Friday, April 19, 2024

RC@5: Dogrel by Fontaines D.C.

Record Club covered this album exactly five years ago. I gave it another listen this week. Here are some thoughts.


Dogrel
Fontaines D.C.
Week 11: April 14-20, 2019

I like how the Sunday write-up for this album, from way back in April 2019, explicitly states that this album was designed to stand in contrast to last week's Cat Heaven... but that the contrast was "Dog" vs. "Cat." There is irony in the fact that this is the only situation in which I'd ever prefer dog over cat, but let's not go down that road today. Instead, let's point out the fact that an allusion to pets is far from the only contrasting element of these two albums.

In the context of Record Club, we get in these back-to-back album choices two completely opposite experiences. Cat Heaven, as discussed last week (in 2024), was important as a writing exercise. I learned—perhaps not within its week, but definitely in the years since—that curiosity and humility were important, and ultimately made RC work smoothly. But then Dogrel comes in, all swagger and drama, and ends up being an extremely high-quality album, sincerely one of my favorites of the past five years, and makes me wonder whether an album like this should get anywhere near Record Club in the first place.

I chose the album, and I chose it knowing that I'd probably love it, so I have no one to blame but myself. But it's definitely the type of album that makes me think about why we choose certain albums for this club, and whether there are albums that are too much of a sure thing to be considered. The best albums in Record Club end up being those albums that come out of nowhere and surprise you. In the past five years, I've found that I more and more attempt to choose albums that I'm not sure about, albums that I probably wouldn't be listening to without the obligation of writing a review creating pressure to listen closely. At least in those cases, there's the possibility of surprise.

There was no surprise here. I bought into the hype for this band before they released their debut, and the hype paid off when it dropped, and I gave it a good grade because a good grade was deserved, and still is. But all that almost makes Record Club superfluous, in retrospect, and that's the part I don't like. There have been albums over the years that make a huge impact on me because of their time in the spotlight in RC, and I have fond feelings for those albums not in small part due to the context. My love of Dogrel has almost nothing to do with Record Club, and that ain't fair to Record Club. (Maybe I'll eventually think back on Tigers Blood in the same way, an instant classic so good that it overshadows Record Club itself, though only time will tell, and the regret will be softened by the fact that I didn't pick it.)

There's also the problem of the actual writing of the review being a lot more difficult when you like an album a lot right from the get-go. There's no journey to speak of. There's no hook. There's nothing interesting, because "this is really good!" is not interesting. I personally devolved into writing some bullshit about a trip to Ireland, overstating a theme of the album that was designed to be understated. Again, I'd learn the art of choosing albums, over time.

Despite my misgivings about this classic album's place in the pantheon of Record Club, I do appreciate the opportunity to revisit Dogrel this week. Just a fucking incredible album. Would've been the clear #1 album of the year if Pkew Pkew Pkew didn't accidentally stumble into my alcoholic's black heart. In retrospect, I think this ended up being a pretty important album in my journey toward "knowing music." Prior to Fontaines D.C., I held myself at a bit of a remove from genres like post punk, using the excuse of "repetition = boredom." Fontaines showed me that it's more than just repetition for repetition's sake. The repetition of certain lyrics can be soothing. Done in the right way, it can even be cathartic. Anything I wrote about any music like this before 2019 can be completely discarded. This is a new era. Fontaines D.C. leads the way.

I enjoy reading multiple reviews during any given week of Record Club because it gives a great sense of the idea that we are all on our own paths when it comes to music. Nate had understood what post punk is long before Fontaines D.C. came onto the scene, so he was able to employ comparison. Erin didn't say "post punk" once, and is instead on a different path of exploring themes like Catholic guilt, which was a great hook for a review. Only three reviews, but three completely different perspectives, adding up to a really fulfilling week, even at only three reviews. I love Record Club.

But yeah, I think generally, RC works best when we're using this space to discover music together. The act of choosing Dogrel feels like I was trying to drag everyone on a music journey that I wanted to take solo. The ship would correct itself over time, and in the moment, there could have been way worse results than having to review one of the best albums of the past half-decade.

1 comment:

Joe K said...

I've been doing this for eleven weeks now, and this is the third time that I wrote a five-year retrospective and then the artist announces a new album in the same week (previously Maggie Rogers and La Luz).

Looking forward to upcoming album announcements from PUP, Lake Street Dive, Johnny Nash (who died in 2020), and Lizzo (who quit music because she was unable to stop forcing her employees to attend strip clubs against their will).