Record Club covered this album exactly five years ago. I gave it another listen this week. Here are some thoughts.
Theon Cross
Week 28: August 11-17, 2019
Well, it wasn't for lack of trying.
I am so glad that we covered Fyah in Record Club early on. It was a nice entry into jazz music. Not that it was a "good beginner's jazz album" or any other similar descriptor, but its tuba-forwardness really provided a nice ready-made hook for all those beginner music critics on Week 28. It didn't stop people (myself included) from ruminating on What Jazz Music Is, but it softened the landing, I think.
Still, though, five years later and a few more listens under my belt, and I still can't get over the fact that the tuba sounds absolutely ridiculous in the lead position. Maybe I've been unconsciously conditioned throughout my lifetime to think that the tuba is a silly instrument. If it's my fault, then fine, I'll take the heat. But because of my flaws of opinion, I struggle to listen to Fyah and not scoff a little at how much cooler it might have sounded if the bass took over for the tuba. On the other hand, we wouldn't be talking about this fucker if it was a bass-forward album. So there's the trade-off.
It's probably cheap to talk about "jazz" in a jazz album review, but it's a tough genre to crack, and I have patience for our former selves as we worked through it. I will say that this was probably one of my earlier moments of self-reflection within a Record Club review about Record Club reviews, in that I was self-aware that this review was following a pattern that indicative of "learning how to write" and couldn't last forever. I am still not so sure about jazz, but I'm a lot farther along in the process.
I love reading old reviews from RC writers, regulars and irregulars alike. Just as I was honing the craft, so too were they in their own individual ways. You had Nate sharpening the snark and wit, and introducing a then-unnamed uncle who would eventually turn into a Record Club alumnus and contributor. You had Sam widening his scope and managing to meld together a discussion about sitcom television with one about the energy of jazz, which manages to not be as far a reach in Sam's hands as the idea seems in mine now. You had Sean, turning something simple into something complexly philosophical (e.g. "who am I if I like jazz?"), which I appreciate immensely. And you had Stephan, who does the work in sounding professional, and whose personality is just beginning to shine through the cracks of that professionalism (and would truly come to fruition a few summers later during SSC, I'd argue).
I love reading old reviews from RC writers, regulars and irregulars alike. Just as I was honing the craft, so too were they in their own individual ways. You had Nate sharpening the snark and wit, and introducing a then-unnamed uncle who would eventually turn into a Record Club alumnus and contributor. You had Sam widening his scope and managing to meld together a discussion about sitcom television with one about the energy of jazz, which manages to not be as far a reach in Sam's hands as the idea seems in mine now. You had Sean, turning something simple into something complexly philosophical (e.g. "who am I if I like jazz?"), which I appreciate immensely. And you had Stephan, who does the work in sounding professional, and whose personality is just beginning to shine through the cracks of that professionalism (and would truly come to fruition a few summers later during SSC, I'd argue).
On a different note (contextual, not metatextual), it's pretty interesting to think about Theon Cross's place in the jazz world. When we were reviewing Fyah, I was not familiar with his other work. I didn't know he was in Sons of Kemet. I have at least heard of those guys, the jazz group being at the very least popular enough that they crossed over to the indie rock blogs and got enough coverage on there that I'd recognize the name. The drummer of that band is Tom Skinner, who you'll recognize from the Smile, a band otherwise comprised of members of Radiohead, who would become RC alumni 244 weeks after Theon. It's all connected, baby, and sometimes it takes five years to appreciate all the connections.
I reached out to the Record Club captain who chose Fyah originally, Stephan, and asked him if he was still bopping along to Fyah on a typical day. He indicated that, after a brief spell of the songs popping up in the Spotify algorithm, he basically never listens to it anymore. Which is understandable. I can't say I have either. I think that's okay. I don't think all of these albums are meant to be infinitely repeatable. I think some exist to be there at one specific point in the journey, and eventually fade. I was really glad to hear Fyah. I don't think it's essential, and I don't think it's worthy of too much praise, but I do think that it was important for us as a club to touch on these sounds, briefly, before we attempted some stronger and/or stranger jazz.
Theon is out there sharing his love of tuba with the world. I won't follow him down his own path, but I will happily wish him well.

No comments:
Post a Comment