Thursday, October 12, 2023

Never Seen It, #119 of 200: No Country for Old Men

Grab your air-powered captive bolt pistol and join us as we continue down the list of 200 movies I've never seen before.


No Country for Old Men
2007
Joel and Ethan Coen

You've read conversation with Frank and with Fisher in this column before, but No Country for Old Men was the first time they had each separately requested to converse about the same movie. So we sent some emails back and forth between the three of us. Thanks, pals.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe: One of my secret shames is that, if I don't "get" a movie, I'll run off to the internet as soon as it's finished, and search for "what it means," basically. I don't need to do this for every movie I watch—definitely didn't need any explainers for Jackass Forever, I was pretty confident in that one—but some are definitely head-scratchers. No Country for Old Men? A lock for this phenomenon. Tommy Lee Jones talks about his dream, says he woke up, and then... fade to black. WHAT?!

But I don't want to just run off to the goddamn world wide web anymore. That makes me feel weak. I'm at the point now where I should be able to think on it for a little bit, and attempt to form some opinions or some theories or whatever from my own experience with the film. Even if it's bullshit, I want to at least try. After the credits roll, I'll put the phone down, load the dishwasher and brush my teeth, and by the time I get into bed, write at least one paragraph on my phone before I go to any website. So I tried it with No Country for Old Men. Thought on it, and wrote the following:

No Country for Old Men is only part of the story. Which is frustrating, but it's supposed to be. "It ain't all about you. That's vanity." We know how it's going to turn out, but it's not our place to see it. That's why it had that title. We are the old men, expecting movies to show us everything and hold our hand. But it's a new world out there, and it's confusing, and maybe we should just accept it. The hero is going to die off-screen. No idea what happens to our gal or even with the villain. Not until we get to the other side, at least.

And then of course I'm going to read up on it, but I want to start with my gut reaction first, and then go from there. There are obviously different interpretations out there. I read a lot about free will versus predetermined fate, and that kind of thing. Lots to think about. But this is my first question. What do you make of the ending? I.e. what is this movie really about? No wrong answers.


Frank: So Joe, I think you are on the right path. I think something that blew my mind the first time I saw this was assuming Josh Brolin was the main character, when in actuality Tommy Lee Jones is the main character. The movie is not about Josh Brolin getting away with the money, or even getting tragically killed in a heroic standoff with Anton Chigurh. He gets killed by the other Mexican drug cartel that we had kind of forgotten about because of the force of nature that is Javier Bardem! Essentially Brolin, the character we follow the most, is not our protagonist but a red herring. I had never seen anything like that before, it was really special to me.

This also means that our protagonist and antagonist never actually meet, never have a confrontation. The closest is the moment where Anton is potentially behind that door? or is that just Ed Tom being afraid that he is? THAT is what I think the movie is about. Ed Tom Bell is too afraid to face whatever this unstoppable evil is behind that door. He is afraid to fight the monster. He is an old man and he is afraid of being defeated by the thing he has been fighting against his whole life. Consider this line from the first narration he gives at the start of the movie:

"It's not that I'm afraid of it. I always knew you had to be willing to die to even do this job. But, I don't want to push my chips forward and go out and meet something I don't understand. A man would have to put his soul at hazard. He'd have to say, 'OK, I'll be part of this world.'"

He is taking that as a failure, but I think what his uncle points out is that "evil" will never not be there. Good men can't defeat it, all they can do is hold it back the best they can, until the next generation comes along, but the fight is never going to have an end. There will always be an Anton Chigurh, an unstoppable force.

I think the dreams are him coming to peace with continuing his dad's legacy, even if he can't beat the evil, and that his dad who has passed away is waiting for him in heaven, the reward for a life lived as a person who tried.


Fisher: I like this movie to be a case-by-case basis of its "thesis." I appreciate the myriad viewpoints. Let the people decide.

The Coen Bros. have a history of stark portrayals of violence. I take this movie as another "And always remember, people, violence can visit you whenever the fuck it wants."

But of course I'm here for all things Tommy Lee Jones. And yeah, truly he's the protagonist. Brolin is just a guy in it with a lot of screentime. Jones's story bookends the piece. Performance is flawless.

And I can absolutely see the Coens exercising their anxieties through Tom Bell. Probably one day, not long before the movie came to life, they thought to themselves, "Oh shit, we're old now." And they sought catharsis through the words of Cormac McCarthy.

But like what the film MEANS... I'm not interested in making a point to defend because I think anything goes. All points equal. Not to be diplomatic, but because there are several themes you could point to that are so well exhibited and thus could be argued to be "the point."

But if I'm leaning in any directions: watch out for violence, pick your existential battles, and humble yourself. That would be my case. Maybe because these are all three points I'd like to see humanity embrace.

Question: Did you guys understand the machinations of the plot soon enough after? I didn't until my third or fourth viewing. With probably some online assistance as well.


Joe: That's a great question, man. Especially because the implied follow-up question is "does it matter if we know all the plot machinations?" And maybe the answer is yes, it does matter. I'm trying to get to the point where maybe I accept that there are going to be parts of the story that I don't necessarily get. I think this is a just a personal adverse reaction I have to my in-laws talking shit on Everything Everywhere All at Once. It's like, yo, Butch, just because you don't understand it doesn't mean you can say it's a shitty movie. If the plot is bothering you, then that's your fault, not the movie's.

Anyway, where was I. Did I understand the plot of No Country for Old Men? Enough that I was able to hang on. There's an expectation that there's an adjustment period when you first start a film, as you figure out what the fuck is happening here. I don't necessarily know if I "get" at this point why Anton Chigurh wanted the money (besides the fact that it's a lot of money), and perhaps I don't know about the dead bodies at the beginning, like, did Chigurh do that?

But I would also argue that knowing those answers does nothing to add to my understanding of this film. And if the film decides that those plot points aren't important enough to spell out, then maybe it's telling me I don't necessarily need to know.

Which is such a bullshit copout, right? But I guess that's just where you're catching me right now, dudes. Why this film is (or, in this case, could be) important to me is where I connect with it emotionally. And I'm seeing it as an exercise in not knowing, or in training me to appreciate without the knowing, or something like that.

Frank, bring me back down to earth.


Frank: Two thoughts, as a repeat viewer on some plot points: 1) I think Chigurh wants the money purely out of the principle that he was hired to get it, and he always finishes a job (even if he goes in and murders the company that hired him); 2) the dead bodies at the beginning are a Mexican cartel. The MacGuffin of this movie is all just a drug deal that went wrong.

I think an important thing to note is this is reportedly one of the better adaptations out there in terms of loyalty to the book. Most of the dialogue is literally just transcribed from Cormac McCarthy. So what do the Coen Brothers have to offer then? I think that the emotional impact you mentioned, Joe, is the answer. I can wax poetic about the existential philosophy of Tommy Lee Jones and the nature of evil all day long, but what sticks with me in this movie is the scene in the hotel as Josh Brolin is waiting for Javier Bardem to come into his room, the footsteps stopping right in front of his door, the outside lights turned off. That is moviemaking. That made me feel something. The dialogue is fantastic, but the camera work, especially the cinematography of the "master of darkness" Roger Deakins, really is what makes this movie special. 

2007 really was an incredible year of movies for me. There's this, Ratatouille, Zodiac, Atonement, Superbad, and There Will Be Blood. I want to focus on There Will Be Blood for my next question, which is intrinsically linked in my mind with No Country For Old Men (fun fact, they were filming at the same time, only a few miles away from each other). To me, these movies are quintessentially American, sharing themes in destiny, greed, and the failed American Dream. How important do you think the setting of this movie is? The Vietnam War hangs in the background pretty heavily, and I think the title is not just referring to the countryside, but a decaying America. Am I overthinking this?


Fisher: I wholeheartedly endorse Frank's points made about the plot. It took until my third, maybe fourth viewing before I could confidently state the machinations. I know I didn't NEED to understand it. I enjoyed it well before I ever did. But understanding certain characters' motives really helped scratch an itch.

The Coen Brothers are twenty-five-year veterans by the time this movie releases. To Frank's point: the filmmaking on display here is beyond reproach. Doesn't matter how good/bad/accurate the dialogue is. I might wager you could figure out the plot of the film on mute and without subtitles. The pacing and cinematography tell the story as well as the words.

2007 was a fabulous film year. As for the relevance of the setting, I am unsure. I could sit here and probably wax on about how it could only be set in 1980 Bumfuck, Texas. But for all I know, one could probably explain how 1970 NYC would be more appropriate.

The Coens have an established hard-on for Texan landscapes. And they have a thematic history of violence being thrust into the lives of "ordinary" people.

As for Vietnam, I'm not gonna spend any more time thinking about its relevance. Because I don't know its relevance. I'm sure it's relevant. I'm just unsure how it's relevant. Maybe Brolin's experience there would parallel TLJ's disillusionment? The sheriff sees the world he knew turning upside down. Brolin saw the world he knew turned upside down. Where this train-of-thought leads, I have no idea. 

My best guess on the title is that it's kinda summed up by, was that the Sheriff's brother? Uncle? The guy who delivers the "that's vanity" line. Shit changes, sometimes on a dime, and you just have to accept it. If you walk around carrying outdated beliefs for too long, then you might not "survive." Although in this case, I suppose I didn't need quotations.

I don't think you're overthinking things because I don't think this movie can be overthought.

My question: It can be no stretch to suggest that Chigurh represents the very notion of death. Does his portrayal strike you as accurate, or fair in that regard?


Joe: Gotta touch on Frank's Q real quick, since IMDrewB mentioned the connection in his There Will Be Blood interview too (the oil rig explosion on the set of There Will Be Blood halted production next door at No Country for Old Men because the smoke was too thick).

"Decaying America" strikes me as the throughline here. With There Will Be Blood, there was a sort of cautionary tale, that the pursuit of power would ultimately lead to one's downfall (and, if what's his name was a symbol of America and its endless pursuit of power through capitalism, then maybe a warning that America was headed down the wrong path). With No Country for Old Men, that pursuit of money and power is maybe even more ruthless? With Chigruh, there's no emotion there, no passion, just money as a matter of principle. "This is what I'm going to do, and there's nothing anyone can do to stop me." For all you The Wire fans out there: Daniel Plainview is to Avon Barksdale as Anton Chigurh is to Marlo Stanfield.

Javier Barden definitely earned that Oscar, by the way. This wasn't a very "showy" performance, which I feel like usually earns the Oscar. Instead, it was quiet and menacing, and frankly fucking scary. I hate the overuse of the word "iconic" on the internet, but Chirgurh's weapon of choice feels iconic to me.

I love the idea of this character representing death itself. Death is inescapable, both in the real world, and in this film. And it's senseless. Some of the most tense scenes in the film were when Chirgurh asked his potential victim to flip a coin. The shopkeeper calls it right, and by pure luck, he lives. Carla Jean refuses to choose. We don't get to see the outcome, but what's clear is that the choice matters. She refuses to kowtow to death. If death comes for her, then that is what's meant to be. This feels like a character taking the reins of her destiny (comparable to Ed Tom, maybe, who similarly refuses to play the game, and shows a weird kind of bravery in taking himself out of the game).


Frank: I think a lot of things go into making an all-time great movie, and something that the Coens excel at is filling their cast with excellent supporting casts. This movie is filled to the brim with character actors who are the secret spice to make sure movies pop, and I just don't want them to go unmentioned. Obviously Woody Harrelson, but also Stephen Root, Barry Corbin, Raising Hope's Garret Dillahunt, and Beth Grant, who in my mind has found an incredible career playing mothers-in-law. They all do the most with the little they are given. 

There are about sixteen minutes of music in this movie in total, and most of it comes during the end credits. What do you think of this choice to heighten the atmosphere, specifically, is this lack of score something you became aware of as you were watching? 


Fisher: To have a movie with virtually no score is a CHOICE. Fortunately for the Coens, they're world-class filmmakers who could make a movie on mute and you'd still be enthralled. I don't know if I noticed this silence on my first go-'round, but it has been on my mind since. And I like this choice.

This movie could be just as phenomenal with a steady score. But by omitting one, all other aspects are forced to shoulder a heavier load. And by doing so it makes us appreciate those pieces that much more. Fortunately AGAIN for the Coens, they're cast and crew are also world class:

Cinematography: Best guy in the business 
Antagonist: Wins the Oscar
Protagonists: TLJ, everybody loves him. Brolin, everybody went on to love him.
Supporting cast: As Frank said, all bangers.

Primo storytellers, primo actors, primo technicians. Put those things together and it... doesn't always work. But this time it did. It really fuckin' did.

This is a candidate, if not a shoe-in, for my top ten all-timers. It's the first movie I saw at a Ritz downtown. Among the first movies I ever went to alone. I wasn't a Coen fanatic at the time, but the trailer had me HYPE. It sat in my mind like a lead weight for days afterwards.

Sitting here thinking of how else to praise it. See it if you haven't. There ya go.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Thanks again to Frank and to Fisher. See you guys around the blog sometime.

JOE'S GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: There was a question as to whether I meant Ocean's Eleven from 2001 or Ocean's 11 from 1960 when I put this movie on the big list. Definitely the newer one—I'd rather watch paint dry than subject myself to more Frank Sinatra.

No comments: