Wednesday, February 2, 2022

Never Seen It, #70 of 200: Garfield: The Movie

Pull up a big plate of lasagna and get ready for the next movie on this list of 200.


Garfield: The Movie
2004
Peter Hewitt

I can't imagine that there is that much to talk about today, right? I mean, this film was exactly what I expected. No alarms, no surprises. I can think of at least three things to talk about briefly, and maybe we'll do a short list of the movie's worst moments, and then we'll call it day. What do you say, gang? An easy day today? My only regret is that this blog post isn't being published on a Monday.

First in terms of priorities is the ax I gotta grind. As you may already know, the one and only Bill Murray voices our titular feline. I can't say it's a terrible choice—Billy Murray seems in real life about as grumpy as Garfield seems in the comics. And I can't even say that I begrudge Bill Murray for taking the role. If it's true that Murray recorded a lot of his dialogue while on the set of The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou, then that's easy fucking money. Go for it, dude.

I guess what I do take issue with is the bullshit with Murray claiming that he only took the role because he "thought scriptwriter Joel Cohen was Joel Coen of the Coen Brothers." He's made this claim in two different Reddit AMAs, so he's apparently sticking to this story, but it's such a fucking lie, and I don't like it. First of all, thinking that one half of the Coen Brothers would go solo to write a Garfield script would show how moronic you are, and even Bill Murray isn't that much of a moron. Second, actors drop out of projects all the fucking time. There's no way that Murray is making it past day one without finding out who really wrote the script, and if he really felt like he was duped in some manner, then he could easily drop the whole thing. But he didn't. Third, none of this explains why Murray also did the sequel.

At a certain point, you gotta either take the L, or just be honest that this was a purely financial endeavor (lots of money for easy work). I have no problem with actors of Bill Murray's pedigree taking these shit kid movie voice acting jobs, but just be straight with me, man. Don't shit on my head and say it's lasagna.

The next thing I noticed, once the most recent internal Murray fracas died down in my head, was that Garfield: The Movie stole liberally from the Toy Story franchise. The plot is mostly just a rehashing of Toy Story 1, and there are at least two big set pieces ripped right from Toy Story 2. Garfield feels about Odie the same way that Woody feels about Buzz—he feels replaced in their owner's eyes—and so he accidentally "loses" Odie. After the other pets call out Garfield for more or less being the cause of Odie's disappearance, Garfield stages a rescue mission, finds Odie, and brings him home. Just replace Sid with Stephen Toblowsky and it's exactly the same. As far as Toy Story 2 comparisons go, there is a scene in which Garfield and a rat (voiced by the anti-Semitic Nick Cannon) duck under traffic cones and try to cross a busy street (just like Buzz and the gang do), and the big finale takes place on a luggage conveyor belt (though this time it's at a train station, not an airport, but close enough for it to be suspicious!!).

I didn't google it yet because I don't want to be disappointed that this is already a known theory, that scriptwriters Joel Not Coen and Alec Sokolow (who incidentally called Murray's claims "complete horse shit") stole a lot of stuff from Toy Story and got away with it. On the other hand, I wonder if Toy Story's plot was similar to any other children films that already existed. Maybe the idea of "primary subservient feels replaced by owner" isn't all that special, and that plenty of films have done it. Maybe it's me who's the criminal here, for not knowing enough about movies to speak coherently on these points.

None of this matters to the intended audience, and I suppose this is the final thing we should mention before bowing out. I watched Garfield with Willow and Martha, and they seemed to enjoy it (well, the former more so than the latter, but I think that has more to do with teeth coming in than anything else). I always feel the need to step back during reviews of children's movies and consider the fact that this movie isn't meant for me. True, that's no excuse for a shitty movie—bad movies are bad no matter who they are intended for, and this one was bad—but it's still something to consider. Why bother talking shit on Garfield: The Movie on a blog intended for adults? What's the point here? Who am I trying to convince exactly?

My thought today, though, went in the opposite direction. My thought wasn't that my children's consumption habits were negatively affecting me. Quite the opposite—I was really glad W and M were there with me. I had to watch Garfield, and their presence made it more palatable for me. They acted as a buffer between a grown man and a bad children's film. Their reactions to the movie were able to hold many of the negative feelings I would've felt otherwise. It went from "Garfield: The Movie is irredeemable" to "Well, at least the majority of the people in the room enjoyed Garfield: The Movie." It makes me feel like there's some type of purpose to this movie project, even the nadirs. I didn't like Garfield: The Movie, but two of the people I care about most in this world really did, and that makes me feel good.

Still... shit movie. To wrap up, here are some of its worst moments, presented in the order that I wrote them down:
  • Garfield drinks milk, belches, turns to the camera, and says "Got milk?"
  • Garfield does an Elvis impression
  • Garfield claims that Odie has changed him "from a chick magnet to a tick magnet."
  • Garfield and Odie dance to the Black Eyed Peas
  • Garfield tells Odie "Let's play brain surgeon; will you go get my power tools?"
  • Garfield crawls up the muumuu of a large woman, and said large woman proceeds to destroy an entire dog show competition while trying to get Garfield out of said muumuuu
  • I'm pretty sure Garfield also implies that there is a connection between muumuu and the woman's weight through the muu/moo homophone
  • Garfield gets home from the dog show by hitching a ride under the car, Cape Fear-style
  • Garfield sings "New York State of Mind" by Billy Joel but replaces "york" with "dog," referring to the new dog, Odie
  • There is an excessive amount of Pepsi and Wendy's ads
  • Like the live action remake of Lady and the Tramp, Garfield implies that every dog pound has one large red button that, if pushed, makes every single cage door open, allowing every dog in the pound to escape
  • Garfield also implies that every train station has one single large red button that can turn on the brakes on every single train simultaneously
  • Stephen Tobolowsky's big villain moment occurs when the camera zooms in on his face and he says in a sinister fashion: "I hate lasagna."
  • Garfield says "You had me at hello" to Jon even though Jon didn't say the word "hello."
  • The movie ends with a dance number, as all children's movies must.
GRADE: 1 puke out of 5
 
NEXT TIME: We go from lasagna to pottery when we watch Ghost (and talk about it with a PoYB contributor)

No comments: