1993
Jonathan Demme
I think that even if the movie wasn't called Philadelphia (some of the other possibilities originally: At Risk, People like Us, Probable Cause), we'd still be asking the question: Why Philadelphia? We kind of already went over this a few movies ago, after Mystic River—it's more than just the fucking location. Yes, technically Philadelphia was shot in Philadelphia because this is the city whose film office had the most realistic courtroom available to shoot in over a long period of time, and yes, because it is shot on-location, there are plenty of scenes with recognizable settings to those who reside here. But still. If this movie ended up in New York, they wouldn't have fucking named it New York City. There's a deeper meaning here.
But you're gonna have to take this Philadelphian's word with a grain of salt, I guess. I view my hometown favorably. I sincerely believe that Philadelphians are every bit as passionate and as loyal and as intensely devoted to our principles and values as the boilerplate Philadelphia reputation suggests. Screenwriter had this to say: "The City of Brotherly Love, the Declaration of Independence... I mean, perfect, right?" That's true, but it's also more than that. Historical items like the Declaration of Independence are the ideals of the past, but they ripple into the present. Whether your typical Philadelphian would frame it this was or not, it doesn't matter—even unconsciously, we strive to put into practice the idea that all men are created equal, and the thing that levels that playing field and makes us equal in the way the Founding Fathers promised is the fact that we share the bond of this city we call home.
But you're gonna have to take this Philadelphian's word with a grain of salt, I guess. I view my hometown favorably. I sincerely believe that Philadelphians are every bit as passionate and as loyal and as intensely devoted to our principles and values as the boilerplate Philadelphia reputation suggests. Screenwriter had this to say: "The City of Brotherly Love, the Declaration of Independence... I mean, perfect, right?" That's true, but it's also more than that. Historical items like the Declaration of Independence are the ideals of the past, but they ripple into the present. Whether your typical Philadelphian would frame it this was or not, it doesn't matter—even unconsciously, we strive to put into practice the idea that all men are created equal, and the thing that levels that playing field and makes us equal in the way the Founding Fathers promised is the fact that we share the bond of this city we call home.
You can name a thousand local and even recent examples of why this isn't true, of course. I'm in love with Philadelphia and no one has ever said love made sense. There is so much about this city that is unjust, unfair, and cruel, but the reason I get so angry about that shit is because I think that cruelty is below the standards that we've set for ourselves as a city. If you were to make Philadelphia today, it would be about an opioid-addicted trans youth of color living under the El at K&A. When I say that the open-market heroin camps in Kensington are shameful, I am not making the McGruffian/Republican argument that those who are addicted are weak and deserve to disappear. On the contrary, I'm saying that the human beings in that situation are my Philadelphian brothers and sisters, and the shame falls squarely on those of us who have the power to address this issue but choose not to.
When we says "what would this movie look like today" and then give a present-day twist on the concept, what we're really saying is that pain and conflict and despair and cruelty are cyclical. No one ever asks that hypothetical about a film and finds that the answer is "this movie couldn't be made today because all our problems have been solved." The sickness of today is the sickness of yesterday, repackaged.
It's cyclical, but it's still interesting—and a little heartbreaking—to view previous iterations of the cycle through a film like this. I was alive for the AIDS epidemic but clearly wasn't old enough to understand it or be aware of it at all. When I speak highly of Philadelphia, I'm using my modern, rose-colored lens. The Philadelphia presented in this 1993 movie is not very kind, nor should it be presented as such. This is ignorance on my part, but the homophobia was extremely shocking to witness. Ignorance of the past, and also privilege as a white male cishet, yes. But in the circles I frequent as a 34-year-old residing in Philadelphia, homophobia is not the norm. It exists, and it'll take longer than one single generation to root it out completely, but what I'm saying is that in this previous spin through the cycle of pain, in Philadelphia's Philadelphia (and in any other major metropolitan area in the country, of course), circa 1993, homophobia was normal and accepted, so much so that pretty much an entire generation of men were killed by a virus and the general populace didn't seem all that concerned about it one way or the other. When Denzel Washington's Joe Miller says at the beginning of the film that he thinks that all f-words should die, and then lovingly kisses his only mildly annoyed wife, I'm taking that at face value. This is how it was, and I'd be lying if I said that I wasn't taken aback by the ideas that were presented as a truth of yesteryear.
It's cyclical, but it's still interesting—and a little heartbreaking—to view previous iterations of the cycle through a film like this. I was alive for the AIDS epidemic but clearly wasn't old enough to understand it or be aware of it at all. When I speak highly of Philadelphia, I'm using my modern, rose-colored lens. The Philadelphia presented in this 1993 movie is not very kind, nor should it be presented as such. This is ignorance on my part, but the homophobia was extremely shocking to witness. Ignorance of the past, and also privilege as a white male cishet, yes. But in the circles I frequent as a 34-year-old residing in Philadelphia, homophobia is not the norm. It exists, and it'll take longer than one single generation to root it out completely, but what I'm saying is that in this previous spin through the cycle of pain, in Philadelphia's Philadelphia (and in any other major metropolitan area in the country, of course), circa 1993, homophobia was normal and accepted, so much so that pretty much an entire generation of men were killed by a virus and the general populace didn't seem all that concerned about it one way or the other. When Denzel Washington's Joe Miller says at the beginning of the film that he thinks that all f-words should die, and then lovingly kisses his only mildly annoyed wife, I'm taking that at face value. This is how it was, and I'd be lying if I said that I wasn't taken aback by the ideas that were presented as a truth of yesteryear.
Coming at this film from the perspective of "your typical 2023 Philadelphian" almost does the film's significance a disservice, because it was so much more than just a simple representative of the spirit of one city. Philadelphia is credited as the film successful motion picture film to capture the AIDS epidemic as it really was, and is further credited with helping shift the cultural perception of the epidemic and on the LGBTQ community in general. Wikipedia says that it was one of the first mainstream films to "portray gay people in a positive light." I don't doubt the veracity of that claim, but I am shocked nonetheless. 1993 seems like just yesterday. (A sidenote here might be that it's weird to me to hear people always saying shit like "it feels like things are getting worse every day in America," when there are plenty of metrics that might say things were much, much worse 30 years ago.)
It's never ham-fisted in its positive portrayal, by the way. Tom Hanks is beautifully understated in his role as Andrew Beckett. He never paints himself as some sort of LGBTQ icon or activist. He's in court fighting his former employer because he believes he was treated unfairly, that's all. He would have had every right to view his courtroom battle as symbolic of gay men everywhere fighting for equal rights, but the film succeeds in part because it allows the audience to see it that way without the characters needing to say it. I won't spoil the ending of the film here (just in case you're reading before you've seen the film, you fool!!!), but the final three minutes are stunningly beautiful, as it poignantly celebrates the life of Andrew Beckett, and thus makes the final argument that this was a life worth celebrating.
Maybe the true beauty of this film is that there are multiple lenses that you can view it through—the past and the present and the future, the hyperlocal and the generally local and the global, the character study and the parable and the historical fiction, the perspective of things being better and the perspective of things are still bad just in a different way. In every iteration, though, the message is nearly underlined: life is only worth living if we are kind, even in the face of injustice. It might seem ironic to some that a movie named after the city of Philadelphia would ultimately be about kindness, but those who see irony can fuck right off. Philadelphia is perfectly named.
GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Another story about our city, I guess, who know: The Philadelphia Story.
It's never ham-fisted in its positive portrayal, by the way. Tom Hanks is beautifully understated in his role as Andrew Beckett. He never paints himself as some sort of LGBTQ icon or activist. He's in court fighting his former employer because he believes he was treated unfairly, that's all. He would have had every right to view his courtroom battle as symbolic of gay men everywhere fighting for equal rights, but the film succeeds in part because it allows the audience to see it that way without the characters needing to say it. I won't spoil the ending of the film here (just in case you're reading before you've seen the film, you fool!!!), but the final three minutes are stunningly beautiful, as it poignantly celebrates the life of Andrew Beckett, and thus makes the final argument that this was a life worth celebrating.
Maybe the true beauty of this film is that there are multiple lenses that you can view it through—the past and the present and the future, the hyperlocal and the generally local and the global, the character study and the parable and the historical fiction, the perspective of things being better and the perspective of things are still bad just in a different way. In every iteration, though, the message is nearly underlined: life is only worth living if we are kind, even in the face of injustice. It might seem ironic to some that a movie named after the city of Philadelphia would ultimately be about kindness, but those who see irony can fuck right off. Philadelphia is perfectly named.
GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Another story about our city, I guess, who know: The Philadelphia Story.

No comments:
Post a Comment