Record Club covered this album exactly five years ago. I gave it another listen this week. Here are some thoughts.
PUNK
CHAI
Week 7: March 17-23, 2019
Way too much time obsessing over the vocals, in my five-years-removed opinion. I guess I'm mainly talking about myself here, since, reading back on the reviews at the time, I'm the only one who made it part of the thesis of the review. Yes, they are of a higher pitch than what we are used to in the music we usually listen to. But sometimes, what is "new" can be uncomfortable. A full five years removed from my first week with CHAI, and I barely even notice the vocals.
I do recognize the sugar-fueled pop music that acts as a necessary bedrock for these vocals. The key change on "Family Member," the nasty synth groove of "Curly Adventure," the blast-off in "Great Job," the overall busy sounds that remind me of the Go! Team. The music is what makes it good, and the vocals are what makes it memorable, and so overall, I'd say: really good album. Probably my favorite out of the seven that were covered in RC up to this point.
My review is defensive, but I'd argue for a good reason. (It was not because I picked the album, by the way. That's not how I operate in this club.) I just know that a large segment of the population are going to immediately be turned off by the vocals. Whether this particular group of friends are comprised of too many of those who would be turned off is a different question; I'm talking about America at large. I'm really glad that Jenny was still around at this point, because she represented at that point the voice of the "average listener." and not a bunch of music-obsessed freaks. She didn't like it. So there you go. I got preemptively defensive about it, because I think that your average listener is wrong.
CHAI was in the unique position during Week 7 of Record Club that it was early enough to remember, regardless of how good or how bad it was. Bob, who was not a writer for the blog at that point but heard this album from Jenny at the time, still recalls hearing PUNK for the first time, and brings it up to me every once in a while. If this was Week 97, CHAI would've been a drop in the bucket. But to Bob, this was his first exposure to Record Club, and it made a mark. Bob is another "average listener," exemplified by the fact that he said he doesn't "have enough time to listen to a full album every single week" for Record Club but very often writes in his Song Challenge write-ups how he lets the algorithm make him listen to songs. That's absolutely the logic that an "average listener" would employ. And he hated CHAI! It was necessary to get defensive!!!!
I do recognize the sugar-fueled pop music that acts as a necessary bedrock for these vocals. The key change on "Family Member," the nasty synth groove of "Curly Adventure," the blast-off in "Great Job," the overall busy sounds that remind me of the Go! Team. The music is what makes it good, and the vocals are what makes it memorable, and so overall, I'd say: really good album. Probably my favorite out of the seven that were covered in RC up to this point.
My review is defensive, but I'd argue for a good reason. (It was not because I picked the album, by the way. That's not how I operate in this club.) I just know that a large segment of the population are going to immediately be turned off by the vocals. Whether this particular group of friends are comprised of too many of those who would be turned off is a different question; I'm talking about America at large. I'm really glad that Jenny was still around at this point, because she represented at that point the voice of the "average listener." and not a bunch of music-obsessed freaks. She didn't like it. So there you go. I got preemptively defensive about it, because I think that your average listener is wrong.
CHAI was in the unique position during Week 7 of Record Club that it was early enough to remember, regardless of how good or how bad it was. Bob, who was not a writer for the blog at that point but heard this album from Jenny at the time, still recalls hearing PUNK for the first time, and brings it up to me every once in a while. If this was Week 97, CHAI would've been a drop in the bucket. But to Bob, this was his first exposure to Record Club, and it made a mark. Bob is another "average listener," exemplified by the fact that he said he doesn't "have enough time to listen to a full album every single week" for Record Club but very often writes in his Song Challenge write-ups how he lets the algorithm make him listen to songs. That's absolutely the logic that an "average listener" would employ. And he hated CHAI! It was necessary to get defensive!!!!
God... five years feels like forever ago. It's been so long that CHAI have released two more albums in the time since and then broke up. I get it, though. People don't take you seriously because of your brash style, but there is only so many times you can dial down the style before you lose some elemental part of your being. Nothing to do but to fade away. Your average indie music fan in the year 2036 might say something like "hey, do you remember CHAI?" and the answer might be a noncommittal "I guess?" Not for Record Club, though. We'll always remember.

No comments:
Post a Comment