Tuesday, June 9, 2020

Top Five Tuesday: Avoiding Albums of the Week

It should be clear to you at this juncture that I have a lot of opinions about music. I'm not saying I'm necessarily good at expressing those opinions, but the opinions are there, and they are bountiful.

That prosperity of sentiment extends even to the weekly album choices for Record Club. I have opinions about what makes a "good" Record Club album pick, and what makes for a "bad" pick. But I mostly keep those opinions to myself, because I like the fact that there are many hands on the wheel. If I started handed out judgments as to what albums we should review each week before the week even starts, then it starts to feel like the Joe Show, and I don't want that. Plus, telling someone that I don't feel like reviewing the album they want to review just makes me seem like an asshole. Which I am, but I try not to be, ya feel me?

But I'll share with you one little morsel of an opinion right now. In my opinion, picking the popular indie rock albums is the most boring thing one can possibly do. Every year, there are a dozen or two of these "big tent" album releases in the indie world, those albums for which everyone has an opinion, and everyone is writing about on the blogosphere. And I hate when Record Club covers these albums, especially due to the fact that we never get around to them until like months later, when everyone has already said everything that needs to be said about these fuckers.

Again, this is only my own personal dumb opinion, but I'd rather see Albums of the Week that aren't being talked about already. Give me those bands I've never even heard of. Give me the pop stars I wouldn't normally attempt to understand. Give me random albums from the '70s and let's see if we can uncover something new. Give me anything besides these albums that we've all already digested, both in print and in the ear.

I'm not even saying that the albums themselves are bad. For the most part, they are great! Some are occasionally my favorite albums of the year! But I just find it tedious as fuck to have to give them extra time, to have to stretch them out and try to find something fresh to deliver, something that no one else has said. That's not the true spirit of Record Club to me. Record Club is about finding some new emotion through music, discovering music that you didn't even know could affect you like it does. It's not about rehashing something that Stereogum just spent a week rehashing not three months ago.

Okay, so there's not really much I can do about this. Even typing five paragraphs on the subject is making me seem a little extra. Record Club isn't what I want it to be, it's what YOU want it to be. If people want to listen to a popular, well-known indie rock album, and then ask their friends what they think about it, then so be it. What the fuck can I do but grin and write the damn review?

Well... there's one thing I can do. I can abuse the rules a little bit. One of the rules for picking an album states that it can't be an album that I've already written about on this blog. So today's Top Five is going abuse the format, and list the Top Five Albums I Don't Want Picked for Record Club. And I will write a quick review for each. That way, if someone tries to pick any of these albums, I won't have to worry about wanting to say that it's a bad pick but then let 'em pick it anyway. Instead, I'll just be able to say "Sorry, it's a great album, but it's ineligible because I already wrote about it."

These are indie rock albums from 2020. I will probably do a similar list for 2019 and 2018 at some point, just in case. The fact that they were so easy to write is me proving to myself that these are definitely albums that I don't want Record Club to worry about. These are the albums that are great to listen to, but not very fun to think about too deeply. The second part of the equation is important to me! (And probably just me!)

Top Five Album Reviews That I Didn't Want to Write for Record Club

5. NO DREAM by Jeff Rosenstock


Consistency breeds boredom, even if it's consistently great. Another Jeff Rosenstock album? Ho hum. NO DREAM is unimportant in the macro. In the micro, however, Rosenstock is just as vital as ever. His particular brand of balls-to-the-wall pop punk was perfected long ago (probably during his Bomb the Music Industry! days), and it remains pretty much perfect now.

This dude can rip through bangers about difficulties of growing up at the drop of a hat, and then rip through another banger about a shitty AirBnB, seemingly in the same breath. It's admirable that every eighteen months he can just throw an album like this on the internet. It seems effortless. I would love to be able to do anything like Jeff Rosenstock plays punk.

NO DREAM is gonna be one of those albums that I never remember until I randomly play it on a whim, at which point I will spend 40 minutes wondering why the hell I don't listen to it more.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

4. Have We Met by Destroyer


Destroyer does a really good job at creating that spacey, minimalistic, end-of-the-night-walk-home-type music. This is not something I rarely say for anyone else, because this type of music is a hard sell for me, and Destroyer is really the only artist I can think of that does it and I still listen.

Have We Met is an album full of these anti-bangers. They are the sort of songs where Destroyer (stage name of Dan Bejar) sneers his cackling wit over a heady synth tone. That sounds awful, and for most people it is, but here, it works like gangbusters a large part of the time.

It's probably the lyrics, right? Destroyer is fucking brilliant with words. His lyrics make it seem like he is writing them in real time. Here's how he starts the album: "I was like the laziest river / A vulture predisposed to eating off floors / No wait, I take that back / I was more like an ocean / Stuck inside hospital corridors." It's that middle part, the "no wait" line, that gets me. No one else is doing this shit, this sort of meta self-aware songwriting. I love it. (His "cue fake drums" line gets all the love in most reviews, and yeah, that's a perfect fucking line too. There are a lot of perfect lines on this album.)

Does Destroyer travel too far down the path sometimes during his 3 AM stroll? Sure he does. Sometimes the synths stretch toward infinity and it gets painfully boring (jeez... the album ends awfully, doesn't it?). But then there's Destroyer, to bring us back with a deadpan quip. I like this album, and it's not the type of album I usually like.

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

3. Miss Anthropocene by Grimes


There are albums that I like. There are follow-up albums to those first albums that copy the formula but make the whole aesthetic a lot darker. I tend not to like those albums as much. I get that Grimes is feeling some darkness within her, but it just doesn't translate as well into a successful pop album. Maybe I just lack an appreciation for industrial music, I dunno.

We should also consider that sometimes an artist is unlikable enough that it starts to affect my ability to enjoy their music. I don't hate Grimes or anything, but she gets more eyerolls out of me than almost any other musician on earth (give or take a Kanye). Can we take seriously anyone who defends their creepy billionaire boyfriend with such zealousness, and subsequently has a child with said billionaire, whom they name "X Æ A-Xii"? No, I cannot take it seriously.

There are bits and pieces of Miss Anthropocene that are sticky, that stay in my head for a few minutes after the album ends. Grimes is obviously talented. But none of this comes together like a good pop album should. Exploring the hole you're stuck in is admirable, but it's time to escape and shine a little light on this shit.

GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 

2. The New Abnormal by the Strokes


There's a 2018 Julian Casablancas quote from a Vulture profile that I think about a lot:

"I just saw Annihilation, and I was talking to someone about how Natalie Portman was also in the Thor movies and thinking that was interesting. She was mind-blowing in Annihilation, and I just thought she probably does some things out of passion and certain things that are more pay-the-bills. I think actors do that and it doesn’t mean they don’t like what they’re working on. It’s a different kind of energy. That situation may be similar to me and the bands I play in."

I thought about that quote while listening to The New Abnormal—which I've done a lot this year—because it doesn't sound like that quote is true anymore. There's a lot of weird shit on The New Abnormal. If not "weird" in the literal sense, then absolutely a bunch of shit that you would've never found on Is This It or Room on Fire.

So the Voidz (Casablanca's self-described passion project) are clearly influencing the Strokes (Casablancas' Marvel blockbuster). The frontman, whether purposefully or accidentally, has dragged his main stage production into the sideshow shadows a little bit. I like the Strokes and the Voidz a lot as separate entities, and so I have no problem with their sensibilities being blended a little bit.

I could also understand why you might have a problem with this. If you are a Strokes purist, then there's gonna be some shit that pisses you off here. If you love the Voidz because they are strange and twisted and somehow make practically unlistenable noise ultimately joyfully catchy, then the sleek Strokes sounds here are gonna be avoided anyway. Me? I'm no purist, and I have no expectations. The New Abnormal is a good time.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


1. Making a Door Less Open by Car Seat Headrest


I've written before about how third albums fascinate me, and while Making a Door Less Open is not a third album, the theory still applies (all you have to do is ignore EIGHT self-released Bandcamp albums and also a quasi-compilation of rerecorded older songs?!). It applies because MaDLO is the album that the artist mixes it up a little bit, just so that this isn't yet another album of the same sound that the artist is known for.

As often happens, there are mixed results. Being a big fan of Car Seat Headrest, I may be more forgiving of some of the less successful results. "Hollywood" is the best example because it was the first single, and was met with a strangely negative reaction by the general indie rock-inclined public, but I think it's pretty okay. Not great, but it sounds enough like the Dandy Warhols that I'll give it a pass.

This is Car Seat really, really leaning into the electronica aspects of his sound. Fine. There are songs on this album that layer on thickly the synths, and it works like gangbusters. "Can't Cool Me Down" has an extremely memorable keyboard part that you wouldn't find on Teens of Denial. "Life Worth Missing" is built on a synthy foundation, but somehow still exists as CLASSIC Car Seat Headrest ("There Must Be More Than Blood"—same, but slower).

Yet there are also a few songs that don't work at all. "Deadlines (Thoughtful)" sounds like a misguided attempt at club music, which is bad, but possibly not as bad as something like "Deadlines (Hostile)," which is just straight up unmemorable.

Still, give me something like "Martin," and I'll mostly be happy. I listen to "Martin," et al, and I understand that Car Seat Headrest is still Car Seat Headrest. He may be stretching the sound, and it might not work all the time, but I'll mostly always love this shit. Even when the stretchmarks are showing.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 

HONORABLE MENTION: I mentioned this album a few weeks ago, but it probably wasn't enough to disqualify it from Record Club, so let's go ahead and do that right now.

Reunions by Jason Isbell & the 400 Unit


It's funny how we indieheads rally around the few country artists that we deem "genuine." I wouldn't be surprised if it turned out that there were other worthy country artists out there who weren't covered on Stereogum. I don't have the time or the desire to try to find out, to be honest. What I do know is that Jason Isbell, at the end of the day a country artist, is definitely worth everyone's time.

What is it about Jason Isbell that speaks to hearts universally? Perhaps it's his ability to speak frankly about the human condition. He knows he is a flawed man. He has trouble with alcohol ("It Gets Easier"). He knows that there's always something more that we could be doing, but we don't ("What've I Done to Help"). He has trouble letting go (um... "Letting You Go").

And he's so good about speaking these stark truths in such poetic language. This isn't a six-pack-in-the-styrofoam-cooler country rock. This is whisky-neat country rock. Dude knows how to stir some emotion out of you.

If I think any parts of Reunions are pandering or cloying, then that's more my problem them his. I should just get over myself and accept the fact that I am just as flawed as Isbell is.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: