Joe's weekly reflections on the greatest teenage rock 'n' roll cover band to ever come out of Rockledge, PA in the mid-'00s, covered on the blog one song at a time.
"Life in a Bottle"
a Burholme original
Damn, it's been a minute since we've covered in this blog column a Burholme original. I have to imagine that this is a product of Mike's humility (not embarrassment) regarding the performance of something that he, our chief songwriter, wrote. Like, maybe this is him copping to the fact that something like "Cute Without the 'E' (Cut from the Team)" was a better song than anything we as a band could ever come up with ourselves, and so why not just play those instead?
What I will argue here—with a bunch of caveats, but still—is that the Burholme song "Life in a Bottle" is better than most of the other songs that we played, originals or covers. I cannot imagine that Mike is still reading this blog these days, so I feel comfortable saying this without risking the act of pumping up his already inflated ego too much. He did great here. This is one of the good songs. I wish we had a better copy of it. Or: I wish that a more competent band had taken it to the heights that it deserved and get Mike his payday (plus a few spare dollars for me and Kev-o).
What I will argue here—with a bunch of caveats, but still—is that the Burholme song "Life in a Bottle" is better than most of the other songs that we played, originals or covers. I cannot imagine that Mike is still reading this blog these days, so I feel comfortable saying this without risking the act of pumping up his already inflated ego too much. He did great here. This is one of the good songs. I wish we had a better copy of it. Or: I wish that a more competent band had taken it to the heights that it deserved and get Mike his payday (plus a few spare dollars for me and Kev-o).
Music criticism is a completely subjective game, and so it is with unavoidable subjectivity that I say that "Life in a Bottle" is a great fucking track. There is no possible way for me to remove myself from the center of the conversation. I like "Life in a Bottle" because it meant something to us at a pivotal time in our lives. If I had heard a version from, I don't know, the fucking Kooks or maybe Rooney or whatever, singing this song on Pandora radio in 2012, then I would've dismissed it as paper-thin treacly bullshit. But the treacle can become poignant when baked at the right temperature. Creating this fucking thing from whole cloth and presenting it to friends and family as one of a few treatises on living life in the moment as a youth was the exact right circumstances to make "Life in a Bottle" one of my favorite songs ever, period, end of run-on sentence.
This is not the first time this song has appeared on this blog. As was the case with the last Burholme original that this column covered, "Modern Day Juliet," "Life in a Bottle" was included on the Electric Drum Condition EP, so named because the recording session at Mike's uncle's home studio was the first time I had ever played on electric drums, and they sound fucking TERRIBLE. If you're currently ranking the most embarrassing aspects of this Burholme retrospective on PoYB, then this has to be your #1. Truly dogshit.
I'm not going to link to the mp3 file directly (find it on your own, you fucking sadist), but I need to bring it up here anyway, because it's a crucial document of the lyrics in this song. I can hear a Mike's melodramatic words there clearly enough on that copy to transcribe (98% of) them. On this YouTube copy of an old VHS home video digitalized through illegal Chinese software and embedded on a Blogspot blog post? I can't hear shit. Transcribing would be a losing game.
You can read what I transcribed from the EP at the bottom of this post. The interesting thing is taking those lyrics, and then listening to the "Life in a Bottle" performance from August 2007. They don't really match up that well! This tells me that Mike took the hatchet to his words at some point in those eighteen months in between the two takes.
Jury's out as to whether they were an improvement of not. I'd say that the biggest change comes in the chorus, and it turns the entire point of the song on its head. Compare for yourself. First, the early '06 edition:
And now the August 2007 edition:
That, among other changes (for example, the protagonist doesn't get murdered with a gun for not living life to the fullest in the newer version), turn "Life in a Bottle" from bleak emo drama to boys-are-back-in-town-style rock theatrics. I don't really have an opinion on which is better, and I don't know if I have a right to say, despite being a 1/6th owner of the songwriting credits. I will let it affect my assumptions about Mike's high school experience, and how his life probably got a lot better during junior and senior year, to the point where his song about death and regret felt outdated and too moribund. Put it this way: if we were up there singing a song about pissing away our youth, then "Life in a Bottle" probably would've shown up earlier in the setlist.
I'm serious about this song deserving a better home than a fucking blog with a fucking shit mp4 file. I used to joke around that Wolf Parade stole from us with their 2010 song "Ghost Pressure" and its bridge and outro repeating the phrase "shake me up" a half dozen times. It was just a joke, but it was a joke borne from an inherent need for this song to find a wider audience. That would've been fine! Steal from us, Wolf Parade! The ensuing court date and extremely small and gracious settlement would do more than enough to expose "Life in a Bottle" to a wider audience.
I don't know how this would be feasible, but I imagine giving the song to an established TikTok-famous pop-punk band who isn't afraid of being viewed as lame through cliché sentiments about the power of kids and their rock 'n' roll, and letting them record their own version. Maybe even letting Mike S. Esq. feature on the vocals for one take as a lark. Either that or slip the live karaoke band at Fergie's a benjamin to make it happen. I don't know, something. Anything.
Like I said, I only love this song because I was part of this song. I understand that other people may not feel the same way. Maybe even Mike doesn't feel the same way anymore, I don't know. But I'm glad I got to hear this song again from an actual outside source today, because, if I'm being honest, it hasn't left my head for the past eighteen years.
Jury's out as to whether they were an improvement of not. I'd say that the biggest change comes in the chorus, and it turns the entire point of the song on its head. Compare for yourself. First, the early '06 edition:
"If you had life in a bottle, would you shake it up? (shake it up)
Would ya watch the good times rising to the top? (to the top)
Would ya smash the glass and watch your memories bleed? (the memories bleed)
'Cause some things are too painful for me and you to sing"
And now the August 2007 edition:
"If you had life in a bottle, would you shake it up? (shake it up)
Would ya watch the good times rising to the top? (to the top)
We're gonna pull the cork and let the good times roll,
'Cause we're just kids, and all we know is rock 'n' roll!"
That, among other changes (for example, the protagonist doesn't get murdered with a gun for not living life to the fullest in the newer version), turn "Life in a Bottle" from bleak emo drama to boys-are-back-in-town-style rock theatrics. I don't really have an opinion on which is better, and I don't know if I have a right to say, despite being a 1/6th owner of the songwriting credits. I will let it affect my assumptions about Mike's high school experience, and how his life probably got a lot better during junior and senior year, to the point where his song about death and regret felt outdated and too moribund. Put it this way: if we were up there singing a song about pissing away our youth, then "Life in a Bottle" probably would've shown up earlier in the setlist.
I'm serious about this song deserving a better home than a fucking blog with a fucking shit mp4 file. I used to joke around that Wolf Parade stole from us with their 2010 song "Ghost Pressure" and its bridge and outro repeating the phrase "shake me up" a half dozen times. It was just a joke, but it was a joke borne from an inherent need for this song to find a wider audience. That would've been fine! Steal from us, Wolf Parade! The ensuing court date and extremely small and gracious settlement would do more than enough to expose "Life in a Bottle" to a wider audience.
I don't know how this would be feasible, but I imagine giving the song to an established TikTok-famous pop-punk band who isn't afraid of being viewed as lame through cliché sentiments about the power of kids and their rock 'n' roll, and letting them record their own version. Maybe even letting Mike S. Esq. feature on the vocals for one take as a lark. Either that or slip the live karaoke band at Fergie's a benjamin to make it happen. I don't know, something. Anything.
Like I said, I only love this song because I was part of this song. I understand that other people may not feel the same way. Maybe even Mike doesn't feel the same way anymore, I don't know. But I'm glad I got to hear this song again from an actual outside source today, because, if I'm being honest, it hasn't left my head for the past eighteen years.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
LYRICS (2006 EP version)
You're at a crossroads now
In the early daylight
Where hurt's so fresh, you think that you just might
Give up today, it's not worth the fight anymore
You're at the bus stop, in the hectic frenzy of the
Stories that they are inventing
They make the weekend seem so cool
Just another lame Monday at your local lame school
You jump off the bus, running home for the store
Don't quite know what you're looking for
But in the back, under some dusty LPs,
You find a dirty glass bottle with a label that reads:
If you had life in a bottle, would you shake it up? (shake it up)
Would ya watch the good times rising to the top? (to the top)
Would ya smash the glass and watch your memories bleed? (memories bleed)
Just some things are too painful for you to sing
So you try it out now, when you're surprised
You find yourself becoming all the good times
You decide not to smash it, at least for a little while
So you sprint to school, just a block or two
Set the bottle in your locker, and then you
Spend the rest of your day with the lighter staff(???)
With the smile on their face, they found you dead
The bottle choked you to death for sure
The bullets hit you near the corner store
Knowing fate was such a fiend
You breathe out now, let the memories bleed, 'cause:
You breathe out now, let the memories bleed, 'cause:
If you had life in a bottle, would you shake it up? (shake it up)
Would ya watch the good times rising to the top? (to the top)
Would ya smash the glass and watch your memories bleed? (the memories bleed)
'Cause some things are too painful for me and you to sing
Would ya
Would ya shake it up
Oh would you shake it up, shake it up
Shake it up, shake it up,
Shake it up, shake it up,
Shake it up, shake it up,
Shake it up, shake it up,
Shake it up, shake it up,
Shake it up, shake it up,
Shake it up, shake it up
Would you shake it up?
Oh would you shake it up?
Shake it up, shake it up,
Shake it up, shake it up,
Shake it up!
No comments:
Post a Comment