Friday, February 4, 2022

Bless This House, Joe


If god is all-powerful and all-knowing, then why does he allow bad things to happen? If god isn't all-powerful and all-knowing, then why is he considered a god?

I'll add this to the classic paradox: if god is able to reveal himself, and did so 2022 years ago in order to save mankind, then why doesn't he do it again? If god exists, then why does he allow us to go on guessing whether he exists or not? Wouldn't proving his own existence help us out in pretty tangible ways here on earth?

E.g. if I god came down to earth on a big cloud and he proved within a shadow of a doubt to all mankind that he was real and he was god, and then he said that if you act like a good person (and defined "good person" in very specific ways) then you will live forever in heaven, and if you aren't a good person, then you are going to burn in hell for all eternity, then I think a heathen like myself would be EXTREMELY motivated to start acting like a "good person" as that god defines it. Our society would be able to come together and do everything right, because we'd know exactly what it took to avoid hell and earn entry into heaven, which totally exists. Every problem would be solved.

So if god can do something like that (and he can, in this hypothetical, since he's done it before), then the fact that he hasn't done it recently means that he doesn't fucking care about us, or is at least apathetic enough about the whole earth ordeal that he certainly doesn't deserve our praise and adoration, and that we shouldn't bother kidding ourselves that asking the bearded man in the sky is going to make one fucking iota of a difference either way.

If we can say with certainty that the central reason for the existence of Bless This House by Mahalia Jackson is one of religious adoration for god and the religion that follows god's alleged teachings, then I think it's also safe to say that that message is falling on deaf ears this week. I do not believe in god, because to believe in god would be to believe in a supernatural being who allows pain and suffering to exist and to torture us, and I can't imagine that any sentient being could ever be so cruel.

If I was an asshole—debatable, but you probably have your strong opinions on the matter—then I would just leave the review at that. "Oh, this is an album about god? Pass." That would be the easiest path to take. Seeing as I try not to be an asshole, regardless of whether I believe assholes are going to be punished by a god eventually, I'm going to take some other approaches to my view of Bless This House. It is my duty as an agnostic reviewing a gospel album. The idea of "god" doesn't have to be the end of it.

The first approach is to take the subject matter out of the equation altogether. "Gospel music" is more than the god topic. It also has a particular tone, a specific timbre, its own collection of tropes. You could theoretically make an album that sounds exactly like gospel music, but is actually about, I dunno, buffalo chicken wings. You could have Mahalia Jackson singing about her favorite meal at Wing Stop, and as long as she working those pipes in a glorious fashion over a ragtime-esque piano/percussion duo or a church organ, then it's gonna sound like a gospel album. To actually be "gospel" is to sing about god in this very specific way, but the audience has no obligation in that regard. I can consider a gospel album without considering god.

So if I take this first approach, then I'll say that Bless This House is fine. It certainly sounds very old. It's rudimentary music from an artist who absolutely has every excuse in the world for making rudimentary music (seeing as it was made 66 years ago and is made in the same vein as music that was made much earlier than that). It's exciting because good vocal performances are always exciting, regardless of the context. The context is less exciting because boring music is always gonna be boring, no matter what vocal superstar is blasting away on top of it.

I thus find this approach pretty limiting, because it gives me no appreciation for Bless This House whatsoever. Why would it? When have I ever expressed appreciation for this type of music? Honestly, at this point, any music like this from the 1950s, traditional arrangements and what have you, have been flattened out so much by pop culture that there's nothing left. It's sonic wallpaper on a prestige drama, regardless of whether its use is sincere or ironic. That's why I (and others, I assume) always reference the O Brother, Where Art Thou? soundtrack as a shorthand for "old timey music," because that was the last time that this music was employed in the service of a TV show or movie and the music itself was the point. Every other old song, like this collection of twelve gospel songs by Mahalia Jackson, sounds extremely odd in the context of an "album." This sounds like a soundtrack. The music is superfluous.

Let's try the other approach. This approach asks us to consider, not the music, not the theme, but the artist herself. Maybe the point isn't god, and it isn't the vocals. Maybe the point is that Mahalia Jackson was a historical figure that we need to learn about and appreciate, and if we can do that, then the music will at least earn its existence, if not also open itself up to enjoyment, appreciation, whatever. (I won't go as far as to say "we need to think of Mahalia Jackson as god" but you get my point.)

I definitely didn't know the extent of Mahalia Jackson's work in the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s until I started previewing the album last Sunday. Regardless of the specifics—though you should definitely check those out too, outside of a Friday morning music review—I think it's pretty safe to say that Mahalia Jackson's voice was utilized to bring people together. That's the power of her talent, that it was able to bring people together.

The cause was equal rights. The method was singing about god. It doesn't really matter what my thoughts on god are, because the truth of the matter is Mahalia Jackson sang about god, and that singing about god united large swaths of people under one noble cause. It wasn't just that we the people are demanding equal rights, it's that god himself is also demanding equal rights. The argument is a lot tougher to fight when you bring god into the equation. Then, of course, there's also the whole idea that gospel music is traditional, and so a lot of the advocates of Civil Rights were raised on gospel music, and thus Mahalia Jackson's music had a way of bringing people together nostalgically as well.

I don't want to pretend to be an anthropologist here. I wasn't around during the Civil Rights Movement. I am not well-read on the subject. I'm simply trying to present an empathetic view of the music and the scene that the music represented. There were people who fought for and who died for equal rights in this country, and if the music from Bless This House contributed in any tangible way to that important fight, then it should be exalted, regardless of the whole "god" thing.

Way back in the day, I remember going to a church to see Mike's uncle (the same uncle who let us record this monstrosity in his studio) play guitar in the church band. I don't know the denomination, but it was one of those Churches that had a "youth night" and played rock music and then had a preacher toward the end try to get any "inspired" youth to come up to the altar and "renounce satan" or whatever. I certainly didn't go to the altar or speak in tongues, but I do remember how surprisingly at peace I felt that night. It was because of the music. Even to celebrate a god I did not believe in and occasionally disdained, I still felt that sense of connection with the community I found myself temporarily a part of for one evening. Music has such an immense fucking power about it. Music is more powerful than any god.

So there is no doubt in my mind how important Mahalia Jackson must have been in her time. Her voice had the power to bring people together during a time when society was sharply divided. In this way, I appreciate Bless This House. I get the importance here.

And it is with great regret that I must now drop the other shoe with a great big "but." Yes, Mahalia Jackson is important, but: Bless This House did not do much to inspire me. I love that it inspired others in a certain time frame, and I'm so thankful. This agnostic loser, however, gets no sense of satisfaction from the religious album we heard this week. And until god reveals himself to be real and says that if I want to get to heaven that I need to start praise his name in the form of religious music, I will mostly be ignoring any and all music like this.

GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5

No comments: