Friday, February 25, 2022

The Family Tree: The Roots, Joe


Part of my job at [employment] is to facilitate parenting groups, and the groups that I've been facilitating so far all are supposed to end with an activity called your "family portrait." Basically, the participants draw four pictures, each one representing a period of your life (usually: birth to elementary school, high school to present, how you got involved in [agency], and your future aspirations). You show your pictures, and then you tell your story, for close to an hour or more. The point of this exercise is that, by examining your own life and your relationship with the people who surrounded you as you grew up, you start to make connections with the relationships you've formed in the present, and see how it's all a pattern.

By an incredibly happy coincidence, I am witnessing my first family portraits this week in my first group, and am starting to prepare my own family portrait to present to my peers, the very same week that I spent listening to Radical Face sing songs that basically amount to a family portrait. I mean, there's literally a song called "Family Portrait." I don't know if Radical Face (a.k.a. Ben Cooper) is referring to a literal portrait, a figurative portrait, or the art therapy that we employ in group, but it all amounts to the same thing—here is the story of a family. These are the low points. These are the struggles that made us who we are. This is our history.

What I'm writing now (what you are reading) is not art therapy. Not today. This is an album review. So in that context, I can say that Radical Face nails the conceit. The eleven songs cover multiple generations of this fictional(?) family, and combined with the pdf explainer thingy, I feel like I'm getting the full portrait. I'm a big fan of a good concept album, and unlike many concept albums (e.g., I dunno, The Wall, or Tommy, to name the big ones, whatever), The Family Tree is incredibly simple. Here is a family. This is their story. Knowing from personal experience through group, and now through this album, just hearing a family's story can be an incredibly moving experience.

It is also okay when a family's story is imperfect. I'm not even talking about the fact that we're only getting about one-third of the story by exclusively listening to The Roots, and not The Branches or The Leaves. Nothing you can do about that in the confines of Record Club.

Nah, I guess I'm mainly talking about the music, which I consider good but not great. Cooper's voice is ethereal, and thus lacks the heft that may or may not have been required to convey some of the heavier emotions here. It works as a sad voice, but very rarely is it powerful. I could've used some more power. Looking at a picture of Ben Cooper prior to cracking open this album, I would've assumed that this was a man with a deep, soulful voice. Not so. I blame Dave, who said that Cooper "reminded [him] of Ed," who is our most Andre-the-Giant-esque friend. These vocals are more Vizzini than Fezzik.

The sounds of The Family Tree: The Leaves are similarly reserved, and again, I think this works really well in the context of "sad family story." I think there could've been more of a balance between the sad and the angry/euphoric/enthusiastic/agitated/etc. A lot of these songs feel like they are building up to a catharsis that never arrives. And that's kind of a bummer, from a sonic standpoint.

However, I'll backtrack and reiterate that I think these imperfections fit well with the idea of a family portrait. A stronger voice might come off as performative, whereas a family portrait works best with a quiet humility. A catharsis might imply an ending, whereas family portraits could potential sprawl outward forever, depending on the lineage. I shouldn't be complaining about what we get here; I should instead be thankful that we got to hear this story at all.

There is nothing more interesting than someone's life story. It requires an incredible amount of bravery to put your own personal truth out there, to lay out what went wrong so that you can determine what can go right in the future, to examine those intimate details of your life and your family's life. It's some heavy shit! And it doesn't matter whether it's the true story of a parent ensnared in the child protective services system or the fictional story of 19th century bloodline as told by a 21st century folk artist, family portraits are very often engaging and effective ways of telling a story.

But since this is an album review: I just wish the music was up to par.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: