Monday, April 22, 2024

A Year of Blind Spots: Dirt


Dirt
Alice in Chains
1992

I was listening to this album as I was driving in the rain last week, and "Rain When I Die" came on, and I imagined what it would be like if I died in my car, right there and then, while it was raining, as Alice in Chain's "Rain When I Die" was playing out of the Grand Caravan's speakers. If the information about my musical selections during my death were disseminated to friends and family, there would be a select few who'd know why I was listening to it (i.e. not because I was a huge Alice in Chains guy, but because I was trying on something I wasn't familiar with to see if it fit). Others might consult a medium named John who they seem to have on-call for some reason (there is no room in this blog post for me to travel down that road of thought). If there was an afterlife and I was there, pondering the coincidence, I might ponder the reasons we listen to music, and whether one of those reasons could be that we secretly want to be depressed.

I don't know what I was expecting when I began listening to Dirt (if I'm being completely honest with you, even though that honesty will result in great shame for me and my family, I think I mixed up Alice in Chain with Alice Cooper), but I probably expected something like this. Extremely dour grunge rock, big walls of feedbacked guitars, some of it like a Xerox of Guns n' Roses (though maybe I'm just saying that because Gilson already made the connection in a recent YSC entry, appropriately labeling this band as full of "depressingness"). I like it but I don't love it, and the lack of anything resembling fun gets to me over its almost hour runtime. When your big song is about a rooster, you know something is a little off.

There is a direct line drawn between Alice in Chains and Live, the most recent grunge and/or alt-rock band covered in this column. The line is implicit, drawn through the music only (geographically, Seattle and York, PA, are not very close). Grunge music, basically, or whatever "grunge" music is defined as in retrospect. Using the two bands as a comparative exercise is helpful in this case, as we can see what the problem is with this album today: very few hooks. I don't mind the overall dark sentiments of this type of sound. I'm not expecting party music. But I do like being able to hum along, despite the oppressively depressive qualities. And I don't get that with Alice in Chains.

Could just be an off week for me, emotionally speaking, and those types of weeks tend to affect my listening habits. I just didn't really have the energy to face an hour of this kind of music this week more than the requisite number of times. But, see, this is what I'm talking about—my frame of mind seems to be kinda perfect for this heavy grunge music, no? Wouldn't it make sense that my ill-will toward life would feed into the darkness of Alice in Chains? And if it doesn't work under these circumstances, wouldn't that mean that I know for certain that this music isn't for me?

I don't know. Could be that I picked the wrong album too. The Jar of Flies EP might have been a better choice. It's only a half hour, and it seems to get all the critical love, as far as I can tell from some googling. Oh well. I'll be happier soon, and I'll listen to some other music, and I won't remember any of this. That's how it goes.


No comments: