From where I'm standing, it sure didn't seem like he was watching 200 films he's never seen before.
Rashomon
1950
Akira Kurosawa
I absolutely love the idea that the story as presented is not what it seems. Narrative devices such as unreliable narrator, or a play-within-a-play kinda thing where a character is telling a story to other characters, all those kinds of things really do it for me. So it was a pleasure watching an originator of a particular subset of this idea. Here is a film that maybe wasn't the first to feature a narrative as told from multiple and conflicting perspectives, but definitely the most famous, so much so that the narrative device is named after the film. I love Rashomon-style storytelling. As to Rashomon, the film itself, I was a little less impressed. But that's okay! Watching the conflicting narratives unfold was more than worth the price of admission.
The story here involves a frame story of a woodcutter and a priest relaying the tale of a samurai's murder. The story, via these two characters, is told from the perspectives of the thief at the trial, the samurai's wife at that same trial (the woodcutter and the priest were present at the trial, you see), the dead samurai himself via a medium (it sounds even more insane when I type it out), and the woodcutter, who reveals his true version of the story at the end, and his motivations for keeping his version close to his chest until then.
Hearing the same story told in four different ways is the hook that makes me believe that this is a great movie. That, plus the fact that we don't ever really get to know what the actual truth is in this case. Maybe one version is completely true. Maybe all four of them are half true. That's not really for us as the audience to know, and that's the beauty of it. It's beautiful because it so accurately reflects how our own world operates. We see what we want to see, and we remember half as much, ya know? I believe that no one was accurate in their tale, and I also believe that everyone believed that they were completely accurate in their tale. That's called being human.
Loving Rashomon for this reason runs parallel to my love of that qualitative research class that I took a year and a half ago, because they both deal with the same phenomena. The Rashomon effect is a legitimate theory in the field of ethnographic research. When we observe, it's important to not only note what we are observing, but also why we are observing, and how that reason affects the observation, and also what we as the observer brings to the environment in which we are observing, and how our perspective is going to change based on both how the observed perceives the observer in addition to how the observer perceives the observed. Throw in the fact that I was drunk for a lot of that qualitative research class, and so, like, how does that affect the research, and even how that affects my recollections of doing the research? There is literally a recording of me getting drunk during our class period, and so you would think that would provide an objective perspective of the situation, and yet recall that I chose to hit play on the recorder, and I chose to transcribe, and I chose to present it on the blog after the fact, and I remember it with rose-colored glasses because of the alcohol in my veins then and the lack of it in my veins now. Complicated stuff, and really ripe for good storytelling. So I appreciated thinking about all of this in the aftermath of watching this classic film.
The actual movie, I don't know, maybe not so much. It lasted a crisp 88 minutes, but seemed a lot longer. It felt like it could've been shorter, what with all the unnecessary screaming and long still reaction shots... like it got to the point where I thought maybe the film was attempting to annoy me on purpose, as if to say that it's uncomfortable to hear someone else's perspective on a tale you think you know. There was some aspects to the narrative that came off like they aged poorly too—the only thing that remained consistent through all four versions of the story was the misogyny of early-20th-century Japan. I'm not faulting the film for being culturally accurate regarding a different time; rather, it just added maybe one complication too many regarding the complexities of my understanding of the narrative. Finally, the conclusion of the framing story (and the final conclusion of the film itself) felt a little tacked on to me. I won't spoil it, but it felt slightly like a stab at unearned poignancy. I admire the attempt, though, and maybe the power of that ending will reveal itself to me in time, but I'm not quite there.
I loved Rashomon for what it means for storytelling, but not for what it is as a film. If that makes sense. But who knows if any of this is true. It's just one perspective. Now is the time for you to tell me I'm wrong and to tell this story from your perspective.
The story here involves a frame story of a woodcutter and a priest relaying the tale of a samurai's murder. The story, via these two characters, is told from the perspectives of the thief at the trial, the samurai's wife at that same trial (the woodcutter and the priest were present at the trial, you see), the dead samurai himself via a medium (it sounds even more insane when I type it out), and the woodcutter, who reveals his true version of the story at the end, and his motivations for keeping his version close to his chest until then.
Hearing the same story told in four different ways is the hook that makes me believe that this is a great movie. That, plus the fact that we don't ever really get to know what the actual truth is in this case. Maybe one version is completely true. Maybe all four of them are half true. That's not really for us as the audience to know, and that's the beauty of it. It's beautiful because it so accurately reflects how our own world operates. We see what we want to see, and we remember half as much, ya know? I believe that no one was accurate in their tale, and I also believe that everyone believed that they were completely accurate in their tale. That's called being human.
Loving Rashomon for this reason runs parallel to my love of that qualitative research class that I took a year and a half ago, because they both deal with the same phenomena. The Rashomon effect is a legitimate theory in the field of ethnographic research. When we observe, it's important to not only note what we are observing, but also why we are observing, and how that reason affects the observation, and also what we as the observer brings to the environment in which we are observing, and how our perspective is going to change based on both how the observed perceives the observer in addition to how the observer perceives the observed. Throw in the fact that I was drunk for a lot of that qualitative research class, and so, like, how does that affect the research, and even how that affects my recollections of doing the research? There is literally a recording of me getting drunk during our class period, and so you would think that would provide an objective perspective of the situation, and yet recall that I chose to hit play on the recorder, and I chose to transcribe, and I chose to present it on the blog after the fact, and I remember it with rose-colored glasses because of the alcohol in my veins then and the lack of it in my veins now. Complicated stuff, and really ripe for good storytelling. So I appreciated thinking about all of this in the aftermath of watching this classic film.
The actual movie, I don't know, maybe not so much. It lasted a crisp 88 minutes, but seemed a lot longer. It felt like it could've been shorter, what with all the unnecessary screaming and long still reaction shots... like it got to the point where I thought maybe the film was attempting to annoy me on purpose, as if to say that it's uncomfortable to hear someone else's perspective on a tale you think you know. There was some aspects to the narrative that came off like they aged poorly too—the only thing that remained consistent through all four versions of the story was the misogyny of early-20th-century Japan. I'm not faulting the film for being culturally accurate regarding a different time; rather, it just added maybe one complication too many regarding the complexities of my understanding of the narrative. Finally, the conclusion of the framing story (and the final conclusion of the film itself) felt a little tacked on to me. I won't spoil it, but it felt slightly like a stab at unearned poignancy. I admire the attempt, though, and maybe the power of that ending will reveal itself to me in time, but I'm not quite there.
I loved Rashomon for what it means for storytelling, but not for what it is as a film. If that makes sense. But who knows if any of this is true. It's just one perspective. Now is the time for you to tell me I'm wrong and to tell this story from your perspective.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Gotta assume that Rebel Without a Cause is a Western, but you can't trust me on any of this shit.

No comments:
Post a Comment