Wednesday, April 17, 2024

The Burholme Tapes: "Sweet Caroline"

Joe's weekly reflections on the greatest teenage rock 'n' roll cover band to ever come out of Rockledge, PA in the mid-'00s, covered on the blog one song at a time.


"Sweet Caroline"
originally by Neil Diamond

One of the consistent threads of this column that is worth revisiting in its final days is the idea that I do not remember 98% of anything that's happened in my life, and that percentage clip remains about the same when we're talking about a teenage garage rock covers band that I was a part of in my youth. I remember what's on the screen because the screen is showing me what happened. Anything that happened when Kev's dad's cameras weren't rolling is up for debate.

A key aspect to the engine that ran the Burholme machine was the act of choosing a song, and then tentatively playing that song a few times as a sort of trial run, to see if that song would be feasible to play in concert (or at the very least would be fun to jam out to in the garage). We weren't the greatest musicians on the face of the earth; we couldn't play every song. There was a weeding out process. "Hey, I think we should play 'Down by the Seaside' by Led Zeppelin" can become "There's no fucking way we can play that since Jimmy Page's guitar tabs for that song are not known to any mortal human being" real quickly.

What I'm saying is that I cannot bring up a single memory from the depths of my brain involving this stage of the process, for any song. It's weird. There are some songs that I remember saying "hey, this seems like a good one to play," but then the next memories involving any of those particular songs is the act of playing them live. It's like my brain didn't see fit to include any training montages.

So there must have been a moment when we, the Burholme power trio, decided that "Sweet Caroline" would be a good song to play near the end of our final concert, since it was a singalong song that everyone knew. But I don't remember! I haven't held a single memory of playing this song anywhere except that church hall during that concert in August 2007. It's weird and unsettling, how easily memories can slip through your fingers and are lost forever. I don't like it.

But I like "Sweet Caroline." Judging by the reaction from the crowd, everyone there loved it as well. As Mike points out in the pre-song shoutout, this is one of those songs that can bridge generation gaps. My dad might have been out of touch enough to think that "Mardy Bum" was an original song, but when he heard the opening guitar lick of "Sweet Caroline," he knew exactly what he was hearing. And all the younger kids, the teens in the audience up front, they all knew the words too, even the unofficial made-up "bah bah bah" lyrics. It doesn't matter if approximately half of those kids were approaching their joy of recognition in an ironic sense—joy is joy, and we all felt it there, in that moment. Good times never seemed so good.

Maybe my brain doesn't remember anything else because it doesn't need to. This is all I need. I need simply to hear some idiots lurching through a classic rock standard, and I need to hear our friends joining us in the ritual.

Still, I do wish that I had the means to remember more. Forgetting is an uncomfortable act for me. Through this blog, I will my past to inform my present and help prepare for the future, but that can't happen if there isn't enough past to work with. Through the Burholme Tapes, I'm finding that it's extremely difficult to fill in the memories when they aren't right there on the video screen. I'm glad I'm here watching, but the exercise has its limits.

This isn't an act of "living in the past," nor is it an act of "letting go." It's part of an active ritual that's taking place right here, in adulthood, at the age of 35. Our past informs our present. I watch "Sweet Caroline" as performed by Burholme, and I know exactly where I want to be right now. I don't want to be there in the church hall, and I don't want to be stuck in 2007. I want to be here, but I want to feel that sense of community and camaraderie, even if it is imported from the past and refashioned for today. I am getting that here for sure. And we'll be getting it in this column for three more weeks.

No comments: