Monday, March 11, 2024

A Year of Blind Spots: Throwing Copper


Throwing Copper
Live
1994

I may have "discovered music" in the early aughts, but that's just me trying to spin a yarn about my life. We had the radio on throughout the '90s. I heard what they were playing. I'm familiar with the alt-rock classics. No one in my life was actively encouraging musical discovery, which is why I had to take matters into my own hands later on, and "discover" it on my own. But there was plenty of passive listening in the car (or minivan).

Many of the rock songs from the '90s are known entities for me at this point, through efforts in the subsequent two decades to reach back into the canon. There are also plenty of songs that I would be able to say truthfully "oh hell yeah, I know this song, great fucking tune," but have no idea who sang it or when. Passive listening creates the groove in my brain, but active listening is how one actually gains the knowledge, and that just doesn't happen without effort.

But imagine my surprise when I finally dig into the album Throwing Copper by the terribly-named '90s alt-rock band Live, and find that most of the "I love this song but I don't know who sings it" songs from my youth are on the same fucking album. "Selling the Drama," "I Alone," "All Over You," and "Lightning Crashes" are all here, and I knew them all already. And I loved them all already, if we're being honest. I know at this point that they sound like "generic alt-rock," but that "generic" descriptor had to come from somewhere, right? The word shares the same root as "gene." This sound is in Live's genes.

What my experience this week tells me—or reconfirms for me for the thousandth time—is that passive listening is not enough. Listening to music isn't just about having a passing familiarity with a song that was technically forced upon you by radio DJs through car speakers thirty years ago (or same today but with the fucking Spotify algorithm). It's about knowing where a song comes from, and knowing a song's motivation, and having a grasp of what it means, and attaching your own meaning to it beyond simple sterile nostalgia. Hearing these songs still being played occasionally in my own minivan now as I spin the dial is one thing, but understanding that all these songs spring from the same source, and are part of a single, era-defining narrative, is a completely different thing. A lot of the time in this column, I walk away liking the big hits a little less. Here, though, I found a new appreciation for them.

The irony, I guess, is that the simple sterile nostalgia of song recognition is ultimately what kept Live going for the past thirty years, and the pursuit of making a living through audiences' willingness to pay cash to see those four songs played live at a casino near you (maybe even Live!) is also what mostly tore Live apart. This Rolling Stone article from February 2023 now functions as an essential text to Live in the 21st century, and the turmoil that happened post-COVID. I can't really blame the three non-Ed Kowalczyk members of Live for being upset that they were kicked out of the band. I also can't really blame Ed Kowalczyk for not wanting to deal with Ponzi schemes and rapist hangers-on and drummers who have join the QAnon movement while he's just trying to eke out a living playing the songs that people recognize from their family minivans in the mid-'90s.

We want bands like this to exist in amber, frozen in time, their known songs preserved for eternity, but that's not how it works. The members of Live don't suddenly vanish when their fifth Throwing Copper single "White, Discussion" underperforms on the charts. These are human beings—flawed, but still human—and they live and breathe today, in 2024. They made an album packed with hits and worthy deep cuts ("Shit Towne" forever), so much so that, in my eyes, they are a band that defines an entire genre, and so why shouldn't they live off that? Sure, the guitarist is by most accounts a manipulative alcoholic who lost all his royalty money investing in a fake fiber optics company, but I don't see how that should affect how I feel about Throwing Copper.

It's some good shit. If you grew up passive listening like I did, it's time to get active on this one.


No comments: