This list of 200 movies I've never seen before is TEARING ME APART!!!
Rebel Without a Cause
1955
Nicholas Ray
There's no need for reverence when it comes to watching films, especially the ones your never seen before up until that moment. The people that worship certain films are doing so on their own terms, for their own reasons, and it doesn't make any sense for me to approach any of these films in the same way. I can build my own reverence for any particular art over time, through my own experiences. It doesn't happen immediately, and it does no favors to try to force it.
Still, of all the films that I've seen on this list so far, Rebel Without a Cause felt the closest to one of those experiences, like it was the weight of context that was forcing me to not look away, as opposed to the merits of the film itself. I felt reverence toward the movie, even on my first go-around, and even though the movie itself wasn't perfect (and maybe wasn't even good). I could feel in the moment, as it was happening, that this movie was IMPORTANT. That doesn't inform the quality of the film itself, but it informs my viewing experience (if that makes sense).
A few aspects of Rebel Without a Cause made me feel this way in the moment, and I'll go through them, but the first and foremost is obviously James Dean. I know the name because it's a name that everyone knows, but I've never seen any of his films before this (which isn't too preposterous, since he died at the age of 24 and had eight film credits to his name). I know the name, and that's about it. (Well, okay, I also know that an unhinged monologue performed by an alcoholic father in Infinite Jest went very hard on James Dean's method acting, but maybe this isn't the audience to touch on that one.) Watching this movie, I can say: pretty fucking captivating. I'm not the guy who's going to say whether it is incredible acting or overhyped (my opinion is sullied by the fact that I recognized the "you're tearing me apart!" from The Room's reusing of the line), but it without a doubt made me feel something. It was moving. I, along with probably anyone else who has seen any of his films, regret the fact that we won't get to see what else he could've done.
Because he died in a car crash even before the film was released, and, as these things usually go, death weighs heavily on the film in a sort of metatextual way. I don't know, man, it's hokey to put it this way, but this movie features a fucking car crash that kills a kid! And the characters that witness it just kinda brush it under the rug! There's a tension there between fiction and nonfiction, even if I'm reading that tension a bit too literally. He's a method actor, though, right? If he was trying really hard to feel the emotions that Jim Stark was feeling at that juncture of his life, and those methods informed the work, and then the work was cut short because of your boilerplate teenage tragedy, then what does that say about how we view the acting? You see what I'm saying here?
If you take the reverence I felt in the face of the famous acting, and apply it more broadly, then the second part of Rebel Without a Cause that felt big and important to me was the moral panic that it no doubt in my mind caused at the time. Was glad to see I was correct during my post-film-Wikipedia-scroll ritual. One of the focuses of this film was to "show you how it really was" with teens in these suburban environs, and the delinquency that sprouts on the underbelly of malaise. The year was 1955, and films just simply were not showing these types of situations. Rebel Without a Cause (and James Dean) changed all that. That's what I mean by feeling the importance here. This is what was important.
Because he died in a car crash even before the film was released, and, as these things usually go, death weighs heavily on the film in a sort of metatextual way. I don't know, man, it's hokey to put it this way, but this movie features a fucking car crash that kills a kid! And the characters that witness it just kinda brush it under the rug! There's a tension there between fiction and nonfiction, even if I'm reading that tension a bit too literally. He's a method actor, though, right? If he was trying really hard to feel the emotions that Jim Stark was feeling at that juncture of his life, and those methods informed the work, and then the work was cut short because of your boilerplate teenage tragedy, then what does that say about how we view the acting? You see what I'm saying here?
If you take the reverence I felt in the face of the famous acting, and apply it more broadly, then the second part of Rebel Without a Cause that felt big and important to me was the moral panic that it no doubt in my mind caused at the time. Was glad to see I was correct during my post-film-Wikipedia-scroll ritual. One of the focuses of this film was to "show you how it really was" with teens in these suburban environs, and the delinquency that sprouts on the underbelly of malaise. The year was 1955, and films just simply were not showing these types of situations. Rebel Without a Cause (and James Dean) changed all that. That's what I mean by feeling the importance here. This is what was important.
There's a shock in experiencing something new, and though I and almost 70 years removed and do not feel that the content of the film was "new" to me, I also think that the initial shock in 1955 was large enough that the tremors are still rippling through time. So that's why I felt reverence toward the film, I think, despite the fact that a lot of it felt hackneyed and melodramatic and kinda corny to this modern viewer, and also a lot of it didn't really make sense on a logical level (wild how all of this shit happens in a 24-hour period). Reverence because I know that this is NOT how the film was perceived at the time. It must've hit theaters like a fucking nuclear device. I feel the heat from that impact from way back when, even if I don't necessarily feel it from my own television screen.
I don't even have to go back as far as 1955 to try to see this thing from a different perspective, though. I can just go back to 2006ish, the heart of my teenage years, and I think about that time in my life and wonder what I would've written about on my Xanga, had I see Rebel Without a Cause then. Certainly I wouldn't be marveling at the cinematography or the acting. I would have seen this movie from exactly one single perspective: my teenage eyes, connected to my heart.
It would've been all "I can relate to Jim Stark in this film!" and all that. Okay, fine, with the barometer on my own teenage emotional inner turmoil turned down a bit, and in a suburban context that took the threat of death and violence a little more seriously, but still. "You're tearing me apart!" would landed on me like a cut on the chest in a knife fight. And the dude in the conservatory who says that, when earth is finished, the idea of the human race will be of little consequence to the history of the universe—my teenage face would've mirrored Dean's in that moment. That's the whole thing when you're a teenager—there's a lot of confusion, and you feel all these dark feelings inside and you don't really know why. And if Rebel Without a Cause really was the first movie to show that with unflinching frankness and veracity, then I can more than understand the hold it must have had over audiences of its time, both the teenagers who saw themselves on the screen, and the adults who were seeing behind the curtain for the first time (some of them took the display worse than others, I imagine).
Like Rashomon last week, this was a film that felt more important than actually great. Unlike Rashomon, the importance felt so overwhelming as I was watching that I cannot help but call it great anyway. This, despite its myriad flaws—all those can be tossed into the bin clearly labeled "70-year-old film, handle with care." What you're left with is a legendary film that wears that legendary status right there on its plain white T sleeve.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
STRAY THOUGHTS: (I'm going to start putting some miscellaneous discussion points in this tiny space below the grade, as I feel like there are always important aspects to these films that I just don't have the space or the energy to attempt to include in the main essay, but that I feel like I should mention here so it doesn't seem like I'm blowing past this thing without giving it the proper care it deserves) Good acting by the non-James Dean folks, including the grown-up Natalie Wood (last seen here in a non-grown-up role), and the young Sal Mineo; I didn't know what to make of Wood's character wanting to kiss her dad, that whole thing felt underbaked; I also don't know what to make of retroactive claims that Mineo's character was supposed to be gay, as that just feels at best like a try-hard deepening of a character who needed no further depths, and at worst like queerbating; jeez there are a lot of crazy and dumb plot points in this film, the more I think about it (the dad wearing an apron, and Jim saying that he should smack his wife around to prove a point...?), but I'm sticking with that grade!!; I'm a sucker for a good Dutch angle, and boy did I feel that fucking camera in my goddamn soul when it tilted like that during the argument in the stairwell.
It would've been all "I can relate to Jim Stark in this film!" and all that. Okay, fine, with the barometer on my own teenage emotional inner turmoil turned down a bit, and in a suburban context that took the threat of death and violence a little more seriously, but still. "You're tearing me apart!" would landed on me like a cut on the chest in a knife fight. And the dude in the conservatory who says that, when earth is finished, the idea of the human race will be of little consequence to the history of the universe—my teenage face would've mirrored Dean's in that moment. That's the whole thing when you're a teenager—there's a lot of confusion, and you feel all these dark feelings inside and you don't really know why. And if Rebel Without a Cause really was the first movie to show that with unflinching frankness and veracity, then I can more than understand the hold it must have had over audiences of its time, both the teenagers who saw themselves on the screen, and the adults who were seeing behind the curtain for the first time (some of them took the display worse than others, I imagine).
Like Rashomon last week, this was a film that felt more important than actually great. Unlike Rashomon, the importance felt so overwhelming as I was watching that I cannot help but call it great anyway. This, despite its myriad flaws—all those can be tossed into the bin clearly labeled "70-year-old film, handle with care." What you're left with is a legendary film that wears that legendary status right there on its plain white T sleeve.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
STRAY THOUGHTS: (I'm going to start putting some miscellaneous discussion points in this tiny space below the grade, as I feel like there are always important aspects to these films that I just don't have the space or the energy to attempt to include in the main essay, but that I feel like I should mention here so it doesn't seem like I'm blowing past this thing without giving it the proper care it deserves) Good acting by the non-James Dean folks, including the grown-up Natalie Wood (last seen here in a non-grown-up role), and the young Sal Mineo; I didn't know what to make of Wood's character wanting to kiss her dad, that whole thing felt underbaked; I also don't know what to make of retroactive claims that Mineo's character was supposed to be gay, as that just feels at best like a try-hard deepening of a character who needed no further depths, and at worst like queerbating; jeez there are a lot of crazy and dumb plot points in this film, the more I think about it (the dad wearing an apron, and Jim saying that he should smack his wife around to prove a point...?), but I'm sticking with that grade!!; I'm a sucker for a good Dutch angle, and boy did I feel that fucking camera in my goddamn soul when it tilted like that during the argument in the stairwell.
NEXT TIME: I don't know what Requiem for a Dream is about, but something about that title rings a bell for me and says "this is going to be a fucked-up movie." We'll see.

No comments:
Post a Comment