Thursday, June 25, 2020

The Albums That Matter: Turn to Gold

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE. This is the final day of a non-alphabetically-ordered album. Thanks for putting up with me as I try to find ways to lessen the self-imposed burden of twice-a-day blogging (spoiler: this was not a good way to lessen it).


Turn to Gold
Diarrhea Planet
2016

I haven't outright stated it over the past three days, but it's at least been alluded to—a band's legacy is important. When a band doesn't have one at all, it feels sad. When a band has a great one, then we must question what it about them makes them so well-remembered. When a band doesn't have a necessarily great legacy, we must wonder if they really deserve the negativity. What I love about Diarrhea Planet though (besides their name) is that they chose to control their own legacy. They were at the highest peak (relatively speaking), and they decided to walk away. There was no backslide, no stagnation, and no souring. Diarrhea Planet will live forever.

Of course, this is rock and roll in the 21st century, so when I say things like "highest peak," there are naturally some caveats that come with such statements. Rock has never been this culturally insignificant. Your grandma has never heard of Diarrhea Planet. What I mean is that, within our tight little circle of friends and strangers who appreciate "good music" in a mostly-indie rock sense, Diarrhea Planet was one of the good ones, and their star seemed to still be on the rise (as much as a band called "Diarrhea Planet" could be, anyway) when they called it quits. They went out on "top," the quotation marks surrounding the word "top" being everyone else's fault, not ours.

I guess we're supposed to be talking about an album here—Turn to Gold is the penultimate part of this band's story. It's a great fucking album. It's also their last. It's pure unadulterated guitar rock when it doesn't feel like anything is guitar rock anymore. They have four guitarists! Most bands are lucky to have one, and they have four! This is some good shit.

Two years after Turn to Gold hit the proverbial shelves, Diarrhea Planet broke up with a series of farewell concerts in their hometown of Nashville, TN. This blog post is supposed to be about an album, but it's really about a band, and the manner in which they broke up, as covered in this Stereogum cover story. Maybe I would've assumed they simply "couldn't hack it" as a band if I hadn't read that interview.

But it made me consider the toll that being in a rock band can take on a person, and it made me consider that maybe I take this beautiful art for granted sometimes. The sometimes-frontman of DP, Jordan Smith, is quoted in saying "I love doing this, but I miss waking up and being happy." I want to listen to music that makes me happy, and Turn to Gold has made me happy more often than not, but I can't live with knowing that it's at the expense of someone else's happiness.

So by breaking up, Diarrhea Planet has added an extra layer of meaning to their best and final album. These are the happy sounds of an extremely sad group of individuals, who thought that making music would make them happy, but all it did was bring them stress and the immense weight of higher expectations. Before their breakup, Turn to Gold was the sound of some kids kicking and screaming against the idea of adulthood. After their breakup, Turn to Gold is the sound of some kids kicking and screaming against the idea of adulthood, and losing.

All bands are fated to eventually die. I get that. But there's something powerful in committing to going out in style. Turn to Gold does that, and more.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "Life Pass"



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • Didn't want to mention it in the article proper, but the Stereogum piece makes sure to mention the fact that all these guys are entering the workforce after DP wraps up. One of them is in nursing school, the other is getting a degree in electrical engineering, etc. Something about this makes me so incredibly sad, but I didn't mention it above because I already wrote something like this for Tapes 'n Tapes and for The Bad News Bears, just in the last week and a half alone. Maybe it's because I too have given up on any dreams of being important in this world, and have settled into a nice quiet home life, but I appreciate when other people do make it, when they are able to live out their wild dreams. When they can't, when members of a crazy six-piece certifiable fucking rock band have to quit because they couldn't make it work, and have to live as a fucking electrical engineer, it just fucking bums me out, man.
  • I didn't want to misrepresent myself by talking about DP's live shows, because I never attended one. By all accounts, they were legendary. For someone like myself who doesn't attend many shows, I will have to just imagine what they were like, and allow them to pass into myth, like any other band I never got the chance to see in their prime. 
  • ALBUM COVER: Gold lettering on a black background, with the name Diarrhea Planet in small cursive letters. Pretty simple stuff. The music can speak for itself.
  • ALBUM TITLE: The Stereogum piece made the case that it's really tough out there for rock bands to be financially secure, so maybe this was DP trying their best to will financial stability into their lives.
  • PREVIOUSLY ON PoYB: "Life Pass" really is a good song.
  • We didn't talk about the name of the band. We don't really have to. If you aren't listening to a band because you are uncomfortable with the idea of fecal discharge, then that's your loss.

NEXT TIME: Better Oblivion Community Center by Better Oblivion Community Center (yeah, we're back to the alphabetical order, as this week was just an anomaly, a showcase for PoYB's least beloved column—sorry about that)

No comments: