Saturday, February 5, 2022

A Year of Blind Spots: Sail Away


Sigh... there's the whole Toy Story thing. I feel bad for the guy in some respects, that he's had a long, respectable career as a singer-songwriter, not only with a dozen studio albums, but also over two dozen film scores, and yet the one single thing that defines Randy Newman to my generation is his voice in the Toy Story movies. I guess I can't feel that bad, though, since how many of us are able to immortalize their voice like Randy Newman did through Toy Story? Every kid knows that voice. I didn't play Sail Away for my kids this week (because it was boring, not because it was inappropriate or anything), but had I done so, W would have assuredly said: "Toy Story!"

It was an arduous task, working backwards in this way this week. To go from "this is the guy who performs 'You Got a Friend in Me'" back to "this guy actually has other music" was strange and not very satisfying. I just want to be clear, though, that I didn't have a negative opinion of Sail Away because "it wasn't Toy Story" or anything like that. As if his signature sound in a kids movie somehow spoiled me to the rest of his discography. I would only say that, yeah, I guess I wished Sail Away was a little more like "You Got a Friend in Me," only because Sail Away was boring as shit.

Weirdly, I could draw a line from this album to Father John Misty's Pure Comedy. I can rarely stand the sad-sack dude at the piano shtick, even when it's winking, but on both albums, I can barely detect the wink. (Or maybe Misty is winking so quickly that I can't detect it anyway, I dunno.) All I know is that it was fucking tough to drag myself through a whole album of religious music and then have to listen to Randy Newman somberly touch on the same subject with "He Gives Us All His Love." Lots of slow music this week. I didn't like it.

I feel like I've known Newman's name and voice since before I can remember. And I was always vaguely known that he had a whole music career before he got wrapped up in the Woody and Buzz saga. I just assumed that that career had to have been inspiring for him to get the Pixar job in the first place. But that doesn't seem to be the case. This man is the Toy Story singer, and that's all he'll ever be.



No comments: