Monday, October 30, 2023

RC f/u #23: Margo Price, American Trappist, Menzingers, Hidden Things

Anyone who has a problem with the "no repeat artists" rule in Record Club should find solace in the fact that once you are a part of the Record Club family, you're trapped here forever. So if you want to know about an artist's new work even after we've covered a previous album in RC, then you came to the right place.


Strays II by Margo Price
Released: October 13, 2023
Follow-up to: Strays, Week 229

I don't even know if this album should be here. Is Strays II a completely separate album from Strays, or are these nine new songs part of a "deluxe edition" of some sort? I'm choosing to see it as the former, since I don't fuck with bonus tracks of any kind, but I do fuck with Margo Price.

I hemmed and hawed a lot in my Strays review about some of my own personal shit—the success of which varies, depending on how much you care about the peccadilloes of some random blogging asshole—but what was lost in the shuffle was the fact that, man, you can't really call Margo Price's music "country" or even "Americana" anymore, can you?

I have no stake in the fight over Price's soul, and I like Americana but don't consider myself a defender of the genre or anything, so I really don't care all that much. But as someone who has been listening to Margo Price for a few years, I can say that the transition happened so slowly that I honestly didn't even notice until halfway through my fourth or fifth spin of Strays II. All of a sudden, it was like, holy shit, wait, there's no country music on this record.

What would you call it? Now that's usually an answer that I'm ill-equipped to give. Folk rock, maybe? Like, in the Laurel Canyon sense? Could you reasonable call this a facsimile of classic rock, in quality and sound if obviously not in a chronological sense? Yes to all of the above. I like it a lot. I like it enough that it retroactively makes me like the album that it's a sequel to even more. Which is rare of sequels, now that I'm thinking about it.

Bottom line: keep it up, Margo Price. Do whatever you want to do. I'm glad I'm here for it.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5 (+0.5 from previous review)


Poison Reverse by American Trappist
Released: June 9, 2023
Follow-up to: Tentanda Via, Week 42

Let's not undersell this album with any tangential observations—Poison Reverse is a good album, and I'm thankful to know it through the fact that the artist is a long-time Record Club alumnus. Most of the albums I cover in this supplemental RC column are either 1) albums I'd be downloading anyway, or 2) albums that I'll probably never listen to again. Poison Reverse is a rare third option: an album that I listened to in order to briefly review, but ended up liking so much that I'll download it anyway.

The second thing I'll say, after the fact that it's worth your time, is that American Trappist seem to have finally (at least from my personal perspective) carved their niche and their own brand and their own particular sound. My first review back in 2019 (written in haste before Martha was born, mind you) spoke to the degree in which I heard other artists' sounds in American Trappist's photocopy. I still hear some Bruce Springsteen via War on Drugs (like in "Temple Song"), and I still hear some Wilco (like in "Nobody's Laughing"), etc., but I also hear what I now know is American Trappist.

Alt-rock and grunge are hot right now, and it was nice that those sounds are now baked into the equation. "What Did I Wish For?" rocks, no question. "Seg Fault" has a clear and concise guitar solo that sounds fresh and exciting. "Lamentations" gives me a good fix of a sort of Win Butler-esque vocals, but in a refreshingly non-rapey way. True, these are not "new" sounds in general, but being new for American Trappist, I can say that this band is certifiably established in doing their own thing. (It's also a lot more fun than the last outing, The Gate, which is a good thing. Sean's worries about his friend don't seem to have gone to waste.)

There is certainly some stuff that doesn't quite work here ("Ruthie's Blues" a bit too forgettable, "Orlando" inducing blue balls), but overall, I'm more than satisfied. American Trappist will never be the best band on the planet, but it's the type of band that you're sincerely glad to have around. And they are the type of band that make you appreciate Record Club, in its ability to bring this type of music around, and keep it here.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5 (+0.5 from first review and most recent review, though that most recent one was probably overrated a touch)


Some of It Was True by the Menzingers
Released: October 13, 2023
Follow-up to: Hello Exile, Week 36

A complete list of surprising sounds on the new Menzingers album:

1. The marching band percussion at the end of "Nobody Stays"
2. The gang vocals at the end of "Running in the Roar of the Wind"

And even that second one is a bit of a stretch. You expect gang vocals on such an album, but I included it on the shortlist because maybe you don't expect that many people. It sounds like there are hundreds singing the chorus there. I liked it.

But yeah, the fact that a list of "surprising sounds" is comprised of maybe one and a half items should heavily imply that on Some of It Was True, you overwhelmingly get the sounds you typically expect from these guys. The sound is established, and it is not very malleable.

Still, it's long been established that it's a sound I quite like, and so I'm pretty comfortable having it back in my life. When that rip-roaring chorus of "Alone in Dublin" hits—"She knows my heart! She knows how to start it!"—I know that I'm right where I belong. A big ol' Welcome Back to the punk rockers with whom I'm growing old.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5 (-0.5 from previous review)


Night Work by Hidden Things
Released: March 10, 2023
Follow-up to: Not Even Regret, Week 102

There remains a conflict of interest, both in the fact that Hidden Things is the moniker of the uncle of my friend / PoYB contributor Nate, and in the fear that the artist in question could feasibly be reading these words, thus obliterating the wall that needs to exist between artist and critic for this whole fucking cottage industry to sustain itself. In order to maintain the purity of these proceedings, I refuse to engage critically. Still, that refusal butts up against my responsibilities as Record Club editor-in-chief to let you know that one of our esteemed alumni, Hidden Things a.k.a. Uncle Greg, has a new album this year, and that you should listen to it if you like good music.

I asked Nate a few weeks ago if he knew that Uncle Greg had a new album out. Of course he knew, but I didn't mean it that way. I knew he knew, I just wanted him to say something about it. I'm copying and pasting Nate's concise response, without permission, only because I have a feeling that this is his sincere take; had I asked him to write something about Night Work for PoYB, there would have been the requisite ironic sheen attached. Ain't no time for that.

"I did know that Uncle Greg released an album this year, and while I cannot in good faith say this is a non-familial opinion, I can say that I think it might be his best album I've ever heard from him across all his bands, full stop. Was quite proud of it."

I think it's reasonable, from even an objective point of view, to say that Night Work is a leveling-up of the sounds that we heard on Not Even Regret. There's more of a variety, and so a greater chance that you're gonna find a specific sound that works for you. I find myself the most comfortable in the space between jangle pop and punk rock, like in "Pass the Time," and I definitely appreciate a lethally catchy hook such as the chorus of "Serious Type." But I'm speaking idly here. I'm not make any sort of judgment. I'm just pointing to an album that I like and asking you to check it out to see if you like it too.

I also think that the idea of liking something more because you personally know the person who made that thing is an idea worth exploring. I can't explore it within myself here because I don't actually know Uncle Greg. But I wonder about Nate and about the whole extended clan in their family and I'm pondering the value of such a bond through the lens of artistic criticism. Like, the fact that it's not "I only like this album because I know this person," but rather, "I like this album both separate from and in conjunction with my relationship to the artist, and that makes it special in two different ways." Maybe a thought that's not really for me to parse out, at least not here and not now.

GRADE: No grade given, but this one is even better than the last one.


Alright, roll call! What do we have left for 2023, as it stands right now? Albums from: Animal Collective, Jamila Woods, Bad Bunny, Free Throw, the Rolling Stones, Empty Country, PinkPantheress, Dolly Parton, and Danny Brown.

No comments: