Saturday, March 30, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 40: Gilson

Prompt: "The song that someone told you was their favorite song and in that moment you knew for certain that they had different taste in music than you"

Selected by Gilson


"Honestly"
Cartel
Chroma, 2005

The year was Who Cares, and the place was my brother's house. I think it was a 30th birthday party for my now sister-in-law, and my friend Dan and I were in the backyard talking about, I think, the National, or some such band. It was relatively early in the night, so intoxication was not an issue at this moment. A gentleman (I think a boyfriend of said SIL's sister? it's getting confusing mind your business) made his way over to Dan and I and asked what we were talking about. We said music, he asked what kind we like. Indie rock, some punk (Dan's more Bon Iver than I am, which could be its own response to this prompt).

"Oh yeah, I like that stuff too, ever listen to Cartel?"

I don't think I had, but I knew them by reputation. Dan and I, being the self-serious music aficionados we are, scoffed. And we kinda froze this dude out of the conversation.

We are jerks. I now look back and marvel at this gentleman's courage and lack of social anxiety to approach us at all. If I had that kind of self-assuredness my life would be a lot different.

In Volume No. 12035346 of "The Book Is Better Than the Movie," I recommend reading the book High Fidelity. In the book, as opposed to the movie, SPOILER ALERT our protagonist Rob goes to a friend's house and has a great time. Only at the end of the night does he see that this dude's music collection sucks. In this moment, unlike the movie, Rob realizes that things like music taste, while they do matter, matter less than we tend to believe a lot of the time. This dude was probably a good hang, and I'm sorry I was a dick to him.

*crosses dude at party off of his 8th step amends list*

That was a joke.

No comments: