"No Reason"
Big Thief
from Dragon New Warm Mountain I Believe in You
2022
I spend most of my Saturdays on this blog talking about "blind spots" in my music listening. When I write that phrase, I'm referring more to those artists and albums that have been said to be worth everyone's time, and I just haven't checked it out at all. It's more of a gap than anything else, and it's easily filled.
Another type of "blind spot," however, could be those artists that you are familiar with, that everyone and their mother seems to love, and yet they are artists you can't bring yourself to connect with on any meaningful level, even after repeated attempts. They continuously get love on the forums and from your peers, and every time it happens, you can't help but get this quizzical look on your face like: what? You are talking about that band again? It just doesn't make sense, and it feels like it never will.
If we're considering "blind spots" that fit this alternate definition, then I'll say that there is no bigger blind spot for me in the past five years than Big Thief.
If you've never heard of them, well... I guess they are the other kind of blind spot for you. But I've tried Big Thief numerous times. Their first four albums got more than one spin from me each at least, and every single listen resulted in me scratching my head. Especially since this was also the band getting outlandish praise online, making them seem like they were the best indie rock band of the '10s. It just didn't make sense to me, how such a thoroughly average-sounding band could earn such wild acclaim.
I'm definitely not one of those guys who is gonna get bitter at the band, or anything like that. The hate doesn't curdle in these situations, but rather it almost calcifies into a sort of jealousy. So many other people are finding joy in this music, but why can't I? What is it going to take to find anything to like about this fucking band? I wanted in. It's that desire to experience what my peers are experiencing that drives me to listen to each new Big Thief release as it hits the public.
One such opportunity arrives a week and a half ago. Dragon New Warm Mountain I Believe in You, the new album, is almost as long as its title. 82 minutes of new Big Thief music. Yet again, it is being hailed as a masterpiece, their best yet, AotY candidate in February, and so on and so forth. I dug in.
I suppose my problem with Big Thief is that they felt so small, so insignificant. They were nothing to get excited about (hence my confusion), because there simply didn't seem like there was enough to grab ahold of. And if I'm not liking their music so far, it might seem like a fool's errand to commit to now listening to a double album from one of the most perplexing bands. If I didn't like Big Thief in 40 minute chunks, why would I like them at 80?
Actually, it's the opposite. If Big Thief sounded small to me, then the solution might just be to pump up the quantity. Go big. Double albums, traditionally, give off an air of importance. The heft lends it some value. I can't possibly toss off a double album—logically, it wouldn't be a double album if it didn't mean something, right? Maybe that's just my White Album fandom speaking through me. I dunno.
In any case, I was going to try it regardless, and as it turns out, the double album thing is exactly what I needed. This album is very good. It covers a lot of ground—double album, duh—but the high points are high enough that I'm gonna keep listening to the low points too, to see if they eventually smooth out. Key point, though, is that I'm going to keep listening. To Big Thief!
It's just a good feeling, to feel like I finally cracked some inscrutable code. I didn't get it then, but I get it now. I don't even care if it's Stockholm Syndrome. Whatever it takes, man. Whatever it takes to believe the hype. "Best band in the world"? Not quite. But I can at least squint and see how that could make sense to certain people. Whereas before, it completely baffled me.
You know what would make me feel even better? If I felt like I could possibly write something here to convince you, the reader, that Big Thief's new album is worth your time. Short of embedding the album's best song above (which I did—or wait, no, maybe it's "Red Moon"?), there's really nothing I can do. I wouldn't even know where to start. All I know is that, if you are like I used to be and you think Big Thief are completely overrated, then that's a journey you're going to have to take on your own. There's nothing I can do to convince you. This is either a band that, at any given time, you're going to understand or you're not.
What I can say is that, if you don't get it now, there's still hope. Fuck what everyone else is saying, me included. Just keep listening. This applies to all music. I'm not saying you're going to love everything just by exposing yourself to it, but you will understand it. Sometimes that's the most important thing. Liking something after that is the cherry on top.
On the other hand... I am never going to listen to that Beach House album that came out last weekend. I just don't get it, and I never will.
No comments:
Post a Comment