I said at the beginning of the year that A Year of Blind Spots would be mostly focusing on artists who are not currently on my iPod, but that there were a handful of exceptions. This is one of them. Why is Genesis an exception? Well, I was mostly interested in their existence prior to Peter Gabriel leaving the band. As I soberly detailed in the first half of my A Trick of the Tail review last year, Genesis went through a huge transition when their first frontman left the band, and Phil Collins stepped into the limelight to lead the band afterward. A Trick of the Tail was their first album without Peter Gabriel. The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway is their last album with Peter Gabriel.
So, there's the context. And I'll be honest, the context was pretty much all I had time for this week. School kicked my fucking ass, and it figures that a 94-minute prog rock opera would be up next in the rotation during such a week (to say nothing of the coincidence that our primary music criticism vehicle on the blog was also covering a concept album). Oh, I listened to a lot of Genesis, don't worry. I have opinions. Opinions such as: the title track is a fucking monster; songs like "Back in N.Y.C." and "Carpet Crawlers" show the wide range that prog rock can cover while still be certifiably prog rock; Phil Collins obviously fashioned his vocals after Peter Gabriel, because it was tough to tell the difference sometimes.
But the big thing I'm missing is the rock opera's story. I am partially aware of the fact that The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway is about a fictional protagonist named Rael, a Puerto Rican teen living in New York, who goes through a psychedelic journey to rescue his brother John. I only know this from reading the context though—I know that Peter Gabriel took charge of writing all the lyrics because the other ideas presented by the band were "too twee" and that "prancing around in fairyland was rapidly becoming obsolete" and so on. I didn't actually read up on the story though. I didn't have time!
I don't even know if it would make a difference though. I am still undecided if these wacky '70s rock operas' stories actually contribute to the power of the music, or if the music can just stand alone. I'm way more interested in the metatext of Peter Gabriel's schism from the rest of the band as a result of this album than I am in whatever the fuck Rael is up to (apparently he has to fight creatures with sores all over their bodies, as just one example?). Here is the album that broke Genesis—that's the story. And in true rock opera fashion, we are exploring Genesis' story in nonchronological fashion—first we listened to the them pick up the pieces, and then we see where the pieces shattered in the first place.
And please let none of this spoil the fact that I was able to listen to over an hour and a half of new (to me) music from one of rock 'n' roll's seminal prog rock gods. This was a very good album. And who knows, maybe some day I'll have time to actually go through the lyrics. Maybe it'll make the album even better. For now, though, I'm cool just rocking out and assuming that the story will be there for me when I have a moment for it.
No comments:
Post a Comment