"Defeat"
Animal Collection
from Isn't It Now?
2023
I don't necessarily have that much to say about the new AnCo album. You get what you get with these guys. Some of it is catchy, and some of it is oppressively irritating. The annoying stuff is mostly the vocals. That "FloriDada" song that got mentioned in a couple RC reviews at the beginning of last year ends up being the rule, not the exception. It's just, like, off-putting when they are all singing together. It's droid-like. It's also kind of like the underwater-ish vocals from Grateful Dead's "Rosemary," which is totally the Dead's worst song, and not something to be consciously emulated. So, if you're looking to get the best out of AnCo and are rummaging through Isn't It Now?, then maybe you can skip the dreck like "King's Walk."
The only song that is out-and-out interesting on this new album of theirs is "Defeat," which made me do a double take when it came on the first time. 22 minutes?! Both hilarious and daunting that this fucking band is going to stick a song at that length right in the middle of an otherwise milquetoast psych outing. Song lengths like that beget attention. They have mine.
Songs that stretch 22 minutes usually are described like this: "Everything the band does well is here in this song!" I'll agree with the premise if we excise the word "well" from that sentence. Objectively, everything Animal Collective does is here; subjectively, most of it is not well. The high point is minutes ten through twelve, give or take a minute in either direction, when "the serpent in the water the mirror" (or whatever) comes in, and the rhythm is discernible, and AnCo hits the widescreen theatrics that they possess at their best (this is probably the only time on Isn't It Now? that this happens). Otherwise, this is long, drawn-out ghostly chants and other miscellaneous bullshit that just grates on my nerves.
I don't understand why a band would take what might normally be a pretty decent three-minute psych pop song, and stretch it in both directions until it turns into a painful display of adequacy at best. But then, I've never pretended to understand Animal Collective.
Songs that stretch 22 minutes usually are described like this: "Everything the band does well is here in this song!" I'll agree with the premise if we excise the word "well" from that sentence. Objectively, everything Animal Collective does is here; subjectively, most of it is not well. The high point is minutes ten through twelve, give or take a minute in either direction, when "the serpent in the water the mirror" (or whatever) comes in, and the rhythm is discernible, and AnCo hits the widescreen theatrics that they possess at their best (this is probably the only time on Isn't It Now? that this happens). Otherwise, this is long, drawn-out ghostly chants and other miscellaneous bullshit that just grates on my nerves.
I don't understand why a band would take what might normally be a pretty decent three-minute psych pop song, and stretch it in both directions until it turns into a painful display of adequacy at best. But then, I've never pretended to understand Animal Collective.
The most interesting reaction to this song, in my opinion, showed up in a Stereogum comment section last summer (that I only saw when I went back, post-listen, to try to see if anyone else on the internet was as worn out from AnCo as I am after this outing). Here it is in full. The full exchange is six comments and took ten days to complete.
I like the pithy way in which this conversation lays out the two main opposing viewpoints one could take when discussing art. What is art, and who has the right to judge it? The person who has an established voice but uses that POV to dismiss, or the person who comes out of nowhere to defend one's right to exist? I'd be interested to see who you believe is "Defeat"ed in this exchange. I agree with jim regarding Animal Collective and about this song (mostly), but I appreciate Grod's defense more, vis-à-vis art in general. True, "Defeat" is mostly agonizing, and yet, I am really thankful that it's here, if only to discuss and to use as a lightning rod of sorts, and I would never wish it away.
But that's what I say when I'm wearing my Record Club hat, typically, and I say it in that context because I am also defending Record Club's right to exist, as a lab to experiment with subjective opinions. At a certain point, though, the subjective opinion itself needs to be chiseled into stone, and if we stop at "I'm glad this is here to discuss," then music criticism becomes to wishy-washy and ceases to mean anything at all.
It's okay to hate something, I think is what I'm trying to say. You can do that while also relishing the opportunity to hate. I think that "Defeat" is mostly a bad song, despite the bouncy and all-too-brief middle section, and I like thinking about it and writing about it and discussing it with people through the internet cables stretched under the ocean, but none of that changes the fact that it's just not that good overall. This is good, and this is bad. You see what I mean.
I like the pithy way in which this conversation lays out the two main opposing viewpoints one could take when discussing art. What is art, and who has the right to judge it? The person who has an established voice but uses that POV to dismiss, or the person who comes out of nowhere to defend one's right to exist? I'd be interested to see who you believe is "Defeat"ed in this exchange. I agree with jim regarding Animal Collective and about this song (mostly), but I appreciate Grod's defense more, vis-à-vis art in general. True, "Defeat" is mostly agonizing, and yet, I am really thankful that it's here, if only to discuss and to use as a lightning rod of sorts, and I would never wish it away.
But that's what I say when I'm wearing my Record Club hat, typically, and I say it in that context because I am also defending Record Club's right to exist, as a lab to experiment with subjective opinions. At a certain point, though, the subjective opinion itself needs to be chiseled into stone, and if we stop at "I'm glad this is here to discuss," then music criticism becomes to wishy-washy and ceases to mean anything at all.
It's okay to hate something, I think is what I'm trying to say. You can do that while also relishing the opportunity to hate. I think that "Defeat" is mostly a bad song, despite the bouncy and all-too-brief middle section, and I like thinking about it and writing about it and discussing it with people through the internet cables stretched under the ocean, but none of that changes the fact that it's just not that good overall. This is good, and this is bad. You see what I mean.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Isn't It Now? by Animal Collective
Released: September 29, 2023
Follow-up to: Time Skiffs, Week 158
GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5 (-1.0 from previous review)


No comments:
Post a Comment