Joe is working through an arbitrary and unpublished list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.
Play
Moby
1999
The term I learned this week was "muzak." It's been used on this blog before, mostly by Sunny, and I was able to pick up on what it meant then through context clues, but this was the first time I actually made the effort to google it and read about it a little bit. Muzak is music that basically acts as background recordings for department stores and the like. It's elevator music. It's music in the technical sense but doesn't exist to be noticed like most music is. It is instead designed to fade away from consciousness. (The word is actually a registered trademark, but that's a whole different thing I won't get into here).
I wouldn't say that Moby's Play contains muzak, for a few reasons. But I also think that it's closer to muzak than most objectively popular music is able to get to. This is what makes Play unique. It is bizarre in how unassuming it is. It would be like if you're standing in the elevator and all of a sudden you realize that the muzak playing is actually a soft instrumental version of a song you know intimately. I know some of these songs. They don't fade into the background. They are unique and sometimes striking. And yet they bear many of the hallmarks of your most generic muzak heard in any Macy's or Sears. So it goes.
If there is an overall feeling or sound to this thing, it's that, but in reality, Play is all over the place (mostly in a good way). There are a couple songs that I actually did know—the legitimately sound-collage-y "Porcelain," known from who knows where, and "South Side," a for-real hit that I probably know better as the Gwen Stefani-hopping radio remix. So that's one part of it.
Another part is that Moby discovered the field recordings of Alan Lomax, mainly consisting of old gospel recordings sung by long-ago folk singers of an African American heritage. Basically the same stuff that would inspire the soundtrack for O Brother, Where Art Thou? a year later. Moby samples shit out of those recordings, placing the chanting among techno beats, gratuitous with repetition. This was heard a month or two ago in YSC, when we listened to "Honey," which is one sample repeated over and over and over on top of a similarly hypnotic piano riff. We watched Holes that weekend. It was fine. I did hear the Moby song though. It fit really well! Since it's sampling a old slave song, basically, while Shia LaBeouf and his pals play characters who are basically new slaves.
So that's another part. And then the third part takes up much of the back half of Play, and it sounds like a low-rent version of shit that we already heard when we listened to Massive Attack and the like. Which is not necessarily a bad thing, but it's closer to muzak then you'd hope. And also makes me think about the fact that most of these songs were sold for placement in TV shows and movies and commercials, the true capitalistic power behind Moby's most popular album. I'm told that this shit was everywhere. That's probably why it sounds so familiar. And why not sell out? What the hell else are you gonna do with an album like this? It's muzak. It's music made to stand behind other art. It makes sense. I'm not angry. I just find less artistic appeal in Play because of that, that's all.
Then there's "Bodyrock," which samples an early-'80s rap song called "Love Rap" by Spoonie Gee and the Treacherous Three, and I don't really know that it fits into any of the categories I've already described. I bring it up, though, to prove how varied this album is. You can't just say "oh, it's samples of field recordings of traditional songs" because it's only partially that. You can't say it has a surprising number of hits because the singles existed most outside measurements like "placement on Hot 100." You can't say it was unpopular either, since it's sold twelve million copies worldwide in the past 25 years.
You could probably say it's boring if you wanted to, but you can't say it's offensively so. It's only boring if you let it slip into the background. Which, sure, that'd be easy, but probably too easy. There is a story here. There is an impact, even if that impact is soft, or maybe you don't realize it for a while.
If there is an overall feeling or sound to this thing, it's that, but in reality, Play is all over the place (mostly in a good way). There are a couple songs that I actually did know—the legitimately sound-collage-y "Porcelain," known from who knows where, and "South Side," a for-real hit that I probably know better as the Gwen Stefani-hopping radio remix. So that's one part of it.
Another part is that Moby discovered the field recordings of Alan Lomax, mainly consisting of old gospel recordings sung by long-ago folk singers of an African American heritage. Basically the same stuff that would inspire the soundtrack for O Brother, Where Art Thou? a year later. Moby samples shit out of those recordings, placing the chanting among techno beats, gratuitous with repetition. This was heard a month or two ago in YSC, when we listened to "Honey," which is one sample repeated over and over and over on top of a similarly hypnotic piano riff. We watched Holes that weekend. It was fine. I did hear the Moby song though. It fit really well! Since it's sampling a old slave song, basically, while Shia LaBeouf and his pals play characters who are basically new slaves.
So that's another part. And then the third part takes up much of the back half of Play, and it sounds like a low-rent version of shit that we already heard when we listened to Massive Attack and the like. Which is not necessarily a bad thing, but it's closer to muzak then you'd hope. And also makes me think about the fact that most of these songs were sold for placement in TV shows and movies and commercials, the true capitalistic power behind Moby's most popular album. I'm told that this shit was everywhere. That's probably why it sounds so familiar. And why not sell out? What the hell else are you gonna do with an album like this? It's muzak. It's music made to stand behind other art. It makes sense. I'm not angry. I just find less artistic appeal in Play because of that, that's all.
Then there's "Bodyrock," which samples an early-'80s rap song called "Love Rap" by Spoonie Gee and the Treacherous Three, and I don't really know that it fits into any of the categories I've already described. I bring it up, though, to prove how varied this album is. You can't just say "oh, it's samples of field recordings of traditional songs" because it's only partially that. You can't say it has a surprising number of hits because the singles existed most outside measurements like "placement on Hot 100." You can't say it was unpopular either, since it's sold twelve million copies worldwide in the past 25 years.
You could probably say it's boring if you wanted to, but you can't say it's offensively so. It's only boring if you let it slip into the background. Which, sure, that'd be easy, but probably too easy. There is a story here. There is an impact, even if that impact is soft, or maybe you don't realize it for a while.
I was in the Stereogum comment section underneath a news article about Moby stepping out of the public eye because he had released a memoir in 2019 claiming that he had dated Natalie Portman but Portman denied it and called him creepy, and one of the comments had more upvotes than I had seen on any one comment in a long time, and it said "oh lordy his troubles so hard," and I read it at the exact same time that the line dropped on "Natural Blues" (and then repeated itself approximately 120x), and it got an audible laugh out of me. I probably read that comment before but obviously it didn't land until right now, finally listening to the sample on "Natural Blues" and getting the reference.
But it's fucking bizarre that this kind of song, on this kind of album, would have such longevity that you can drop a reference like that twenty years later and make a bunch of people laugh at the reference. It doesn't seem like the type of album that could do that at any point, let alone for that extended a period of time. It is, though. Play, beyond any comprehension, is an important and popular album, and sounds kinda nice, so who cares. Music, muzak, whatever.
But it's fucking bizarre that this kind of song, on this kind of album, would have such longevity that you can drop a reference like that twenty years later and make a bunch of people laugh at the reference. It doesn't seem like the type of album that could do that at any point, let alone for that extended a period of time. It is, though. Play, beyond any comprehension, is an important and popular album, and sounds kinda nice, so who cares. Music, muzak, whatever.
No comments:
Post a Comment