Wednesday, April 24, 2024

Never Seen It, #143 of 200: Requiem for a Dream

We got a winner! We got a winner! We got a winner! Three rules to turning your life around. Step one: no more red meat! Step two: cut out that refined sugar! Step three: watch 200 movies you've never seen before!


Requiem for a Dream
2000
Darren Aronofsky

As is the case for many of these films, I have a hazy recollection of someone's reaction to seeing Requiem for a Dream. I don't remember who or when. Must have been years ago. Or maybe it was Pam recently. I'm not sure, and the details don't matter. What matters is that there was an impression made on me that Requiem for a Dream was a "fucked-up" movie. So the anticipation in finally watching it three-to-twenty years later was discovering what that meant. What does it mean that a piece of art is "fucked up"?

The two possibilities are that it is a fucked-up subject matter, or that the manner in which the film is presented is itself fucked up. Throughout this fucked-up film, Darren Aronofsky manages to do both. It's a fucked-up movie, and it's shown to the audience in the most fucked-up way possible. And then when we talk about a film or a filmmaker being "divisive," then this is what we mean: how much can you tolerate how fucked up this thing is? I could tolerate it (or at least felt like I should), and thus, I liked this film. But while watching it, I could totally empathize with those who could not.

Requiem for a Dream is not subtle. The "whole point" is presented early and hammered into you often. It almost feels stupid to write about it, since it is so obvious (on purpose—more on that in one second). But the overarching point here is that addiction is bad. There is no ambivalence regarding this thesis statement, and maybe there shouldn't be. It's easy for us as humans to make such a statement, especially these days, when we see the destruction that addiction hath wrought plainly in the light of day. But in Requiem for a Dream, it's meant to be obvious. And the structure of the film makes it so that it starts obvious, and then gets more obvious, and then even more obvious, to the point that the final twenty minutes feels like the movie just absolutely drowning you in misery to make it's point undeniable. It's not just "addiction is bad," it's "let's show you how deep this thing fucking goes, and then you'll be unable to disagree."

This acts as a sort of defense for the film, I guess. That there is no subtlety and that the lack of subtlety was on purpose. I read a description of this theory in an AVClub write-up for Requiem that I liked: the Pee-wee Herman Defense. I've NEVER SEEN anything Pee-wee-related, but I found this clip of the titular character performing a pratfall and claiming that he meant to do that. (The competing theory, named similarly according to Urban Dictionary, is that the Pee-wee Herman Defense is just accusing your enemy of exactly what they accuse you of, i.e. "you haven't paid your taxes in years" and "no YOU haven't paid your taxes in year," but this isn't what I'm referring to here.) I like giving a film the benefit of the doubt, that anything it does was done on purpose. There was a hubbub in the comment section a few weeks ago about Poor Things, and I presented the Pee-wee Herman Defense before I even knew its name. So clearly I'm a big fan of examining a film's so-called flaws to understand what it is trying to say, as opposed to doing what some people do and just saying that the film is shitty because of those flaws. Seems more fun that way.

I'm a moron when it comes to movies, but even I could understand why they kept showing those quick close-up shots of the drugs and the pupils dilating—to show the before/after of taking a hit, and putting that change right in the audience's faces. I knew why there were split screens, even when the characters who were split were occupying the same space—to show the emotional distance between them, despite the physical closeness. And I get why half of the film was devoted to the mother, who was not taking any illegal drugs—to show that the descent into addiction and despair could happen to anyone, and even due to good intentions. None of this is particularly nuanced, but the film meant to lack nuance. That's the fucking point.

I'm not creating strawmen here. This really is a divisive film. That aforementioned AVClub article mentions how one of the editor's reaction upon seeing the film was "Aronofsky's career is over." Which was not true, technically, but I think true in spirit, in that there was no way that this filmmaker could ever reach mass audiences, if he was committed to making this type of movie. I've (surprisingly) seen four additional Aronofsky films (The Wrestler, Black Swan, mother!, and The Whale), and I can personally attest to the fact that he is more than occasionally "too much," but that also never so by accident. And I like "too much" when you can make an argument that it's on purpose.

It's also nice talking about the shit that we can all agree on, right? I think that the acting is great from top to bottom. Ellen Burstyn more than deserved the Oscar nom, breaking the film's structure for a solid five minutes as she delivers a (purposefully, ironically) heartwarming monologue to her wayward son. Jared Leto was such a convincing creep on screen that it made me forget that he's a fucking creep behind the scenes. Jennifer Connelly was such a good actor that she remained one of the most attractive actresses of all time even at her character's lowest (or does that make her a bad actor? no, it's not her fault that there's literally nothing anyone could ever do to make her seem unattractive). Marlon Wayans convinced me that he's not just a comedic actor. Even a bit part for Keith David made me theorize that they hired him as The Princess and the Frog's Dr. Facilier based on his Requiem role.

I'll also make the case here for at least one subtlety. I liked how the film didn't feel the need to explain the cycle of desperate need and euphoric but all-too-brief high and brutal withdrawal that comes with the substance abuse. I am probably wrong but I don't think that anyone even mentions any of the drugs by name. It's more, like, implied. The only thing we as the audience needs to know what's happening are those close-ups of the eyeball, pupils dilating.

I also feel like the Mom side of the bifurcated story was not only necessary, but also a lot more effective for me as a viewer. I've been pretty upfront about my own addiction issues on this blog, and I've dealt with all that as best I could, and although my drug of choice was alcohol and I've sincerely never even touched any of the drugs that were passed around off-screen in this film, I could still relate to the cycle and the pain to some degree. But with Ma, Sara Goldfarb, Burstyn's character, the issue isn't really substance abuse, at least not at first. It's more that she's unhappy with herself, and wants to find a way to change. And she thinks she's going about it the right way by getting a prescription. The main issue is weight, and a sub-issue is sugar intake. As I start to get deeper into sobriety, and somehow find myself fatter than I ever was when I was drinking, I can see myself in those feelings, and specifically, how those tendencies of addiction can manifest in even so-called non-drugs like sugar. I know that I'm addicted to sugar. I am starting to feel the same way about cookies as I did about alcohol a year and change ago. The binging and purging, the shame, the inability to stop, the negative health consequences, the anxiety in the aftermath of consumption, etc.

So I think if Requiem for a Dream is trying to make a point, and it's trying to be very clear about that point, then that's okay. Sure, there's no subtlety or nuance. Maybe there shouldn't be. Maybe abuse and addiction and that inevitable downward spiral should be shown to the audience in the most fucked-up way imaginable. That's probably good thing, to show how fucked up it is. This is a fucked-up movie. We can all agree on that. So maybe there's value in trying to understand what makes it so fucked up.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: We already watched #144, so we're skipping to #145, Rocky II, finally. I know he wins, but I don't know anything else. I imagine it'll be fun.

No comments: