Tuesday, October 10, 2023

Phony Beatlemania: "Paperback Writer"

Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #23 and is featured on pages 158-162.
 
 
"Paperback Writer"
single
1966

The way this book puts it, here's how "Paperback Writer" came to be: one day, Paul showed up at John's house and was like, "Hey, we should start a song that goes 'Dear Sir or Madam'," and then they proceeded to spend a day plucking an entire pop song out of thin air.

I've wasted words on this blog before describing how much I hate when pop music is made this way. The example I've used in the past is the Bangles' "Eternal Flame," and how its songwriter was like "Hey, the phrase 'eternal flame' would be a good title for a song," and then they worked backward from there. My gut reaction is that it doesn't fucking mean anything, ya know? If you're just putting words on a page and you're trying to match those words to the right chords and melodies, then that feels cheap. Where's the heart? Where's the power in meaning? It might sound good or even great but ultimately it rings hollow to me.

Sometimes. Obviously I'm not here to bash this wonderful Beatles song. It's just discombobulating to me to read that pop musicians have been writing songs this way since time immemorial. You don't think of the Beatles as "pop stars," but they ruled the pop charts. It's not their fault that pop music's sound has changed so dramatically over the decades. I just have a snap reaction that I need to tamper sometimes, and it's the feeling that when a pop musician has the unique talent of spinning bullshit into gold, that we should be suspicious of that. Maybe I should take it easy, since some of that gold is "Paperback Writer," and I cannot deny the majesty of this little two-minute jam.

Plus, I get the feeling that the subject matter of "Paperback Writer" is speaking directly to what I'm talking about. There's a lot in the book about how "Paperback Writer" is a rare Beatles hit that isn't about love or romance, but I'm less concerned about that. I'm more interested in the idea that "Paperback Writer" is the first Beatles hit that is about the very idea of writing a hit Beatles song.

The paperback book that the titular author is writing is in fact a metaphor, you see. The author says that he wrote a great book but that "I could make it longer if you like the style / I can change it 'round" if the publisher wants. Basically, the narrator is saying that, even though they think the book they wrote is a winner, that changes can be made if anyone else feels that they are necessary. The details aren't important, it's the idea that this thing exists and that it's gonna make everyone a lot of money.

Paul McCartney is saying that, with a song like "Paperback Writer," it doesn't really matter what it's about, and it doesn't matter if the lyrics actually mean anything at all or they just sound nice, and it doesn't matter how many chords you use (just two for this song, I'm told), and it doesn't matter whether there really is a paperback writer or it's figurative or it's all fictional or it's all bullshit or it's a vacuous attempt at more fame and more money and more success. What's important is that it exists, and whatever it is, that it sparks joy in the listener.

That's not even mentioning the fact that one of those listeners—yours truly—is invested in the lyrics of this song because they are weirdly reflective of my own life. Not that I actually want to be a published authors, but still: Dear sir or madam, will you read my blog? It took me years to write, would you take a look? It's five thousand blog posts, give or take a few, I'll be writing more in a week or two. And so on and so on.

Here's the genius of the Beatles. They admit that it's all a facade. Paul fucking admits it right fucking there that "Paperback Writer" is bullshit cobbled together on a whim one day because he thought of the opening line and went from there. And yet! Despite the alleged vacuousness of the songs lyrics and meaning, the audience hears this pop song and finds immense and integral meaning in it anyway. I hear a glorious, catchy rock song about a man who is weighing the futility of the thing in life that brings him joy, and the bravery it takes to be open and honest about one's pursuits, especially in the face of their purported worthlessness. Even if Paul didn't give a fuck about any of that and just wanted to hit #1 on the charts again, he still puts it out there, and its meaning grows from the outside in.

It works that way. It can also work as a two-minute break from the world, a vacation with the Beatles. It can work whatever way you want. You are in control. The Beatles are just giving you the high-quality typewriter. It's up to you to write your own story.

BEATLES TRIVIA: So wait, what the fuck is Ringo doing in the video (embedded at the top of this blog post)? The other three lads are looking cool and cucumbers with their respective guitars, but I guess Ringo didn't feel like bringing the drum kit? Here's a funny Reddit thread wondering the same thing, with no clear answers. Occam's razor says that it was just funnier to see Ringo chilling in the garden instead of playing a drum set. This really pains me to admit, but if I'm going to laugh at Ringo's shenanigans in this regard, then I'm going to have to retract any previous criticisms I had when Charlie Watts pulled the same shit during the COVID lockdown nonsense. I don't see how I can avoid being a hypocrite otherwise.

BETTER BEATLE: John apparently called this song "son of 'Day Tripper,'" which is this list's #32 entry. Regardless of whether that's accurate or not, it gives us a good entryway to comparison—is "Day Tripper" better than "Paperback Writer"? On some days, yes, and on others, no. I will confess that I think Otis Redding's cover of "Day Tripper" is better than both of them.

NEXT TIME: "Happiness Is a Warm Gun" at #24

No comments: