe: One of my secret shames is that, if I don't "get" a movie, I'll run off to the internet as soon as it's finished, and search for "what it means," basically. I don't need to do this for every movie I watch—definitely didn't need any explainers for No Country for Old Men, I was pretty confident in that one—but some are definitely head-scratchers. Paddington 2? A lock for this phenomenon. Paddington talks about his dream with Knuckles McGinty, says he woke up, and then... fade to black. WHAT?!
But I don't want to just run off to the goddamn world wide web anymore. That makes me feel weak. I'm at the point now where I should be able to think on it for a little bit, and attempt to form some opinions or some theories or whatever from my own experience with the film. Even if it's bullshit, I want to at least try. After the credits roll, I'll put the phone down, load the dishwasher and brush my teeth, and by the time I get into bed, write at least one paragraph on my phone before I go to any website. So I tried it with Paddington 2. Thought on it, and wrote the following:
Paddington 2 is only part of the story. Which is frustrating, but it's supposed to be. Mr. Curry yelling "We don't want him here!" into the microphone. We know how it's going to turn out—the criminal justice system is cruel toward bears, and designed as a sort of new slavery, post-Bear-Jim-Crow—but it's not our place to see it. That's why it had that title. We are the Paddingtons too (2), expecting movies to show us everything will turn out okay and hold our hand. But it's a new world out there, and it's confusing, and maybe we should just accept it. Uncle Pastuzo is going to die off-screen. No idea what happens to our gal or even with the villain. Not until we get to the other side, at least.
Jk, jk, sorry for wasting your time with this awkward gag that no sensible blog reader would be expected to get. Here is my real question: The internet tells me that this movie that I just watched is better than Citizen Kane, and I have a hard time disagreeing. What are your thoughts? Which movie is better: Citizen Kane, or motherfucking Paddington 2?!
Frank: I just finished re-watching to refresh my memory of all the important Paddington details. will write up a first response in the morning.
Joe: Sweet, that will give me time to rewatch Citizen Kane.
Frank: Sight and Sound Magazine sends out a poll of the greatest movies of all time which they send out to international film professionals every ten years., From 1962 to 2002, Citizen Kane was ranked as the greatest movie ever made. In 2012, it came in second, overtaken by Vertigo. In the most recent poll of 2022, which introduced a vast new amount of women and POC voters into what had widely been a stodgy old white man affair, it STILL came in third.
OBJECTIVELY, Citizen Kane is a great movie, introducing countless new techniques and monumentally expanding the possibilities of the language of film. It also might be an 80-year-long overcorrection for Hollywood, kind of shrugging at the movie as it came out and being turned off by Orson Welles' singular auteurism in an industry that had heretofore celebrated the genius of movie studios over directors.
Here is my secret... I am left rather cold by Citizen Kane. I can appreciate it, I can nod in agreement at its impressiveness, but it doesn't move me. Casablanca moves me, City Lights moves me, Singin' in the Rain moves me. Great movies can hold up and be timeless. Some filming techniques are timeless in Kane, but I don't know if I really care about the arc of the character, I don't know if it has aged poorly, or maybe was cold and distant when it came out.
Paddington 2 does not leave me cold. It leaves me delighted and charmed and thoroughly enjoying myself. Perhaps it doesn't do anything to revolutionize film, perhaps it isn't a visual astonishment (although I'd argue the use of the pop-up book and Mrs. Brown's animated drawings are unique and exciting visual choices), but there are a lot of things that I love in it that I think are Great, and not just great for a family movie. First and foremost I think the script is absolutely incredible. Literally EVERY detail that is introduced in the first half is brought back and used in some way up through the climax. It is lean, it moves, and even vignettes that you assume are just excuses for sight gags for Paddington to get into some slapstick trouble and come back in meaningful plot ways later on. It is so tight and impressive to me.
I get suspicious when the internet says something like Paddington 2 is better than Citizen Kane because I suspect it is ironic hipsters, snarking at the perceived greatness of Kane by using what they consider to be a trite children's film as their weapon of irony, somehow making fun of both movies simultaneously. Greatness is subjective and objective in different ways, for sure, but a question I tend to ask myself is "Were the filmmakers successful in everything they were attempting to do" and then judge accordingly from there. It feels like P2 succeeds on many many fronts. What I wonder, and I guess my first question, is that in 80 years, will people still be arguing over and watching Paddington 2 the way they do CK?
OBJECTIVELY, Citizen Kane is a great movie, introducing countless new techniques and monumentally expanding the possibilities of the language of film. It also might be an 80-year-long overcorrection for Hollywood, kind of shrugging at the movie as it came out and being turned off by Orson Welles' singular auteurism in an industry that had heretofore celebrated the genius of movie studios over directors.
Here is my secret... I am left rather cold by Citizen Kane. I can appreciate it, I can nod in agreement at its impressiveness, but it doesn't move me. Casablanca moves me, City Lights moves me, Singin' in the Rain moves me. Great movies can hold up and be timeless. Some filming techniques are timeless in Kane, but I don't know if I really care about the arc of the character, I don't know if it has aged poorly, or maybe was cold and distant when it came out.
Paddington 2 does not leave me cold. It leaves me delighted and charmed and thoroughly enjoying myself. Perhaps it doesn't do anything to revolutionize film, perhaps it isn't a visual astonishment (although I'd argue the use of the pop-up book and Mrs. Brown's animated drawings are unique and exciting visual choices), but there are a lot of things that I love in it that I think are Great, and not just great for a family movie. First and foremost I think the script is absolutely incredible. Literally EVERY detail that is introduced in the first half is brought back and used in some way up through the climax. It is lean, it moves, and even vignettes that you assume are just excuses for sight gags for Paddington to get into some slapstick trouble and come back in meaningful plot ways later on. It is so tight and impressive to me.
I get suspicious when the internet says something like Paddington 2 is better than Citizen Kane because I suspect it is ironic hipsters, snarking at the perceived greatness of Kane by using what they consider to be a trite children's film as their weapon of irony, somehow making fun of both movies simultaneously. Greatness is subjective and objective in different ways, for sure, but a question I tend to ask myself is "Were the filmmakers successful in everything they were attempting to do" and then judge accordingly from there. It feels like P2 succeeds on many many fronts. What I wonder, and I guess my first question, is that in 80 years, will people still be arguing over and watching Paddington 2 the way they do CK?
Joe: My take on the Paddington 2 vs. Citizen Kane meme is that it exists to piss off people who are going to scoff at the idea that Paddington 2 could ever be considered a "better film" than Citizen Kane.
The metric used to "prove" that Paddington is better than Kane is RottenTomatoes, which, as we all know, is not necessarily going to be a true reflection of worth. Which is a better film, one with 100 B-minus reviews, or one with 99 A-plus reviews and 1 C-minus review? RottenTomatoes would say the former. All personal feelings about Citizen Kane aside (I need to rewatch it at some point, it's been a while), I think it's ridiculous to say that Paddington 2, a very well done children's film from 2017, is better by literally any metric (besides, I don't know, asking my five-year-old child or something, but that's a whole different kind of subjective).
But so any claims of "Paddington 2 is better according to one of the most popular movie-ranking metrics on the internet!!" is a troll move. E.g. I was at lunch with Sam a few days ago, and I tried out the whole "Paddington 2 is better than Citizen Kane" joke with him, and he took it very seriously. Not in that he got, like, pissed off or anything like that, but his response was "No, here is why Citizen Kane is better." That's the joke!!
I think the joke might be a little mean-spirited, in that it's taking the piss out of something that some people care about a lot and take pretty seriously (film), but if that's so, then the joke is on the person, not necessarily either movie. At least that's how I see it. I could see the viewpoint that it's making fun of Citizen Kane and Paddington 2, but I don't know. It helps that Paddington 2 is a legit good movie. This isn't a Bee Movie situation. The reviews (now a measly 99% positively rated, more on that at some point) didn't come out of fucking nowhere. This isn't a fucking scam or ruse. 99% of critics on the record enjoyed this movie, and they aren't wrong. The ironic hipsters are wielding RottenTomatoes as their weapon, not P2 itself. The RT system is flawed, and they are utilizing that flaw to crack jokes at the film connoisseur's expense.
But to answer your question: absolutely not. There is nothing controversial about this film. There isn't really anything to argue about in the text itself. It's fun, it's lighthearted, it's great for all ages, it has some legitimately good jokes and bits, it has a really pleasant message, it's brightly colored and exciting in the way being at a carnival is exciting, with the sights and sounds. Yes, it was on my list originally because of the Citizen Kane thing, so yes, this movie was just in the right/wrong place at the right/wrong time. But if I live to be 114 years old and I'm thinking about Paddington 2, it's going to be because of the goddamn meme, unfortunately. The only hope is that someone found this movie because of the meme (like me, I guess), and subsequently found it to be charming enough to keep watching it (there are plans to get the kids involved in this fucking thing as we speak—the mongrel dog that Paddington rides, Wolfie, has the same name as one of their favorite stuffed animals here). But the starting point remains the same.
It sounds like we're both on the same page here, in terms of Paddington 2's quality. Something I was thinking about while watching is how kind and decent this movie's protagonist is. So decent that this film briefly turns into It's a Wonderful Life—when Paddington goes to jail, we see how worse off everyone back in his old London neighborhood is, and how grumpy and mean everyone has gotten in his absence. But I was also wondering whether this has any effect on one's critical takeaway for Paddington 2 in general. I.e. does having a genuinely happy and kind and well-meaning and honest and courteous and decent protagonist make you, the audience member, more likely to think the same thing about the movie itself? Does Paddington's goodness extend to Paddington, either consciously or subconsciously? Does the relentless optimism in the film make it difficult to be pessimistic about the film?
The metric used to "prove" that Paddington is better than Kane is RottenTomatoes, which, as we all know, is not necessarily going to be a true reflection of worth. Which is a better film, one with 100 B-minus reviews, or one with 99 A-plus reviews and 1 C-minus review? RottenTomatoes would say the former. All personal feelings about Citizen Kane aside (I need to rewatch it at some point, it's been a while), I think it's ridiculous to say that Paddington 2, a very well done children's film from 2017, is better by literally any metric (besides, I don't know, asking my five-year-old child or something, but that's a whole different kind of subjective).
But so any claims of "Paddington 2 is better according to one of the most popular movie-ranking metrics on the internet!!" is a troll move. E.g. I was at lunch with Sam a few days ago, and I tried out the whole "Paddington 2 is better than Citizen Kane" joke with him, and he took it very seriously. Not in that he got, like, pissed off or anything like that, but his response was "No, here is why Citizen Kane is better." That's the joke!!
I think the joke might be a little mean-spirited, in that it's taking the piss out of something that some people care about a lot and take pretty seriously (film), but if that's so, then the joke is on the person, not necessarily either movie. At least that's how I see it. I could see the viewpoint that it's making fun of Citizen Kane and Paddington 2, but I don't know. It helps that Paddington 2 is a legit good movie. This isn't a Bee Movie situation. The reviews (now a measly 99% positively rated, more on that at some point) didn't come out of fucking nowhere. This isn't a fucking scam or ruse. 99% of critics on the record enjoyed this movie, and they aren't wrong. The ironic hipsters are wielding RottenTomatoes as their weapon, not P2 itself. The RT system is flawed, and they are utilizing that flaw to crack jokes at the film connoisseur's expense.
But to answer your question: absolutely not. There is nothing controversial about this film. There isn't really anything to argue about in the text itself. It's fun, it's lighthearted, it's great for all ages, it has some legitimately good jokes and bits, it has a really pleasant message, it's brightly colored and exciting in the way being at a carnival is exciting, with the sights and sounds. Yes, it was on my list originally because of the Citizen Kane thing, so yes, this movie was just in the right/wrong place at the right/wrong time. But if I live to be 114 years old and I'm thinking about Paddington 2, it's going to be because of the goddamn meme, unfortunately. The only hope is that someone found this movie because of the meme (like me, I guess), and subsequently found it to be charming enough to keep watching it (there are plans to get the kids involved in this fucking thing as we speak—the mongrel dog that Paddington rides, Wolfie, has the same name as one of their favorite stuffed animals here). But the starting point remains the same.
It sounds like we're both on the same page here, in terms of Paddington 2's quality. Something I was thinking about while watching is how kind and decent this movie's protagonist is. So decent that this film briefly turns into It's a Wonderful Life—when Paddington goes to jail, we see how worse off everyone back in his old London neighborhood is, and how grumpy and mean everyone has gotten in his absence. But I was also wondering whether this has any effect on one's critical takeaway for Paddington 2 in general. I.e. does having a genuinely happy and kind and well-meaning and honest and courteous and decent protagonist make you, the audience member, more likely to think the same thing about the movie itself? Does Paddington's goodness extend to Paddington, either consciously or subconsciously? Does the relentless optimism in the film make it difficult to be pessimistic about the film?
Frank: I want to make it clear that I can appreciate the meme and also film snobs deserve to be knocked down a few pegs; it's movies, not rocket science. We could get into the insanity of ranking art to begin with, and more and more as I get older I feel like letting people like what they like. If it is the best movie to you, how magical and special that is. Gatekeeping in movies is dumb. It is along the lines of pretending never to have heard of Harvard when talking to an alumni.
This is where I think Paddington 2 really benefits from being a sequel, and perhaps superior to the first film. All sequels in my mind, in order to defend the necessity of their existence (in which we believe that popular art is in fact necessary), need to have something new to say, or expand on the freedoms allowed by not needing introductory exposition.
Paddington 1's main conflict is a familiar one. Curmudgeonly Mr. Brown needs to be won over by Bear whom the rest of his warm family connects with, and he learns a lesson on what family actually means. There is an arc where a main character is NOT into the relentless optimism, and then is worn down. That's the central conflict and its a very familiar trope.
To your point, Paddington 2 is able to thrive in almost everyone loving Paddington already. There is no real conflict in this movie. The plot is just kind of a mess he needs to get out of, no real character change happens. Hugh Grant is the antagonist, but there is no real danger he isn't going to get his comeuppance from the Browns. Knuckles is always going to have a change of heart. It reminds me of when Parks and Recreation changes its tone from being annoyed at how much of a nerd Leslie Knope is, and steers into "isn't it incredible that a passionate annoying nerd like Leslie Knope exists, and aren't we all better for it?" Maybe it IS a manipulation of our cynical hearts to make an overwhelmingly positive and kind movie with no conflict, but no more manipulative than using the tragedy of a child's death to make us feel sad, or a boogey man popping up on screen to scare us.
I think treacly and sickly sweet make me cynical. I could use more unabashed genuine kindness in the world.
Speaking of the antagonist Hugh Grant... I think he absolutely crushes in this movie. Here is someone whose reputation tumbled from A-list leading man to awkwardly rude Daily Show interview. taking the piss out of himself and doing it enthusiastically. All the real headshots of Hugh in his house make me laugh. This was a real esteem raiser for me. Are there specific things you liked about the movie beyond the general vibe??
This is where I think Paddington 2 really benefits from being a sequel, and perhaps superior to the first film. All sequels in my mind, in order to defend the necessity of their existence (in which we believe that popular art is in fact necessary), need to have something new to say, or expand on the freedoms allowed by not needing introductory exposition.
Paddington 1's main conflict is a familiar one. Curmudgeonly Mr. Brown needs to be won over by Bear whom the rest of his warm family connects with, and he learns a lesson on what family actually means. There is an arc where a main character is NOT into the relentless optimism, and then is worn down. That's the central conflict and its a very familiar trope.
To your point, Paddington 2 is able to thrive in almost everyone loving Paddington already. There is no real conflict in this movie. The plot is just kind of a mess he needs to get out of, no real character change happens. Hugh Grant is the antagonist, but there is no real danger he isn't going to get his comeuppance from the Browns. Knuckles is always going to have a change of heart. It reminds me of when Parks and Recreation changes its tone from being annoyed at how much of a nerd Leslie Knope is, and steers into "isn't it incredible that a passionate annoying nerd like Leslie Knope exists, and aren't we all better for it?" Maybe it IS a manipulation of our cynical hearts to make an overwhelmingly positive and kind movie with no conflict, but no more manipulative than using the tragedy of a child's death to make us feel sad, or a boogey man popping up on screen to scare us.
I think treacly and sickly sweet make me cynical. I could use more unabashed genuine kindness in the world.
Speaking of the antagonist Hugh Grant... I think he absolutely crushes in this movie. Here is someone whose reputation tumbled from A-list leading man to awkwardly rude Daily Show interview. taking the piss out of himself and doing it enthusiastically. All the real headshots of Hugh in his house make me laugh. This was a real esteem raiser for me. Are there specific things you liked about the movie beyond the general vibe??
Joe: Ya know, it's funny, I spent so much time thinking about Citizen Kane that I hadn't even given Paddington 1 a single second of thought until you brought it up. Which is weird, but not too weird, I guess. Weird in that this is a fucking sequel, and trusts us to know who these characters are already, and I didn't, I've never seen the first film, and yet that didn't seem to be much of a problem. It wasn't like watching Reba episode 100 without seeing the first 99. I had no questions about the logic of this one based on the pieces I was missing from the last one. But also, it wasn't that weird. This isn't the first children's film sequel I've seen before the original, and it won't be the last. Maybe they are designed that way. But now that you mentioned it, it does totally make sense that Mr. Brown is gonna be the skeptic in the first film. Maybe I would've appreciated his part in this Paddington 2 story if I had known that or thought about it at all.
I feel like I need to mention that I found Leslie Knope annoying in every iteration of her character through every season, but that's not something we need to get into here. I could watch ten seasons of Paddington & Recreation no problem.
Yeah, there was a lot to like here. Hugh Grant is a big one. This was at least the third time he's shown up in a Never Seen It movie, but definitely never like this. Good fun. It was all good fun because it seemed to be pretty self-aware about the stakes being low and about the audience not expecting much. There was some slapstick that was clearly designed for children, like the judge getting his head shaved accidentally by Paddington. It's not like I hated it or anything, but those laughs weren't for me (and, in fact, I'm told that that scene in particular is ripped straight from one of the books, which are definitely designed for children).
But there were other parts that I laughed out loud for, simply because they were designed to be ridiculous. I'm thinking of when that same judge is on the train with his wife, and the train waiter spills something on him. He yells, "I was spilled upon by chilled liquid!" in the most British way possible. That feels like a script rewrite at some point, like maybe originally it was "you spilled it on me!" but then a script doctor was like "what is the funniest way we could say that?" And it was funny! For no other reason than some put-upon grumpy British old man said something in a funny way. And I liked how the film was comfortable doing that.
Another example is when Knuckles gets a marmalade sandwich accidentally placed in his mouth. When the camera lingered on Brendan Gleeson's mesmerized face for about three seconds too long, I could literally hear Frank F****** laughing from the other side of the city. Another one was the grandma's reaction to hating Hugh Grant's character: "Actors lie for a living!" Maybe that was a P1 callback, I'm not sure. But it was enough of a non sequitur for me that I laughed. Because it's a ridiculous thing to say! So many little moments like that.
And let's not forget that this is a children's movie in which the stuffed teddy bear protagonist GOES TO PRISON. I feel like I take that kind of shit for granted sometimes, and I have to consciously remind myself that this is absurdity that works. Any question you might ask makes it funnier. E.g. what, so the British penal system allows for a bear to be blamed for theft of a priceless item even if the item in question isn't found? And the fact that the film is making me ask questions about bears going to prison and smoking guns feels like a win for the film. The absurdity piles on naturally.
I like the way you put this: "Were the filmmakers successful in everything they were attempting to do?" So basically, approaching the art on its own terms. Paddington 2 seems particularly inviting in that way. The film is silly and heartwarming, and it's really easy to approach it that way too. This is something I think about a lot in Record Club reviews. For music, it's easier to get lost in your own expectations or desires. "This album didn't hit me this week like it should have because I had the flu" or something like that. It can be a challenge to first figure out what the artist wants, and then second, to try to abide by those terms.
That's why the negative review that eventually ruined Paddington 2's perfect 100% RT score is such a fucking bad-faith piece of shit. The author clearly has expectations based on his experiences with entertainment outside the movie itself. He liked the books, and this isn't like the books. What a terrible movie to make that argument about. This isn't like fucking Peter Rabbit 2, in which James Corden obnoxiously sarcasms his way across an incredibly insincere take on a humble gentle children's tale. I've actually never read the Paddington books, but I assume they are genial and kind, and that's what I get from this film too.
My question, then, I guess could be seen in bad faith too, but let's try it. Say that you had an axe to grind and you were the self-appointed ruiner of perfect RT scores, and so you were writing a negative review of Paddington 2. HOWEVER, in your case, you fully adhere to the "Were the filmmakers successful in everything they were attempting to do?" guideline. You approach Paddington 2 on its own terms and still write a negative review. What would be in that review?
I feel like I need to mention that I found Leslie Knope annoying in every iteration of her character through every season, but that's not something we need to get into here. I could watch ten seasons of Paddington & Recreation no problem.
Yeah, there was a lot to like here. Hugh Grant is a big one. This was at least the third time he's shown up in a Never Seen It movie, but definitely never like this. Good fun. It was all good fun because it seemed to be pretty self-aware about the stakes being low and about the audience not expecting much. There was some slapstick that was clearly designed for children, like the judge getting his head shaved accidentally by Paddington. It's not like I hated it or anything, but those laughs weren't for me (and, in fact, I'm told that that scene in particular is ripped straight from one of the books, which are definitely designed for children).
But there were other parts that I laughed out loud for, simply because they were designed to be ridiculous. I'm thinking of when that same judge is on the train with his wife, and the train waiter spills something on him. He yells, "I was spilled upon by chilled liquid!" in the most British way possible. That feels like a script rewrite at some point, like maybe originally it was "you spilled it on me!" but then a script doctor was like "what is the funniest way we could say that?" And it was funny! For no other reason than some put-upon grumpy British old man said something in a funny way. And I liked how the film was comfortable doing that.
Another example is when Knuckles gets a marmalade sandwich accidentally placed in his mouth. When the camera lingered on Brendan Gleeson's mesmerized face for about three seconds too long, I could literally hear Frank F****** laughing from the other side of the city. Another one was the grandma's reaction to hating Hugh Grant's character: "Actors lie for a living!" Maybe that was a P1 callback, I'm not sure. But it was enough of a non sequitur for me that I laughed. Because it's a ridiculous thing to say! So many little moments like that.
And let's not forget that this is a children's movie in which the stuffed teddy bear protagonist GOES TO PRISON. I feel like I take that kind of shit for granted sometimes, and I have to consciously remind myself that this is absurdity that works. Any question you might ask makes it funnier. E.g. what, so the British penal system allows for a bear to be blamed for theft of a priceless item even if the item in question isn't found? And the fact that the film is making me ask questions about bears going to prison and smoking guns feels like a win for the film. The absurdity piles on naturally.
I like the way you put this: "Were the filmmakers successful in everything they were attempting to do?" So basically, approaching the art on its own terms. Paddington 2 seems particularly inviting in that way. The film is silly and heartwarming, and it's really easy to approach it that way too. This is something I think about a lot in Record Club reviews. For music, it's easier to get lost in your own expectations or desires. "This album didn't hit me this week like it should have because I had the flu" or something like that. It can be a challenge to first figure out what the artist wants, and then second, to try to abide by those terms.
That's why the negative review that eventually ruined Paddington 2's perfect 100% RT score is such a fucking bad-faith piece of shit. The author clearly has expectations based on his experiences with entertainment outside the movie itself. He liked the books, and this isn't like the books. What a terrible movie to make that argument about. This isn't like fucking Peter Rabbit 2, in which James Corden obnoxiously sarcasms his way across an incredibly insincere take on a humble gentle children's tale. I've actually never read the Paddington books, but I assume they are genial and kind, and that's what I get from this film too.
My question, then, I guess could be seen in bad faith too, but let's try it. Say that you had an axe to grind and you were the self-appointed ruiner of perfect RT scores, and so you were writing a negative review of Paddington 2. HOWEVER, in your case, you fully adhere to the "Were the filmmakers successful in everything they were attempting to do?" guideline. You approach Paddington 2 on its own terms and still write a negative review. What would be in that review?
Frank: Two things jumped to my mind. And of course, the caveat is this is PICKING NITS.
But using that criteria, I think the movie fails at looking beautiful sometimes. They do not have a gigantic budget, and the CGI animation suffers, as CGI animation often suffers. That seems like an insane insult to the fact that the animators make you care about a brought-to-life talking bear and how magical that is, but the hi-definition camera sometimes lends itself to showing the strings so to say. And it is frustrating because there ARE beautiful moments of animation, for me, especially during Paddington's daydreams of his Aunt in the pop-up book London. The all-time great movies tend to hold up visually, à la Snow White or Pinocchio or Bambi are still monuments of animation achievement. And if you can't be monumentally beautiful, be weird and unique and gritty like Labyrinth, which seems to have held onto people's imaginations (like your wife) into adulthood. I just wish this blew me away visually as consistently as it does structurally.
Secondly, I think that if the slapstick scenes don't work for you, that is a failure on their part, not your taste. Nothing matters more in comedy than timing, and slapstick especially for people over eight years old has a razor-thin margin of error for timing, but I DO think it is possible to film the scenes of Paddington in the barbershop or in the prison laundry room could, if they had perfect timing, elicit laughter from you and me.
Something I think about and am curious about your thoughts: This is a British Film. Are British movies Foreign Films? I guess by that I mean it's easy to treat movies that are in Spanish or French or Iranian as cultural documents that I don't have full understanding of. These movies for me as an American viewer tend to be expansive learning experiences into cultures that I am ignorant of, and I don't know if that is an intended consequence of the filmmakers, who I assume are making these movies for their own cultures' audiences. So it's just a bonus for me! When movies are in English, I don't think about it as much, because of so much shared cultural understanding, but there is no question this is a British movie, made for British audiences. So then, are we getting the true Paddington experience?
But using that criteria, I think the movie fails at looking beautiful sometimes. They do not have a gigantic budget, and the CGI animation suffers, as CGI animation often suffers. That seems like an insane insult to the fact that the animators make you care about a brought-to-life talking bear and how magical that is, but the hi-definition camera sometimes lends itself to showing the strings so to say. And it is frustrating because there ARE beautiful moments of animation, for me, especially during Paddington's daydreams of his Aunt in the pop-up book London. The all-time great movies tend to hold up visually, à la Snow White or Pinocchio or Bambi are still monuments of animation achievement. And if you can't be monumentally beautiful, be weird and unique and gritty like Labyrinth, which seems to have held onto people's imaginations (like your wife) into adulthood. I just wish this blew me away visually as consistently as it does structurally.
Secondly, I think that if the slapstick scenes don't work for you, that is a failure on their part, not your taste. Nothing matters more in comedy than timing, and slapstick especially for people over eight years old has a razor-thin margin of error for timing, but I DO think it is possible to film the scenes of Paddington in the barbershop or in the prison laundry room could, if they had perfect timing, elicit laughter from you and me.
Something I think about and am curious about your thoughts: This is a British Film. Are British movies Foreign Films? I guess by that I mean it's easy to treat movies that are in Spanish or French or Iranian as cultural documents that I don't have full understanding of. These movies for me as an American viewer tend to be expansive learning experiences into cultures that I am ignorant of, and I don't know if that is an intended consequence of the filmmakers, who I assume are making these movies for their own cultures' audiences. So it's just a bonus for me! When movies are in English, I don't think about it as much, because of so much shared cultural understanding, but there is no question this is a British movie, made for British audiences. So then, are we getting the true Paddington experience?
Joe: This is a good question, and it's a good one because it's a question I've never tried to answer, despite the fact that I have definitely used the words "British film" as a description. What is a British film? It has to be more than a gut reaction or a response to silly British accents.
Does the fact that I find it humorous that I'm talking about what constitutes "British film" during a discussion about fucking Paddington 2 make me an American? Maybe.
But here is what I found through some extremely light googling:
1. British films move slower and have more dialogue.
2. British films don't have your so-called A-list stars, and even the most well-known or most critically appreciated are content to work small, meaty roles in lieu of "starmaking" roles.
3. There is subtlety in British film that is lacking in the spectacle of American film.
So if all of these things are true in Paddington 2 (and I would argue they are), and we are to assume that this is how it should be (and I would argue it is, since it is based on the Paddington books come from England starting in 1958), then this seems like the true Paddington experience to me.
I am so sorry for bringing up the Peter Rabbit movies again—I don't know if you've seen them, and if you haven't, don't let the Vampire Weekend soundtrack fool you, they fucking suck turds—but this probably speaks to why those movies are terrible and this Paddington movie works well. Peter Rabbit, a similar children's book character, has been thoroughly Americanized in the film adaptations. Loud explosions, brash pop culture references, marquee names doing the voice acting, fast and "witty" dialogue. This is the American way, and it's a poor fit for a humble British children's literature rabbit, and no fucking amount of obnoxious winking meta commentary from blowhard asshole James Corden can save it.
So maybe this has something to do with children's film more than adult film? Like, Ocean's Eleven wouldn't work as a British film, at least not under these criteria.
Alright, I think we may have stretched out this Paddington 2 discussion for as long as it deserves. My final question—besides asking you to drop your grade, which you may do before you sign off—goes something like... I'm wondering if there is room in this world for film that is just good enough. I feel like I take for granted, at least in this space that I've carved out for us on the internet, that there are just so many fucking GREAT ALL-TIME CLASSIC films that I've yet to see, and for which I'll devote a lot of my time thinking about and writing about and discussing and marveling over. But then there is also this other type of film. I'll reiterate that I don't think we'll be talking about Paddington 2 decades from now (unless the meme or this blog accidentally make it so—I'm saying that it won't be talked about in that time based on its own merits), but it was still kinda nice talking about it now, sharing a few days of discussion about this film that is totally good and nice and fine and enjoyable, but also might not necessarily be changing the world. What do we do with these types of films (besides have a serious discussion about it on Blogspot)?
Does the fact that I find it humorous that I'm talking about what constitutes "British film" during a discussion about fucking Paddington 2 make me an American? Maybe.
But here is what I found through some extremely light googling:
1. British films move slower and have more dialogue.
2. British films don't have your so-called A-list stars, and even the most well-known or most critically appreciated are content to work small, meaty roles in lieu of "starmaking" roles.
3. There is subtlety in British film that is lacking in the spectacle of American film.
So if all of these things are true in Paddington 2 (and I would argue they are), and we are to assume that this is how it should be (and I would argue it is, since it is based on the Paddington books come from England starting in 1958), then this seems like the true Paddington experience to me.
I am so sorry for bringing up the Peter Rabbit movies again—I don't know if you've seen them, and if you haven't, don't let the Vampire Weekend soundtrack fool you, they fucking suck turds—but this probably speaks to why those movies are terrible and this Paddington movie works well. Peter Rabbit, a similar children's book character, has been thoroughly Americanized in the film adaptations. Loud explosions, brash pop culture references, marquee names doing the voice acting, fast and "witty" dialogue. This is the American way, and it's a poor fit for a humble British children's literature rabbit, and no fucking amount of obnoxious winking meta commentary from blowhard asshole James Corden can save it.
So maybe this has something to do with children's film more than adult film? Like, Ocean's Eleven wouldn't work as a British film, at least not under these criteria.
Alright, I think we may have stretched out this Paddington 2 discussion for as long as it deserves. My final question—besides asking you to drop your grade, which you may do before you sign off—goes something like... I'm wondering if there is room in this world for film that is just good enough. I feel like I take for granted, at least in this space that I've carved out for us on the internet, that there are just so many fucking GREAT ALL-TIME CLASSIC films that I've yet to see, and for which I'll devote a lot of my time thinking about and writing about and discussing and marveling over. But then there is also this other type of film. I'll reiterate that I don't think we'll be talking about Paddington 2 decades from now (unless the meme or this blog accidentally make it so—I'm saying that it won't be talked about in that time based on its own merits), but it was still kinda nice talking about it now, sharing a few days of discussion about this film that is totally good and nice and fine and enjoyable, but also might not necessarily be changing the world. What do we do with these types of films (besides have a serious discussion about it on Blogspot)?
Frank: Something that I appreciate about your Never Seen It project is that it's not all Great Classics on "most important lists.'. Some are just good enough, some are so bad that they are good, and some are just bad. And that's how art is! And they all gave you something, you took SOMETHING from the experience. Obviously, most of the "non-important" stuff doesn't survive the age of time, so we get Shakespeare and not "fill in the blank any other playwright from Elizabethan England." So it goes.
I have used this book, 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die, as my guiding star of important movies from across the world over the last 115 years. I've had this book since I was fifteen, and new editions have come out almost every year since, so the actual total list has become 1198 movies. I still have to see 660 of them! My point is I certainly appreciate a guide of what the great movies are, and it definitely introduced me to great movies from Iran, Japan, Sweden, the Former Soviet Union, etc., that I probably never would have gotten around to seeing, and I am grateful and a more complete person than I was.
But it is exhausting sometimes. It is a slog. There is a four-hour Belgian movie that most recently topped that Sight and Sound poll, and I have been ABSOLUTELY DREADING watching it. Even though I'll probably love it. It is intimidating the shit out of me... Anyway I guess my point is (finally he gets to it!) it is a great and powerful experience to go see an orchestra perform Mozart or Beethoven, and it is amazing to listen to a Pink Floyd or Jay-Z album when you are fifteen and it feels like it changes your life, but sometimes it is an equally great and powerful experience to go watch an indie rock band at a dive bar who are kind of sloppy but everyone is having a great time. Paddington 2 made me happy to watch, it gave me joy. It might not change the world, but that is all you can ask for out of art, and I am very glad that it exists. I hope "lesser" movies that are just well-made escapes continue to exist
FRANK'S GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
JOE'S GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Another children's film—Pan's Labyrinth.
I have used this book, 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die, as my guiding star of important movies from across the world over the last 115 years. I've had this book since I was fifteen, and new editions have come out almost every year since, so the actual total list has become 1198 movies. I still have to see 660 of them! My point is I certainly appreciate a guide of what the great movies are, and it definitely introduced me to great movies from Iran, Japan, Sweden, the Former Soviet Union, etc., that I probably never would have gotten around to seeing, and I am grateful and a more complete person than I was.
But it is exhausting sometimes. It is a slog. There is a four-hour Belgian movie that most recently topped that Sight and Sound poll, and I have been ABSOLUTELY DREADING watching it. Even though I'll probably love it. It is intimidating the shit out of me... Anyway I guess my point is (finally he gets to it!) it is a great and powerful experience to go see an orchestra perform Mozart or Beethoven, and it is amazing to listen to a Pink Floyd or Jay-Z album when you are fifteen and it feels like it changes your life, but sometimes it is an equally great and powerful experience to go watch an indie rock band at a dive bar who are kind of sloppy but everyone is having a great time. Paddington 2 made me happy to watch, it gave me joy. It might not change the world, but that is all you can ask for out of art, and I am very glad that it exists. I hope "lesser" movies that are just well-made escapes continue to exist
FRANK'S GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
JOE'S GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Another children's film—Pan's Labyrinth.

No comments:
Post a Comment