The textual: Animal Collective's newest album, Time Skiffs, was released on February 4, 2022, and features nine brand new songs from the indie rock institution, which will be reviewed here on Puke on Your Birthday now. I like the album.
The contextual: The 2010s saw Animal Collective gradually fall out of critical favor. Their big hit of the aughts came at the tail end of that decade—Merriweather Post Pavilion, known generally as one of the most important works of art of the '00s indie rock golden era. But the albums that preceded it—Sung Tongs in 2004, Feels in 2005, and especially Strawberry Jam in 2007—were all rising action.
Whereas the '10s were a bit of a falling action (what goes up must come down). The only two albums released that decade were 2012's Centipede Hz and 2016's Painting With, the latter which featured maybe the most irritating song of all time, Animal Collective or otherwise—"FloriDada," a grating testament to Animal Collective's reluctant staying power.
So with Time Skiffs and its warm welcome by critics and listeners alike, Animal Collective finds themselves in a sort of coming-home-party situation. It's easy to empathize, however, with the partygoers who find themselves at that Coming Home Party having spent the last decade-plus not really missing the guest of honor at all. What an awkward situation. Especially if that same partygoer had his opinion of AnCo hardened into diamond at the end of the '00s, when he just didn't get "My Girls" or any of that shit, and all the while flowers were thrown repeatedly at the band's feet, and that partygoer has maintained since his first month of undergrad that Strawberry Jam is the true high water mark here. And we're throwing a fucking Welcome Home Party for these jabronis? I didn't even know they were ever coming back!!
The subtextual: The grooves cannot be denied by anyone, regardless of one's level of skepticism. Strip away the pressure of time that might warp one's perception of the once mighty freak folk heroes, and we find 47 minutes of psychedelic weirdness that more than occasionally comes in contact with the catchy. Bands that are this able in mixing the traditional pop hook and the bizarre noise should be revered, not reviled.
"Strung with Everything" is the best example of what the band seems to have hoped to achieve with Time Skiffs. Indeed, it is a sampling of the very best that this band has in general hoped to achieve in their near-20-year existence. It starts with an 84-second noise collage, which gets your hopes down, but then the clicking groove comes in abruptly and gets things moving. Quickly after that, the hippie-dippie harmonies are chipping away at your psyche. Things seem normal, but before you know it, the whole thing is blowing up into widescreen music festival theatrics. If you're paying attention, you can feel the band start to gain momentum, but if you lose focus, then the big climax hits you like a fucking firework explosion. That last minute, when Avey Tare's voice starts cracking like it's goddamn 2008, you can practically feel the confetti rain down on you.
The stops and starts are baked into the premise of this band. They did, after all, "stop" making waves for almost an entire decade before "starting" up again in 2022. So it might be no surprise that the end of the album stops with the bangers and starts settling into a bit of a humdrum, like they are running out of steam. Perhaps, like many other animals, they are settling down for another long hibernation. If their intention was to send us off by tucking us into bed, then that goal has been achieved.
But the end result does not negate the journey of large bonfires and loud noises. It is a measured cacophony that only a vaunted band such as Animal Collective could create. There will be much rejoicing with this one, assuming you were a fan to begin with.
The metatextual: I wrote all that on Monday, and now it's Thursday, and I'm still trying to figure out how to wrap it up in the "metatextual" section, usually this reviewer's bread and butter. I think I'm thrown a little by the fact that two separate RC writers implied this week that they may or may not be "intimidated" by the regular RC writers, and I'm more worried at this point, not about how to wrap up my thoughts on Time Skiffs, but how I can put a stop to those misplaced fears and get more people involved, and whether the metatextual is contributing to the problem.
I feel this underlying need to include the maximum amount of people for everything I do. It's been part of my nature for decades now, and it hasn't subsided into my mid-30s, even though the "everything I do" part has been whittled down substantially due to parenthood. (There's a lot to say about these emotions and whether they might fall under the umbrella of narcissism or not, but let's table that discussion for a different time.) If I'm going to organize Record Club weekly, then I'm going to have a desire to see as many people participate weekly as I can. Thinking about Animal Collective was fun, but that's not the point; the fun part is thinking about Animal Collective together. And if people are choosing not to participate, then that means that's a part of the fun that is lost. And I'd like to change that.
But I don't even know if that's possible, right? Because I also love writing unreasonably lengthy bullshit (see: this review right now), and if that's going to "intimidate" someone, then I don't necessarily think that I need to sacrifice what I love to service inclusion. (Plus: there's the fact that Nate and Sunny and Pam already write pretty much every week too and that's pretty fucking fun, as far as I'm concerned.)
In fact, I'd argue the opposite should be true, even though it appears that it isn't—showing you that you are allowed to write a completely superfluous postscript at the end of your review, even though it really doesn't have anything to do with the Time Skiffs that you're reviewing, showing you that there are no rules for reviewing albums on this blog, that you can literally write whatever the fuck you want, that there is no pressure at all, like for real, at all, this should all encourage you to write more.
We're so fucking indoctrinated by our elementary school teachers that our written word should be constantly evaluated and critiqued and compared to others, that even years later it's tough not to scroll through and see what everyone else wrote and see how your own hypothetical written review might compare. Don't do that. We're not here to prove that we are scholars. That isn't the fucking point. The point is to listen to music, and then share your opinion about that music with your peers. That's all. It doesn't matter how you share your opinion. Share it in whatever way gives you joy. But fucking share it! Here is your opportunity!
I have shared my opinion about Animal Collective's Time Skiffs with you today. I have written that I like the album, that Time Skiffs significantly raises my previously dirt-level low opinion about Animal Collective, that most of it works because it locks into a groove, even though that groove starts to run out of steam by the end, that none of this makes me a "fan" of Animal Collective but hey it's better than nothing.
This is the text. There is context that describes Animal Collective's history and colors in my own personal history with the band. There is subtext that hints as to how I am feeling without using the word "I" but also describes how you might feel if you are not me. There is metatext that breaks the fourth wall and makes the reviewer a character in the review. Choose one of them. Choose all of them. Choose none of them. Do your own thing. Just do something. There's nothing to be intimidated about. There are no limits: let's talk about Time Skiffs. What did you think?
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
No comments:
Post a Comment