Follow along in the book HERE. Today's "song" is at #36 and is featured on pages 226-242. See the full list of their Top 100 Beatles Songs HERE.
The Abbey Road Medley
Abbey Road (obviously)
1969
No!! Booooo!!! Fuck these losers for including a collection of songs as one unit on their list of Top 100 Songs. It completely undermines the entire fucking premise of this book. There are rules for a reason! You can't just wantonly break those rules! It makes you guys look like a bunch of punk-ass bitches!!!
Look, I'm an albums guy. I like listening to albums. Albums are both collections of songs and unified works of art. An album is technically a playlist, but the intentionality of the artist who created it is what gives it meaning, and makes it pure art. But we're here to discuss songs. Songs, specifically. Each of the 100 items on this list should be a fucking song, singular. If you wanted to make a "Top 100 Beatles Music" list, then that's a whole different thing. But no. This is songs. Because it's songs, we're not including albums. You wouldn't say that Revolver is one of the best Beatles songs of all time, would you? No, you fucking wouldn't. That doesn't make sense. So tell me how it makes sense to say that "half of Abbey Road" is one of the best Beatles songs of all time?
Look, I'm an albums guy. I like listening to albums. Albums are both collections of songs and unified works of art. An album is technically a playlist, but the intentionality of the artist who created it is what gives it meaning, and makes it pure art. But we're here to discuss songs. Songs, specifically. Each of the 100 items on this list should be a fucking song, singular. If you wanted to make a "Top 100 Beatles Music" list, then that's a whole different thing. But no. This is songs. Because it's songs, we're not including albums. You wouldn't say that Revolver is one of the best Beatles songs of all time, would you? No, you fucking wouldn't. That doesn't make sense. So tell me how it makes sense to say that "half of Abbey Road" is one of the best Beatles songs of all time?
Yes, fine, it's okay to see this collection of songs as one cohesive work of art. I'm not saying that. This was, in fact, the intentions of the Beatles, as noted in the book and in my brain from way back. The Beatles took some spare partial songs, and purposefully pushed 'em together at the back of an album, and did work to make 'em flow into one another, in order. You are certainly allowed to make an opinion statement like: "Fuck, I love the medley on Side 2 of Abbey Road." Totally valid. The problem is when you try telling me that this is all one song, literally. It's fucking not. Don't insult us by pretending otherwise. The Beatles purposefully made each section its own song, and thus, you CANNOT include all of them together on one single item line of a BEST SONGS list. Fuck, man.
And, furthermore, this undermines a few of the arguments made in favor of the songs we've already covered. Think back on "A Day in the Life." If you go under the "Why This Is the Best Beatles Song" section in that chapter of the book, you'll see something like "because it was so cool that Paul and John combined spare partial songs into one big song." That's literally what they did. But if that's your argument, then you're saying that it's a valid argument when the partial songs are literally made into one song. It can't also be an argument for when they take partial songs and just sequence them on the same side of an album. You CANNOT have it both ways, you ignorant fools!!!
I'm all about pressing the rules without breaking them. That's been my m.o. in life as well as on this blog. The rules exist so that you can test their boundaries. From that testing, and the resulting tension, comes the best art. You need limitations in order for that art to flower, however. Jack White ain't shit without Meg White's limitations, you feel me? And so if you're going to make a Top 100 Beatles Songs list, then you have to stick to the implied rules of that descriptor. You have to stick to rules, or else you just look like a chump.
I would have had zero issue with naming "The End" as the 36th-best Beatles song of all time and using the "The End" write-up to talk about the Abbey Road medley. I actually think that would've been kinda cool. Stick to the rules, but press the limits as to what those rules call for. That would have also forced the authors to make the case for their inter-medley selection. I.e. yes, all of these songs are cool, but which is the best representative of the medley as a whole? Instead, by breaking the rule completely and disrespecting the Top 100 list and its audience, there is this sort of leveling-out of the songs that feels bland. What, you're saying that "The End" is just as good as "Golden Slumbers"? Fuck out of here with that nonsense.
It's frustrating to me because every week I return to this space and yet again have temporarily adjust the way I view the world, from an album-centric viewpoint to a song-centric viewpoint. I miniaturize my emotions and consider the four-minute pop song as a complete work of art. It's not easy. And then I have to come here this week and see that I'm not even listening to a goddamn song? I'm listening to ten songs over 20 minutes? And I'm being told that this is true art, comparable to the best Beatles songs? Maybe this is speaking to my own limitations here, and my limited worldview. Fine, I'll accept that. But if I'm going to accept it, then you have to promise not to shit on my head and tell me its shampoo. Don't fucking tell me that "Abbey Road Medley" is the goddamn 36th-best Beatles "song" that's ever existed.
I would have had zero issue with naming "The End" as the 36th-best Beatles song of all time and using the "The End" write-up to talk about the Abbey Road medley. I actually think that would've been kinda cool. Stick to the rules, but press the limits as to what those rules call for. That would have also forced the authors to make the case for their inter-medley selection. I.e. yes, all of these songs are cool, but which is the best representative of the medley as a whole? Instead, by breaking the rule completely and disrespecting the Top 100 list and its audience, there is this sort of leveling-out of the songs that feels bland. What, you're saying that "The End" is just as good as "Golden Slumbers"? Fuck out of here with that nonsense.
It's frustrating to me because every week I return to this space and yet again have temporarily adjust the way I view the world, from an album-centric viewpoint to a song-centric viewpoint. I miniaturize my emotions and consider the four-minute pop song as a complete work of art. It's not easy. And then I have to come here this week and see that I'm not even listening to a goddamn song? I'm listening to ten songs over 20 minutes? And I'm being told that this is true art, comparable to the best Beatles songs? Maybe this is speaking to my own limitations here, and my limited worldview. Fine, I'll accept that. But if I'm going to accept it, then you have to promise not to shit on my head and tell me its shampoo. Don't fucking tell me that "Abbey Road Medley" is the goddamn 36th-best Beatles "song" that's ever existed.
As a sort of self-defense mechanism, I am going to spend the remaining of this paragraph just pretending that the authors chose "The End" for this space, and not some unholy amalgam of ten goddamn songs. If we were here for "The End," then I'd marvel at the Ringo Starr drum solo, and wish that the man had had more time to flex during his stint as the drummer for the most famous rock band in history. I'd also say something snarky about the final line, I think. "And in the end / the love you take / is equal to the love you make" sounds like some faux-intellectual tenth-grader AIM away message content (as I'm sure it literally was when I was in tenth grade and on AIM). Does it actually mean anything? I guess it means that you need to love in order to be loved. Which is fine. Probably not fitting for the final line uttered by the Beatles during recording sessions. Also: anything poignancy you could possibly wring from this dreck is immediately undercut by the toss-off insulting bullshit of "Her Majesty."
Clearly I am just taking out my frustration on the songs today. My frustration's source is the authors of the book, Stephen J. Spignesi and Michael Lewis, and NOT the Beatles themselves or their songs. These are good songs. Shit, these are great pieces of songs, and the Beatles do a real fine job stringing them together to make the back half of this album feel cohesive and artistic and fun. I just think it's fucking stupid that I'm over here talking about albums now, when really we're supposed to be talking about the songs. What's next? Are these fuckers gonna try to tell me that Disc 1 Side B of The White Album is one of the best Beatles songs of all time? How about the four original non-film orchestration songs on the Yellow Submarine LP as one of the best Beatles songs of all time? Maybe we can just say that the entire LOVE Cirque du Soleil CD compilation is the 87th-best Beatles song of all time? Hmm????
Clearly I am just taking out my frustration on the songs today. My frustration's source is the authors of the book, Stephen J. Spignesi and Michael Lewis, and NOT the Beatles themselves or their songs. These are good songs. Shit, these are great pieces of songs, and the Beatles do a real fine job stringing them together to make the back half of this album feel cohesive and artistic and fun. I just think it's fucking stupid that I'm over here talking about albums now, when really we're supposed to be talking about the songs. What's next? Are these fuckers gonna try to tell me that Disc 1 Side B of The White Album is one of the best Beatles songs of all time? How about the four original non-film orchestration songs on the Yellow Submarine LP as one of the best Beatles songs of all time? Maybe we can just say that the entire LOVE Cirque du Soleil CD compilation is the 87th-best Beatles song of all time? Hmm????
BEATLES TRIVIA: I did not know that "Her Majesty" was originally supposed to be in between "Mean Mr. Mustard" and "Polythene Pam." That would've made more sense! Imagine the fucking hubris that Paul fucking McCartney must have possessed to think that his 20-second song about wanting to fuck Queen Elizabeth would be great as the final song on what was then supposed to be the final Beatles album. Jesus fucking christ, get me out of here.
BETTER BEATLE: Not applicable. This isn't a song, and so I can't name a song better than it. Maybe I should say that "the entire Beatles discography" is a better Beatles song than "the Abbey Road Medley." If you think that sounds stupid, well then, you've finally grasped my point.
NEXT TIME: "Sexy Sadie" at #37 (it is a song)
No comments:
Post a Comment