Monday, October 16, 2023

SO/SN/SB/SB — 10/16/23

Something Old

I randomly threw Snail Mail's Valentine on the iPod the other night at dinner, and Pam was like, "Wait, I thought you didn't like this album?" If you read my review, you'd know that I was disappointed with the album, at least in the context of the weekly RC act of review writing. But just because it didn't work for me that week doesn't mean my feelings about it won't change over time. Unless the album is a true piece of shit, I'm gonna keep it around, with the hopes that one day, I'll randomly push play and all of a sudden discover something worthy. Things change, is the idea.

A band I haven't thought about in years is Ought, and their name stood out as I swirled the clickwheel and scrolled down the artists list on the iPod, for no particular reason. I tried More Than Any Other Day, and honestly was kinda blown away with how good it was. It's this sort of nervy post-punk that feels really combustible and threatens to explode even in its quiet moments. I like how it seems a lot looser and more ramshackle than your typical tight post-punk unit. This album soundtracked a really nice train ride for me.

For better or worse, running a blog for over fifteen years means I can use the search bar and find out what I've said about Ought in the past, and boy... the results were not pretty. In 2015, I missed the point of repetition in post-punk music. In 2014, I embarrassingly mislabeled Ought as "dad rock." Worst of all, in 2018, Ought caught a stray bullet in a really poorly written Savages write-up, where I described the post-punk sounds of Ought as "a fucking drag" (please don't even look at the comments on that one).

But see, this is what I'm talking about. Things change. Listening to music and learning about your own tastes is a lifelong process. I was wrong about Ought in some pretty cringey ways, and yet being wrong then can only mean I'm right now, and that ultimately feels real nice. Discovery is good; rediscovery is better. And I guess this makes more room for criticism too. Be brave enough to say something negative now, because the good thing is you can always go back on it later on and just admit that you were wrong.


Something New
 
Pam and I had a brief discussion after we watched Bottoms, the new high school lesbian-fight-club comedy film: can you be "too old" for new movies? Quantitatively, I was laughing more than Pam while watching this film, but I'm also a few years younger than her. I agree with the concept that maybe some comedy is age-dependent. What I see in Bottoms is a very loose style of comedy, how a lot of the humor threatened to break the fourth wall without actually doing it, and how the banter was fast and harsh and intends to shock in some really fun ways. I associate all that with younger generations.

I think another aspect that you can't forget is exposure. I think I would classify some of the humor in Bottoms as absurdist, in the way that it maybe didn't make sense in the structure of the film but was funny in its own right because it didn't make sense. I'm spoiling a throwaway gag when I give this example, so be aware—there's a bit where the girls are fighting members of a rival football team, and the one football player gets stabbed with a sword (and before this Bottoms was not that type of movie). It's absurdist because no one has a reaction to this besides the two main characters, and their reaction is "lol I think we killed somebody, like for real," and that's it. I think in order to appreciate that type of comedy, you need to be exposed to it often in order to "get" that it's a joke. And the understanding is that maybe there are different levels of exposure here, and that age factors into about 50% of it.

The bottom line (whoops) is that I found this film to be extremely charming and funny in some pleasantly off-kilter ways, but I can understand if maybe it's not your cup of tea for whatever reason (age, propensity for more traditional comedy, whatever).
 
 
Something Borrowed
 
I would not have known about a new Pkew Pkew Pkew album if I was subscribed to Brendan Menapace's Substack newsletter, so that alone is worth the price of admission. So I listened to Siiick Scenes a bunch of times, and really enjoyed the album, despite some of the same extra-textual issues I took with Pkew x3 last time (and not even mentioning again how much I fucking despise this band's name). But I thought the interview also did a good job at fleshing out some of the themes are buried underneath the usual malarkey that this band typical presents.

"One of the things I wanted to talk about the most was how you guys enlisted Craig Finn from the Hold Steady to serve as a 'lyrical consultant' for this album. How did that working relationship come to be?

He's always just kind of been ready to jump in and do that since he did Optimal Lifestyles and Open Bar with us. I always think of it like when you're in school and your teacher says you can, like, hand something in early and get notes, and then hand it in again for real. And that's just kind of how it feels to me. Why not run it by him? And he's always been down to do it. It's fun to work with him, too. He's really good at it, which isn't surprising. He's good at getting you to think of new ideas and explain sort of how he works, which is cool.

...

What changed in your own process here that made you want to look backwards instead of the present like you have in the past?

I think the big thing for me is that I wanted to write songs, but I wasn't going out and doing anything, and I'm not really good at making up stories. So it kind of just has to be stuff that's happened.

Did Craig ever try to get fiction out of you?

No. I don't think I could. It's funny, cause that's what's great to work with him—I don't even want to write like him. I appreciate how he's maybe one of the best in the world at it, but it's not my thing. But, like, it's cool to have that in the mix and maybe move towards it eventually. But right now it hasn't worked out that I can do that."

Read the whole thing HERE. I feel like the idea of a "lyrical consultant" is not something you hear about too often in indie rock, so it was cool to hear some inside baseball takes on it in the interview. I had totally forgotten that Craig Finn was part of this band's structure until I read about it here. I really like the discussion of fiction writing versus non-fiction writing in music, and how each can serve a purpose.

This kind of answers a question that I had last time, how I was openly wondering whether the dudes in Pkew Pkew Pkew were open and honest with themselves about the substance use, or if it was just all fictional fun. Now here is the frontman saying that, no, this is based on our lives. Obviously that discussion takes on a whole different timbre and hue due to my own personal circumstances, but we don't necessarily have to go down that road here. I'm just saying that there is a non-zero number of times that I've listened to "Drinkin' Days" in the past 216 days and have cried, and that maybe that song represents feelings and emotions within Mike Warne that he isn't even aware of.

In any case, I arrive at the music making no judgments, besides the ultimate judgment of Pkew Pkew Pkew's music continuing to kick ass in the silliest way possible.
 
 
Something Blue
 
Totally okay if you know something isn't for you, and you continue to avoid that thing because you know yourself and you don't want to waste your time. You don't have to love everything. It's okay.

I guess I'm speaking to myself in the preceding paragraph. Sometimes I put pressure on myself to find something worthy in every piece of music (see a good example of that pressure relieved in today's Something Old). But sometimes, a piece of music isn't necessarily in your wheelhouse, and you know this already, and you've known it forever, and so for that art, it's okay to just... let it go. Let someone else enjoy it. Don't feel pressure to engage.

Blonde Redhead recently released their tenth album, and first in nine years. It's called Sit Down for Dinner. I am going to pass. I have nothing against Blonde Redhead's music. It's fine. But I just know that it's not really for me. I actually saw this band headline a show at the TLA way back in 2007 (which would've been their tour for their 2007 album 23, if Wikipedia is to be believed). They were totally fucking fine, but made very little impression on me one way or the other. I was only there because a friend liked them, and that was one of the summers of my life where I literally went out and did something with friends every single night from Memorial Day to Labor Day. They were fine. A little boring.

I would never begrudge anyone for enjoying something that I don't. I wouldn't even be upset if it was a band whose music I fucking hated, let alone a band that is just fine. I think I just need to accept the fact that there isn't enough time in the week to get into every single album that is released. Even writing these words in the Something Blue section, I'm thinking to myself "well, what if I gave it a chance, maybe I would like it, you never know," but NO. No. I saw and heard Blonde Redhead perform with the own eyes and ears respectively, in person, live, and this is an easy band to earmark to say no, I can skip this one, and it's fucking okay to do so.

2 comments:

Nate said...

WELL WELL WELL WELL WELL

Joe K said...

Ooh, tough break for everyone who picked the "under" on the over/under for the bet "how long will it take Nate to comment on this blog post to subtly inform the audience that, yes, he was right about Ought this whole time," which was set at over/under 30.5 minutes. It in fact took Nate an entire 45 minutes after publishing to respond. Better luck next time!